The pseudo-scientific hogwash that you JREF´ers put up with from your own buddies is beyond belief:
No matter the lack of Zn after MEK wash of fig 14, and everything else, you all continue the old MEK-Tnemec hand-wave like you never heard of an objection. The only aluminate in Tnemec is bound up with Calcium, but figure 17 in the Bentham paper does show aluminum rich area without Calcium. This means no Calcium Aluminates, and therefore figure 14 cannot be Tnemec.
But if you think you can improve the reputation of this JREF forum with this act, by all means continue.
I expected this kind of childish nonsense from Sunstealer, but not you Kminek, although that is starting to change. First of all the ignition point is the center of the peak, not start of exotherm, as this is a peculiarity of the DSC. If you don´t believe me, look at figure 29 in Bentham and see that Harrit´s chips ignite at 430 while Tillotson chips ignite at 530, but if your twisting of reality were true you would have to agree that both chips ignite at the same temperature, approximately 400 degrees. Stop the hogwash.
Secondly, as you have observed in previous posts, you cannot use controlled DSC burning to compare to ignition time of uncontrolled burn by, say, torch.
You have to compare burn of material X in DSC to material Y also in DSC.
Time to consider your company and your reputation.
Sunstealer:
Chips a-d contain no aluminates.
MEK chip does contain aluminates.
No matter the lack of Zn after MEK wash of fig 14, and everything else, you all continue the old MEK-Tnemec hand-wave like you never heard of an objection. The only aluminate in Tnemec is bound up with Calcium, but figure 17 in the Bentham paper does show aluminum rich area without Calcium. This means no Calcium Aluminates, and therefore figure 14 cannot be Tnemec.
But if you think you can improve the reputation of this JREF forum with this act, by all means continue.
Sunstealer: The DSC curve in Harrit et al shows the main exotherm occurring between approximately 370°C and 470°C, so
Kminek: Apparently, exothemic reactions (burning) started at about 330-370 degrees C in the case of two "bigger" exotherms. You do not see that?
I expected this kind of childish nonsense from Sunstealer, but not you Kminek, although that is starting to change. First of all the ignition point is the center of the peak, not start of exotherm, as this is a peculiarity of the DSC. If you don´t believe me, look at figure 29 in Bentham and see that Harrit´s chips ignite at 430 while Tillotson chips ignite at 530, but if your twisting of reality were true you would have to agree that both chips ignite at the same temperature, approximately 400 degrees. Stop the hogwash.
Secondly, as you have observed in previous posts, you cannot use controlled DSC burning to compare to ignition time of uncontrolled burn by, say, torch.
You have to compare burn of material X in DSC to material Y also in DSC.
Time to consider your company and your reputation.

Just look at Basile standing infront of an EDX semi-quantitative analysis showing less than 2% Al present in his sample and claiming it's thermite, it's comedy gold!