WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

The pseudo-scientific hogwash that you JREF´ers put up with from your own buddies is beyond belief:

Sunstealer:
Chips a-d contain no aluminates.
MEK chip does contain aluminates.

No matter the lack of Zn after MEK wash of fig 14, and everything else, you all continue the old MEK-Tnemec hand-wave like you never heard of an objection. The only aluminate in Tnemec is bound up with Calcium, but figure 17 in the Bentham paper does show aluminum rich area without Calcium. This means no Calcium Aluminates, and therefore figure 14 cannot be Tnemec.

But if you think you can improve the reputation of this JREF forum with this act, by all means continue.

Sunstealer: The DSC curve in Harrit et al shows the main exotherm occurring between approximately 370°C and 470°C, so

Kminek: Apparently, exothemic reactions (burning) started at about 330-370 degrees C in the case of two "bigger" exotherms. You do not see that?

I expected this kind of childish nonsense from Sunstealer, but not you Kminek, although that is starting to change. First of all the ignition point is the center of the peak, not start of exotherm, as this is a peculiarity of the DSC. If you don´t believe me, look at figure 29 in Bentham and see that Harrit´s chips ignite at 430 while Tillotson chips ignite at 530, but if your twisting of reality were true you would have to agree that both chips ignite at the same temperature, approximately 400 degrees. Stop the hogwash.
Secondly, as you have observed in previous posts, you cannot use controlled DSC burning to compare to ignition time of uncontrolled burn by, say, torch.
You have to compare burn of material X in DSC to material Y also in DSC.

Time to consider your company and your reputation.
 
Time to consider your company and your reputation.

Can we assume you will be at the forefront of a push for the Jones/Harrit guys to release their data or at least allow access to their chips?

It must be puzzling to you why they are so protective of their work and why they don't want others to confirm it.
 
Stick to the subject at hand, the chips. If your buddies have made some experiments where they reproduce ignition results by Harrit et al, please show them. Remember those iron spheres?

Oh, and what happened to your admission to Ryan that he was right about Millette fraud charges?
Great question JTL, I wrote on Ryan's blog that I missed the one sentence in Jenkins's complaint where she asserts "fraud" on a study led by Paul Lioy (if my memory serves me correctly) where Millette was on the team. I also mentioned that the only time Cate Jenkins mentions and focuses on Millette personally in any of her complaints against the EPA is when she praises his work. Will you please ask Kevin Ryan why he has not posted my blog entry? In the interests of total accuracy I did indeed admit that I had missed that one sentence where Millette is obliquely and indirectly referred to, which Kevin Ryan pulled out of her EPA complaint. But that acknowledgement, combined with the reference to jenkins's directly praising Millette, has not been allowed to be posted yet by Kevin Ryan. I hope in the interest of clarity and truth that you contact him and confront him with the same enthusiasm with which you enjoy confronting me.

You are an extremely irritating and unpleasant person who has ignored my sentence: "I think it's time you acknowledge that your global assertion, "none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims" is simply false." That was a global claim about all of us, AND not just about the chips. And I spent over a hundred hours organizing and dealing with the Millette experiment so don''t go telling me I haven't done any experiments. I will not respond to anything more you say until you retract that global and false accusation.
 
Last edited:
Why should I waste my time amusing you by answering 17 questions when you have no qualms about using lies to respond?
LMAO :D
Actually, you amuse me quite well by run run ruuuunning away from all those questions! :D :D

There are no shortage of examples;

Extract from the 2009 Bentham Paper:
"Red/gray chips were subjected to heating using a differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The data shown in Fig. (19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC samples all ignited in the range 415-435 ˚C."

MM

The only "lying" there are actually Harrit et al.
Well, perhaps not lying - being the bloody amateurs they are, they may simply be unqualified to read DSC curves.

Look - here is the DSC curve from the Tillotson and Gash paper:

TG_Fig3_colored.png


As you can see, it is endotherm below ca. 380 °C, but exotherm above that.
Power increases to ca. 2 W/g at 490 °C, and then the power increase rate increases (curve gets steeper), till it peaks at just under 5 W/g and at ca. 525 °C.

Would you say that this sample ignited at 380 °C, at 490 °C, at 525 °C, or did not ignite at all?
Give reasons for your answer!


Now look at the DSC curve for ono of Harrit's chips - the MacKinlay 1 sample:

HarritFig19-1_vs_TG_Fig3.png


It goes into exotherm territory at 45 °C - does it ignite then?
It surpasses 2 W/g at ca. 250 °C - does it ignite then?
It surpasses 5 W/g (the peak power of Tillotson's nano-thermite) at ca. 380 °C - does it ignite then?

If you think that Tillotson's sample ignited at all AND Harrit's sample did NOT ignite at 380 °C or below, you've got some 'splainin' to do :D
 
Mohr: Great question JTL, I wrote on Ryan's blog that I missed the one sentence in Jenkins's complaint where she asserts "fraud" on a study led by Paul Lioy (if my memory serves me correctly) where Millette was on the team. I also mentioned that the only time Cate Jenkins mentions and focuses on Millette personally in any of her complaints against the EPA is when she praises his work. Will you please ask Kevin Ryan why he has not posted my blog entry?

You are saying you have posted this comment on Ryan´s blog but that he has removed it or not allowed you to post it? I will ask him about it. By the way you say "if memory serves" but as we know your memory has not proven to be very reliable, since you forgot about your promise that Millette would replicate the Bentham tests.

Just to get this fraud charge thing straight, you have admitted that Jenkins charged some studies that Millette participated in with fraud, but you think that because Jenkins did not especially take the time to mention all authors, you think this means those authors are not involved in the fraud charge?

Just out of curiosity, did Jenkins take the time to charge specifically ANY of the authors, say, the leader Paul Lioy?

You are an extremely irritating and unpleasant person who has ignored my sentence: "I think it's time you acknowledge that your global assertion, "none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims" is simply false." That was a global claim about all of us, AND not just about the chips.

I did not ignore your statement, you simply took my quote out of context, and you did not understand the answer. My assertion is not false unless you show me some of those experiments that supposedly back up the claims made here about the ignition results. And yes, it was a "global" claim about all of you, IN THE CONTEXT OF THIS THREAD, WHICH IS THE CHIPS! And the context was also narrowed down for you even more in my original, uncut, statement:
One of the sobering realizations I have made, coming to this forum, is that none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims. I am still hoping it is possible to get those spheres "normally" with the DSC, but as I told you before, talk won´t do it no more.

Do you understand the context in above quote? You do realize that taking quotes out of context is not what a trained journalist is supposed to do?:mad:

And I spent over a hundred hours organizing and dealing with the Millette experiment so don''t go telling me I haven't done any experiments. I will not respond to anything more you say until you retract that global and false accusation.

Just because you organized the Millette study and paid him, does NOT mean you have done any experiments.
 
Last edited:
Hey Chris,
I think jtl is trying to tell you that you should be starting up fund raisers all the time and travelling around the world making a few bucks.

I guess that would be his idea of experiments ?
 
I expected this kind of childish nonsense from Sunstealer, but not you Kminek, although that is starting to change. First of all the ignition point is the center of the peak, not start of exotherm, as this is a peculiarity of the DSC. If you don´t believe me, look at figure 29 in Bentham and see that Harrit´s chips ignite at 430 while Tillotson chips ignite at 530, but if your twisting of reality were true you would have to agree that both chips ignite at the same temperature, approximately 400 degrees. Stop the hogwash.
Secondly, as you have observed in previous posts, you cannot use controlled DSC burning to compare to ignition time of uncontrolled burn by, say, torch.
You have to compare burn of material X in DSC to material Y also in DSC.

Time to consider your company and your reputation.

Jtl: I wrote:
"Apparently, exothermic reactions (burning) started at about 330-370 degrees C in the case of two "bigger" exotherms."

This is indeed a plain, undeniable truth, which cannot be changed by your words about peculiarity of DSC. What we see are slow exothermic processes starting at ca 330-370 degrees C and with maximum rates at ca 430 degrees C, lasting several minutes. This is what wee see.

Nobody compares here the heating with torch with heating in DSC, except perhaps some truthers;)
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by jtl View Post
...First of all the ignition point is the center of the peak, not start of exotherm, as this is a peculiarity of the DSC. ...


This is false.

Did he just say that when the fire is at it's max output then that is when it starts?
 
Did he just say that when the fire is at it's max output then that is when it starts?

In a nutshell, yes. It's really very obvious how and why he is wrong. 9/11 Truthers - making up excuses as they go since 2001.
 
This is false.
It's unbelievable the way jtl attacks people who understand DSC yet continues to utter complete rubbish on a subject he knows nothing about. I don't know why Chris entertains his nonsense. He's simply trolling - he's a blowhard, shout loudly and often and hope he gets attention. He offers no insight into the subject at all.

As for MM, here's the relevant "runaway" smilie - :runaway

I really don't see the point anymore and I'm losing interest. The material in question is red paint adhered to rust, simple as. Truthers can trumpet as much as they like, but they are never going to get Harrit's failure of a paper recognised outside of the tiny number of truther's who've read it and an equally small number of debunkers who've ripped the paper to shreds.

I bet less than 100 people world wide have read the paper from start to finish, even fewer have actually understood the data. Even the authors didn't understand the data! :roll: Just look at Basile standing infront of an EDX semi-quantitative analysis showing less than 2% Al present in his sample and claiming it's thermite, it's comedy gold!

Millette's study was supposed to settle the issue, however, truthers will never accept an answer that doesn't say "thermite". They are not intellectually robust enough to analyse the data nor honest enough to admit wrong.

The fact that Jones, Harrit and Basile refuse to supply samples they claim are thermite for independent analysis should set alarm bells ringing. Doubly so for their flat out refusal to release data from tests they have already performed and promised, in the paper, to release. This is a classic indication that the authors are frauds and peddling woo-woo.

Truthers never question or hold the authors to their words instead they defend them at all cost.

No-one outside of JREF is interested and why should they be? Millette's study is a waste of time, which is why I never contributed towards it. It's nice from my professional point of view to be proven right, but any competent materials engineer/scientist would have looked at the same data and made the same conclusions.

Chris - if you want more answers then don't piss about with nonsense like Yahoo "Answers". If you want more answers confirming the right answer that the material is red paint then you are going to have to be less naive.

Rule #1 - Never mention thermite, ever. Do that and 99% of people will laugh and not respond to you because they think you are crazy.

Rule #2 - Never mention 9/11 conspiracy, ever. Do that and 99% of people will laugh and not respond to you because they think you are crazy.

Understand that all of this nonsense is crazy talk. People will treat you just the same as if they encounter the nutter on the bus or the man with the "The End is Nigh" sandwich board in the street. That may sound harsh, but I think it's fair.

If you really, really, really must have more answers then simply email the Harrit paper to materials engineers/chemists at universities and ask their opinion.

Don't go into any length at all just say, hi, I came across this paper, I don't fully understand it, can you please read it and give me some brief feedback. Thanks. That's it.

Don't mention thermite, don't mention 9/11, don't say why you are doing what you are doing, don't say you've got someone else to do experiments, just the absolute basics. These people are busy and don't want their time wasted, but the odd one or two will read it out of curiosity during a lunch break or in the pub and some may even reply. Be prepared for a very, very low number of responses.

Think of it a bit like a mail shot.

Even if you get 10,000 replies all saying the material is red paint, it still won't convince the truthers - nothing ever will.
 
Now for something new on the thread topic - Millette's Dust Study itself!

In Appendix G, he has shown results of EDS Mapping of a chip he had soeaked in MEK for 55 hours. The results are summarized thus:

Phase|Elemental Composition|% of Area Covered
1|Primary: Al nearly equal Si >Fe|24.10
2|Primary: C|33.02
3|Primary: High Si|7.92
4|Primary: Si>Fe>Al|11.57
5|Primary: Fe>Si>Al|3.24
6|Primary: Al nearly equal Si &Fe|20.15

He states: "No aluminum-only phase detected" - and that is correct; in none of the six phases is there more Al than anything else.

BUT! If this chip were the same material as chips a-d, or LaClede paint, I'd expect to see Al=Si everywhere. But that is not the case:
  • Phases 1 and six have "Al nearly equal Si", and those account for 44.25% of the area
  • Phases 3, 4 and 5 all have Si > Al; these account for 22,73% of the area
(The rest, 33.02%, is "primary C", but the corresponding map shows colored pixels mostly outside of the chip; does that mean the percentages apply to the entire image, and those 33.02% "primary C" are mostly carbon tape, onto which the specimen is attached?)

So it appears that 2/3 of the mineral phase have the expected "Al=Si" signature, but the other 1/3 have significantly more Si than Al, or hardly any Al at all. I'd think this is mainly silica then - which we have neither in chips a-d nor in LaClede paint!



Another slight problem I have with this EDS map is resolution: The map images, as I can grab them from the PDF file with a right-click and "copy image", are 186 pixels wide. They have a scale bar of 32 pixels = 100 µm. That's a resolution of ca. 3 µm/px.
SEM-EDS mapping can do better than that, and should do much better than that if we are to discern "nano" scale particles. Perhaps Millette's actual resolution is much better (I'd expect and hope for 100 nm/"px"), but I'd want to know this.

Farrer's image resolution in Fig. 10 is about 10 nm/px, in Fig 15 it's ca. 750 nm/px.


(I am aware that image resolution may well not be the same as actual EDS data resolution / spot size; but the image has to be good for something, so I assume a straightforward relationship)
 
So it appears that 2/3 of the mineral phase have the expected "Al=Si" signature, but the other 1/3 have significantly more Si than Al, or hardly any Al at all. I'd think this is mainly silica then - which we have neither in chips a-d nor in LaClede paint!
Not in chips a-d based on what?

I mean, he selected chips matching all characteristics of a-d. What makes you think that chips a-d would not have behaved this way in MEK?

My point being, Millette's chips didn't have this either to start with, right?
 
Last edited:
Hi JTL,

I have decided there is no further point in our discussions. I wish you well in your research, but our conversations have become fruitless. Your condescension and putdowns of my memory at every opportunity, your insistence that I haven't done any experiments when I organized a major experiment, and my reactions to you, calling you irritating etc., are taking the conversation nowhere. It is always my goal to try to retain civility and respect and I am getting too irritated with you personally to live up to my own personal ideals. I continue to be open to working with anyone to find a mutually-agreed-upon protocol for testing the chips with a lab both sides can agree is independent, assuming someone else has the funds to pay for such a study (around $6,000-$10000!). I continue to hope Steven Jones will release samples of his red-grey chips and the unpublished data he claims to have.

If anyone else wants to try to carry on a conversation with JTL they are welcome to try. JTL I wish you well and apologize for anything I may have said that was offensive or hurtful to you or others.
 
Not in chips a-d based on what?

I mean, he selected chips matching all characteristics of a-d. What makes you think that chips a-d would not have behaved this way in MEK?

My point being, Millette's chips didn't have this either to start with, right?

Based on Fig. 7, 10 and 11a:

Fig 7 shows that Al=Si overall in the red layers of these four chips
Fig. 10 shows that that Al and Si have identical spacial distribution, and both correlate with the platelets. In other words, there is no region, no particle in that image which contains Silica (Si, but no Al)
Fig. 11a shows that the platelets contain Al=Si

The platelets are kaolin clay - zero doubt about that.
Kaolin contains Al and Si in equal amounts. It is pervasive in these chips.
There would have to be some excess in Si in Fig. 7 if there were significant silica in addition to kaolin, but there isn't.


As far as I can see, Millette provides no EDS spectrum or BSE images for that chip shown in Appendix G, so I can't assess if it really has the same EDS characteristics and pigment morphology as chips a-d.
Correct me if I am wrong I spent little time on this.
 
Gentlemen, my weak mobile broadband signal won't allow me to download the contents of the dropbox. On an another site when I was citing Millette's work as disproving that of Harrit and Jones, I was handed this, and I'm unable to check it.

I quote a note from Dr Millette's progress report
Revised Report of Results: MVA9119
Progress Report on the
Analysis of Red/Gray Chips
in WTC Dust
Prepared for:
Classical Guide
Denver, CO

James R. Millette, Ph.D.
Executive Director

"Notes on the Source of the Red/Gray Chips
At the time of this progress report, the identity of the product from which the red/gray chips were generated has not been determined. The composition of the red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments) does not match the formula for the primer paint used on iron column members in the World Trade Center towers (Table 1)."
So much for the paint theory..


Is this correct?
 
Last edited:
"It is always my goal to try to retain civility and respect and I am getting too irritated with you personally to live up to my own personal ideals."

Hmm.

"If the Nazis [POWs] and the Americans could work together on a project during the fierce fighting of WWII, it's nice to know Truthers and Debunkers can do the same!"

Somehow I find it very very difficult to place much faith in the integrity of a 'part time' investigative journalist who believes people who are honestly trying to find out the truth about 9/11, are comparable to WWII-era German Nazis.

MM
 
Gentlemen, my weak mobile broadband signal won't allow me to download the contents of the dropbox. On an another site when I was citing Millette's work as disproving that of Harrit and Jones, I was handed this, and I'm unable to check it.

I quote a note from Dr Millette's progress report
Revised Report of Results: MVA9119
Progress Report on the
Analysis of Red/Gray Chips
in WTC Dust
Prepared for:
Classical Guide
Denver, CO

James R. Millette, Ph.D.
Executive Director

"Notes on the Source of the Red/Gray Chips
At the time of this progress report, the identity of the product from which the red/gray chips were generated has not been determined. The composition of the red/gray chips found in this study (epoxy resin with iron oxide and kaolin pigments) does not match the formula for the primer paint used on iron column members in the World Trade Center towers (Table 1)."
So much for the paint theory..


Is this correct?

It is correct that Millette wrote this.

What is not correct is the implied assumption that there was a single "the formula for the primer paint used on iron column members in the World Trade Center towers (Table 1)".
Table 1 shows the composition of one of the primers (plural!) that are known to have been applied to WTC steel, namely Tnemec Red 99, specified to be applied to the WTC perimeter columns. That formula contains, among other, ingredients, Zinc Chromate. Even though Millette, citing Harrit, gives a too high number for the expected Zinc content (it is Harrit who committed three to five rather stupid mistakes in the reference), the conclusion is correct that the chips that Harrit concentrated on can't be this Tnemec primer from the perimeter columns, because they contain no, or too little, Zinc.

However, there was at least one other primer paint, applied by the LaClede Steel Company to the floor joists. Their composition is Zinc-free. Some of the chips that Millette studied, and the Chips a-d in the Harrit study, have elemental spectra that are an excellent match for the LaClede primer.

Millette apparantly wasn't aware of the existence of the LaClede primer at the time he released this preliminary report, but he is now, and will account for it in the final report.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom