WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Well, I've no time to dig into this now but it sounds to me like you're saying Millette's chips do not correspond to chips a-d, and that would have serious implications.
Not chips (plural) - I am talking just about this one chip which Millette first soaked in MEK and then did an EDS-map on.
Yes, it would have the implication that I can't say at this time that "Millette found elemental Al in (a-d)-like chips using EDS mapping". Thew results of his FTIR and TEM tests still stand.

One objection that comes to mind is that figs. 10 and 11a are from chip a (or from another chip from dust sample 1), and that says nothing of chips b-d.
No. All four chips share EDS-characteristica of Al=Si & Fe; all four have the same kind of hematite grains and kaolin plates; all four have the same hue and luster. If you reject that a-d are really all the same material, then you have no two chips of the same material. That amounts to nihilism :p
 
Our efforts to find paint primer from a WTC truss is still being met with frustration... You may remember our attempts to get paint from the Red Knights, a motorcycle/firefighters' club who has a WTC memorial with the trusses. An FDNY first responder agreed to ask them personally for a small paint sample, giving us the maximum possible credibility for our request. Their response? "It's a no go. Their thinking is that they don't want to ligitimize any 911 truther arguments."

I suspect that a real investigative journalist with some stature would have been much more successful.

A (redacted) (redacted) who has a 9/11 hobby is likely to be shown the door right quickly.

MM
 
I just pulled up this chart of melting points of various metals:


Metal Melting Point
(oC) (oF)
Admiralty Brass 900 - 940 1650 - 1720
Aluminum 660 1220
Aluminum Alloy 463 - 671 865 - 1240
Aluminum Bronze 600 - 655 1190 - 1215
Antimony 630 1170
Babbitt 249 480
Beryllium 1285 2345
Beryllium Copper 865 - 955 1587 - 1750
Bismuth 271.4 520.5
Brass, Red 1000 1832
Brass, Yellow 930 1710
Cadmium 321 610
Cast Iron, gray 1175 - 1290 2150 - 2360
Chromium 1860 3380
Cobalt 1495 2723
Copper 1084 1983
Cupronickel 1170 - 1240 2140 - 2260
Gold, 24K Pure 1063 1945
Hastelloy C 1320 - 1350 2410 - 2460
Inconel 1390 - 1425 2540 - 2600
Incoloy 1390 - 1425 2540 - 2600
Iridium 2450 4440
Iron, Wrought 1482 - 1593 2700 - 2900
Iron, Gray Cast 1127 - 1204 2060 - 2200
Iron, Ductile 1149 2100
Lead 327.5 621
Magnesium 650 1200
Magnesium Alloy 349 - 649 660 - 1200
Manganese 1244 2271
Manganese bronze 865 - 890 1590 - 1630
Mercury -38.86 -37.95
Molybdenum 2620 4750
Monel 1300 - 1350 2370 - 2460
Nickel 1453 2647
Niobium (Columbium) 2470 4473
Osmium 3025 5477
Palladium 1555 2831
Phosphorus 44 111
Platinum 1770 3220
Plutonium 640 1180
Potassium 63.3 146
Red Brass 990 - 1025 1810 - 1880
Rhenium 3186 5767
Rhodium 1965 3569
Ruthenium 2482 4500
Selenium 217 423
Silicon 1411 2572
Silver, Coin 879 1615
Silver, Pure 961 1761
Silver, Sterling 893 1640
Sodium 97.83 208
Steel, Carbon 1425 - 1540 2600 - 2800
Steel, Stainless 1510 2750
Tantalum 2980 5400
Thorium 1750 3180
Tin 232 449.4
Titanium 1670 3040
Tungsten 3400 6150
Uranium 1132 2070
Vanadium 1900 3450
Yellow Brass 905 - 932 1660 - 1710
Zinc 419.5 787
Zirconium 1854 3369

Crazy idea maybe, but... when the red-gray chips ignite, the claim from Harrit et al seems to be that iron microspheres are created at temperatures above the melting point of steel or iron, around 2750 F. If we can't measure the temperature of igniting chips, is there a chance we can have a small chip of, say, brass or copper, whose melting point is around 1800 F, still well below that of steel, to see if iron microspheres are created at lower temperatures than melting steel during this process? In other words, the igniting chip would heat up a nearby chip of copper and if it didn't melt the copper from the ignition we would know the ignition never reached 2700 degrees F? (I notice uranium would melt at the perfect temperature for such an experiment but for other reasons would not recommend it!) This melting of a "neighbor metal" to get a sense of the temperature of the igniting chip may be a bad idea, just brainstorming.
 
Last edited:
You are a fraud.

Now you have a documented charge of fraud against yourself. Which is, according to your standards, an indication that you are a fraud.

Great! Now let's go on.

Documented charges of fraud against Jones, must mean Jones is a fraud.
Documented charges of fraud against Harrit, must mean Harrit is a fraud.

Or maybe it takes more than a charge of fraud for someone to be a fraud?

Oh boy, the comedy is wonderful, I had to wait a couple of minutes to stop laughing.. I really wonder if the reason for the constant name-calling of Jones et al is that you guys really don´t know the difference between documented charges of fraud and anonymous trolls calling people names on a stupid forum. Dragging your knuckles much lately?

What a joke:D
 
Oh boy, the comedy is wonderful, I had to wait a couple of minutes to stop laughing.. I really wonder if the reason for the constant name-calling of Jones et al is that you guys really don´t know the difference between documented charges of fraud and anonymous trolls calling people names on a stupid forum. Dragging your knuckles much lately?

What a joke:D

You deny well established principles of Physics & Chemistry, and you accuse OTHERS of being knuckle-draggers?

I bet your globe is a square, and it has the sun revolving around it.
 
Oh boy, the comedy is wonderful, I had to wait a couple of minutes to stop laughing.. I really wonder if the reason for the constant name-calling of Jones et al is that you guys really don´t know the difference between documented charges of fraud and anonymous trolls calling people names on a stupid forum. Dragging your knuckles much lately?

What a joke:D
Does a charge of fraud equal fraud?
 
Oh boy, the comedy is wonderful, I had to wait a couple of minutes to stop laughing.. I really wonder if the reason for the constant name-calling of Jones et al is that you guys really don´t know the difference between documented charges of fraud and anonymous trolls calling people names on a stupid forum. Dragging your knuckles much lately?

What a joke:D

In the fall of 2005, Jones made up thermite as the cause of the WTC collapse. It is nonsense. Is nonsense better than fraud. It seems to be fraud now as Jones takes his lie and makes up a paper to support his fantasy of thermite.

What do you call misleading people on 911? Fraud, or insanity?

Jones is very personable, as he spreads one of the dumbest lies on 911 because of hate, or some political bias. Does Jones believe the ends justify the means. Do his lies about 911 justify his goal of stopping war?

Do you need a copy when Jones first started his insane claims on 911? I got the letter he wrote.

Millette can't find engineered thermite in WTC dust. The best you can do is find some Etch-a-Sketch junk on some rust.

When will Jones stop spreading fantasy on 911?
 
Thermite being used to take down the WTC on 9-11 is a lie.

Jones and all who spread this lie, should be charged with a crime.
 
MM neither you nor anyone else on the 9/11 Truth side has ever acknowledged what Cate Jenkins ACTUALLY SAID about Jim Millette. The only time she has ever mentioned Jim Millette personally and by name in an EPA complaint of hers, she wrote, "“Another independent research group, MVA Scientific Consultants, Inc., also found that the smallest WTC dust particles (0.5 to 2.5 microns) contained 26.5% cement particles in samples about ½ mile away from Ground Zero.
“There are 2 credible studies that determined the concentration of concrete in the smallest WTC dust particles, and the concentrations of concrete in the larger particles.

“Both the Delta Group at the University of California at Davis, and MVA Scientific Consultants, Inc. are highly prestigious groups, having received numerous EPA grants for similar studies on fine particulates.

“MVA was a major contract laboratory to EPA in the evaluation of WTC dust after 9/11, but performed its study of the concrete content of WTC dust independently. Dr. Millette of MVA was an expert witness on behalf of the Department of Justice and EPA suit against W.R. Grace for the Libby, MT asbestos Superfund site.”

I'll keep mentioning this quote until it is acknowledged. How Kevin Ryan and his followers can say that Jenkins has directly accused Millette of fraud is beyond me. And even if she did, the fact that she also said this means that she has contradiocted herself and her testimony against Millette is therefore worthless.

Amazing how NO 9/11 Truth person on these threads has EVER acknowledged this obvious problem with Kevin Ryan's misleading ad hominem attackj against Millette.
 
Oh, am I?

Kindly present your iron-clad evidence that thermite was used to take down the WTC towers.

Well, he does have some paint chips that if you spin the DSC results the right way, neglect the amount of elements found, and "forget" about tests that were performed and the results weren't released, might convince some folks there was thermite. And that's about it.
 
And even if she did, the fact that she also said this means that she has contradiocted herself and her testimony against Millette is therefore worthless.
She even contradicts herself in the same paper where she accuses the Lioy team of fraud, because she uses the same results they published, which had a pH right at the limit of dangerousness, for accusing another unrelated study of publishing a pH value that was under that limit.
 
Chris: As for your post 2024:

No, it wouldn't work. "Reference chip" of some metal with known melting point, even if it is in close vicinity or direct contact with burning red/gray chip, wouldn't be heated up to the temperature of burning chip. It would just absorb some of the heat of burning, lowering the temperature of the red/gray chip.

I wrote you that in "my oven", I have no chance to measure the temperature of burning chips. But such temperature can be measured by proper methods, namely differential thermal analysis (DTA).

Interestingly, the calorimeter Netzsch DSC 404C, which was employed by Bentham team, offers this option (it is a modular system).
In other words, this device is capable of measuring either the heat flow into/from the sample (DSC), or temperature change in the sample caused by some process (DTA).
But, Bentham team used only DSC option for unknown reason.

As a reminder, here is again a DTA curve for authentic "superthermite":

picture.php


As you can see, the exothermic thermitic reaction at ca 560 degrees C was pretty rapid in that case, but the temperature of the sample was increased only by some 50 degrees C/mg. (But, Gash et al did not write what was the mass of this sample, which seems to be an important detail, since temperature increase is plotted as oC/mg)
 
Last edited:
Thermite being used to take down the WTC on 9-11 is a lie.

Jones and all who spread this lie, should be charged with a crime.

I'm not sure whether desperate fanatics Jones, Harrit et al should be charged with a crime or fraud.

But we could nominate the Bentham paper for Ig Nobel prize;) I will soon check what is necessary for such a nomination...
 
Last edited:
Mohr: The only time she has ever mentioned Jim Millette personally and by name in an EPA complaint of hers, she wrote...
"Dr. Millette of MVA was an expert witness on behalf of the Department of Justice and EPA suit against.."

So what? You have already admitted that Jenkins (in the document that Ryan cites) charged a couple of (EPA) studies with fraud in which Millette participated. You actually think that you can change this fact by citing some other document where Jenkins names Millette by name and calls him an "expert witness for the EPA"?

Who do you think is responsible for those studies charged with fraud? The authors maybe? You never answered my question about whether or not Jenkins singled out some authors or if the fraud charge implicates all of them? You guys should dedicate a special thread to this subject since you keep bringing it up.
 
Last edited:
... Jenkins ... charged a couple of (EPA) studies with fraud ... those studies charged with fraud ... the fraud charge ...

Well, perhaps you should give a clear, unambiguous (as in unqualified "Yes." or "No.") answer to this first:

Does a charge of fraud equal fraud?

I don't think anyone should reply to you before you have answered LSSBB's question.
 
Originally Posted by LSSBB View Post
Does a charge of fraud equal fraud?

I don't think anyone should reply to you before you have answered LSSBB's question.

Charge of fraud does not mean the author is guilty of fraud, that has to be examined in each case. But Ryan did not say Millette is a fraud, he said Jenkins charged his studies with fraud, which is true.

Mohr´s attempts to hide this fact with misleading statements and/or blaming Ryan for an "ad hominem attack" do not make Mohr look good. I do realize Mohr is simply confused and out of his element, but enough is enough.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom