WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

With no thermite damage to WTC steel, the thermite fantasy failed.

The best Harrit can do is mangle physics.
The top of WTC1 came down – with sudden(!) onset – and with
constant (!) acceleration equal 2/3 (two thirds) of free fall. You
agreed to this number (courtesy David Chandler) in our radio
debate (triumphant: ”It is much less that free fall”).
In that moment, you lost two thirds of your argument.
A downward acceleration of 2/3 G means, that the interaction
(Newton 3rd) with the support in only 1/3 of its static weight.
OK?
So, for all the damage which you assign to the potential energy is
only left:
1/3 x 4 x 10^11 Joule = 36300 kWh (kWh is a unit easier to embrace
for most).
You cannot use the same potential energy to accelerate the top
section and to crush the rest of the building. Energy can only be
spent once.
911 truth physics, and 911 truth thermite - nonsense. How can people be so stupid...

Millette can't find thermite because no thermite was used on 911.
 
There is no link to Harrit's July 27, 2011calculation, or did I miss it?

Interesting bit is the 10% iron-oxide thing - I wonder what Harrit based this on! And if he has a similar estimate for Al!

After all, since pure thermite is a tad less than 75% iron oxide, 10% iron oxide in the red layer means that, effectively, 86% of the red layer is not thermite. It means that thermite provides only less than 0.53 kJ/g of energy to the red layer material, even if you assume enough elemental Al and a perfect reaction efficiency.

The DSC-tests measured 1.5 to 7.5 kJ/g for entire chips (including the inert gray layer!), that 2,8x to 14.1x the maximum possible yield from Harrit's estimate of thermite content.
So Harrit implicitly confirms that the DSC curves are dominated by exotherm reactions that are NOT the thermite reaction.

If pure thermite reaches a temperature of 2500 °C when it reacts, then mixing 14% thermite with 86% non-thermite would yield a composite temperature of roughly 350 °C (depending on the relative heat capacities) - not enough to melt any metal or produce any gas.

Harrit implicitly confirms that the red layer, if it contained thermite at all, would be impotent.

Here's the link from Harrit to Hightower email:
http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/08/27/nanothermite-if-it-doesnt-fit-you-must-acquit/
Also search for "143,000" in that thread.
Mark
On Wed, 2011-07-27 at 01:38 +0200, Niels Harrit wrote:
> Mr. Hightower.
>
> This is meant as an order-of-magnitude estimate only. Every assessment will
> be conservative so that the final volume of applied thermitic material
> should be a safe lowest-limit.
>
> The RJ Lee Group carried out an investigation of the WTC dust very early
> following 9/11.[1] Their reports were published in 2003[2] and in 2004.[3] A
> wealth of findings therein indicated extreme temperatures during and
> preceeding the collapse.[4] But most importantly, in the present context,
> the RJ Lee group found a whopping 5.87% content of iron-rich spheres in the
> dust (see Table 3, p.28 in the 2003 report). In the same table a 0.04% is
> reported as the expected value in normal building dust. So 5.83% of the
> finding must be considered abnormal.
>
> According to the RJ Lee group, the dust was pushed through pedestrian
> tunnels that connected WTC2 to the adjacent Deutsche Bank Building at 130
> Liberty Street where RJ Lee Group took samples.[1] If any change in
> composition due to gravity occured during this event, it must have reduced
> the relative amount of iron-rich spheres present in the dust, since iron has
> a density of 7.9 g/cm3, while that of e.g. concrete is much lower, as it can
> vary from 2,.3 to 3.4 g/cm3. That is, a content of 5.83% iron-rich spheres
> is a lower limit for the dust produced at the WTC2 site.
>
> The only explanation for the presence of iron-rich spheres in these
> quantities is the occurrence of thermitic processes (paint, incendiaries,
> explosives) preceeding the collapses or during the collapses of the Twin
> Towers.
>
> The National Resources Defense Council (NRDC) report estimated more than 1.2
> million tons of building materials were pulverized during the whole WTC
> event.[5] However, the lowest and most reliable estimate of the mass of one
> of the towers (WTC1 or WTC2) is 288.000 metric tons.[6] This is the ”raw”
> building. To this, let us add 50.000 tons, accounting for everything you put
> into such a tower, but subtract the 90.000 tons (too high, conservative)
> structural steel. Then, we end up with ca. 250.000 tons of pulverizable
> material per tower (WTC1 or WTC2).
>
> In order to stay on the absolutely safe side, let us subtract a further
> 50.000 tonnes and say that the RJ Lee Group sampling was representative of
> 200.000 tonnes pulverized tower.
>
> This means, that there were produced at least 0.0583 x 200000 = 11.660
> tonnes iron-rich spheres per tower. The iron-rich spheres contained varying
> trace amounts of aluminum and silicon (which in itself is an unambiguous
> proof of their thermitic origin). Since no overall quantitative estimate of
> these contaminants exist, let us lower the amount of pure iron formed in
> thermitic processes during and preceeding the collapse of one tower to
> 10.000 tons.
>
> As I suggested, let us fancy a thermitic material with an ironoxide content
> of 10%. This is arbitrary. You may substitute this number with any other
> below, say, 50%.
>
> The molecular mass of Fe2O3 is 159.7, iron is 55.8 each. That is, ferric
> oxide produces 70% elemental iron upon reduction.
>
> So one kilo of the thermitic material can produce a maximum of 70 g iron.
>
> If we assume, that ALL the thermitic material should react to form iron
> spheres (please notice, that this is another highly conservative condition),
> RJ Lee Groups observation implies that:
>
> (10000 x 1000 x 1000)/70 = 143.000.000 kg =
>
> 143.000 metric tons thermitic material
>
> was present in WTC2 prior to collapse.
>
> Of course, it is five times less, if the iron oxide content is 50%.
>
> Still, it’s a lot.
>
> Find the error!
>
> NH
>

 
Here's the link from Harrit to Hightower email:
http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/08/27/nanothermite-if-it-doesnt-fit-you-must-acquit/
Also search for "143,000" in that thread.
...

Ayy, thanks! I didn't look at the comment section!

So 10% iron oxide is arbitrary, and he thinks 50% is possible, too.
I guess he didn't really take a close look at his red-gray material! It isn't awfully hard to get a rough estimate of the relative volume of the iron oxide grains, from analysing the SEM images.

Find the error?
Plenty.
After reading yoiur spoiler hastily, and without consulting any further references:
  1. It's not true that Most of the non-steel debris was turned to dust, at least not of the kind that was found in 130 Liberty Street. It is thus invalid to exptrapolate the RJ Lee findings to the bulk of the buildings' mass
  2. It is not true that no data exists on the amount of Al in WTC dust - the USGS and EPA databases contain such values
  3. It is not true that silicon is an indicator of the presence of thermite
  4. It is not true that aluminium is an unambiguous indicator of the presence of thermite
  5. It is not true that the RJ Lee value of almost 6% is a lower limit for the iron content in all the dust and debris - in fact, it an outlier value: EPA, USGS, UC Davis reported iron contents betweem 0.5% and 4%, with an average near 2% (from memory; numbers are not exact, but close)
  6. It is not true that this dust, sans thermite, would have been expected to only contain 0.04% iron-rich spheres. That is a reference to building dust produced by inhabiting the building, which is then dominated by organic fibers, skin flakes and the likes. On the contrary, the expectation was from the beginning that dust from a builing collapse would be very much different from "normal" office dust, as it is expected to contain a drastically higher inorganic mineral content, specifically of Fe, Si, Al and Ca. Harrit's argument puts the logic of the RJ Lee finding on its head.
And of course, as Hightower points out: Harrit's result of 29,000 tons of thermite or more is so riciculously far outside any logictically sane order of magnitude - this alone, the abject lack of plausibility - should ring a giant bell that his entire argument is bogus.
 
........And of course, as Hightower points out: Harrit's result of 29,000 tons of thermite or more is so riciculously far outside any logictically sane order of magnitude - this alone, the abject lack of plausibility - should ring a giant bell that his entire argument is bogus.
Minimum,per Tower! There's no Sanity Check. The claims are not integrated with what is known about thermite. The low mix amounts of reputed thermite, the inability of a 100 micron layer to damage the structure (the Bentham and Millette images show only 10-30 microns), the colossal amounts of this material.
 
Last edited:
nope. you still dont get it. they had different samples.

According to Harrit's paper that's impossible. As long as you extract chips from the WTC that have a visible red/gray layer and are attracted to a magnet, those chips, based on the tests performed in the paper, are thermitic.

If you are saying otherwise, then Harrit's conclusion in the paper is wrong.

Bentham paper said:
Based on these observations, we conclude that the red layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust is active, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or explosive material.

There is no data published in that paper that shows the chips extracted with the above two criteria were found to supposedly be anything but thermitic.

The fact that Millette used the same extraction method as stated in the paper and got DIFFERENT results proves Harrit's paper is a farce.

Furthermore, if Harrit and his group separated out paint chips as MM likes to believe, why did they not test those and publish the findings? Why go to outside data from other sources when you had paint chips right in front of you?

How come Harrit and his group did not perform the resistivity tests on three of the four chips in the paper to rule out those chips as being paint like Jones implies Millette should have done?
 
Minimum,per Tower! There's no Sanity Check. The claims are not integrated with what is known about thermite. The low mix amounts of reputed thermite, the inability of a 100 micron layer to damage the structure (the Bentham and Millette images show only 10-30 microns), the colossal amounts of this material.

On commenter points this YT interview with Harrit (Danish with English subtitles; start at 4:45) where Harrit speaks of "over 10 tonnes, possible 100 tonnes" of unreacted thermite.
Unfortunately, he does not extrapolate from there to the total amount before the bulk was allegedle ignited to blow up the place.

(OT: And he goes on to invent a few more numbers, which are not in evidence. At 6:44: "Hundreds of thousands of people around the world have long known that the buildings were demolished" - when in fact no more than a couple of tens of thousands of people have stated as much. 7:06 - "Each day, thousands of people realize that the WTC was demolished" - when in fact only a handful, never more than a few dozend, of people per day were added to the "TM".)
 
Just out of curiosity. Senenmut keeps bringing up the "scientific method". Is there really enough data in the Harrit et al report to actually reproduce it exactly? As far as I can tell there is not.

Wouldn't this (if it's incomplete) be something that would cause a paper to fail "peer review"?
 
Just out of curiosity. Senenmut keeps bringing up the "scientific method". Is there really enough data in the Harrit et al report to actually reproduce it exactly? As far as I can tell there is not.

Wouldn't this (if it's incomplete) be something that would cause a paper to fail "peer review"?

This hinges critically upon the answer to the question:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​

Now, we may disagree what the correct answer is, but if you answer "yes, all red-gray, magnetically attracted chips from WTC dust are the same material", then you must also agree that the chips that Millette studied are that same material, and since Millette proved rigidly that the Al-Si-rich platelets are Kaolin, and that there is no elemental Al detectable in the chips, you must agree that these chips - ALL of them! - do NOT contain thermite.

If on the other hand you allow as possible, likely or certain that these chips are different materials, then the study should have attempted to identify the different kinds of materials, and should have found criteria by which to separate them, and it should be clear from the paper which criteria, beyond "magnetic attraction" and "look red-gray", were used to select the specimens used in the study. Harrit et al failed to do that. While they present some detailed data chips a-d to demonstrate their similarity, they show no data from the MEK-soaked chip that matches the data for chips a-d, except for it ebing red and gray. In fact, they point out that both the overall XEDS spectrum (Fig. 14) and the EDS-map (Fig 15) are different from their counterparts (Fig. 7 and 10). Also, the focused XEDS spectra of Si-rich regions within the matrices (Fig. 11a vs. Fig 16) also differ significantly. The best explanation for this is that the MEK-chip indeed represents a material different from chips a-d.
For the four chips tested in the DSC that gave rise to the four DSC curves in Fig. 19, no data at all is available that would allow a comparison with either chips a-d or tzhe MEK-soaked chip.
The same goes for all the DSC residues - the authors provide no data at all that would allow a determination if those specimens are the same, or a different material, from chips a-d or the MEK-chip.


To form their their conclusion, Harrit et al conflate test results from chips a-d ("nano-sized particles" within the matrix), the MEK-test ("presence of elemental Al") and the DSC-tests ("energetic"; "form iron-rich spheres") and say that "the" red matrerial of "the" red-gray chips is a form of active, unreacted nanothermite. This conflation is invalid if you can't rule out that the chips represent different materials. It thus appears that the authors of the paper believe, insinuate, assume that every red-gray chip that is magnetically attracted to a magnet is the same material. In that case, as I said, Millette directly refutes the conclusion. Alternatively, the paper is so incomplete that the study can't be replicated with the data contained in it - and that should indeed be cause for editorial intervention. Which is a nice way of saying: Crap paper.


So truthers have a three-way-choice: The paper is either
Invalid (if authors allow for multiple materials)
or
Disproven by Millette (if authors insist that all chips conforming to the selection criteria, which includes Millette's, are the same material)
or
Incomplete and irreproducible crap (if Harrit et al did use a consistent method to make sure they studied one and the same material, but forgot to tell what it is)

The choices aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. Since the authors remain ambiguous about the central question, I think all three apply at the same time, plus a fourth: The paper is deliberately fraudulent.
 
Last edited:
This hinges critically upon the answer to the question:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​

Now, we may disagree what the correct answer is, but if you answer "yes, all red-gray, magnetically attracted chips from WTC dust are the same material", then you must also agree that the chips that Millette studied are that same material, and since Millette proved rigidly that the Al-Si-rich platelets are Kaolin, and that there is no elemental Al detectable in the chips, you must agree that these chips - ALL of them! - do NOT contain thermite.

If on the other hand you allow as possible, likely or certain that these chips are different materials, then the study should have attempted to identify the different kinds of materials, and should have found criteria by which to separate them, and it should be clear from the paper which criteria, beyond "magnetic attraction" and "look red-gray", were used to select the specimens used in the study. Harrit et al failed to do that. While they present some detailed data chips a-d to demonstrate their similarity, they show no data from the MEK-soaked chip that matches the data for chips a-d, except for it ebing red and gray. In fact, they point out that both the overall XEDS spectrum (Fig. 14) and the EDS-map (Fig 15) are different from their counterparts (Fig. 7 and 10). Also, the focused XEDS spectra of Si-rich regions within the matrices (Fig. 11a vs. Fig 16) also differ significantly. The best explanation for this is that the MEK-chip indeed represents a material different from chips a-d.
For the four chips tested in the DSC that gave rise to the four DSC curves in Fig. 19, no data at all is available that would allow a comparison with either chips a-d or tzhe MEK-soaked chip.
The same goes for all the DSC residues - the authors provide no data at all that would allow a determination if those specimens are the same, or a different material, from chips a-d or the MEK-chip.


To form their their conclusion, Harrit et al conflate test results from chips a-d ("nano-sized particles" within the matrix), the MEK-test ("presence of elemental Al") and the DSC-tests ("energetic"; "form iron-rich spheres") and say that "the" red matrerial of "the" red-gray chips is a form of active, unreacted nanothermite. This conflation is invalid if you can't rule out that the chips represent different materials. It thus appears that the authors of the paper believe, insinuate, assume that every red-gray chip that is magnetically attracted to a magnet is the same material. In that case, as I said, Millette directly refutes the conclusion. Alternatively, the paper is so incomplete that the study can't be replicated with the data contained in it - and that should indeed be cause for editorial intervention. Which is a nice way of saying: Crap paper.


So truthers have a three-way-choice: The paper is either
Invalid (if authors allow for multiple materials)
or
Disproven by Millette (if authors insist that all chips conforming to the selection criteria, which includes Millette's, are the same material)
or
Incomplete and irreproducible crap (if Harrit et al did use a consistent method to make sure they studied one and the same material, but forgot to tell what it is)

The choices aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. Since the authors remain ambiguous about the central question, I think all three apply at the same time, plus a fourth: The paper is deliberately fraudulent.

Perfect description of what the problem is. Thanks for this and well done Oystein!
 
Perfect description of what the problem is. Thanks for this and well done Oystein!
I agree! Well said Oystein.

As you know I asked two PhD chemist about this paper and they both agree "the data does not support the conclusions".

I recently asked them if they could duplicate the study given the information in the paper (I did not mention any comment from the authors outside the paper and neither follow the CT angle). Their answer was no. The paper does not contain enough information to duplicate the study. They also concluded (they felt) this was intentional. ;)
 
Last edited:
Here's the link from Harrit to Hightower email:
http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/08/27/nanothermite-if-it-doesnt-fit-you-must-acquit/
Also search for "143,000" in that thread.

T. Mark Hightower says thermite did not do it, but T. Mark Hightower is a false flag 911 truth nut. T. Mark Hightower says no thermite, but...
No, it can't be thermite, but it can be...
This helps to illustrate the magnitude of what we may be dealing with in the destruction of the Twin Towers and points towards the possibility of nuclear devices or even possibly some more esoteric directed free energy technology such as what Dr. Judy Wood hypothesizes, in her book, "Where Did the Towers Go?" All WTC destruction hypotheses are speculative, and these are no exception, but these do seem to fit the magnitude of the iron-rich sphere data better than the nanothermite hypothesis. Dr. Judy Wood's hypothesis is also a nuclear hypothesis of sorts, in that she refers to Low Energy Nuclear Reactions as a possible part of the esoteric technology used. http://tmarkhightower.wordpress.com...-the-dust-point-to-nuclear-or-dew-hypotheses/

We have nuts with bigger delusions debunking Jones. Sadly, T. Mark Hightower works for or with NASA. Loons who are paid by our tax dollars. I know how we can save 60k/yr and increase the IQ of NASA.


It is ironic the number of loons from 911 truth debunking the thermite loons. What a movement.
http://tmarkhightower.wordpress.com...-from-the-911-world-trade-center-catastrophe/
Poor T. Mark, a 911 nut is debunking the Jones/Harrit failed paper.
So when I saw the towers collapsing I said “THE CIA!”. Had to be. I knew that when professional golfer Payne Stewart’s plane went off target from its intended flight path, NORAD had an F-16 on that planes wing within minutes. http://tmarkhightower.wordpress.com/2011/09/05/remembering-our-awakenings-to-the-911-false-flag/
80 minutes dork. Why are smart nuts so darn gullible.

Moving from thermite to beam weapons and nukes - debunking thermite ends up being a trip to insanity for 911 truth experts in woo.

Why can't 911 truth debunk's Millette's paper?
 
Last edited:
You wrote this in response to:
Harrit et al say that chips a-d are thermite.
Did Harrit et al "produce iron and silicon rich microspheres" from chip a, chip b, chip c, or chip d?​
But totally, and cowardly and dishonestly, "forgot" to address what you quoted at all.
which chips of millettes produced iron and silicon rich microspheres?

Please answer the question:
Did Harrit et al "produce iron and silicon rich microspheres" from chip a, chip b, chip c, or chip d?

which chips did not produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. in other words, they all did.
It's unequivocally and 100% a cowardly and dishonest dodge of the part that you quoted - I wrote:
You are dodging the point that, if you accept that chips a-d are the same, for a set of reasons, then you must also accept that the chips that Millette proved to NOT contain any elemental Al and thus NO thermite are also that same material, for the exact same reasons.​
Would you please address substantially my point:
If you accept that chips a-d are the same, for a set of reasons, then you must also accept that the chips that Millette proved to NOT contain any elemental Al and thus NO thermite are also that same material, for the exact same reasons.
i dont have to accept anything until he replicates! get that though your head.


Why did you cowardly dodge a part of what you quoted? Deliberate dishonesty? You quoted me:
So, Senemut, do you agree that chips a-d are all the same material? Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on!​
But you cowardly dodged the second part: Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on!

Please answer now, in substantial detail: Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on that chips a-d are all the same material!
read the paper. watch the vids. has jones said that one, two, or three chips that were chips of interest did not react and produce iron and silicon rich microspheres in the dsc?


What a dishonest coward you are! You again quoted me, and did not reply to what you quoted! What are you afraid of?? I said:
Again: Did Harrit et al heat chips a? Chip b? Chip c? Or chip d? Senemut, yes, no, or you don't know?
Of course you know that answer: There is no indication that any of chips a-d were tested in the DSC or otherwise heated.​
Would you now please give a courages and honest answer to the question: Again: Did Harrit et al heat chips a? Chip b? Chip c? Or chip d? Senemut, yes, no, or you don't know?
which one of jones chips did NOT produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?

Of course, if you are honest and courageous, you will and must answer "I, Senemut do not know". Of course, I fully expect you to remain a dishonest coward who is too afraid to admit that we have no *********** clue whether or not the material that chips a-d represent was heated in the DSC or not, or whether microspheres were produced from it. This means: We can't reproduce the DSC experiment, because Harrit et al, in their incompetence, forgot to give us information on which of the several materials gave which DSC results. So much for reproducibility! If only you had the heart to honestly answer a few questions!
wrong. again, which chip did not form iron and silicon rich microspheres?
if millette will not do it, send some chips my way and ill get it done.



No, I mean like the text that I wrote, that you quoted, that you then completely dodged around like a dishonest coward. See, I wrote:
You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, righ? So: Which of these kinds produce microspheres? You know the answer: It's "we don't know, because the data is insufficient".​
Notice there is a question in it: You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, right? Please answer this question, exactly as I posed it! No dodging! No running away like a coward! No dishonesty!! I did NOT mean "henryco's red red chips" at all, because I did NOT write "red red", I wrote red-gray, you dishonest coward! Don't change my words to suit the question to your dishonest purposes!
its not dishonest. its a fact that henryco found red red chips. im sure jones would have seen these in his samples if they were there (in his samples).
Just answer exactly this: You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, right?
like red red chips from henryco's sample that jones didnt find or multilayer chips that millette and henryco did not find.

And when you have answered that question, then answer the next: So: Which of these kinds produce microspheres?
chips from jones and basile's samples. did millettes sample?

And dare you not giving an answer that is different from "I, Senemut, have no *********** clue! Harrit et al, in their incompetence, gave us insufficient data!", because everything else would be dishonest! I am sick and tired of your dishonesty, in case you didn't notice yet!
:rolleyes: you know what needs to be done.


He makes no mention either of the fact that they were studying different materials, because the red-gray chips aren't all the same material! That's why the entire DSC stuff is crap, that's why the paper is crap.
jones samples from different locations react to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. how many chips did jones state did not react in the dsc to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres? that would be zero in case you didnt know. haaaaa yes. your right. jones has one type and millette the other!! bingo. you done it.

You are a liar. I admit no such thing. Stop the dirty bloody lies!
you just dont believe in the scientifc method and replication of experiments.


It does, unfortunately, this addresses only a small part of what I wrote and you quoted, which was:
"In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it?​

so you think tillotson's is a "broad."
What do Harrit et al say on this matter?"
Please comment on the first sentence: "In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Do you agree or not? Notice that both these curves exceed the power maximum of Tillotson's 90% pure thermite (ca. 5 W/g) over a span of more than 70 °C, or a duration of more than 7 minutes. This is, as DSC-curves go, a broad signal. The black curve in particular showed an exotherm continuously for more than half an hour! Please comment on this!
if you think they are "broad" then tillotson's must be "broad" too.
is that a correct assumption?
the paper talks about the energy release.

Then I want you to answer this: Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it?
No dodging allowed!!
What reaction or reactions are responsible for the exotherm that starts as low as 170 °C for the black curve? Which reaction or reactions is responsible for the width of the curve and the height of the maximum? I give you a hint: It can't be the thermite reaction! Please spell out the answer: What reaction produced the bulk of the black curve?
You may QUOTE Harrit et al when you spell out the answer. After all, I asked you: What do Harrit et al say on this matter? and expected you to actually answer that question - courageously and honestly.
i dont think they know yet.


Did Tillotson's thermite reaction produce a wide or a narrow curve? As wide, or as narrow as the black and the green curves?
Please compare the black and the green curves with Tillotson's curves! Do so courageously and honestly! You will find that they are not similar at all, beyond being exotherm!


Just look at the data! The green and black curves are quite different from the blue and red!
yet they still produced iron and silicon rich microspheres. did millettes?

No, we do NOT know that!
Please show us Farrer's traces for epoxy!
Please show is the data which informs us on the material that Farrer used! How large were his epoxy samples? What else did they contain?

You gullibly believe some second-hand statement, without supporting data, from the man who is rightly under attack for being responsible for a crap paper.
you gullibly believe millette's chips are the same kind of material studied by jones and crew without him replicating replicating replicating!!

Show us the data, or admit that you have blind faith in Jones!
its not faith that i believe a broad curve would happen when epoxy is heated in a dsc, its common sense.
 
What folly! Harrit did NOT work at all with the MEK soaked chip. I am not even at all sure he did any of the experiments reported in the paper! I know that Farrer did most of the analytical work - Fig. 2-11 for sure, and the DSC test. I am fairly sure he did the EDS work on DSC residues. I am fairly sure Jones did the tests on the MEK soaked chip (Fig. 12-18). What did Harrit do? Nothing! He sat a continent away. Harrit was pretty late to the show. Jones invited Harrit to become lead author when BYU didn't want Farrer to appear as lead author of such a crap paper - at least that's what Dirk Gerhardt aka Sitting Bull told me, a German truther who had correspondence with several of the authors and also has a copy of Griscom's peer-review.

And what a gullible fool you are! You take Harrit's word for it? That's assuming the conclusion! The question here is: Do Harrit's comclusions follow validly from their data? You can't just say "I'll take Harrit's word for it", for that would be blind and stupid, uninformed faith!


What a pathetic, dishonest dodge!
This Harrit-letter does not at all address what I wrote and what you quoted:

Those that Harrit et al heated up in a dsc and look at the curve and checked for iron and silicon rich microspheres - did those "look similar via xeds" to chips a-d? Did they "look similar via xeds" to the MEK-soaked chip?

You will admit, I hope, that you have no *********** clue.​
You see, Harrit presents no XEDS-data for chips that they heated up in a dsc. No one did.
He did not show, and did not compare, the XEDS graphs of the MEK-soaked chip, which is off-topic here anyway.

So Senemut, would you please refrain from more dishonest dodges, and directly address my post:

Those chips that Harrit et al heated up in a dsc and look at the curve and checked for iron and silicon rich microspheres - did those "look similar via xeds" to chips a-d? Did they "look similar via xeds" to the MEK-soaked chip?

If you were courageous and honest, your answer would be: "I, Senemut, have no idea. They forgot, in their incompetence, to include XEDS data on those chips".
i think ill listen to someone that actually did some research on these chips.
 
i think ill listen to someone that actually did some research on these chips.
Err, Millette did do some research on the chips. In fact he used far better methods to identify the material than the people you champion. You don't like it because it debunks Harrit'a paper and therefore destroys your position. I think I'll listen to someone who knows what they are on about as will anyone reading this thread. You can bitch and moan about microspheres all you like, but the simple fact is Millette identified all of the component parts of the red/gray material. It's not our problem that you and others steadfastly refuse to accept such analysis and instead concentrate on points that have absolutely no bearing in identifying exactly what the material is.

It's laughable that you agree that the red material/layer Millette examines matches all of the characteristics of the material that Harrit's team observed in chips a, b, c, d, yet steadfastly refuse to acknowledge it is the same material. That goes against all reason, all data and scientific method.

There simply is no point in trying to show you otherwise because you are not interested. Instead you simply make it up as you go along. You have never performed any materials analysis in your life; you don't have the qualifications to do so, you don't have the experience to analyse the data, you haven't any experience in operating or any understanding of the machinery that generates the data and you certainly don't have the reasoning skills to follow through the analysis. (Hell, you don't even have the common courtesy to spend a tiny amount of time punctuate your posts). Why should anyone accept your point?



To summarise:

Harrit et al

Red layer -

Rhomboid particles: Fe2O3
Hexagonal platelets: Don't know.
Carbon Matrix: Don't know.

Gray layer: Don't know.

Sunstealer (Days after looking at the data in Harrit et al.)

Red layer:

Rhomboid particles: Fe2O3 pigment.
Hexagonal platelets: Kaolin
Carbon Matrix: Possible epoxy.

Gray layer: Oxidised steel.

Millette

Red layer:

Rhomboid particles: Fe2O3 pigment.
Hexagonal platelets: Kaolin
Carbon Matrix: Epoxy

Gray layer: Steel.

Using Harrit et al's own data I correctly identified all four constituents of the chips.

Millette identifies all four constituents of the chips and effectively backs up my analysis of 4+ years ago.

Harrit et al get 1/4 right.

Oystein sums it all up perfectly.

It's back onto ignore for you because the whole "iron and silicon rich microspheres" nonsense that your repeat like a parrot doesn't wash.
 
This hinges critically upon the answer to the question:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?​

i fixed it for ya.

Are all red-gray chips from each sample that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields the same material in some samples, altogether different material in some samples, or two or more different materials in some samples.



So truthers have a three-way-choice: The paper is either
Invalid (if authors allow for multiple materials)
or
Disproven by Millette (if authors insist that all chips conforming to the selection criteria, which includes Millette's, are the same material)
or
Incomplete and irreproducible crap (if Harrit et al did use a consistent method to make sure they studied one and the same material, but forgot to tell what it is)

The choices aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. Since the authors remain ambiguous about the central question, I think all three apply at the same time, plus a fourth: The paper is deliberately fraudulent.

once millette takes it upon himself to follow the scientific method and replicate to verify is it the same material or not, then we can make choices.

or he can give a sample to someone who can get the job done.
 
Err, Millette did do some research on the chips. I
some chips....yes. but did he follow the scientific method and replicate the experiments and produce iron and silicon rich microspheres so one can see that they are the same material.
 
"Oystein.

Do you agree that Dr. Harrit et al discovered iron-rich microspheres in the DSC residue of chips originating from 9/11 WTC dust?"
"Yes (depending on what you mean by "iron-rich" and "sphere"), they report such.

Now you - please answer:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.

Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d? (Of you course you DON'T. Nor does Jones claim that they did this test on chips a, b, c or d.)
"

Thank you for replying.

By microsphere, I meant spheres, spheroids, droplets, and Mark Basile's observation of a molten iron films.

And you've read the 2009 Bentham paper which used the term "iron-rich".

I can tell you what some of the paper's scientists had to say;

Dr. Steven Jones said:
"A separate sample was sent to a scientist, Mark Basile working in New England and he also sees the same active red/gray material. I have to say one thing while I am discussing the efforts by Mark Basile. He was the first one to ignite a red/gray chip and observe the spheres, the tiny iron-rich spheres in the residue after the red/gray chip is ignited."

Mark Basile - Chemical Engineer said:
"If you take these chips and section them, and look at them before you ignite them, there are no iron micro-spheres, there are no iron particles, there are no iron films contained in these chips. It is only after you bring them up to their ignition point and they go through their thermitic reaction, that liquid iron is produced and the energy is released. These chips are not naturally occurring."

Dr. Steven Jones said:
"We found that the spheroids that are rich in iron produced by the DSC test, that is, by the ignition of the red material in the DSC, these have a signature that is rich in iron but not enough oxygen to make even FeO. So that indicates to us that the iron has been reduced which again is a signature for the thermite reaction. So the formation of the spheres which implies a very high temperature, over 1400 C and the reduction of the iron oxide to an iron-rich phase indicates that a thermitic reaction has occurred and therefore we are able to call this material, an active thermitic material."

Dr. Harrit said:
"A scientific paper is a set of data and the best hypothesis rationalizing the observations. Fe-rich spheroids are observed after a thermite reaction. Fe-rich spheroids have never been observed unless there was a thermite reaction."

So getting back to your question about resistivity data;

Dr. Harrit said:
"When doing a scientific, instrumental investigation, there always is a great number of control experiments, which are implicit to every serious worker in the field. It is understood by the experienced reader, that these tests have been done, since you cannot put every basic control test image or report every bit of supporting data in a journal article. The articles would be so enormous that no one would bother reading them and no journal would possibly care to print them. There are some things that are implied.
Thus, numerous background studies were carried out which were not reported in the red/grey chips paper."

This seems reasonable.

But what is the point.

You are ignoring the gun that keeps on smoking.

Iron-rich forms, produced by iron-melting temperatures, represents compelling evidence that supersedes Dr. Millette's unpublished opinion that the 9/11 WTC dust red chips looked like innocuous toilet bowl dust (kaolinite).

MM
 
Last edited:
thanks mm
cool, i did not know he sent a sample out. take note millette and chris mohr.
jones-
"A separate sample was sent to a scientist, Mark Basile working in New England and he also sees the same active red/gray material. I have to say one thing while I am discussing the efforts by Mark Basile. He was the first one to ignite a red/gray chip and observe the spheres, the tiny iron-rich spheres in the residue after the red/gray chip is ignited."

i remember basile talking about getting a sample from a museum.
 
Last edited:
thanks mm
cool, i did not know he sent a sample out. take note millette and chris mohr.
jones-
"A separate sample was sent to a scientist, Mark Basile working in New England and he also sees the same active red/gray material. I have to say one thing while I am discussing the efforts by Mark Basile. He was the first one to ignite a red/gray chip and observe the spheres, the tiny iron-rich spheres in the residue after the red/gray chip is ignited."

i remember basile talking about getting a sample from a museum.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1TwVACENAo Where is the Aluminum oxide? Where? How will you wave your hands that hard? First flight by hand waving?

Funny stuff, it is not thermite. Looks like sugar, or vermiculite. Jones has lied for 7 years. Millette wins, and is backed up with no damage by thermite to any steel at the WTC on 911. Now what? Keep posting, hoping your fantasy will come true?

90 degrees off on the DSC? Not thermite, and this proof is in the Jones paper published in a vanity journal. oops http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111JonesDelusion.jpg
90 degrees C off, that is significant, and can't be explained by you, Jones or Harrit - Old Harrit will say 2/3 of the energy released during collapse is gone, hands wave, and gone. No chemistry, and no physics. Lucky Millette is not a 911 truther.

Please explain why the DSC is off by 90 degree C? Anything? No, you will ignore, and repeat some other failed Jones failed paper point.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/JetFuelandWoodBeatThermite.jpg
I don't understand why Jones fake thermite does not match real thermite in energy. Why? You can't answer that without major hoopla.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/JonesHarritDelusion.jpg
Why would they publish proof they did not find thermite? Insanity, stupidity, or ... what? A lot of "or what".

Lucky Millette left out the "or what" in his study.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for replying.

You're welcome. I had hoped you'd respond in kind, but I find...


So getting back to your question about resistivity data;
...that you give me a nasty LIE instead!

Because my MAIN question wasn't about resistivity data at all! Why do you write such a shameless, bold-faced, bloody lie? How low are you willing to sink? You quoted my question, and thus everybody can see what my question was:
Now you - please answer:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.
​

Please answer this question! The follow-up,
Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d? (Of you course you DON'T. Nor does Jones claim that they did this test on chips a, b, c or d.)​
only serves as a little help with the "ALL the objective criteria" part, and if you were honest (which you manifestly are not) you would answer "no, I do not have any such resistivity to argue from" (but you won't, because you are determined to remain dishonest and a coward).



Please answer the question now, and nothing else:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
List ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom