WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Can you show us the data that Jones refers to here?
Can you give us details of the epoxy paint that Jones refers to here?
No?
Oh!
So you just believe Jones, right? Because he is the authority whom you will believe, no matter what, right?
number one, it makes sense and number two, i believe farrer did do it. why would he lie about such a simple experiment.

You are gullible.

haha!! who is the real gullible one here. that would be you trying to associate millette chips to jones chips when millette did not replicate the experiments and produce iron and silicon rich microspheres!! all i/we can say are they are similar but they are not conclusively the same material until he starts to replicate, replicate, replicate!

By the way: In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it? What do Harrit et al say on this matter?
very broad? just like tillstson very broad curve.

 
Congratulations to senenmut for his replication of using the words "iron and silicon rich microspheres" :D
 
Curves don't match, except in the minds of 911 truth followers, a cult of thermite

number one, it makes sense and number two, i believe farrer did do it. why would he lie about such a simple experiment.



haha!! who is the real gullible one here. that would be you trying to associate millette chips to jones chips when millette did not replicate the experiments and produce iron and silicon rich microspheres!! all i/we can say are they are similar but they are not conclusively the same material until he starts to replicate, replicate, replicate!


very broad? just like tillstson very broad curve.

[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_285445198c414e5e1d.jpg[/URL]
Proof in Jones paper that they found dust, not thermite.

thum_285445198c414e5e1d.jpg

The curves don't match. You debunk yourself, but you don't know it. Wow.

The DSC does not match. The curves don't match; In fact the curve for Jones Fake Themite matches burnt wood, or soil. The DSC for burnt wood and soil match the dust Jones has. BINGO. Do you do any rational research?

Do you think before you post the DSC that shows the samples don't match thermite?

Did you see the energy release from the dust does not match thermite?

no, you don't care, you have the super fantasy of thermite. You want Millette to do tests which don't identify themite because Harrit and Jones did the test to fool you and a few fringe conspiracy theorists. And they did.
 
Last edited:
lets see those.....
Got some money to pay? I am an engineer, min 4k per day. You expect me to produce reality? Will you understand, drop the fantasy of thermite? No.

You posted proof and now move the goal posts. Why are the DSC different? Why is DSC a waste of time? Why is DSC not suited for more than fooling gullible conspiracy theorists?

Why can't you do research? Research and simple understanding of chemistry and reading comprehension show Jones and Harrit's conclusion is nonsense, or a lie. Research defeats the fraud, and will help understand Millette, and reality.

Look them up. Search for matching curves, it will be funny when you find them and understand Jones made up thermite with no evidence. Please lets see the damage to WTC steel by thermite.

lol, you are more likely to find the curves (100% more), than thermite damage to WTC steel (zero%). 12 years are near - and no joy for 911 truth. 12 solid years of failure.
 
Last edited:
Research defeats the fraud, and will help understand Millette, and reality.

your exactly right that research defeats fraud. when millette does the research to replicate jones' chips and does a dsc or heat his above 430C or a resistivity test then we can talk.

the reality is millette needs to replicate. do you think millette would do different tests if he got some of jones' chips?

do you think serious researchers would do other tests on millettes chips?
 
your exactly right that research defeats fraud. when millette does the research to replicate jones' chips and does a dsc or heat his above 430C or a resistivity test then we can talk.

the reality is millette needs to replicate. do you think millette would do different tests if he got some of jones' chips?

do you think serious researchers would do other tests on millettes chips?
After that, does he have to wear the same clothes and stand on one foot like they will claim they did?

Why do tests that don't prove anything?

Are samples a-d the same material? If so, why would you ask Millette to reproduce tests on the same material?
 
... a resistivity test then we can talk.

...?

There is no damage to steel at the WTC due to thermite. Thus, thermite is a fantasy; like Bigfoot or Santa Claus. A lost argument due to evidence. Your fantasy thermite is nonsense.

What does a resistivity test have to do with thermite? Explain in detail.

Got any media attention for the fantasy yet? Bigfoot gets more reality based press coverage.
 
After that, does he have to wear the same clothes and stand on one foot like they will claim they did?

after that, we would have the results that either confirm that millettes chips produce iron and silicon rich microspheres or not.
 
after that, we would have the results that either confirm that millettes chips produce iron and silicon rich microspheres or not.
Iron and silicon rich micro-spheres occur in fires like the WTC. Does not mean thermite. It means you are desperate to keep your fantasy.
 
Why wouldn't Millettes' chips behave the same? They are chemically identical, right?

not right. they look similar via xeds but until ya heat it up in a dsc and look at the curve and check for iron and silicon rich microspheres, then maybe we can say they are the "same."
 
not right. they look similar via xeds but until ya heat it up in a dsc and look at the curve and check for iron and silicon rich microspheres, then maybe we can say they are the "same."

Who told you that ?

Was it MM ?
 
lol
:rolleyes:

you havent been paying attention. just start off on page one of this thread and read from there.

Lol :rolleyes:

Why don't you read this page :D sunstealers post is a good explanation or perhaps you could give me a good explanation as to why DSC is the only way to establish if the red gray chips are thermite ?

How about you explain to me how the DSC curves are the same when they peak at different temperatures ?
 
Lol :rolleyes:

Why don't you read this page :D sunstealers post is a good explanation or perhaps you could give me a good explanation as to why DSC is the only way to establish if the red gray chips are thermite ?
so you would take a sunstealer quote over the scientific method!! the dsc is to find out if millettes chips have a similar curve and to see if the produce iron and silicon microspheres.

How about you explain to me how the DSC curves are the same when they peak at different temperatures ?
considering there are variations from spot to spot on the chips and variations from chip to chip, that could be why there is variation to the curves.

one of the main points about what millette found is that his chips are epoxy based.
and from the dsc curve of epoxy we find that:
"When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things."

use your brain and dont allow people like sunstealer to tell ya what to think. him and oystein dont want to follow the scientifc method and REPLICATE the experiments.
 
so you would take a sunstealer quote over the scientific method!! the dsc is to find out if millettes chips have a similar curve and to see if the produce iron and silicon microspheres.


considering there are variations from spot to spot on the chips and variations from chip to chip, that could be why there is variation to the curves.

one of the main points about what millette found is that his chips are epoxy based.
and from the dsc curve of epoxy we find that:
"When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things."

use your brain and dont allow people like sunstealer to tell ya what to think. him and oystein dont want to follow the scientifc method and REPLICATE the experiments.

Oh I get it, you want me to use brain and believe people like Jones. :D

Jones was under the impression he had found thermite without any experiments, he watched it pouring out of one of the towers :D

He wrote a paper where he shows fire fighters dipping their hands in molten metal :D he also show diagonal cuts on the steel at the base of the towers supposedly made by thermite, I was under the impression the collapse of the towers started towards the top.

I think it's you that needs to use your brain, Tons of thermite igniting with no bright light.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom