WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

So you're not sure about the Bentham paper's conclusion? That all red/gray chips magnetically extracted from a pile of WTC dust are supposedly thermitic?

from jones samples...yeah. did you read anywhere that after the dsc that one or two or three paint chips did not react to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres? i didnt.
 
from jones samples...yeah. did you read anywhere that after the dsc that one or two or three paint chips did not react to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres? i didnt.

You're still clinging to the "Jones' sample" eh?

Why?

Let me ask you this. How do you know a sample is the right one BEFORE you extract the chips?

The paper concludes (incorrectly) that any red/gray layered chip extracted from any WTC dust pile will be thermitic. The four piles that collected in the paper were from different sources.

If Harrit wasn't sure of the conclusion above, please explain why he, in the video below, talks about a large jar of dust he just received, from which he takes a small sample and puts it into a plastic bag in order to give to the audience to separate with a magnet.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I51fDKsuJ_I

Listen closely at starting at 10:00 (he'll talk about iron spheres and the chips).

What does Harrit say about the red/gray chips starting at 10:21?

With a little bit of luck, you may also get a chance to see.. I don't know about this sample, I just got it yesterday morning, I don't know how much is in it, but these red, we call them chips, is what we're gonna talk about for the next 20 minutes or half hour.

So if he hasn't look or tested the sample in the video, how is he so sure that if anyone gets red/gray chips to attract to the magnet, those chips will be the same as the ones in his paper? No mention of a resisitivity test. No mention that SOME of the red/gray chips could be paint or another substance.

The bottom line is, Harrit and his cronies believe that ANY red gray chips extracted from from ANY WTC dust pile with a magnet will be thermitic.

There is no dispute about that.
 
Last edited:
You're still clinging to the "Jones' sample" eh?

Why?

Let me ask you this. How do you know a sample is the right one BEFORE you extract the chips?

The paper concludes (incorrectly) that any red/gray layered chip extracted from any WTC dust pile will be thermitic. The four piles that collected in the paper were from different sources.
the paper is not incorrect. they showed what the dsc produced. not one mention of any chips not reacting to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

If Harrit wasn't sure of the conclusion above, please explain why he, in the video below, talks about a large jar of dust he just received, from which he takes a small sample and puts it into a plastic bag in order to give to the audience to separate with a magnet.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I51fDKsuJ_I

Listen closely at starting at 10:00 (he'll talk about iron spheres and the chips).

What does Harrit say about the red/gray chips starting at 10:21?



So if he hasn't look or tested the sample in the video, how is he so sure that if anyone gets red/gray chips to attract to the magnet, those chips will be the same as the ones in his paper? No mention of a resisitivity test. No mention that SOME of the red/gray chips could be paint or another substance.

The bottom line is, Harrit and his cronies believe that ANY red gray chips extracted from from ANY WTC dust pile with a magnet will be thermitic.

There is no dispute about that.

let millette prove them wrong then. either him or another serious researcher can follow the scientific method and replicate the experiemnts. if millettes do not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres, then by george, you got your answer!
 
the paper is not incorrect. they showed what the dsc produced. not one mention of any chips not reacting to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.



let millette prove them wrong then. either him or another serious researcher can follow the scientific method and replicate the experiemnts. if millettes do not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres, then by george, you got your answer!

The paper is wrong regardless. That's what's so funny.

Harrit thinks he proves that ANY red/gray chips extracted from ANY sample of WTC dust with a magnet is thermitic hence why he says what he says in the video above.

Jones contradicts that claim and Millette proves the paper wrong.

If they found paint chips in Jones' samples like Jones claims, why don't THEY go back and test them? Why didn't they do it in the first place? It would satisfy YOUR bullcrap claim that they were different samples. If Millette tested his samples, you'd still claim they were the wrong ones and not the same as Jones' samples.

:rolleyes:
 
let millette prove them wrong then. either him or another serious researcher can follow the scientific method and replicate the experiemnts. if millettes do not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres, then by george, you got your answer!

What answer would that be.

Would it be that Jones & co's chips did not produce iron rich microspheres :D
 
thanks for clearing that up. it sounded like jones sent him the sample.
It didn't, but you're welcome.

no its not a last straw. millette never did replicate the experiments to see if his react to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. once he does that, then we can speculate.
Irrelevant, as Harrit et all did not do or document any such test on chip a, nor did they do or document any such test on chip b, , nor did they do or document any such test on chip c, nor did they do or document any such test on chip d.

Millette did all the tests that Harrit et al did on chips a-d and then some.

it takes into account of manipulation. yours is crap b/c you assume all the wtc dust SHOULD represent the same dust.
Why should it not? Both Jones and Basile received a sample from the very same person, who had exactly one bag of dust: Janette MacKinlay. This sample was labeled by Harrit et al as Sample 1, and Chip a was from this sample.

Harrit et al had three more samples - and naturally assume that they all represent the same dust. Strangely, you never had a problem with such an assumption. However, it is more likely that the four samples Harrit et al used were different dusts than that the MacKinlay sample that Basile used was a dust different from the MacKinlay sample that Jones used!

that is a big assumption especially if manipulation and substitution is going on.
The only big assumption here is yours: that "manipulation and substitution is going on". You have provided zero evidence for this!

its part of the topic b/c it is supposedly wtc dust. he said he only found 1 red gray chip and i believe he said he "lost" that one.
What is the source of Henryco's sample? I honestly don't know at this moment.

so it would be interesting if jones found any red red's
Why? We are debating the Harrit and Millette studies. Neither was concerned with red-only chips. You are off-topic. Please don't bring this off-topic distr<action up again. You know that intentional derails are against your Membership Agreement.

did it go through a post office?
I don't know, but I do know that the Harrit/Jones Sample 2 went through a post office ("...sent a portion of this dust to Dr. Jones..."), Sample 3 went through a post office ("...Two small samples of this dust were simultaneously sent to Dr. Jones and to Kevin Ryan..."), and Sample 4 went through a post office ("...sent a sample directly to Dr. Jones..."). This apparently has never bothered you before! How can you, or can they, be certain that their four samples have not been tampered with? How can you, or how can they, be certain, that their four samples represent the same dust?

In fact, how did they ascertain that their four dust samples, none of which was collected and stored in accordance with any good laboratory practice or protocol, is genuine, uncontaminated WTC dust at all? If you worry about tampering at the post office, why don't you worry about these things, or, if you do, how do you decide that all four samples are okay? Please name the objective criteria, and present the data, that you used to make that determination!

In the case of James Millette, he can point to an unblemished protocol and chain of custody, and additionally references previous studies on WTC dust that he compares his samples to, to determine that they are indeed WTC dust. Harrit et al have done no such thing.

if one would really wanted to find out, jones and basile would have to get together and analyze their janette mackinley's samples they both have.
Why? Basile is already acknowledged by Harrit et al in the Bentham paper - they already DID collaborate!

so my statement would work better than yours still:
No, it is still dishonest cowardice and a moronic dodge, heaping more shame upon you.



Please answer the original question:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust (e.g. Janette MacKinley's single sample) with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
 
the paper is not incorrect. they showed what the dsc produced. not one mention of any chips not reacting to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

So the red/gray paint chips attracted to a magnet that Jones said were present produced iron and silicon rich microspheres?
 
from jones samples...yeah. did you read anywhere that after the dsc that one or two or three paint chips did not react to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres? i didnt.

Yes, Niels Harrit himself said so:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9yrMIhVq-G0
At 1:24 minutes: "It takes some experience to find the active particles. Some of them are dead, some of them are active."


Now you:

Did you read anywhere that they thermally tested any chip at all from Sample 2? The DSC test result shown in Fig 19 only has four specimens from Samples 1, 3 and 4.

Did any chips at all from Sample 2 form "iron and silicon rich microspheres"?


Did they test chip a thermally?
Did they test chip b thermally?
Did they test chip c thermally?
Did they test chip d thermally?


You see, some of the red-gray chips, as Harrit clearly said, did NOT react and produce microspheres. And they did not document having done DSC testing on the chips that they used to form their main clonclusion, namely chips a-d and the MEK chip. So by what objective criteria can you decide that those were the "right" chips? List them all, and show that they have been applied to chip a, chip b, chip c, chip d and the MEK-soaked chip!
 
Why can't truthers read? I'm always amazed by the fact that truthers never actually read the paper they actually back, but instead make up nonsense based purely on their need to refuse to admit they are wrong.

From the paper that truthers haven't read.

2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination

For clarification, the dust samples collected and sent to the authors by Ms. Janette MacKinlay will be sample 1; the sample collected by Mr. Frank Delassio, or the Delassio/Breidenbach sample, will be sample 2; the sample collected by Mr. Jody Intermont will be sample 3; and the sample collected by Mr. Stephen White will be sample 4. The red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet, which facilitates collection and separation of the chips from the bulk of the dust. A small permanent magnet in its own plastic bag was
used to attract and collect the chips from dust samples. The chips are typically small but readily discernible by eye due to their distinctive color. They are of variable size with major dimensions of roughly 0.2 to 3 mm.

Fig. (2). Photomicrographs of red/gray chips from samples 1-4 of the WTC dust involved in this study, shown in (a)-(d) respectively. The
inset in (d) shows the chip edge on, which reveals the gray layer. The red/gray chips are mounted on an aluminum pedestal, using a carbon
conductive tab, for viewing in the scanning electron microscope (SEM).

So there you have it. Chips a-d were from 4 different samples of dust taken from different parts of NY.

So if chips a-d are the same material, which they are, and that's concluded in the paper, then it stands to reason that as long as you take WTC dust and use a magnet to separate red/gray chips then you must extract the same material as chips a-d. This shows that Senenmut is just making up nonsense because he knows he's wrong.

Harrit et al - kicking truthers with their own paper since 2009.
 
Why doesn't Jones or Harrit send Millette some red/gray chips they claim are thermite?

Why won't Senenmut spend the same amount of time in trying to get Jones or Harrit to sewnd chips to Millette as he does spouting nonsense at JREF?

All this nonsense was was bound to happen because of the dishonesty of truthers including Jones/Basile/Harrit et. Their refusal to supply material shows that they have zero confidence in their paper and know that if they complied they would be seen to look very silly.

Jones and the rest are frauds.
 
"Oystein.

Do you agree that Dr. Harrit et al discovered iron-rich microspheres in the DSC residue of chips originating from 9/11 WTC dust?"
"Yes, they report such (dependent on what you mean by "iron-rich" and "sphere").

Now you - please answer:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.

Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d? (Of you course you DON'T. Nor does Jones claim that they did this test on chips a, b, c or d.)
"
"So getting back to your question about resistivity data;

Dr. Harrit said:
"When doing a scientific, instrumental investigation, there always is a great number of control experiments, which are implicit to every serious worker in the field. It is understood by the experienced reader, that these tests have been done, since you cannot put every basic control test image or report every bit of supporting data in a journal article. The articles would be so enormous that no one would bother reading them and no journal would possibly care to print them. There are some things that are implied.

Thus, numerous background studies were carried out which were not reported in the red/grey chips paper."

This seems reasonable.

But what is the point?

You are ignoring the gun that keeps on smoking.


Iron-rich forms, produced by iron-melting temperatures, represents compelling evidence that supersedes Dr. Millette's unpublished opinion that the 9/11 WTC dust red chips looked like innocuous toilet bowl dust (kaolinite)."
"I had hoped you'd respond in kind, but I find...that you give me a nasty LIE instead! Because my MAIN question wasn't about resistivity data at all! Why do you write such a shameless, bold-faced, bloody lie? How low are you willing to sink?"

I think you might be confused about which one of us is sinking.

I do not see any reason to belabour the issue of chips a-d. Resistivity testing would have fallen under the "control testing" that Dr. Harrit stated and was not included in the 2009 Bentham paper because a paper won't get published if it is loaded down with superfluous information.

The point you and others keep ignoring is that Dr. Millette's opinion requires the chips tested by Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer, Mark Basile et al, to not behave the way they did.

For Millette's opinion to hold true, Mark Basile must be a liar;

Mark Basile - Chemical Engineer said:
"If you take these chips, before you ignite them, and I have done it, just like I did where I said I exposed a fresh section. I've cut into these chips, dozens, if not hundreds of times and I have never found an iron microsphere inside. I have never found a film of iron inside. It is not there until the chip reacts. When the chip reacts, it produces molten iron. There is no free iron. There is iron oxide before you ignite it but there is no free iron inside these chips."

And Dr. Jones, a distinguished physicist must be lying about the meaning behind a residue containing iron-rich microspheres;

Dr. Steven Jones said:
". . by the ignition of the red material in the DSC, these have a signature that is rich in iron but not enough oxygen to make even FeO.

So that indicates to us that the iron has been reduced which again is a signature for the thermite reaction.

So the formation of the spheres, which implies a very high temperature over 1400 C, and the reduction of the iron oxide to an iron-rich phase, indicates that a thermitic reaction has occurred.

And therefore we are able to call this material, an active thermitic material."

And I guess Dr. Harrit for some unimaginable reason must also be in on this conspiracy you seem to believe in?

Dr. Harrit said:
"A scientific paper is a set of data and the best hypothesis rationalizing the observations. Fe-rich spheroids are observed after a thermite reaction.

Fe-rich spheroids have never been observed unless there was a thermite reaction."

You and Sunstealer obsessing about whether chips a-d are the same is an irrelevant exercise whose only purpose is to block discussion of the real issue.

Dr. Harrit et al have proven that throughout all the 9/11 WTC dust, are chips that have a chemical composition that reacts at ~430C and produces heat capable of melting iron.

Dr. Millette has not proven this to be false!

MM
 
What is the source of Henryco's sample? I honestly don't know at this moment.
someone said richard gage? :confused: so that would probably mean it got sent to gage via mail then to henryco via mail.


Why? We are debating the Harrit and Millette studies. Neither was concerned with red-only chips. You are off-topic. Please don't bring this off-topic distr<action up again. You know that intentional derails are against your Membership Agreement.
it deals with wtc dust. henryco used a magnet and found them. millette used a magnet to seperate dust? it all needs to be looked at.



I don't know, but I do know that the Harrit/Jones Sample 2 went through a post office ("...sent a portion of this dust to Dr. Jones..."), Sample 3 went through a post office ("...Two small samples of this dust were simultaneously sent to Dr. Jones and to Kevin Ryan..."), and Sample 4 went through a post office ("...sent a sample directly to Dr. Jones..."). This apparently has never bothered you before! How can you, or can they, be certain that their four samples have not been tampered with? How can you, or how can they, be certain, that their four samples represent the same dust?


In fact, how did they ascertain that their four dust samples, none of which was collected and stored in accordance with any good laboratory practice or protocol, is genuine, uncontaminated WTC dust at all? If you worry about tampering at the post office, why don't you worry about these things, or, if you do, how do you decide that all four samples are okay? Please name the objective criteria, and present the data, that you used to make that determination!

In the case of James Millette, he can point to an unblemished protocol and chain of custody, and additionally references previous studies on WTC dust that he compares his samples to, to determine that they are indeed WTC dust. Harrit et al have done no such thing.
that was before anyone found the nanothermite.


Why? Basile is already acknowledged by Harrit et al in the Bentham paper - they already DID collaborate!
who knows if they both looked at there mackinlay sample in more detail if basile thinks some are paint chips. we would have to ask them.


No, it is still dishonest cowardice and a moronic dodge, heaping more shame upon you.

its not dishonest. its more accurate of a statement than the one you listed.
 
Yes, Niels Harrit himself said so:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9yrMIhVq-G0
At 1:24 minutes: "It takes some experience to find the active particles. Some of them are dead, some of them are active."

wow. is it from one sample or what? i wish he would be more specific. i know they said they found partially reacted thermite chips so maybe that is what he is talking about. another interesting thing since you guys think the epoxy/steel can cause iron and silicon rich microspheres, how would one chip made from epoxy degrade and the other chip not? just like i said before:

Are all red-gray chips from each sample that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields the same material in some samples, altogether different material in some samples, or two or more different materials in some samples?

interesting find oystein. we can always count on you.
 
Why can't truthers read? I'm always amazed by the fact that truthers never actually read the paper they actually back, but instead make up nonsense based purely on their need to refuse to admit they are wrong.

From the paper that truthers haven't read.





So there you have it. Chips a-d were from 4 different samples of dust taken from different parts of NY.

So if chips a-d are the same material, which they are, and that's concluded in the paper, then it stands to reason that as long as you take WTC dust and use a magnet to separate red/gray chips then you must extract the same material as chips a-d. This shows that Senenmut is just making up nonsense because he knows he's wrong.

Harrit et al - kicking truthers with their own paper since 2009.

im not making up nonsense. i knew they were from different samples. ive read the thermite paper and millettes paper. jones got these samples early on when no one knew about these red gray chips. now the word is out. possible manipulation and substitution claims have been made (henryco).

the best way to move forward is to be skeptical with samples. thats all im saying. and the best way to be skeptical is an adaptation to oysteins remark. it takes into account possible manipulation.

Are all red-gray chips from each sample that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields the same material in some samples, altogether different material in some samples, or two or more different materials in some samples?
 
...
I do not see any reason to belabour the issue of chips a-d. Resistivity testing would have fallen under the "control testing" that Dr. Harrit stated and was not included in the 2009 Bentham paper because a paper won't get published if it is loaded down with superfluous information.
...

Strangely, Harrit et al found it important to belabour the issue of chips a-d - it takes up pages 10-16 of their paper and includes the richest set of data. On the other hand, the resistivitity test only takes up about 0.15 pages. So if brevity and space is an imortant criterion, then it seems that Harrit et al felt that the issue of chips a-d was about 40 times as important as the resistivity issue.

Now I think you will agree that it is important to include in the paper all information that is necessary to replicate the study.



So please, bearing in mind the high priority that Harrit et al placed on chips a-d:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.

Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d?
 
"...I do not see any reason to belabour the issue of chips a-d. Resistivity testing would have fallen under the "control testing" that Dr. Harrit stated and was not included in the 2009 Bentham paper because a paper won't get published if it is loaded down with superfluous information.

The point you and others keep ignoring is that Dr. Millette's opinion requires the chips tested by Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer, Mark Basile et al, to not behave the way they did...."
"Strangely, Harrit et al found it important to belabour the issue of chips a-d - it takes up pages 10-16 of their paper and includes the richest set of data. On the other hand, the resistivitity test only takes up about 0.15 pages. So if brevity and space is an imortant criterion, then it seems that Harrit et al felt that the issue of chips a-d was about 40 times as important as the resistivity issue."

Why do you obsess about inane details that have little to do with anything?

Of course the scientists discuss their findings about the 9/11 WTC dust chips (a-d) at great length.

What is your point?

Of course there was more written about the results of the chip testing than about pre-screening with the resistivity test.

The paper did not discuss all the background investigation and analysis that was performed on similar chips by Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and Dr. Harrit.

Working independently on the 9/11 WTC dust for over a year before the 2009 Bentham paper was published, chemical engineer Mark Basile talked of testing 100's of thermitic red/gray chips and he is credited as being the original discoverer of the iron-rich post-ignition residue.

Like Dr. Harrit indicated, it is not common practise to load up a paper for publication with all the related research than lead up to the final conclusions.

But getting back to your pointless question

While investigating the 9/11 WTC dust for a few years a number things were learned.

But when starting with a bag of generally grayish 9/11 WTC dust, you don't immediately go eureka when you see red/gray chips under the microscope.

You select interesting chip samples and start exploring.

During this exploration, various tests were used in order to observe how the samples would respond.

Some samples were found to be drawn to a magnet.

Some samples were not drawn to a magnet.

By itself, noteworthy but not as yet useful.

Some samples were found to have a high electrical resistance.

Some samples were found to have very low electrical resistance.

When heated, some samples changed little, some turned to ash, and some were very energetic, producing an exothermic reaction at ~430C.

With the discovery that some of their samples had this unexpected and volatile behaviour, naturally the research narrowed.

Looking over their pre-test notes, the scientists would have the results of the earlier tests performed before each chip was ignited.

They would have noted that for the chips that were igniting, all were multiple layered, primarily bi-layer red/gray, that they were drawn to a magnet, and that they had a very low electrical resistance.

And, over time, from all their research studying the chips, the scientists became good at visually recognizing the 'chips of interest' with the SEM.

So when it came time to put together a paper for peer-review, the scientists would have collected data on hundreds if not thousands of candidate chips.

Should they have tried to get Bentham to publish all this superfluous data, or just representative data on a few samples from the same 4 NYC locations?

The answer is obvious.

But I really do not care whether Dr. Millette's chips do or do not match since he refuses to confirm his conclusions.

If he is right, all 9/11 WTC dust chips produce innocent residue when heated to ~430C.

And the observations from countless tests performed by Dr. Harrit et al must be fraudulent.

Until Dr. Millette 'acid-tests' his findings, the issue of chip matching is a moot point.

The real issue is what is the substance that permeates all the 9/11 WTC dust and creates molten iron when ignited at ~430C?

MM
 
Of course the scientists discuss their findings about the 9/11 WTC dust chips (a-d) at great length.

Wonderful. Then you are in an excellent position to answer this:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.

Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d?


Why don't you give it a try? :)
 
Some samples were not drawn to a magnet.
MM probably has me on ignore, but I'd be interested in knowing where the data is for these samples that weren't drawn by a magnet. Where is the data on these non-magnetic samples?

I suspect this is simply another made up statement by MM in order to obfuscate and detract Millette's peerless research and analysis that once and for all show that the paper by Harrit et al is nonsense.

We must be the only people left on the planet that are discussing such a complete irrelevance.
 
Last edited:
Some samples were found to be drawn to a magnet.

Some samples were not drawn to a magnet.

That's wrong, all investigated chips were attracted by a magnet, as the magnetic separation of the chips was the method of choice described on p. 9.

Some samples were found to have a high electrical resistance.

Some samples were found to have very low electrical resistance.

That's wrong, too. There was only on chip that showed a low resistivity, while no chip showed a high resistivity. Harrit et al. didn't test the resistivity of the WTC primer paint, they used a previously published article as reference.

Should they have tried to get Bentham to publish all this superfluous data, or just representative data on a few samples from the same 4 NYC locations?

The major drawback of Harrit's paper is the lack of scientific data. The paper consists of 25 pages, but 50% of the space is filled with, partly unnecessary, pictures, graphs and photographs. The paper contains no quantitative analysis of the chips and the building blocks of the chips are not identified.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom