WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

"...MM fully supports the Harrit et al paper and it's conclusions of thermite, but steadfastly refuses to agree with the authors and their analysis that samples a,b,c and d in Figs 7 & 8 are the same material."

Thank you for making your question more clear.

I have no disagreement with Figs 7 & 8. The 2009 Bentham paper properly identifies them. They show XEDS spectra and BSE images for 4 red chips. Each of these red chips were selected as 'chips of interest' and their a-d designation tells us the geographical location at which their parent 9/11 WTC dust was found.

"The claim that Millette has the wrong chips is obviously wrong and disingenuous too, it obviously implies that Millette doesn't know what he's doing and cannot see that his data doesn't match Harrit et al, except of course his data does match Harrit et al because he used Harrit et al's paper as a basis for his criteria in ensuring he had the right chips to analyse.[/i]"

Now you are getting to the real issue.

I am absolutely sure than Dr. Millette knows exactly what he is doing.

There is a case that can be made that Dr. Millette never fully read the 2009 Bentham paper.

And as a result of not taking advantage of what Dr. Harrit et al learned during early testing of the 'chips of interest', Dr. Millette worked from a much larger cache of 9/11 WTC dust red chips than necessary.

Un-ignited 'chips of interest' would have existed in Dr. Millette's isolation pile but their numbers would have been few compared to the volume of primer paint chips that would have been encountered.

Certainly Dr. Millette would have realized after his magnetic extractions that he had a lot of red chips matching the visual description provided by Dr. Harrit et al.

But his only criteria for selecting his chips of interest for further analysis, was that they were attracted by a magnet and that they had an EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum.

Your list of comparisons certainly reflects an effort to show that Dr. Millette successfully matched the 2009 Bentham paper 'chips of interest'.

But only the two sides involved in the research of these chips can argue for or against the credibility of your list.

The fact is, the Bentham paper authors are not in agreement with Dr. Millette's unpublished convention paper findings.

They believe Dr. Millette had the misfortune of selecting the wrong 'chips of interest' from a large pile of possibles.

I am not saying that Dr. Millette's methods are faulty, but results speak louder than his words.

It is clear that Dr. Harrit et al had to seek out the chips of interest. That attraction by a magnet and a EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum did not guarantee a 'chip of interest'.

As Dr. Harrit said, potential red chips were randomly selected and subjected to a number of tests before they were ignited in the DSC. The scientists could not be certain they had a true 'chip of interest' until they ignited it and examined the residue.

But they had the pre-DSC test results of every red chip used, thermitic or not.

For those red chips that proved to be thermitic, they just looked back over the pre-ignition data to obtain greater knowledge about what 'tells' pointed to a possible 'chip of interest'.

Red was a tell.

Magnetic attraction was a tell.

The Resistivity test was one of those 'tells'. They found that the 'chips of interest' had dramatically low resistance readings (~10 ohms).

With the Resistivity test, they discovered that chips that were primer paint had very high resistance readings (~100,000 ohms).

We can argue over chips 'a-d' forever and get no where.

My point is, there were a lot of red chips that were indeed very similar to the 'chips of interest' but while seemingly identical, they did not behave identically when ignited.

But what cannot be argued forever, is why any red chip found in the 9/11 WTC dust would leave iron-rich microspheres in its residue after ignition, where none previously existed.

Dr. Harrit et al have published there testable proof of thermite.

The only way we can tell if 'the emperor has clothes on' is to reproduce the test that lead to the thermite finding and start the discussion from there.

Dr. Millette knows it and you know it.

MM
 
dprjones '911 termite conspiracy' went into the "0.1%" thing as well, came up with some interesting figures, and pretty much the same conclusion; its bogus.

 
Last edited:
Exactly!
Do you disagree?
Jones seems to be implying that there are (at least) 2 different types of red-gray chips when he suggests that Millette sudied the WRONG kind. Do you see how Jones himself implies there may or must have been at least two kind of red-gray chips?

well im glad you guys think there are 2 types now. sunstealer thought they were one and the same from previous posts.

so one is thermitic and one not thermitic. im glad we can agree on something.
 
Senenmut,

Looking at Jones' statement above that "one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied", how does one do that according to the paper?

According to Jones it was supposedly the resisitivty test in addition to the two criteria.

According to the paper, they tested ONE chip for resistance yet they magically publish results for FOUR chips and conclude that ALL red/gray magnetically attracted chips are thermitic.

How does that work?

BIG mistake.

It proves that Jones is just trying to discredit what Millette found in order to try preserve their paper's so-called integrity.
i dont think they are trying to discredit his paper. it is what it is. im sure its all about the scientific method and being sure what he studied is what they studied.
 
Dr. Harrit et al have published there testable proof of thermite.

The only way we can tell if 'the emperor has clothes on' is to reproduce the test that lead to the thermite finding and start the discussion from there.

Dr. Millette knows it and you know it.

MM

amen to that.
 
Thermite? Who cares...It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

We might as well be talking about peanut butter...
 
amen to that.

You think you have thermite because you were told it was there; no thermite damage to any WTC steel. You have fantasy.

Will Jones, and the insane Harrit be teaming with a newspaper to earn the big Pulitzer; like the guys who got a Pulitzer for Watergate (like the newspaper...)? No. So sad the best 911 truth can do is post lies of thermite when the DSC does not match thermite, and the energy released by the dust does not match thermite - given 4 chances - and they posted the proof they found no thermite - but they said the did - fooling the chemistry free believers in 911 truth lies.


Where is the Pulitzer?

Millette = no thermite - Jones and Harrit fooled those who failed to take chemistry - Millette did not.

Faith based themite lies, amen, you thermite believer guys have a religion of thermite, Jones and Harrit are the prophets. Millette has science, no religion on this topic.
 
well im glad you guys think there are 2 types now. sunstealer thought they were one and the same from previous posts.
Are you acting stupid?
Sunstealer never said all chips are of 1 type.
Sunstealer said: Chips a-d - four specific, individual specimens, are of the same type.
Do you understand the difference between "all X are the same" an "4 X, out of a multitude, are the same"?

For example:
"These 4 individual panties that I picked from my g/f's drawers are the same make and model"
vs.
"All of my g/f panties are the same make and model"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

Now:
"These 4 individual red-gray, magnetically attracted chips that I picked from my samples of WTC dust are the same material"
vs.
"All red-gray, magnetically attracted chips in all of the WTC dust are the same material"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

If your answer, or reasons, are different, then you will have demonstrated that you don't apply logic properly and consistently.

so one is thermitic and one not thermitic. im glad we can agree on something.
You are being deliberately dense, right?
Strawman.
No.
I never said "one is thermitic and one not thermitic"
Sunstealer never said "one is thermitic and one not thermitic"
Why do you put these statements in my mouth?

I say, and Sunstealer agrees: One type is one paint product on steel, the type second is a second, different paint product on steel, and more types very likely exist that are different paint products still (and there may be also non-paint materials, but we have no data that points there or would allow identification)
 
Thank you for making your question more clear.
...

Then why did you not answer the question:

Do you agree that chips a-d are the very same material? Give reasons!


ETA: The "give reasons" question is, more precisely:
"List all the objective criteria by which you decide that two red-gray, magnetically attracted particles, drawn from a sample of WTC dust, are the same material!"
plus
"Please demonstrate that all these objective criteria apply to each of the four chips a-d!"
 
Last edited:
3ug086.jpg
 
Last edited:
well im glad you guys think there are 2 types now. sunstealer thought they were one and the same from previous posts.

so one is thermitic and one not thermitic. im glad we can agree on something.

So you agree there are two types (maybe more) red/gray, magnetically attracted chips?

Then you must disagree with Harrit's paper which concludes that EVERY SINGLE red/gray chip which is extracted from WTC dust via a magnet is thermitic. Is that correct?
 
Now:
"These 4 individual red-gray, magnetically attracted chips that I picked from my samples of WTC dust are the same material"
vs.
"All red-gray, magnetically attracted chips in all of the WTC dust are the same material"
Are those two statenents equivalent? Yes or No, Senemut? Give reasons!

^This...
 
i dont think they are trying to discredit his paper. it is what it is. im sure its all about the scientific method and being sure what he studied is what they studied.

So you agree that Millette had the correct chips based on the two criteria used for extraction in Harrit's paper (visual red/gray layers, attracted to a magnet)?
 
i dont think they are trying to discredit his paper. it is what it is. im sure its all about the scientific method and being sure what he studied is what they studied.
Hi Senenmut,

I truly appreciate your benevolent view, one I have tried to take as I "assume good intention" with people (even those I disagree with). However, you probably know that "they" tried to discredit Millette's paper before it even came out with misleading statements about Millette: http://digwithin.net/2012/02/17/whe...n-response-to-energetic-materials-at-the-wtc/. Kevin Ryan allowed me to respond on this blog at first, but has not allowed me to post links to Cate Jenkins's actual praises of Millette's integrity. Harrit has used this link to discredit Millette when people ask him about Millette's dust study. I am continuing to try to regain trust and a willingness to work together with them (a long letter respectfully requesting chip samples, the release of data they have not published, allowing me to set the record straight re Millette on Kevin's blog, etc) is going out very soon. I no longer assume good intention and am nervous about the response I will get from my requests. Wish me luck, I'd love to find out that my fears are unfounded and that there may yet be a way to work together. There are people in 9/11 Truth (and you Senenmut may well be one of them) who would favor more cooperation in these studies.
 
WTC Dust, I see that you elected to dodge my question once again and thus elected to tacitly retract those claims about the expected behaviour of epoxy in solvents and admit implicitly that you were plain wrong and uninformed.

Thank you.

Bottom line: Difficult to dissolve or not, no epoxy was dissolved from the layered chips. I can't pretend to know what people's motivations for attempting to do things, but the attempt surely did fail.
 
It's time to chime in once again about the lack of reports of any unusual quantities of aluminum oxide in the WTC dust from Millette, Harrit, R.J. Lee, or anyone else.

Or, for that matter, any clumps of solidified material in the debris piles. You'd think there'd be thousands of pieces of iron resembling iron-nickle meteorites all over the place, plus aluminum oxide clumps looking like odd ceramic mini-sculptures. Or something, anything.

Aluminum oxide (alumina) is produced in a 48/52 ratio to iron by the thermite reaction. Since its density is about 1/2 that of iron, it should be around in about twice the volume of any iron.

Where's the alumina?

Right! Since thermite is a mixture of iron oxide and aluminum powder, and since according to Harrit the iron oxide chips are unreacted thermite, they need a partner. Iron oxide alone isn't thermite. Now, in order to believe the thermite hypothesis and account for the lack of aluminum, you have to say that the thermite was imbalanced in the favor of iron oxide without enough aluminum. If the reaction doesn't go to completion, then the chemist made a mistake. Nanothermite chemists are notoriously sloppy, I guess.
 
Thermite? Who cares...It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings.

We might as well be talking about peanut butter...

Agreed. Thermite doesn't do what was done.
 
"So you agree there are two types (maybe more) red/gray, magnetically attracted chips?

Then you must disagree with Harrit's paper which concludes that EVERY SINGLE red/gray chip which is extracted from WTC dust via a magnet is thermitic. Is that correct?
"

Show where the 2009 Bentham paper made such a claim.

They claim that of those red/gray chips that were found to be thermitic, all were attracted to a magnet.

They never claimed that all the red/gray chips attracted to a magnet were found to be thermitic.

If they were making such an absurd claim, why would they expose such a fraud by including a few paragraphs discussing the use of the Resistivity test to remove red/gray paint chips, if they believed all the magnetically collected red/gray chips were thermitic?

MM
 
Originally Posted by Redwood
Fer cryin' out loud, Jones doesn't even state what kinds of paints he tested for resistivity. From the context, it could even be that they aren't standard hematite red primer paint. The article he cites is about a synthetic zinc ferrite primer. And, of course, he doesn’t cite the resistivities listed in the article, which is not available free online. If anyone wants to pay to read it, it’s here:

http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journa...&show=abstract

Ivan found the referenced paper and was so kind to post the table:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8949387#post8949387

Thanks! I notice that the resistivities varied by over 4 ORDERS OF MAGNITUDE!:jaw-dropp, and over three orders of magnitude in the formulations that contain ferric oxide! (I assume it's Fe+3; the table merely says "iron oxide", which isn't at all specific, given the many, many forms of oxides of iron.)

I wonder which of these were chosen by Harrit, et al?:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom