"...I do not see any reason to belabour the issue of chips a-d. Resistivity testing would have fallen under the "control testing" that Dr. Harrit stated and was not included in the 2009 Bentham paper because a paper won't get published if it is loaded down with superfluous information.
The point you and others keep ignoring is that Dr. Millette's opinion requires the chips tested by Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer, Mark Basile et al, to not behave the way they did...."
"Strangely, Harrit et al found it important to belabour the issue of chips a-d - it takes up pages 10-16 of their paper and includes the richest set of data. On the other hand, the resistivitity test only takes up about 0.15 pages. So if brevity and space is an imortant criterion, then it seems that Harrit et al felt that the issue of chips a-d was about 40 times as important as the resistivity issue."
Why do you obsess about inane details that have little to do with anything?
Of course the scientists discuss their findings about the 9/11 WTC dust chips (a-d) at great length.
What is your point?
Of course there was more written about the results of the chip testing than about pre-screening with the resistivity test.
The paper did not discuss all the background investigation and analysis that was performed on similar chips by Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and Dr. Harrit.
Working independently on the 9/11 WTC dust for over a year before the 2009 Bentham paper was published, chemical engineer Mark Basile talked of testing 100's of thermitic red/gray chips and he is credited as being the original discoverer of the iron-rich post-ignition residue.
Like Dr. Harrit indicated, it is not common practise to load up a paper for publication with all the related research than lead up to the final conclusions.
But getting back to your pointless question
While investigating the 9/11 WTC dust for a few years a number things were learned.
But when starting with a bag of generally grayish 9/11 WTC dust, you don't immediately go eureka when you see red/gray chips under the microscope.
You select interesting chip samples and start exploring.
During this exploration, various tests were used in order to observe how the samples would respond.
Some samples were found to be drawn to a magnet.
Some samples were not drawn to a magnet.
By itself, noteworthy but not as yet useful.
Some samples were found to have a high electrical resistance.
Some samples were found to have very low electrical resistance.
When heated, some samples changed little, some turned to ash, and some were very energetic, producing an exothermic reaction at ~430C.
With the discovery that some of their samples had this unexpected and volatile behaviour, naturally the research narrowed.
Looking over their pre-test notes, the scientists would have the results of the earlier tests performed before each chip was ignited.
They would have noted that for the chips that were igniting, all were multiple layered, primarily bi-layer red/gray, that they were drawn to a magnet, and that they had a very low electrical resistance.
And, over time, from all their research studying the chips, the scientists became good at visually recognizing the 'chips of interest' with the SEM.
So when it came time to put together a paper for peer-review, the scientists would have collected data on hundreds if not thousands of candidate chips.
Should they have tried to get Bentham to publish all this superfluous data, or just representative data on a few samples from the same 4 NYC locations?
The answer is obvious.
But I really do not care whether Dr. Millette's chips do or do not match since he refuses to confirm his conclusions.
If he is right, all 9/11 WTC dust chips produce innocent residue when heated to ~430C.
And the observations from countless tests performed by Dr. Harrit et al must be fraudulent.
Until Dr. Millette 'acid-tests' his findings, the issue of chip matching is a moot point.
The real issue is what is the substance that permeates all the 9/11 WTC dust and creates molten iron when ignited at ~430C?
MM