WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

If they were making such an absurd claim, why would they expose such a fraud by including a few paragraphs discussing the use of the Resistivity test to remove red/gray paint chips, if they believed all the magnetically collected red/gray chips were thermitic?

MM

Chips? Plural? They tested one! Here is the quote, direct from the paper.

7. Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?

We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very
little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A multimeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the
formula:

Specific resistivity = RA / L
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2
); L
= thickness (m).

Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5
mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude
less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31].

RED CHIP. SINGULAR. ONE.

They published results regarding four chips. What happened to the resistivity test on the other three? Which chip of the four in the paper had the resisitivty test performed on it?
 
depends on who's sample ya got!;) millette chips vs jones chips

Contradicting yourself? I thought you said that Millette did have the correct chips?

So you agree that Millette had the correct chips based on the two criteria used for extraction in Harrit's paper (visual red/gray layers, attracted to a magnet)?
yes. but remember scientific replication of experiments. produce those pesky iron and silicon rich microspheres and then we can talk.
 
Oh MM.

If you would have just read the last paragraph of their paper...



It doesn't say some, a few, many, a couple, half, 75%, 50%, etc. They imply ALL of the red/gray chips they discovered. Furthermore, nowhere in their paper do they state that their tests and experiments yield anything BUT results that prove the chips to be thermitic.

Question;

If there were unreacted thermite chips in the dust couldn't you just throw a handful of dust into a heating device and watch the bright sparks as the thermite reacted?

Also, does thermite even form chips, from what I've seen of it (only on tv) it looks more like a powder than a solid.
 
you ignore the fact that millette did not get iron and silicon rich microspheres.

Millette did DSC experiments?

If Millette had the correct chips as you finally agreed, how did he get different results??? According to the last paragraph of their paper quoted below, all the red/gray chips were thermitic.

Be careful, he is trying to fool you, Gamolon!
 
Last edited:
Here is a quote from Jones in a letter he wrote to a scientist:

Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.

It is clear that he is saying that they used the resistivity test, in addition to the red/gray layer and magnetic attraction criteria to make sure they had non-paint chips.
On a careful read, I don't read that. I see that implied, not explicitly said. I bet Jones will avoid any direct answer to whether they used the resistivity test for isolation, as that would expose his double standards of requiring others to do it without having doing it themselves. But as long as he can get away with implying it, he's safe.


Also, let me put special emphasis in one part of Harrit's email, for the benefit of other readers:

Harrit's email said:
The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".
That is indeed the only rational interpretation of the paper: the resistivity test is just part of the battery of tests performed on a random sample of the already isolated chips. MM just wants to grasp that straw and is thus stretching the paper's meaning beyond that interpretation (shared by Harrit himself), just because Jones is trying to save his butt by claiming Millette had the wrong chips (which he didn't) and MM is buying it.

But I don't think there's a point. In protecting their beliefs, both MM and Senenmut have reached a level of nonsense that makes it difficult or impossible to hold a rational conversation with them. And WTCDust is following the same path and will soon be there.


They published results regarding four chips. What happened to the resistivity test on the other three? Which chip of the four in the paper had the resisitivty test performed on it?
That question assumes that the chip tested for resistivity was one of chips a-d. I think that assumption is wrong. Looking at the spectrum of the MEK-soaked chip, it's clear that they used very different chips for each test.
 
ok, thanks Oystein. That was interesting,

12,000 tones of thermite! wow. I assume that would be kind of difficult to hide. I mean you would require all the ignition wiring etc on top of that. The whole idea is so ridiculous.

Who needs the thermite to react at all? The buildings would collapse just out of the overload.

:D
 
If Millette had the correct chips as you finally agreed, how did he get different results??? According to the last paragraph of their paper quoted below, all the red/gray chips were thermitic.

you still dont get it. from the bolded above, they might of had all thermitic chips. im glad you recognize jones had thermitic chips!! now that you understand that, you can see that millette had a different type of red gray chip.
 
Which proves Harrit's paper wrong!

?
wrong?
replication of experiments.....thats science ya know.
did millette get iron and silicon rich microspheres?

please tell how one would get iron and silicon rich microspheres from millettes chips?

also from what oystein will not answer:

show us a paint product on steel that produces iron and silicon rich microspheres around 430C.

remember those multilayer chips. millette did not find any of those. coincidence?
 
Thank you for making your question more clear.

I have no disagreement with Figs 7 & 8. The 2009 Bentham paper properly identifies them. They show XEDS spectra and BSE images for 4 red chips. Each of these red chips were selected as 'chips of interest' and their a-d designation tells us the geographical location at which their parent 9/11 WTC dust was found.
This statement does not accept that the samples labelled a-d in the Harrit et al paper are the same material.

Now you are getting to the real issue.

I am absolutely sure than Dr. Millette knows exactly what he is doing.
Good. So why do you refuse to acknowledge the fact that he successfully separated the same type of chips, using the same methods that Harrit et al used?

There is a case that can be made that Dr. Millette never fully read the 2009 Bentham paper.
This is a ludicrous statement. You have already agreed above that Millette is competent. I'll remind you of your own statement:

I am absolutely sure than Dr. Millette knows exactly what he is doing..
So in the same post you are saying that Millette is competent yet incompetent.

Please make your mind up.

And as a result of not taking advantage of what Dr. Harrit et al learned during early testing of the 'chips of interest', Dr. Millette worked from a much larger cache of 9/11 WTC dust red chips than necessary.
No he didn't. WTC dust is WTC dust no matter the amount. Harrit et al, as you well acknowledge had access to dust from 4 locations. That amount is enough to make deductions just as Harrit et al claim. Harrit had access to enough dust, to claim that Millette had access to more and therefore he didn't have isolate the same material is nonsense.

Un-ignited 'chips of interest' would have existed in Dr. Millette's isolation pile but their numbers would have been few compared to the volume of primer paint chips that would have been encountered.
Rubbish. There is no way you can substantiate this. Secondly, if you claim that primer paint chips were present in the dust in such a significant number or proportion then why didn't Harrit et al identify such material in their paper? Why didn't they expressly state that their so claimed thermitic material had been separated from ordinary primer paint chips? They make absolutely no claim in the paper that they identified primer paint! None whatsoever. You are claiming that primer paint was abundant in the WTC dust yet the paper you support makes absolutely no mention of this.

Why is that? Have you contacted the authors to back your statement? The fact of the matter is the authors of Harrit et al claim that all red/gray chips extracted by their own methods are thermite.

Certainly Dr. Millette would have realized after his magnetic extractions that he had a lot of red chips matching the visual description provided by Dr. Harrit et al.
Of course he did. He even says so in his progress report! That is why he used a specific criteria, based solely upon the Harrit at al paper to ensure he identified chips that were the same as Harrit et al isolated as stated in their paper.

But his only criteria for selecting his chips of interest for further analysis, was that they were attracted by a magnet and that they had an EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum.
Of course! That was the best way of ensuring that he could narrow down chips of interest and then further analyse those chips to see if they matched the chips a-d.

He then alanyses those "chips of interest" and finds that they exactly match all of the characteristics of chips a-d in Harrit et al.

If you think that he hasn't then please use the readily available data that Millette provides and compare it directly with the data in Harrit et al.

Your list of comparisons certainly reflects an effort to show that Dr. Millette successfully matched the 2009 Bentham paper 'chips of interest'.
It is not an effort, it is simply the same thing that anyone who is interested in the subject would do. It's not hard to compare data. My analysis and list of comparisons can be done with anyone who has the time and inclination to do so. Truthers don't have that interest in detail, it's the reason why you, Senenmut and any other truther wilfully refuse to actually compare the data in Millette's progress report with Harrit et al. It is simple pattern matching. I'm lucky with regard to the fact that I have experience and understanding of what I'm looking at, but it's not difficult to compare photos and figures. I have referenced the Figs I am comparing so that anyone who has a copy of both Harrit et al and Millette's Progress Report can follow and compare the data. This is not hard.

Why don't you or Senenmut pick a comparison that I have pointed out and look at the data for yourself and then comment on it? Here is an earlier comparison from a post that no truther would comment on:

picture.php


Why do you refuse to comment on the similarities in these images?

Why do you completely refuse to compare Millette's data with the data in Harrit et al?

What are you afraid of? If you had belief in Harrit et al then why do you refuse to look at the data?


But only the two sides involved in the research of these chips can argue for or against the credibility of your list.
Nope. My list was written so that anyone could understand and follow it and the reasoning behind it. I even provided the references to each Fig I was comparing so anyone who had a copy of Millette's Progress report and a copy of Harrit et al could look at the comparisons for themselves.

It's obvious that you and other truthers either don't have copies of the documents or are unwilling to comment on them. That shows your failings.

Why don't you or other truthers perform a modest study of the similarities/discrepancies between the two? No-one is going to bite your head off for doing so.

The fact is, the Bentham paper authors are not in agreement with Dr. Millette's unpublished convention paper findings
.Of course they aren't! Their paper is trash, their conclusions don't fit with their own data. This point is moot.

They believe Dr. Millette had the misfortune of selecting the wrong 'chips of interest' from a large pile of possibles.
What possibilities? Again you fail to read the paper you champion. All chips that are separated by a magnet are thermite according to Harrit et al. Just look at Fig 31 - it doesn't have any of the characteristics of samples a-d yet the authors claim this chip is thermite.

You really ought to familiarise yourself with the the paper that you claim is proof of thermite before attacking Millette for analysing chips that match the criteria for samples a-d in Harrit et al.

Where does Fig 31 fit into this?

I am not saying that Dr. Millette's methods are faulty, but results speak louder than his words.
His results speak far louder than you can imagine. Not only did he use the same method of extraction from the dust that Harrit et al used, but he also used Harrit et al's own data as a point of reference to ensure that he isolated the same material for further analysis. What's more, he used far more advanced techniques to ascertain what the material he had actually was. It's not our problem that this analysis not only concludes that the material is paint, but also the fact that it completely backs my own analysis of the data found in Harrit et al before Millette had even heard of the paper.

I had already shown a few days after the paper was published, using the very data in Harrit et al, that kaolin was present in the red layer and therefore the material was paint. No truther has ever challenged this successfully. This wasn't some superhuman feat, but simply something that anyone who'd studied materials science or geology etc would be able to do.

It is clear that Dr. Harrit et al had to seek out the chips of interest.
Of course he did. If you hadn't noticed that was the entire point of the exercise.

That attraction by a magnet and a EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum did not guarantee a 'chip of interest'.
Of course it did. Once again you are claiming that Millette is incompetent yet, as shown above, you claim that Millette is competent.

Which is it? Give a reason why this is not so and analyse the data that Millette produces and compare it with the data in Harrit et al.


As Dr. Harrit said, potential red chips were randomly selected and subjected to a number of tests before they were ignited in the DSC. The scientists could not be certain they had a true 'chip of interest' until they ignited it and examined the residue.
No this is completely false. There is absolutely no mention of this in the paper and what's more such a method is ludicrous. Does Dr Harrit know that you are misrepresenting him by pursuing this line?

There is absolutely no indication in the paper to suggest what you are saying. Have you even read the paper?

But they had the pre-DSC test results of every red chip used, thermitic or not.
Oh they did did they? Then you will be quite happy in telly everyone which chips were used in the DSC test and the corresponding data in the paper. For example, in Fig 19, which shows 4 DSC traces, can you please tell us which trace the green trace labelled "white" corresponds to in the Harrit et al paper?

Is it sample a) or d) or the one in Fig 31 or the one subjected to 55hrs of MEK?

What is this chip?

Would you please contact the very people you support to clarify this matter.

For those red chips that proved to be thermitic, they just looked back over the pre-ignition data to obtain greater knowledge about what 'tells' pointed to a possible 'chip of interest'.
The phrase "chips of interest" does not appear in Harrit et al. This phrase is used by Millette to identify chips isolated by the same criteria that Harrit et al used, but were further identified by identifying the similar characteristics that EDX examination of the red layer that showed similarities with samples a-d in Fig 7 of Harrit et al.

Red was a tell.

Magnetic attraction was a tell.
Those were the only tells and the only criteria that Harrit et al subsequently concluded were needed to identify thermite material in the dust.

The Resistivity test was one of those 'tells'. They found that the 'chips of interest' had dramatically low resistance readings (~10 ohms).

With the Resistivity test, they discovered that chips that were primer paint had very high resistance readings (~100,000 ohms).
No it was not. You have already been shown this. The paper makes no mention of this tell, it makes no mention of this in the method of isolation, even the authors of the paper have been quoted as saying that this was not the case. The fact that you continue with this nonsense in contradiction of the very people you support shows that you will do absolutely anything to support your view including blatant lying and falsification.

We can argue over chips 'a-d' forever and get no where.
Nope. The fact that you refuse to acknowledge that chips a-d in Harrit et al are the same material and the fact that the reasons and logic behind such a conclusion leads you to the fact that Millette has the same material is the reason why you won't engage.

Show us using the data readily available why chips a-d are different from the chips Millette performed additional analysis on. You can't You won't even dare try even though it's a trivial exercise as I've shown.

My point is, there were a lot of red chips that were indeed very similar to the 'chips of interest' but while seemingly identical, they did not behave identically when ignited.
No there weren't. Please quote from the Harrit et al paper where the explicitly state that this is true.

Where in Harrit et al do they identify chips that appear identical but do not behave identically when ignited.

You once again are making things up. Why do you think that this will go un-noticed? Surely, even you realise that there are people on JREF that have actually read the Harrit et al paper more timed than you but also can analyse the data within? I can quote Fig without referring to the document - you never refer to the document! lol

But what cannot be argued forever, is why any red chip found in the 9/11 WTC dust would leave iron-rich microspheres in its residue after ignition, where none previously existed.
I can offer an explantion but you will never accept it.

Dr. Harrit et al have published there testable proof of thermite.
No they haven't. If Harrit et al were so confident then why have they refused to release any of the material they claim is thermite to independent researchers? Only the brain-dead, non-scientific, ignorant gullible and naive people believe this paper shows thermite. I showed days after it was released that the material contained kaoilin, a widely mined mineral clay but you ignore all the analysis.

The only way we can tell if 'the emperor has clothes on' is to reproduce the test that lead to the thermite finding and start the discussion from there.

Dr. Millette knows it and you know it.

MM
No. There is no thermite, it's you who are the one walking arounf naked.
 
?

replication of experiments.....thats science ya know.
What about the SEM replication experiments and the similarity between these images?

picture.php


Give a detailed analysis, hell any bloody analysis, as to the differences between the two. You won't dare, but the point makes the rest of us chortle at you.
 
What about the SEM replication experiments and the similarity between these images?

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=845&pictureid=7555[/qimg]

Give a detailed analysis, hell any bloody analysis, as to the differences between the two. You won't dare, but the point makes the rest of us chortle at you.

looks "similar" but will it act similar when heated and produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. keep on replicating those experiments till millette either gets the iron and silicon rich microspheres or not.

from blogger

"When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things."

http://911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses
 
?
wrong?
replication of experiments.....thats science ya know.
did millette get iron and silicon rich microspheres?

please tell how one would get iron and silicon rich microspheres from millettes chips?

Try burning the organic resin matrix in an oxygen-containing atmosphere, as Harrit and Jones did with their paint chips.

Oh wait, they're really thermite cleverly disguised at paint, down to the metallic aluminum and silicon platelets made to resemble common aluminum silicate (kaolinite).

In which case, they will ignite under an inert atmosphere. Get back to us when Harrit & Jones do this.

show us a paint product on steel that produces iron and silicon rich microspheres around 430C.

Harrit and Jones's chips would be one. You can duplicate this yourself by igniting any red primer with a combustible base that also contains kaolinite. You'll have no problem finding them, guaranteed.

Meantime, find us a thermite that doesn't produce voluminous quantities of aluminum oxide (alumina), the sine qua non of the thermite reaction. Why don't H&J's thermite paint chips produce any? Did it go down some singularity and come out in some other part of the universe? Where's the alumina?

You could also inform us as to purpose of silicon or silicon compounds in H&J's purported thermite, other than to reduce energy yield per unit weight. Maybe you can ask H&J and pass it on.
 
you ignore the fact that millette did not get iron and silicon rich microspheres.

You ignore what we were debating, which was: Are the red-gray, and magnetically attracted, chips in WTC dust all of the same material? And hence, were the red-gray, and magnetically attracted, chips that Millette studied and presented of the same material as chips that Harrit et al studied and presented? And more specifically: Did Millette study chips, and show that they are NOT thermite, that were of the same material as chips a-d?

Because, you see, you ignore that Harrit et al claim that chips a-d are nanothermite, while Millette proved that this material contains no elemental Al whatsoever (instead, the Al in this material is bound as inert Al-silicate), and is some paint formulation instead.



To get these points clear, and document you understand the argument, please answer the following questions, and try not to run away cowardly from them any longer:

"These 4 individual panties that I picked from my g/f's drawers are the same make and model"
vs.
"All of my g/f panties are the same make and model"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!


"These 4 individual red-gray, magnetically attracted chips that I picked from my samples of WTC dust are the same material"
vs.
"All red-gray, magnetically attracted chips in all of the WTC dust are the same material"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

If your answer, or reasons, are different, then you will have demonstrated that you don't apply logic properly and consistently.
 
Gamolon said:
If Millette had the correct chips as you finally agreed, how did he get different results??? According to the last paragraph of their paper quoted below, all the red/gray chips were thermitic.
you still dont get it. from the bolded above, they might of had all thermitic chips. im glad you recognize jones had thermitic chips!! now that you understand that, you can see that millette had a different type of red gray chip.

You assume that the bolded part is true, merely because Harrit et al wrote it. That's arguing from blind faith. Formally, that's the fallacy of assuming the conclusion to be true.

The entire point of the debate here is to prove (and it is already proven, only you and MM feign to not get it) that the conclusion is invalid, because a) Harrit et al invalidly conflate data point from experiments done on different kinds of materials, and b) Millette has validly proven that at least one of the materials that Harrit et al studied (that which chips a-d are made of) and concluded to contain thermite most definitely does not contain any thermite at all.
 
...
also from what oystein will not answer:

show us a paint product on steel that produces iron and silicon rich microspheres around 430C.
Dishonest distraction and moving the goal posts.
Dishonest, because, as you perfectly well know, that value of "430 °C" is irrelevant here - Harrit et al heated their chips to 700 °C, not to just 430 °C, and allowed them to burn on air. They do not know what happened at which temperature.
Moving the goal posts, because you deliberately ignore, and feign to not understand, that Harrit et al studied different materials, which makes their conclusions invalid.
As concerns formation of microspheres: Since we have no clue from the Harrit et al paper which of the varios materials in their study gave rise to such sphere when heated slowly to 700 °C under air, we are under no obligation to explain it. The experiment cannot be repeated without them telling us which of the various materials to do it on.

remember those multilayer chips. millette did not find any of those. coincidence?
Remember that Harrit et al did not even study those multilayer chips in any depth, nor did they use any data from those multilayer chips to support their conclusions? It's irrelevant, a distraction, and just another attempt by you to move goal posts in your dishonest and cowardly quest to run away from admitting the basic flaws of Harrit et al.
 
...
from blogger

"When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things."

http://911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses
Can you show us the data that Jones refers to here?
Can you give us details of the epoxy paint that Jones refers to here?
No?
Oh!
So you just believe Jones, right? Because he is the authority whom you will believe, no matter what, right?

You are gullible.

By the way: In Figure 19, the black and green curves are "very broad thermal traces" and not spiked. Also, they prove an energy release far beyond that which thermite can possibly do (>4 kJ/g), which proves unambiguously that something other than thermite burned and contributed significantly to the height and width of those traces. Which is it? What do Harrit et al say on this matter?
 
You ignore what we were debating, which was: Are the red-gray, and magnetically attracted, chips in WTC dust all of the same material? And hence, were the red-gray, and magnetically attracted, chips that Millette studied and presented of the same material as chips that Harrit et al studied and presented? And more specifically: Did Millette study chips, and show that they are NOT thermite, that were of the same material as chips a-d?

Because, you see, you ignore that Harrit et al claim that chips a-d are nanothermite, while Millette proved that this material contains no elemental Al whatsoever (instead, the Al in this material is bound as inert Al-silicate), and is some paint formulation instead.
you are making the mistake that the 2 materials (jones vs millette) are the same material.

remember scientific replication of experiments. did millette get iron and silicon rich microspheres. what did millettes dsc look like?


To get these points clear, and document you understand the argument, please answer the following questions, and try not to run away cowardly from them any longer:

"These 4 individual panties that I picked from my g/f's drawers are the same make and model"
vs.
"All of my g/f panties are the same make and model"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!


"These 4 individual red-gray, magnetically attracted chips that I picked from my samples of WTC dust are the same material"
vs.
"All red-gray, magnetically attracted chips in all of the WTC dust are the same material"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

If your answer, or reasons, are different, then you will have demonstrated that you don't apply logic properly and consistently.
there is nothing to talk about here. once again, have you heard of replication of experiments?
 
Try burning the organic resin matrix in an oxygen-containing atmosphere, as Harrit and Jones did with their paint chips.
they did:

"When Dr Farrer burned epoxy paint in the DSC, it gave a very broad thermal trace, NOT at all like the spiked exothermic DSC peak in our Fig 19. This is one of the many tests he did to check things."
http://911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses



Harrit and Jones's chips would be one. You can duplicate this yourself by igniting any red primer with a combustible base that also contains kaolinite. You'll have no problem finding them, guaranteed.
please tell us how this would work?

You could also inform us as to purpose of silicon or silicon compounds in H&J's purported thermite, other than to reduce energy yield per unit weight. Maybe you can ask H&J and pass it on.

i think basile said it might provide fluidity.
 
You assume that the bolded part is true, merely because Harrit et al wrote it. That's arguing from blind faith. Formally, that's the fallacy of assuming the conclusion to be true.

blind faith? i see in the paper all the chips they put through the dsc to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres?

how many of millettes chips produced iron and silicon rich microspheres?


The entire point of the debate here is to prove (and it is already proven, only you and MM feign to not get it) that the conclusion is invalid, because a) Harrit et al invalidly conflate data point from experiments done on different kinds of materials, and b) Millette has validly proven that at least one of the materials that Harrit et al studied (that which chips a-d are made of) and concluded to contain thermite most definitely does not contain any thermite at all.
no. millette did not prove by replication of experiments that his chips are the same to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

therefor jones has a thermitic type and millette does not. its very easy to see. just think and keep in mind scientific replication of experiments. its a cornerstone of science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom