Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
Not chips (plural) - I am talking just about this one chip which Millette first soaked in MEK and then did an EDS-map on.Well, I've no time to dig into this now but it sounds to me like you're saying Millette's chips do not correspond to chips a-d, and that would have serious implications.
Yes, it would have the implication that I can't say at this time that "Millette found elemental Al in (a-d)-like chips using EDS mapping". Thew results of his FTIR and TEM tests still stand.
No. All four chips share EDS-characteristica of Al=Si & Fe; all four have the same kind of hematite grains and kaolin plates; all four have the same hue and luster. If you reject that a-d are really all the same material, then you have no two chips of the same material. That amounts to nihilismOne objection that comes to mind is that figs. 10 and 11a are from chip a (or from another chip from dust sample 1), and that says nothing of chips b-d.