WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Something I have always wondered about this dust stuff and thermite was what are the chances (statistically) that any dust sample from around GZ would contain thermite (or whatever its supposed to contain) given how much dust was created during the collapse from everything that is not thermite. I mean how much thermite was needed anyway?

The thermite people seem to think that any WTC dust would immediately have evidence of thermite in it. Seems to me this would be very unlikely.

And furthermore if the type of dust found that they think indicates thermite, IS found in all samples that have been examined, then I would strongly suggest that it was dust created from something that was all over the WTC in abundance - which would exclude thermite.
 
Bad Boy,

Niels Harrit has in fact said in interviews in the past that he thinks that there must have been thousands of tons of this nano-thermite in the buildings, since so much was left over! This from their observation or estimation that about 0.1% of the dust samples were, by weight, red-gray chips. If they suppose that total mass of the debris was, say, 1 million tons, and a good proportion of that was turned to dust - say, 100,000 tons, then 0.1% of that is 100 tons. BUT what they find in the dust is merely the unburned left-overs of the hypothetical thermite, so originally there should have been ... well, let's boldly speculate ... a hundred times as much, or 10,000 tons.

Tackling this from a different angle: That infamous "6 wt-% of the dust are iron microspheres, says RJ Lee" translates to ... 6,000 tons of iron microspheres total, and if these are the product of thermite, this means 12,000 tons of thermite total.
Of course this begs the question: Why isn't there about as much aluminium oxide, or 3% by weight Al in the dust?


As for the much more reasonable "it's paint" hypothesis: A while ago, BasqueArch calculated an estimate for the total surface of structural steel in both towers:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8058454&postcount=2109
I took his work and estimates that this amounts to roughly 75 tons of paint on structural steel, both of tje twin towers combined. If 1% of that surface flakes off during the collapse and enters the dust (0.75 tons of paint), taking an equal, but heavier layer of oxidized steel with it (gray layer), then we would expect to find "some" (single-digit number of) tons of red-gray chips in the dust.

It is difficult to estimate the amount of dust that was created and settled outside the immediate debris pile. I usually go with an assumption of very roughly 50,000 tons. A few tons of paint chips would be 0.01% of this, so what Harrit et al. reported is one order of magnitude above my expectation. Then again, my inputs have considerable margin of error, and I have yet not accounted for paints other than which was applied to the structural steel of the twins.
 
Fer cryin' out loud, Jones doesn't even state what kinds of paints he tested for resistivity. From the context, it could even be that they aren't standard hematite red primer paint. The article he cites is about a synthetic zinc ferrite primer. And, of course, he doesn’t cite the resistivities listed in the article, which is not available free online. If anyone wants to pay to read it, it’s here:

http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm?articleid=876638&show=abstract
Ivan found the referenced paper and was so kind to post the table:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8949387#post8949387


Then, there's the matter that the chips aren't homogeneous - there's that pesky gray layer, which Troofers can't account for, and the Sanity Squad thinks is oxidized steel spall. Which isn't an entirely bad conductor of electricity, although he assures us the sample he tested had “very little” adhering to it.

Charlatanry, and incompetent charlatanry at that.
Not only that, but since it was made under the erroneous assumption (present throughout the paper) that all the red chips are the same stuff, we have no idea of the composition of the chip (singular - they only report one) that they tested for resistivity.

The biggest problem of the paper is that they report on heterogeneous chips selectively. For example, they take a random sample of chips, and test them for resistivity (Harrit dixit), but only report on one that has an unusual resistivity without specifying its composition. Same with chips a-d, where they find aluminium and iron oxide. Same with the MEK chip, where they claim to find elemental aluminium (but the iron oxide seems gone). Same with the DSC microspheres, which F H-C couldn't replicate. Same with the recent FTIR results, which they admit were obtained from an unusually striped chip. And so on.

The only common denominator of these chips is: they were in the WTC dust, they were attracted by a magnet, and they look red and gray. Other than that, we know nothing about most of them used for further tests.
 
I accept that samples a-d represent 9/11 WTC dust collected from those "a-d" locations.
That is not what I asked and you know it.

We now have a somewhat strange paradoxical, yet amusing situation, whereby MM fully supports the Harrit et al paper and it's conclusions of thermite, but steadfastly refuses to agree with the authors and their analysis that samples a,b,c and d in Figs 7 & 8 are the same material.

What's more amusing is that this point is of no contention whatsoever. I agree totally with Harrit et al that samples a-d are the same material. So why does MM refuse to agree on this point with the very people he champions?

When performing any analysis it helps to look at more than one type of data and to correlate the two. We can do this in Harrit et al in the case of samples a-d and we can clearly see a number of similarities between the chips:

  • All look identical in nature under optical microscopy having both a red and gray layer. See Figs 2 & 5.
  • All have identical EDX spectra for the gray layer material. See Fig 6.
  • All have identical EDX spectra for the red layer material. See Fig 7.
  • All have identical red and gray layer characteristics under visual SEM examination. See Fig 5.
  • All contain the same two type of particles embedded in the same matrix. See Fig 8.
  • The authors acknowledge this in Fig 11 because they give EDX spectra for thin platelets and whitish particles from one chip only (which is sensible - no point in doing anything else.

So there you have it. A sensible, logical analysis that uses nothing more than the ability to match patterns and observe similarities. Yet MM refuses to acknowledge that these samples are the same material against all the evidence and against the say so of Harrit et al, whom he ultimately agrees with. Odd.

The trouble is of course is that if he admits to samples a-d being the same material then he has to agree with the analysis and the reasoning behind why they are the same material. This can only lead in one direction and boy does he know it.

The claim that Millette has the wrong chips is obviously wrong and disingenuous too, it obviously implies that Millette doesn't know what he's doing and cannot see that his data doesn't match Harrit et al, except of course his data does match Harrit et al because he used Harrit et al's paper as a basis for his criteria in ensuring he had the right chips to analyse. He even says so:

The criteria for the particles of interest as described by Harrit et al are: small red/gray chips attracted by a magnet and showing an elemental composition primarily of aluminum, silicon and iron as determined by scanning electron microscopy and x-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS) (Figure 4).

The spectrum may also contain small peaks related to other elements. To that end, the following protocol was performed on each of the four WTC dust samples.

1. The dust sample particles contained in a plastic bag were drawn across a magnet and those attracted to the magnet were collected (Figure 5).

2. Using a stereomicroscope, particle chips showing the characteristic red/gray were removed and washed in clean water.

3. The particles were dried and mounted on a carbon adhesive film on an SEM stub and photographed (Figure 6).

4. Analysis of the surfaces of the chips was done by SEM-EDS at 20 kV without any added conductive coating (Figures 7 and 8).

Red/gray particles that matched the criteria (attracted to a magnet and an EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum) were then considered particles of interest and subjected to additional analytical testing.

Why do truthers ignore these words from the very person who conducted the analysis?

However, we can go even further in showing that Millette has the same chips as Harrit et al by simply using the same reasoning and analysis that we used to determine that samples a-d are the same material:

  • Millette's "chips of interest" look identical in nature under optical microscopy compared to chips a-d. See Fig 2 (Harrit) v Appendix B (Millette)
  • Millette's "chips of interest" have identical EDX spectra for the gray layer material compared with chips a-d. See Fig 6 (Harrit) v Fig 13 and Appendix D (Millette).
  • Millette's "chips of interest" have identical EDX spectra for the red layer material compared with chips a-d. See Fig 7 (Harrit) v Fig 8 and Appendix D (Millette). [This was the initial criteria for chips of interest]
  • Millette's "chips of interest" have identical red and gray layer characteristics under visual SEM examination compared with chips a-d. See Fig 5 (Harrit) v Fig 10 and Appendix D (Millette).
  • Millette's chips of interest contain the same two type of particles embedded in the same matrix. See Fig 5 & 8 (Harrit) v Fig 14 & 15 9119L1560(2) - page 35, 9119L1616 - page 40, 9119X0135 - page 44 (Millette)
  • The hexagonal platelets in Millette's "chips of interest" have identical EDX spectra compared with chips a-d. See Fig 11 (Harrit) v 9119L1560(3) - page 36, 9119L1616(1) - page 38 and Appendix D (Millette)
  • The whitish particles in Millette's "chips of interest" have identical EDX spectra compared with chips a-d. See Fig 11 (Harrit) v Appendix D (Millette)

So to sum up, if MM agrees that samples a-d in Harrit are the same, then he has to admit to the methodology, logic and reasoning behind that statement. If he applies the same logic to Millette's chips then he has no alternative but to agree that Millette's chips match chips a-d and therefore Harrit's chips are paint.

This is the reason why Senenmut and MM refuse to analyse the data, because if they did so, they would see all of the similarities I have pointed out (and referenced) and therefore would have no option but to conclude that Millette's chips are the same material as Harrit's.

Instead they make up strawmen such as the "resistance test" nonsense and secondly they cling to an arbitrary, ambiguous test such as heating the chips in ambient air in a DSC.

Instead of concentrating on what Millette did find and accepting the only conclusion that the material that Harrit et al had was paint, they instead look to deflect and obfuscate by concentrating on needless and unimportant points because it's far too big a step and loss of face to admit they are wrong.
 
so if millette gives out some chips to researchers, you dont want them to do this test on his chips?? is that what your trying to say?


ive read the paper. what you are not getting is that maybe all of jones chips are the same material the same material.


maybe all his were the same material. how many times do i have to repeat myself.



again, maybe his samples are the same material.


and?





not millettes chips...not henryco's chips even though they had similar XEDS spectra. henryco had mostly red chips. i dont recall millette finding specifically red chips. do you see something wrong?



well, tell us how those chips are going to produce iron and silicon microspheres.


yep, to produce iron and silicon rich microspheres. did millettes do that?



millette never did make sure they were the same type of chip. PERIOD. no iron and silicon microspheres = not same material.

just ask millette to do a DSC or a resistivity test or even heat his around 430C or alittle higher to see if they produce iron and silicon rich microspheres.

or get millette to send some of his chips to serious researchers (like myself) to get a DSC and a resistivity test and heat his chips up above 430C

are you against millette sharing his chips?

I don't care what Millette does with his chips and you are totally missing the point.

The point being is that, according to Harrit's paper, no matter where you get a dust sample, as long as you use the two criteria listed within said paper to extract the chips (having a red/gray layer and being attracted to a magnet), every test performed on the extracted chips will yield the same results.

Harrit's Bentham paper said:
All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a red layer and were attracted by a magnet.

Above is how they selected their chips for testing. Period, end of story. Those that claim they did a resistivity test to weed out paint chips are clearly mistaken.

The fact that Millette did in fact use the two criteria and got different results PROVES that Harrit's paper is a farce.

Jones and Harrit contradicted each other which is why they refuse to answer specific questions about the resisitivity test. As per Harrit's email to me, the resistivity test was NOT a test performed to make sure the chips they tested were not paint, but a test performed on random chips to try and stereotype the entire pile of red/gray, magnetically attracted chips as not being paint. Hence, Harrit's statement below to me:

Harrit said:
The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".

The above statement completely contradicts what Jones is trying to claim in that the resisitivity test was used to separate paint chip from thermite chips.


The whole point about Millette and Harrit is this.

Harrit's paper concludes that all chips being extracted from the WTC dust, having a red/gray layer, and being attracted to a magnet, will ALL yield that same results of any test listed in said paper.

Millette proves this to be incorrect because he got different results using the same criteria for separation/extraction.
 
millette never did make sure they were the same type of chip. PERIOD. no iron and silicon microspheres = not same material.

Exactly!

Which proves Harrit's paper completely incorrect. You folks want so bad for the tests performed AFTER extraction from the pile to mean that they weeded out bad chips from other types of red/gray, magnetically attracted chips, but that's not that case.

Millette used the exact same criteria for extraction as Harrit and his cronies and got different results.

Another point. If they did do resistivity tests to weed out paint from thermite, why wasn't this result published? Wouldn't that be important? Wouldn't they be interested in knowing the composition of red/gray, magnetically attracted paint chips compared to red/gray, magnetically attracted thermite chips? This would have given them actual paint chips to test instead of going outside the box to get paint data.
 
The above statement completely contradicts what Jones is trying to claim in that the resisitivity test was used to separate paint chip from thermite chips.
It doesn't contradict it, because in the sentence MM has quoted, Jones is not trying to claim anything; he is insinuating. Jones is very careful with what to say and what not to say but just imply, in order to not be accused of lying. And MirageMemories has swallowed bait, hook, line, sinker, rod and fisherman.

Let's analyze Jones's quotes:

quote 1 said:
Why would he not measure the electrical resistivity of his red material (discussed in our paper) right off? That's what gets me – he could have saved himself a lot of time.
Saved himself a lot of time for what? He doesn't say, he only implies it.

Did Jones et al. measure the electrical resistivity of their red material 'right off'? He doesn't say, he only implies it.

quote 2 said:
Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements.
He omits that they reported the resistivity of the red material of one chip of unknown properties beyond its color and magnetic attraction, which is not necessarily the same resistivity of those chips found by Millette (and I'd even say it's necessarily different).

Will Jones ever clearly state how many chips did they do the resistivity test on, and what results they got, apart from the reported one?

Will he ever specify whether it was a test used for isolation of the chips?

If anyone answers 'yes' to any of these two questions, I demand proof.
 
It doesn't contradict it, because in the sentence MM has quoted, Jones is not trying to claim anything; he is insinuating. Jones is very careful with what to say and what not to say but just imply, in order to not be accused of lying. And MirageMemories has swallowed bait, hook, line, sinker, rod and fisherman.

Let's analyze Jones's quotes:


Saved himself a lot of time for what? He doesn't say, he only implies it.

Did Jones et al. measure the electrical resistivity of their red material 'right off'? He doesn't say, he only implies it.


He omits that they reported the resistivity of the red material of one chip of unknown properties beyond its color and magnetic attraction, which is not necessarily the same resistivity of those chips found by Millette (and I'd even say it's necessarily different).

Will Jones ever clearly state how many chips did they do the resistivity test on, and what results they got, apart from the reported one?

Will he ever specify whether it was a test used for isolation of the chips?

If anyone answers 'yes' to any of these two questions, I demand proof.

Here is a quote from Jones in a letter he wrote to a scientist:

Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.

It is clear that he is saying that they used the resistivity test, in addition to the red/gray layer and magnetic attraction criteria to make sure they had non-paint chips.

Harrit's paper and Harrit's email to me contradict that statement.

Harrit's email said:
The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".

...and...

Harrit's Bentham paper said:
The red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet, which facilitates collection and separation of the chips from the bulk of the dust. A small permanent magnet in its own plastic bag was used to attract and collect the chips from dust samples. The chips are typically small but readily discernible by eye due to
their distinctive color. They are of variable size with major dimensions of roughly 0.2 to 3 mm. Thicknesses vary from roughly 10 to 100 microns for each layer (red and gray). Samples of WTC dust from these and other collectors have been sent directly from collectors to various scientists (including some not on this research team) who have also found such red/gray chips in the dust from the World Trade Center
destruction

...and...

Harrit's Bentham paper said:
All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a red layer and were attracted by a magnet.
 
There's a big difference between:

1. Extracting red/red gray chips from a dust pile, further separating that extracted pile into paint chips or non-paint chips using a resistivity test, and THEN performing the rest of the tests on them.

and

2. Extracting red/gray chips from a pile using a magnet, performing a resistivity test on one or two chips from that extracted pile, and then applying the results of that resistivity test to the entire extracted pile based on two test samples.
 
It's time to chime in once again about the lack of reports of any unusual quantities of aluminum oxide in the WTC dust from Millette, Harrit, R.J. Lee, or anyone else.

Or, for that matter, any clumps of solidified material in the debris piles. You'd think there'd be thousands of pieces of iron resembling iron-nickle meteorites all over the place, plus aluminum oxide clumps looking like odd ceramic mini-sculptures. Or something, anything.

Aluminum oxide (alumina) is produced in a 48/52 ratio to iron by the thermite reaction. Since its density is about 1/2 that of iron, it should be around in about twice the volume of any iron.

Where's the alumina?
 
I don't care what Millette does with his chips and you are totally missing the point.
your point is moot. remember the scientific method.
"Reproducibility is the ability of an entire experiment or study to be reproduced, or by someone else working independently. It is one of the main principles of the scientific method. The result values are said to be commensurate if they are obtained (in distinct experimental trials) according to the same reproducible experimental description and procedure."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_(scientific_method)

so your good with a dsc test and a resistivity test and to heat the chips up to and above 430C?

The point being is that, according to Harrit's paper, no matter where you get a dust sample, as long as you use the two criteria listed within said paper to extract the chips (having a red/gray layer and being attracted to a magnet), every test performed on the extracted chips will yield the same results.

again, maybe that is true in their sample.


Above is how they selected their chips for testing. Period, end of story. Those that claim they did a resistivity test to weed out paint chips are clearly mistaken.

see above for scientific method and what supplemental means. i dont think it matters if they used that test to weed out paint chips or not. they did it and got a number. did millette get the same number?

The fact that Millette did in fact use the two criteria and got different results PROVES that Harrit's paper is a farce.
? how so. did millettes chips make iron and silicon rich microspheres? are you trying to say that there are 2 different types of red gray chips?

Jones and Harrit contradicted each other which is why they refuse to answer specific questions about the resisitivity test. As per Harrit's email to me, the resistivity test was NOT a test performed to make sure the chips they tested were not paint, but a test performed on random chips to try and stereotype the entire pile of red/gray, magnetically attracted chips as not being paint. Hence, Harrit's statement below to me:
and?



The above statement completely contradicts what Jones is trying to claim in that the resisitivity test was used to separate paint chip from thermite chips.
where did you get that?
jones says
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."

supplemental: (from your harriet quote)
1. Something added to complete a thing, make up for a deficiency, or extend or strengthen the whole.
2. A section added to a book or document to give further information or to correct errors.

The whole point about Millette and Harrit is this.

Harrit's paper concludes that all chips being extracted from the WTC dust, having a red/gray layer, and being attracted to a magnet, will ALL yield that same results of any test listed in said paper.
which may be true for his sample.

Millette proves this to be incorrect because he got different results using the same criteria for separation/extraction.
so you think there are 2 different types of chips then?
 
Exactly!

Which proves Harrit's paper completely incorrect. You folks want so bad for the tests performed AFTER extraction from the pile to mean that they weeded out bad chips from other types of red/gray, magnetically attracted chips, but that's not that case.

Millette used the exact same criteria for extraction as Harrit and his cronies and got different results.
so there are 2 different types of red gray chips then?

Another point. If they did do resistivity tests to weed out paint from thermite, why wasn't this result published? Wouldn't that be important? Wouldn't they be interested in knowing the composition of red/gray, magnetically attracted paint chips compared to red/gray, magnetically attracted thermite chips? This would have given them actual paint chips to test instead of going outside the box to get paint data.
its just suplemental like harriet says but it would be a quick and easy way to weed out paints vs thermite chips from what i can gather.
 
It's time to chime in once again about the lack of reports of any unusual quantities of aluminum oxide in the WTC dust from Millette, Harrit, R.J. Lee, or anyone else.

Or, for that matter, any clumps of solidified material in the debris piles. You'd think there'd be thousands of pieces of iron resembling iron-nickle meteorites all over the place, plus aluminum oxide clumps looking like odd ceramic mini-sculptures. Or something, anything.

Aluminum oxide (alumina) is produced in a 48/52 ratio to iron by the thermite reaction. Since its density is about 1/2 that of iron, it should be around in about twice the volume of any iron.

Where's the alumina?

Thanks, that was an inspiration!

whereisalumina.jpg


Extra points if you remember the "WTB" cultural reference.
 
so there are 2 different types of red gray chips then?

According to Jones (and others), yes, maybe more...

Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.


its just suplemental like harriet says but it would be a quick and easy way to weed out paints vs thermite chips from what i can gather.
Really? If that's the case, then why did Harrit and his group not do that? Why was this resistivity test not done on every single chip they extracted using their two criteria of visible red/gray layers and attraction to a magnet? According to Harrit in his email to me, the resistivity test were done on RANDOM chips!

Harrit's email said:
The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".

See the problem yet?

If there are many types of chips per Jones statement above then why does the paper conclude that all red/gray chips attracted to a magnet are thermitic?

Are you saying that Harrit and his group tested evey single chip in their extracted pile to make sure that none were paint to make the paper's conclusion correct? According to Harrit's email statement above to me, the answer is no.
 
Senenmut,

Looking at Jones' statement above that "one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied", how does one do that according to the paper?

According to Jones it was supposedly the resisitivty test in addition to the two criteria.

According to the paper, they tested ONE chip for resistance yet they magically publish results for FOUR chips and conclude that ALL red/gray magnetically attracted chips are thermitic.

How does that work?

BIG mistake.

It proves that Jones is just trying to discredit what Millette found in order to try preserve their paper's so-called integrity.
 
Bad Boy,

Niels Harrit has in fact said in interviews in the past that he thinks that there must have been thousands of tons of this nano-thermite in the buildings, since so much was left over! This from their observation or estimation that about 0.1% of the dust samples were, by weight, red-gray chips. If they suppose that total mass of the debris was, say, 1 million tons, and a good proportion of that was turned to dust - say, 100,000 tons, then 0.1% of that is 100 tons. BUT what they find in the dust is merely the unburned left-overs of the hypothetical thermite, so originally there should have been ... well, let's boldly speculate ... a hundred times as much, or 10,000 tons.

Tackling this from a different angle: That infamous "6 wt-% of the dust are iron microspheres, says RJ Lee" translates to ... 6,000 tons of iron microspheres total, and if these are the product of thermite, this means 12,000 tons of thermite total.
Of course this begs the question: Why isn't there about as much aluminium oxide, or 3% by weight Al in the dust?


As for the much more reasonable "it's paint" hypothesis: A while ago, BasqueArch calculated an estimate for the total surface of structural steel in both towers:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8058454&postcount=2109
I took his work and estimates that this amounts to roughly 75 tons of paint on structural steel, both of tje twin towers combined. If 1% of that surface flakes off during the collapse and enters the dust (0.75 tons of paint), taking an equal, but heavier layer of oxidized steel with it (gray layer), then we would expect to find "some" (single-digit number of) tons of red-gray chips in the dust.

It is difficult to estimate the amount of dust that was created and settled outside the immediate debris pile. I usually go with an assumption of very roughly 50,000 tons. A few tons of paint chips would be 0.01% of this, so what Harrit et al. reported is one order of magnitude above my expectation. Then again, my inputs have considerable margin of error, and I have yet not accounted for paints other than which was applied to the structural steel of the twins.

ok, thanks Oystein. That was interesting,

12,000 tones of thermite! wow. I assume that would be kind of difficult to hide. I mean you would require all the ignition wiring etc on top of that. The whole idea is so ridiculous.
 
so there are 2 different types of red gray chips then? ...

Exactly!
Do you disagree?
Jones seems to be implying that there are (at least) 2 different types of red-gray chips when he suggests that Millette sudied the WRONG kind. Do you see how Jones himself implies there may or must have been at least two kind of red-gray chips?
 
ok, thanks Oystein. That was interesting,

12,000 tones of thermite! wow. I assume that would be kind of difficult to hide. I mean you would require all the ignition wiring etc on top of that. The whole idea is so ridiculous.

Exactly! And to assume the thermite reaction, which emits blindingly bright light, goes unseen, or the mythical "military explosive" variant of nanothermite went unheard, when thousands of tons are insinuated to have been lit within 10 seconds or some such number, defies sanity. In many real CDs, less than 100 kg of explosives are used, and they are heard, unmistakably, by absolute everyone looking on from a distance.
 
Exactly! And to assume the thermite reaction, which emits blindingly bright light, goes unseen, or the mythical "military explosive" variant of nanothermite went unheard, when thousands of tons are insinuated to have been lit within 10 seconds or some such number, defies sanity. In many real CDs, less than 100 kg of explosives are used, and they are heard, unmistakably, by absolute everyone looking on from a distance.

This was special "dim-bulb" thermite which does not burn brightly.

It's made by the manufacturers of Hush-a-Boom.
 
ok, thanks Oystein. That was interesting,

12,000 tones of thermite! wow. I assume that would be kind of difficult to hide. I mean you would require all the ignition wiring etc on top of that. The whole idea is so ridiculous.

Exactly! And to assume the thermite reaction, which emits blindingly bright light, goes unseen, or the mythical "military explosive" variant of nanothermite went unheard, when thousands of tons are insinuated to have been lit within 10 seconds or some such number, defies sanity. In many real CDs, less than 100 kg of explosives are used, and they are heard, unmistakably, by absolute everyone looking on from a distance.

Ok. ~12,000 tons of thermite painted onto WTC1,2 steel structure to melt it. How much surface area of steel would this be?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom