WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Bottom line: Difficult to dissolve or not, no epoxy was dissolved from the layered chips. I can't pretend to know what people's motivations for attempting to do things, but the attempt surely did fail.

No. Wrong.

The bottom line is that you pretended to know that certain solvents are expected to dissolve epoxy, when in fact you did NOT know this, and you don't have the honesty, integrity and character to admit that you were wrong.

This is what makes you a truther: The unability to admit, even to yourself, that you are wrong.
 
Show where the 2009 Bentham paper made such a claim.

They claim that of those red/gray chips that were found to be thermitic, all were attracted to a magnet.

They never claimed that all the red/gray chips attracted to a magnet were found to be thermitic.

If they were making such an absurd claim, why would they expose such a fraud by including a few paragraphs discussing the use of the Resistivity test to remove red/gray paint chips, if they believed all the magnetically collected red/gray chips were thermitic?

MM

http://www.ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf

MM, have a browse through the above and see what's missing.
 
...
They never claimed that all the red/gray chips attracted to a magnet were found to be thermitic.

If they were making such an absurd claim
...

Glad that you start to sense how absurd Harrit et al's claims are. But:

You forgot, or dishonestly or cowardly chose not to, answer the question:

Do you agree that chips a-d are the very same material? Give reasons!

The "give reasons" question is, more precisely:
"List all the objective criteria by which you decide that two red-gray, magnetically attracted particles, drawn from a sample of WTC dust, are the same material!"
plus
"Please demonstrate that all these objective criteria apply to each of the four chips a-d!"
 
You are being deliberately dense, right?
Strawman.
No.
I never said "one is thermitic and one not thermitic"
Sunstealer never said "one is thermitic and one not thermitic"
Why do you put these statements in my mouth?
that is what we have. jones chips are thermitic and millette's are not. 2 different type of chips.

I say, and Sunstealer agrees: One type is one paint product on steel, the type second is a second, different paint product on steel, and more types very likely exist that are different paint products still (and there may be also non-paint materials, but we have no data that points there or would allow identification)
show me a paint product that produces iron and silicon rich microspheres around 430C.

remember those multilayer chips. millette did not find any of those. coincidence?
 
So you agree there are two types (maybe more) red/gray, magnetically attracted chips?
one type of red gray chips in jones and crew samples and a different type in henryco and millette's samples.


Then you must disagree with Harrit's paper which concludes that EVERY SINGLE red/gray chip which is extracted from WTC dust via a magnet is thermitic. Is that correct?

there is no disagreeing. read the above statement.
 
So you agree that Millette had the correct chips based on the two criteria used for extraction in Harrit's paper (visual red/gray layers, attracted to a magnet)?

yes. but remember scientific replication of experiments. produce those pesky iron and silicon rich microspheres and then we can talk.
 
Hi Senenmut,

I truly appreciate your benevolent view, one I have tried to take as I "assume good intention" with people (even those I disagree with). However, you probably know that "they" tried to discredit Millette's paper before it even came out with misleading statements about Millette: http://digwithin.net/2012/02/17/whe...n-response-to-energetic-materials-at-the-wtc/. Kevin Ryan allowed me to respond on this blog at first, but has not allowed me to post links to Cate Jenkins's actual praises of Millette's integrity. Harrit has used this link to discredit Millette when people ask him about Millette's dust study. I am continuing to try to regain trust and a willingness to work together with them (a long letter respectfully requesting chip samples, the release of data they have not published, allowing me to set the record straight re Millette on Kevin's blog, etc) is going out very soon. I no longer assume good intention and am nervous about the response I will get from my requests. Wish me luck, I'd love to find out that my fears are unfounded and that there may yet be a way to work together. There are people in 9/11 Truth (and you Senenmut may well be one of them) who would favor more cooperation in these studies.

cooperation would be nice!
 
cooperation would be nice!
It will be like discussing Santa Claus, substitute the fantasy of thermite. Why is thermite a fantasy; gee whiz, no steel was damaged by thermite.

When will 911 truth figure out the paper published in a vanity journal has a fake conclusion? Never?

Millette can't find thermite, it did not exist at the WTC. The Jones paper is the same as Millette's except Jones and Harrit added stuff to fool the gullible. They added DSC, which 911 truthers have no clue what DSC is for. The DSC curves for the dust are not close to thermite; more like burnt wood, or dirt. Yes, praise DRG, they found dirt, aka dust. It can't be more of a tragedy for Jones and BYU - what a joke. Has BYU asked Jones to cool his delusional claims? Is BYU a rational school, or do they like crazy claims like Jones added to their legacy?

Unlike Watergate, the thermite claim has no evidence; there will be no Pulitzer for lies and fraud of thermite.

What is wrong with Millette's paper? Why has Jones failed to make the news? Why is there no damage to any WTC steel? Because you believe in a fantasy made up by Jones. Does 911 truth have thermite damage to steel? No damage to steel found. Ends the thermite claim.
 
Thermite? Who cares...It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

We might as well be talking about peanut butter...

one may want to severe a beam from the column. or maybe make a beam buckle. all ya gotta do is reduce the steels thickness by an inch and turn it "razor thin."






 
But none of the beams in your photos buckled.

there were some out there:

One piece Dr. Astaneh-Asl saw was a charred horizontal I-beam from 7 World Trade Center, a 47-story skyscraper that collapsed from fire eight hours after the attacks. The beam, so named because its cross-section looks like a capital I, had clearly endured searing temperatures. Parts of the flat top of the I, once five-eighths of an inch thick, had vaporized.

Less clear was whether the beam had been charred after the collapse, as it lay in the pile of burning rubble, or whether it had been engulfed in the fire that led to the building's collapse, which would provide a more telling clue.

The answer lay in the beam's twisted shape. As weight pushed down, the center portion had buckled outward.

''This tells me it buckled while it was attached to the column,'' not as it fell, Dr. Astaneh-Asl said, adding, ''It had burned first, then buckled.''

http://www.nytimes.com/2001/10/02/science/scarred-steel-holds-clues-and-remedies.html
 
there were some out there:

One piece Dr. Astaneh-Asl saw was a charred horizontal I-beam from 7 World Trade Center, a 47-story skyscraper that collapsed from fire eight hours after the attacks. The beam, so named because its cross-section looks like a capital I, had clearly endured searing temperatures. Parts of the flat top of the I, once five-eighths of an inch thick, had vaporized.

Less clear was whether the beam had been charred after the collapse, as it lay in the pile of burning rubble, or whether it had been engulfed in the fire that led to the building's collapse, which would provide a more telling clue.

The answer lay in the beam's twisted shape. As weight pushed down, the center portion had buckled outward.

''This tells me it buckled while it was attached to the column,'' not as it fell, Dr. Astaneh-Asl said, adding, ''It had burned first, then buckled.''

http://www.nytimes.com/2001/10/02/science/scarred-steel-holds-clues-and-remedies.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buygQ1C2GFs&feature=youtube
 
that is what we have. jones chips are thermitic and millette's are not. 2 different type of chips.


show me a paint product that produces iron and silicon rich microspheres around 430C.

remember those multilayer chips. millette did not find any of those. coincidence?

Nice try to move goal posts. Putting them back where there were, here are the questions to you that you chose, in your dishonesty, and perhaps fear, to ignore and dodge:


For example:
"These 4 individual panties that I picked from my g/f's drawers are the same make and model"
vs.
"All of my g/f panties are the same make and model"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

"These 4 individual red-gray, magnetically attracted chips that I picked from my samples of WTC dust are the same material"
vs.
"All red-gray, magnetically attracted chips in all of the WTC dust are the same material"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

If your answer, or reasons, are different, then you will have demonstrated that you don't apply logic properly and consistently.
 
Nice try to move goal posts. Putting them back where there were, here are the questions to you that you chose, in your dishonesty, and perhaps fear, to ignore and dodge:


For example:
"These 4 individual panties that I picked from my g/f's drawers are the same make and model"
vs.
"All of my g/f panties are the same make and model"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

"These 4 individual red-gray, magnetically attracted chips that I picked from my samples of WTC dust are the same material"
vs.
"All red-gray, magnetically attracted chips in all of the WTC dust are the same material"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

If your answer, or reasons, are different, then you will have demonstrated that you don't apply logic properly and consistently.

you ignore the fact that millette did not get iron and silicon rich microspheres.
 
Show where the 2009 Bentham paper made such a claim.

They claim that of those red/gray chips that were found to be thermitic, all were attracted to a magnet.

They never claimed that all the red/gray chips attracted to a magnet were found to be thermitic.

If they were making such an absurd claim, why would they expose such a fraud by including a few paragraphs discussing the use of the Resistivity test to remove red/gray paint chips, if they believed all the magnetically collected red/gray chips were thermitic?

MM

Oh MM.

If you would have just read the last paragraph of their paper...

Based on these observations, we conclude that the red layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust is active, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or explosive material.

It doesn't say some, a few, many, a couple, half, 75%, 50%, etc. They imply ALL of the red/gray chips they discovered. Furthermore, nowhere in their paper do they state that their tests and experiments yield anything BUT results that prove the chips to be thermitic.
 
So you agree that Millette had the correct chips based on the two criteria used for extraction in Harrit's paper (visual red/gray layers, attracted to a magnet)?
yes. but remember scientific replication of experiments. produce those pesky iron and silicon rich microspheres and then we can talk.

If Millette had the correct chips as you finally agreed, how did he get different results??? According to the last paragraph of their paper quoted below, all the red/gray chips were thermitic.

Based on these observations, we conclude that the red layer of the red/gray chips we have discovered in the WTC dust is active, unreacted thermitic material, incorporating nanotechnology, and is a highly energetic pyrotechnic or explosive material.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom