Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
thanks mm
cool, i did not know he sent a sample out. take note millette and chris mohr.
jones-
"A separate sample was sent to a scientist, Mark Basile working in New England and he also sees the same active red/gray material. I have to say one thing while I am discussing the efforts by Mark Basile. He was the first one to ignite a red/gray chip and observe the spheres, the tiny iron-rich spheres in the residue after the red/gray chip is ignited."
i remember basile talking about getting a sample from a museum.
I am glad you bring Mark Basile up, because you say:
I'll give you a chance to actually listen to someone that actually did some research on these chips now:i think ill listen to someone that actually did some research on these chips.
First: Your last sentence is wrong. mark Basile got his sample not from a museum but from Janette MacKinlay, who also gave Jones one of the samples 1-4 that was used in the Bentham study. So Basile's sample has the same source as one of Jones's. Source: 9/11 Free Fall, 27 December 2012, at 22:09: "[Steven Jones ] followed up a couple weeks later and got me in touch with a woman by the name of Janette MacKinlay, which is one of the four samples of dust that was were used in the article that he and the others that he worked with published back around, shortly after that time frame I think it was around 2009 or so, or early 2009 they published. So really, that's kind of when I first started really getting involved in the dust itself. I mean I was doing some reading and learning up to that point, but the actual hands-on began basically around January of 2008."
(He talks about a meeting with Jones in December 2007).
Later in the same interview, at 27:26, he sais: "There are a lot of paint chips in the dust! You should make that perfectly clear! Just when you, if anybody in the audience, let's say, would get out there and get a World Trade Center dust sample, and they pull out red chips from this, I'm not telling anybody in the world that every red chip you're gonna pull out of there is one of these nano-thermite chips. The vast majority of them actually are primer paint, from what I'm finding, but that doesn't mean they all are. And they are not all, because […?...] pulled out ones where I've seen the reaction, I've seen the product, so I know they're in there. But there is also a lot of primer paint chips in there, too." and then, az 28:28: "I think some of the chips that, you know, Jones and all looked at were definitely, you know, primer paint chips, too, so not everything in there was necessarily nanothermite chips."
So Mark Basile makes it perfectly clear that in his expert opinion, he, who studied the red-gray chips, thhinks that some of the chips you pull out with a magnet, and even some of those that Jones studied, are NOT thermite, while he thinks some are. So Mark Basile unambiguously testifies that the red-gray chips that Jones pulled from his dust samples with a magnet represent different materials.
With this in mind, and not forgetting that YOU said you would "listen to someone that actually did some research on these chips", please answer my original question:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
Last edited:
