WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

3uhihh.jpg
 
"Dr. Millette must have read the section of the 2009 Bentham paper describing the results of a simple resistivity test which provided an easy method for further isolating useful low-resistance red/gray chips and eliminating high-resistance red/gray chips like primer paint."
"Stop that dirty rotten lie. It's getting old.

Please answer:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.
Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d? Of you course you DON'T. Nor does Jones claim that they did this test on chips a, b, c or d.

So, MM: Are chips a-d the same material? Yes, no, or don't know?

Only an answer to this question will get you any further. Please answer it honestly.
"

Oystein.

Do you agree that Dr. Harrit et al discovered iron-rich microspheres in the DSC residue of chips originating from 9/11 WTC dust?

MM
 
Oystein.

Do you agree that Dr. Harrit et al discovered iron-rich microspheres in the DSC residue of chips originating from 9/11 WTC dust?

MM

How do you know the spheres were a product of the paints ignition? After welding and spluttering millions of iron microspheres everywhere during construction, whos the say the people in charge of putting the paint on didn't sweep the steel 100% clean before they poured paint all over it? Whos to say the iron spheres you talk about were not there before ignition? buried in between the paint and the steel layer?
 
In an email, Steven Jones told me they found iron-rich spheres AFTER heating their chips and doing the whole DSC thing. They were not there before. I too originally thought it could be from welders' work decades earlier etc, and that may be the case in the WTC dust itself, but the Jones et al test results were: iron-rich spheres created FROM their own heating experiments. Which is why I have found someone who has agreed to take primer paint on steel or rust, heat it up, and compare the "control" unheated chips with chips that have been heated up in a regular fire. If there are iron-rich spheres created in THAT experiment, then we will know that ordinary fires alone can create iron-rich microspheres.
 
In an email, Steven Jones told me they found iron-rich spheres ...
Did Jones explain why his fantasy thermite did not cause damage to any WTC steel on 911? Can Jones explain why the super secret thermite they found did not damage to the WTC?

Jones can't explain why steel at the WTC had no damage from thermite. The reason his paper is worthless.

Iron spheres are found in fires; a fact Jones can't acknowledge, it will ruin his insane claim.

Where is the aluminum oxide?
 
Last edited:
Nope.

Millette extracted the the chips exactly the way Harrit and his group did. Making sure the chips had a red/gray layer and that they were attracted to a magnet. Harrit and his group conclude in their paper that all chips extracted using the above two criteria are thermitic.
nope. you still dont get it. they had different samples.

Millette got different results using the same extraction method proposed by Harrit and his group. This proves that the conclusion in Harrit's paper, that all red/gray chips extracted by a magnet will be thermitic, is completely incorrect.
nope. replication of experiments. PERIOD.

Also, how come they didn't perform resistivity tests on the other three chips in their paper?
supplemental.
 
Millette does not have to do a DSC. No truther has a clue what DSC is used for anyway.
However, Jones and Harrit already proved the dust does not match thermite.

i thought you were going to show me a DSC of "burnt wood and soil" that match the dust Jones has.
 
911 truth can't find DSC, or understand the purpose.

i thought you were going to show me a DSC of "burnt wood and soil" that match the dust Jones has.

I found them in a few seconds. Why can't you? It will ruin your fantasy. I don't have to show you a DSC, you have no clue what DSC is, or why it is used. You believe in woo about thermite being used on 911, which is a lie made up by Jones in 2005, and he got fired from BYU. No big deal, like Santa Claus or Bigfoot, your fantasy is thermite.

Can't find DSC for soil or burnt wood? No wonder you can't see the DSCs don't match.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111JonesDelusion.jpg
They don't match, then it gets funnier as Jones presents heat energies which don't match all over the place.
Jones debunks his lie in the vanity journal paper of woo. No wonder there is no prize for this delusional claptrap.

Play the resistivity card again, I need a laugh before dinner.
 
I found them in a few seconds. Why can't you? It will ruin your fantasy. I don't have to show you a DSC, you have no clue what DSC is, or why it is used. You believe in woo about thermite being used on 911, which is a lie made up by Jones in 2005, and he got fired from BYU. No big deal, like Santa Claus or Bigfoot, your fantasy is thermite.

Can't find DSC for soil or burnt wood? No wonder you can't see the DSCs don't match.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/111JonesDelusion.jpg
They don't match, then it gets funnier as Jones presents heat energies which don't match all over the place.
Jones debunks his lie in the vanity journal paper of woo. No wonder there is no prize for this delusional claptrap.

Play the resistivity card again, I need a laugh before dinner.
since you showed me the dsc for wood and soil, why dont you show everybody. dont be scarred. i found those traces very interesting.
 
since you showed me the dsc for wood and soil, why dont you show everybody. dont be scarred. i found those traces very interesting.
It is self critiquing 911 truth falls for the lies of Jones and Harriett, and think a DSC is needed. It exposes a lack of knowledge in chemistry.

How long will it take you to find the traces? I know thermite was not used on 911; makes your quest a failure.

Where is the damage to steel on 911? Zero was found. Millette can't find thermite in 911 dust unless an etch-a-sketch and rust are mixed up during the collapse.

Gee whiz, no wonder you don't understand Jones paper is nonsense; you don't do real journals; they cost money. Too bad you are not Gage, he makes over 400k a year, and could figure out 911 if he wanted to. All that money could buy subscriptions to real journals; or studies with real money. But Gage is only interested in self-promotion; all the money goes to market his lies to make more money. No study of 911 dust from Gage, he uses the lies of others to fuel his donation machine of woo.

Diesel soot looks like the DSC. What is wrong with it? I was expecting you to explain why I am wrong, but you can't even get out of the box.
 
Last edited:
It is self critiquing 911 truth falls for the lies of Jones and Harriett, and think a DSC is needed. It exposes a lack of knowledge in chemistry.

How long will it take you to find the traces? I know thermite was not used on 911; makes your quest a failure.

Where is the damage to steel on 911? Zero was found. Millette can't find thermite in 911 dust unless an etch-a-sketch and rust are mixed up during the collapse.

Gee whiz, no wonder you don't understand Jones paper is nonsense; you don't do real journals; they cost money. Too bad you are not Gage, he makes over 400k a year, and could figure out 911 if he wanted to. All that money could buy subscriptions to real journals; or studies with real money. But Gage is only interested in self-promotion; all the money goes to market his lies to make more money. No study of 911 dust from Gage, he uses the lies of others to fuel his donation machine of woo.

all i want you to do is show those dsc traces. quit with the hoooopla.
 
all i want you to do is show those dsc traces. quit with the hoooopla.

You are asking an engineer to do work? It cost money. Do you have the money to see the traces? No. Can you find the traces? No.

You believe in fantasy, you can't explain why no steel was damaged by thermite.

What you have is the rant of an insane failed physics professor, fired for spreading woo. And then you are fooled by energy which is off, and a DSC which does not match thermite.

Millette study is find; what did you find wrong? Nothing. You don't understand what DSC is used for. It is funny you want DSC, but can't explain why.

Does Millette understand no steel was damaged by thermite on 911? Do you?

You and Jones have to avoid answering questions, it would ruin the fantasy.

No chemistry, avoid questions. Ironically, there is a bunch of Si in your thermite, which is evidence you don't have metallic Al; which debunks the thermite claim. OOPS. 12 years and you could be a PhD in chemistry, but you picked the lies of Jones; Jones made up thermite for no rational reason, and 911 truth jumped on the boat of no evidence. The best part, the part that make me laugh, 911 truthers have no chemistry background which is exposed when truthers don't ask simple questions, skeptical questions of Jones; His lies are 911 truthers' bible, no questions, only faith. 911 truth spreads BS, comedy for me; Why can't you do simple research to explain what I got wrong; will you ever do it?
 
Last edited:
and maybe they are in his samples. did he once say that his dsc produced chips that had no iron and silicon rich microspheres.

do you not believe in the scientific method? do you think you and millette are better than the scientic method or somehow "higher up" so you dont have to worry about such things and whatever you say goes? millettes samples need to be able to do what jones and crews do...ie produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. once again if you dont know about the scientic method:
wiki-
"Reproducibility is the ability of an entire experiment or study to be reproduced, or by someone else working independently."
You wrote this in response to:
Harrit et al say that chips a-d are thermite.
Did Harrit et al "produce iron and silicon rich microspheres" from chip a, chip b, chip c, or chip d?​
But totally, and cowardly and dishonestly, "forgot" to address what you quoted at all.

Please answer the question:
Did Harrit et al "produce iron and silicon rich microspheres" from chip a, chip b, chip c, or chip d?

its not a doge, its a fact. there are multiple sources of these red gray chips in jones' paper. he did not state that some of the red gray chips did not react in the dsc. millette has anohter lot of the wtc dust. he has not shown that his are the same material...once again...reproducibility.
It's unequivocally and 100% a cowardly and dishonest dodge of the part that you quoted - I wrote:
You are dodging the point that, if you accept that chips a-d are the same, for a set of reasons, then you must also accept that the chips that Millette proved to NOT contain any elemental Al and thus NO thermite are also that same material, for the exact same reasons.​
Would you please address substantially my point:
If you accept that chips a-d are the same, for a set of reasons, then you must also accept that the chips that Millette proved to NOT contain any elemental Al and thus NO thermite are also that same material, for the exact same reasons.

yep...from jones' samples and from what his paper says about his samples.
Why did you cowardly dodge a part of what you quoted? Deliberate dishonesty? You quoted me:
So, Senemut, do you agree that chips a-d are all the same material? Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on!​
But you cowardly dodged the second part: Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on!

Please answer now, in substantial detail: Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on that chips a-d are all the same material!

they worked with this stuff, not you.
What a dishonest coward you are! You again quoted me, and did not reply to what you quoted! What are you afraid of?? I said:
Again: Did Harrit et al heat chips a? Chip b? Chip c? Or chip d? Senemut, yes, no, or you don't know?
Of course you know that answer: There is no indication that any of chips a-d were tested in the DSC or otherwise heated.​
Would you now please give a courages and honest answer to the question: Again: Did Harrit et al heat chips a? Chip b? Chip c? Or chip d? Senemut, yes, no, or you don't know?

Of course, if you are honest and courageous, you will and must answer "I, Senemut do not know". Of course, I fully expect you to remain a dishonest coward who is too afraid to admit that we have no *********** clue whether or not the material that chips a-d represent was heated in the DSC or not, or whether microspheres were produced from it. This means: We can't reproduce the DSC experiment, because Harrit et al, in their incompetence, forgot to give us information on which of the several materials gave which DSC results. So much for reproducibility! If only you had the heart to honestly answer a few questions!


do you mean like henryco's red red chips and the one lone red gray chip he lost! i bet jones would have seen those if they were attracted by the magnet b/c they look similar to the red grays. and they have similar xeds. but jones makes no mention of these red red's. millette makes no mention of multi layer chips that are attracted by the magnet and neither does henryco.
No, I mean like the text that I wrote, that you quoted, that you then completely dodged around like a dishonest coward. See, I wrote:
You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, righ? So: Which of these kinds produce microspheres? You know the answer: It's "we don't know, because the data is insufficient".​
Notice there is a question in it: You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, right? Please answer this question, exactly as I posed it! No dodging! No running away like a coward! No dishonesty!! I did NOT mean "henryco's red red chips" at all, because I did NOT write "red red", I wrote red-gray, you dishonest coward! Don't change my words to suit the question to your dishonest purposes!
Just answer exactly this: You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, right?

And when you have answered that question, then answer the next: So: Which of these kinds produce microspheres?

And dare you not giving an answer that is different from "I, Senemut, have no *********** clue! Harrit et al, in their incompetence, gave us insufficient data!", because everything else would be dishonest! I am sick and tired of your dishonesty, in case you didn't notice yet!

he makes NO mention that one or two or three did not react. all reacted from what the paper tells to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.
He makes no mention either of the fact that they were studying different materials, because the red-gray chips aren't all the same material! That's why the entire DSC stuff is crap, that's why the paper is crap.

As you would admit, if you had already answered all the above question courageously and honestly.

but i am glad that you admit that you are against the scientific method!! take note chris moyer.
You are a liar. I admit no such thing. Stop the dirty bloody lies!

we already went over that and i think even the paper states there may have been more than one reaction.
It does, unfortunately, this addresses only a small part of what I wrote and you quoted, which was:
"In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it? What do Harrit et al say on this matter?"​
Please comment on the first sentence: "In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Do you agree or not? Notice that both these curves exceed the power maximum of Tillotson's 90% pure thermite (ca. 5 W/g) over a span of more than 70 °C, or a duration of more than 7 minutes. This is, as DSC-curves go, a broad signal. The black curve in particular showed an exotherm continuously for more than half an hour! Please comment on this!

Then I want you to answer this: Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it?
No dodging allowed!!
What reaction or reactions are responsible for the exotherm that starts as low as 170 °C for the black curve? Which reaction or reactions is responsible for the width of the curve and the height of the maximum? I give you a hint: It can't be the thermite reaction! Please spell out the answer: What reaction produced the bulk of the black curve?
You may QUOTE Harrit et al when you spell out the answer. After all, I asked you: What do Harrit et al say on this matter? and expected you to actually answer that question - courageously and honestly.

to show you that "wide" dsc curve from tillotson. thats all.
Did Tillotson's thermite reaction produce a wide or a narrow curve? As wide, or as narrow as the black and the green curves?
Please compare the black and the green curves with Tillotson's curves! Do so courageously and honestly! You will find that they are not similar at all, beyond being exotherm!

whose expert opinion is that they put in 2 different types of red gray chips?
Just look at the data! The green and black curves are quite different from the blue and red!

also we know that when farrer burned epoxy "it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19."
No, we do NOT know that!
Please show us Farrer's traces for epoxy!
Please show is the data which informs us on the material that Farrer used! How large were his epoxy samples? What else did they contain?

You gullibly believe some second-hand statement, without supporting data, from the man who is rightly under attack for being responsible for a crap paper.

Show us the data, or admit that you have blind faith in Jones!


And do not forget to address all the things that you quote! Honestly, and courageously. I think the time for your cowardice and dishonesty must come to an end.
 
ill take harrit's word for it when he speaks of the MEK soaked chip since he actually worked with these red gray chips.
What folly! Harrit did NOT work at all with the MEK soaked chip. I am not even at all sure he did any of the experiments reported in the paper! I know that Farrer did most of the analytical work - Fig. 2-11 for sure, and the DSC test. I am fairly sure he did the EDS work on DSC residues. I am fairly sure Jones did the tests on the MEK soaked chip (Fig. 12-18). What did Harrit do? Nothing! He sat a continent away. Harrit was pretty late to the show. Jones invited Harrit to become lead author when BYU didn't want Farrer to appear as lead author of such a crap paper - at least that's what Dirk Gerhardt aka Sitting Bull told me, a German truther who had correspondence with several of the authors and also has a copy of Griscom's peer-review.

And what a gullible fool you are! You take Harrit's word for it? That's assuming the conclusion! The question here is: Do Harrit's comclusions follow validly from their data? You can't just say "I'll take Harrit's word for it", for that would be blind and stupid, uninformed faith!

What a pathetic, dishonest dodge!
This Harrit-letter does not at all address what I wrote and what you quoted:

Those that Harrit et al heated up in a dsc and look at the curve and checked for iron and silicon rich microspheres - did those "look similar via xeds" to chips a-d? Did they "look similar via xeds" to the MEK-soaked chip?

You will admit, I hope, that you have no *********** clue.​
You see, Harrit presents no XEDS-data for chips that they heated up in a dsc. No one did.
He did not show, and did not compare, the XEDS graphs of the MEK-soaked chip, which is off-topic here anyway.

So Senemut, would you please refrain from more dishonest dodges, and directly address my post:

Those chips that Harrit et al heated up in a dsc and look at the curve and checked for iron and silicon rich microspheres - did those "look similar via xeds" to chips a-d? Did they "look similar via xeds" to the MEK-soaked chip?

If you were courageous and honest, your answer would be: "I, Senemut, have no idea. They forgot, in their incompetence, to include XEDS data on those chips".
 
Last edited:
This might help narrow the margin.
From Bazant calculation of entire TTowers mass shed in the dust clouds ~ 20%

“κout= mass shedding fraction = fraction of mass that escapes outside
tower perimeter before the end of crush-down (not afterwards).
Based on video and seismic records,κout≈0.2”
http://www.absolutenetsolutions.com/psych/images2/00 WTC Collapse - Wha#558C6.pdf

Thanks, but afaik, Bazant has the mass of the towers wrong from the start (by a factor of almost 2), I am not at all sure what he bases this mass shedding factor on, and an unknown proportion of that shed mass wouldn't be dust but peeled-off perimeter wall sections.
 
Oystein.

Do you agree that Dr. Harrit et al discovered iron-rich microspheres in the DSC residue of chips originating from 9/11 WTC dust?

MM

Yes (depending on what you mean by "iron-rich" and "sphere"), they report such.


Now you - please answer:

Are chips a-d the same material, yes or no?
Please list ALL the objective criteria that use to make that determination.

Do you have any resistivity data on chip a, b, c, or d? (Of you course you DON'T. Nor does Jones claim that they did this test on chips a, b, c or d.)
 
Senenmut: you truthers are really fine examples of people with pretty bizarre/twisted thinking. You have no problems to believe that Someone Evil bothered with the auxiliary demolition of WTC, although it is very, very apparently absolutely idiotic idea. Perhaps the most idiotic idea ever. On the other hand, you have troubles to believe that wood burns under air (as well as any other organic material), giving exotherms! Mankind has known for tens of thousands years that wood burns when heated, you have not noticed yet? It is no need to measure DSC of its burning, it is pretty well known process, thanks to which mankind e.g. survived Ice Age. You really need the scientific proofs that wood burns, showing exotherms? Silly… Unbelievable:rolleyes:

And back to WTC chips... Once upon a time, Harrit et al explicitly claimed that WTC chips (a) to (d) are nanothermite. They are not, why? Their properties are fully compatible with some red paint on rust flakes. I think that Sunstealer wrote that he could bet even his life that these chips were simply paint chips, more specifically Laclede primer paint chips. Indeed, I fully agree with Sunstealer. Jim Millette clearly showed by several methods us that this kind of chips contains kaolinite as a source of Al and Si XEDS signals. Here is again a comparison of the micrographs of Harrit’s chips (a) to (d) and corresponding Millette’s chips:

Harrit:
picture.php


Millette:
picture.php


picture.php


It is beyond any reasonable doubts that these chips are all the same, more specifically some paint, which had to be present in the WTC dust. And it is clear that XEDS spectra of chips (a) to (d) are in almost ideal agreement with the simulated spectra of the Laclede primer:

picture.php


You truthers simply lost, deal with it. And for Harrit himself, it is a sad end of his scientific carrier. As a chemist, he really had to spend much more time in the search how paints (and polymers) can behave and look. He is a total loser now and he fully deserves it.
 
Last edited:
[my bold]
From email correspondence between chemical engineer T. Mark Hightower and Niels Harrit:
On July 27, 2011, Niels Harrit (chief author of the 2009 nanothermite paper) presented a calculation for how much thermitic material would have been necessary to explain the presence of the many tiny iron-rich spheres in the dust (assuming that a thermite reaction was the source of the spheres).
He gave a range of numbers, based on lower and higher concentrations of the thermite formulation. His lowest figure amounted to 29,000 metric tons of thermitic explosive per tower – a value hundreds of times greater than the calculation for conventional explosives. His “conservative” estimate (based on 10% iron-oxide in the thermitic material) was 143,000 metric tons of thermitic material that would have been placed in each tower. http://www.veteranstoday.com/2011/08/27/nanothermite-if-it-doesnt-fit-you-must-acquit/
[note: thermitic material is red layer only per Bentham paper]​
...

There is no link to Harrit's July 27, 2011calculation, or did I miss it?

Interesting bit is the 10% iron-oxide thing - I wonder what Harrit based this on! And if he has a similar estimate for Al!

After all, since pure thermite is a tad less than 75% iron oxide, 10% iron oxide in the red layer means that, effectively, 86% of the red layer is not thermite. It means that thermite provides only less than 0.53 kJ/g of energy to the red layer material, even if you assume enough elemental Al and a perfect reaction efficiency.

The DSC-tests measured 1.5 to 7.5 kJ/g for entire chips (including the inert gray layer!), that 2,8x to 14.1x the maximum possible yield from Harrit's estimate of thermite content.
So Harrit implicitly confirms that the DSC curves are dominated by exotherm reactions that are NOT the thermite reaction.

If pure thermite reaches a temperature of 2500 °C when it reacts, then mixing 14% thermite with 86% non-thermite would yield a composite temperature of roughly 350 °C (depending on the relative heat capacities) - not enough to melt any metal or produce any gas.

Harrit implicitly confirms that the red layer, if it contained thermite at all, would be impotent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom