You would also think with that much thermite, someone would have found a piece of steel that shows the effect.![]()
Well it was in America! It must be magic
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrOHjcf30-g&feature=youtube
You would also think with that much thermite, someone would have found a piece of steel that shows the effect.![]()
To cover his arse, perhaps? He was the actual lead author of the Bentham paper and chiefly responsible for the bad science and false conclusions in it. Why would he NOT lie about it?number one, it makes sense and number two, i believe farrer did do it. why would he lie about such a simple experiment.
Stop moving the goal post.haha!! who is the real gullible one here. that would be you trying to associate millette chips to jones chips when millette did not replicate the experiments and produce iron and silicon rich microspheres!!
Again: Did Harrit et al heat chips a? Chip b? Chip c? Or chip d? Senemut, yes, no, or you don't know?all i/we can say are they are similar but they are not conclusively the same material until he starts to replicate, replicate, replicate!
You gullibly fell for a simple, sneaky trick: That graph (which, by the way, clearly shows that that chips behaves significantly DIFFERENTLY from the nanothermite reference and hence is NO evidemce for thermite) shows only one of the four traces. The blue curve. Which, although being very much different from the reference, is still the least different.
This could be further turned into a desperate attempt to defend Harrit et al. Just claim chips a-d are paint, but the DSC chips are different. They just happened to be superthermite, unlike a-d and the MEK chip. This is why they make spheres. To rule this possibility out, Millette needs to show that paint can make the spheres in the DSC.
Based on this observations, we conclude that the red layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust is active, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or explosive material.
not right. they look similar via xeds but until ya heat it up in a dsc and look at the curve and check for iron and silicon rich microspheres, then maybe we can say they are the "same."
This is a clear contradiction to the conclusion of their paper:
Dr. Millette must have read the section of the 2009 Bentham paper describing the results of a simple resistivity test which provided an easy method for further isolating useful low-resistance red/gray chips and eliminating high-resistance red/gray chips like primer paint. ...
Now that song is stuck in my head, thanks
From reading the 2009 Bentham paper, Dr. Millette knew that Dr. Harrit et al found great significance in the behaviour of certain red/gray chips that were isolated from the 9/11 WTC dust and heated to approximately 430C.
Dr. Millette could easily have heated some of his "chips of interest" higher than the 400C 'cap' he used for his still unpublished paper.
MM
and maybe they are in his samples. did he once say that his dsc produced chips that had no iron and silicon rich microspheres.Harrit et al say that chips a-d are thermite.
Did Harrit et al "produce iron and silicon rich microspheres" from chip a, chip b, chip c, or chip d?
its not a doge, its a fact. there are multiple sources of these red gray chips in jones' paper. he did not state that some of the red gray chips did not react in the dsc. millette has anohter lot of the wtc dust. he has not shown that his are the same material...once again...reproducibility.You are dodging the point that, if you accept that chips a-d are the same, for a set of reasons, then you must also accept that the chips that Millette proved to NOT contain any elemental Al and thus NO thermite are also that same material, for the exact same reasons.
yep...from jones' samples and from what his paper says about his samples.So, Senemut, do you agree that chips a-d are all the same material? Give reasons: What data do you base your opinion on!
they worked with this stuff, not you.Again: Did Harrit et al heat chips a? Chip b? Chip c? Or chip d? Senemut, yes, no, or you don't know?
Of course you know that answer: There is no indication that any of chips a-d were tested in the DSC or otherwise heated.
do you mean like henryco's red red chips and the one lone red gray chip he lost! i bet jones would have seen those if they were attracted by the magnet b/c they look similar to the red grays. and they have similar xeds. but jones makes no mention of these red red's. millette makes no mention of multi layer chips that are attracted by the magnet and neither does henryco.You agree that there are different kinds of materials among the magnetically attracted red-gray chips, righ? So: Which of these kinds produce microspheres? You know the answer: It's "we don't know, because the data is insufficient".
he makes NO mention that one or two or three did not react. all reacted from what the paper tells to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.You see, Jones is responsible for a crap paper; the DSC test merits no replication, as he forgot to tell us which if the several kinds of red-gray chips they used there.
we already went over that and i think even the paper states there may have been more than one reaction."In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it? What do Harrit et al say on this matter?"
to show you that "wide" dsc curve from tillotson. thats all.Then you went ahead and showed NOT the black and green curves. Why, Senemut? Was that deliberate? Was that consciously dishonest? Were you hoping to fool me, or are you yourself so profoundly fooled by Harrit et al?
whose expert opinion is that they put in 2 different types of red gray chips?You see, if you knew how to read DSC traces, you'd realize that they put at least two different kinds of red-gray chips in the DSC. In all of them, something that is NOT thermite burned on air and was responsible for the most part of the DSC traces. Unfortunately, Harrit et al, in the incompetence or dishonesty, forgot to give us hints which of the several different kinds of materials they wasted in this utterly stupid experiment.
Those that Harrit et al heated up in a dsc and look at the curve and checked for iron and silicon rich microspheres - did those "look similar via xeds" to chips a-d? Did they "look similar via xeds" to the MEK-soaked chip?
You will admit, I hope, that you have no *********** clue.
Originally Posted by Senenmut
?
wrong?
replication of experiments.....thats science ya know.
did millette get iron and silicon rich microspheres?
please tell how one would get iron and silicon rich microspheres from millettes chips?
Originally Posted by Redwood
Try burning the organic resin matrix in an oxygen-containing atmosphere, as Harrit and Jones did with their paint chips.
Oh wait, they're really thermite cleverly disguised at paint, down to the metallic aluminum and silicon platelets made to resemble common aluminum silicate (kaolinite).
In which case, they will ignite under an inert atmosphere. Get back to us when Harrit & Jones do this.
Originally Posted by Senenmut
they did:
"When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things."
http://911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses
Originally Posted by Senenmut
show us a paint product on steel that produces iron and silicon rich microspheres around 430C.
Originally Posted by Redwood
Harrit and Jones's chips would be one. You can duplicate this yourself by igniting any red primer with a combustible base that also contains kaolinite. You'll have no problem finding them, guaranteed.
Originally Posted by Senenmut
please tell us how this would work?
Originally Posted by Redwood
You could also inform us as to purpose of silicon or silicon compounds in H&J's purported thermite, other than to reduce energy yield per unit weight. Maybe you can ask H&J and pass it on.
Originally Posted by Senenmut
i think basile said it might provide fluidity.
Dr. Millette must have read the section of the 2009 Bentham paper describing the results of a simple resistivity test which provided an easy method for further isolating useful low-resistance red/gray chips and eliminating high-resistance red/gray chips like primer paint.
Dr. Millette must have observed a large number of red/gray chips in his pile after using the basic chip isolation method described in the 2009 Bentham paper.
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31].
ill take harrit's word for it when he speaks of the MEK soaked chip since he actually worked with these red gray chips.
http://www.ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf
you still dont get it. from the bolded above, they might of had all thermitic chips. im glad you recognize jones had thermitic chips!! now that you understand that, you can see that millette had a different type of red gray chip.
Bad Boy,
Niels Harrit has in fact said in interviews in the past that he thinks that there must have been thousands of tons of this nano-thermite in the buildings, since so much was left over! This from their observation or estimation that about 0.1% of the dust samples were, by weight, red-gray chips. If they suppose that total mass of the debris was, say, 1 million tons, and a good proportion of that was turned to dust - say, 100,000 tons, then 0.1% of that is 100 tons. BUT what they find in the dust is merely the unburned left-overs of the hypothetical thermite, so originally there should have been ... well, let's boldly speculate ... a hundred times as much, or 10,000 tons.
Tackling this from a different angle: That infamous "6 wt-% of the dust are iron microspheres, says RJ Lee" translates to ... 6,000 tons of iron microspheres total, and if these are the product of thermite, this means 12,000 tons of thermite total.
Of course this begs the question: Why isn't there about as much aluminium oxide, or 3% by weight Al in the dust?
As for the much more reasonable "it's paint" hypothesis: A while ago, BasqueArch calculated an estimate for the total surface of structural steel in both towers:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8058454&postcount=2109
I took his work and estimates that this amounts to roughly 75 tons of paint on structural steel, both of tje twin towers combined. If 1% of that surface flakes off during the collapse and enters the dust (0.75 tons of paint), taking an equal, but heavier layer of oxidized steel with it (gray layer), then we would expect to find "some" (single-digit number of) tons of red-gray chips in the dust.
It is difficult to estimate the amount of dust that was created and settled outside the immediate debris pile. I usually go with an assumption of very roughly 50,000 tons. A few tons of paint chips would be 0.01% of this, so what Harrit et al. reported is one order of magnitude above my expectation. Then again, my inputs have considerable margin of error, and I have yet not accounted for paints other than which was applied to the structural steel of the twins.
Ok. ~12,000 tons of thermite painted onto WTC1,2 steel structure to melt it. How much surface area of steel would this be?