WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Does that mean Millette has not been proven to be a fraud, then?

A charge by itself is not a proof, it has to be examined to determine "a verdict".
What may be perceived as fraud could possibly be a mistake not intentional fraud. Did Millette or anyone from his team of each study respond on their behalf? Start a thread to get to the bottom of this problem.

My point is Ryan was justified mentioning the charges of fraud and Mohr´s attempts to bury them make him look bad, not Ryan.
 
My point is Ryan was justified mentioning the charges of fraud and Mohr´s attempts to bury them make him look bad, not Ryan.

Wouldn't this be spit-balling on the part of Ryan? What was he hoping to achieve?

Looks to me like he was looking for an excuse to not cooperate and you guys bought it.

How's the effort to get the Harrit/Jones guys to release the data they said they had going?
 
So what? You have already admitted that Jenkins (in the document that Ryan cites) charged a couple of (EPA) studies with fraud in which Millette participated. You actually think that you can change this fact by citing some other document where Jenkins names Millette by name and calls him an "expert witness for the EPA"?

Who do you think is responsible for those studies charged with fraud? The authors maybe? You never answered my question about whether or not Jenkins singled out some authors or if the fraud charge implicates all of them? You guys should dedicate a special thread to this subject since you keep bringing it up.


The best part of your post. You can't specify the charges, or point to what was called fraud. You did not look at the studies to find there was no fraud.

If you look carefully at all the steel recovered on 911, and studied; not a single piece has thermite damage. Kind of makes not finding thermite in the dust the only outcome of a study. Millette's findings are confirmed by other dust studies done may years ago. Studies you must of missed, skipped, so you could have Jones thermite to back you fantasy for 911.

Feel free to list what was done wrong, and show it was on purpose. Expose to the world what Millette did wrong. Oops, he failed to confirm your fantasy on 911.


I saw the study, and the charges are BS. Like Jones claim of thermite, BS. As usual with 911 truth, it all turns out to be nonsense. You have thermite nonsense, you have 11 plus years of solid failure from a nut on 911, Jones.
 
Last edited:
A charge by itself is not a proof, it has to be examined to determine "a verdict".
What may be perceived as fraud could possibly be a mistake not intentional fraud. Did Millette or anyone from his team of each study respond on their behalf? Start a thread to get to the bottom of this problem.

My point is Ryan was justified mentioning the charges of fraud and Mohr´s attempts to bury them make him look bad, not Ryan.

Isn't it "Innocent until proven guilty"? Can you see how Ryan's brining this up could just be "poisoning the well", so to speak? Does anything Millette has done in the study he has performed for Chris Mohr justify a fraud charge? Why couldn't Ryan let Millette's data stand on it's own, without tainting it with an unproven fraud allegation in which Millette's direct culpability is tangential at best? This all must be a critical point to you, to continue to harp on it and not on any scientific merits of Millette's work.
 
Isn't it "Innocent until proven guilty"? Can you see how Ryan's brining this up could just be "poisoning the well", so to speak? Does anything Millette has done in the study he has performed for Chris Mohr justify a fraud charge? Why couldn't Ryan let Millette's data stand on it's own, without tainting it with an unproven fraud allegation in which Millette's direct culpability is tangential at best? This all must be a critical point to you, to continue to harp on it and not on any scientific merits of Millette's work.
Even if the claims were true they do not constitute criminal fraud. At most the legal issue is on of misrepresentation in the setting of private contractual obligations. i.e. Millette to Mohr where Mohr as injured party could make claims. What loss has Mohr suffered? Is Mohr likely to take action? Who else has standing to initiate action? ....case over ....actually there is no case....:rolleyes:
 
There are two papers authored by Cate Jenkins.

The first one was dated May 6th, 2007 and contains many accusations against many groups and people. In this paper, under the heading Research lead by Rutgers neutralizes WTC dust before pH testing, she accuses this "Rutgers" group (which Millette was a part) as intentionally and deliberately neutralizing the samples (in water) before testing the pH.

Water or exposure to atmospheric moisture to any material containing
alkaline calcium, sodium, and potassium hydroxides results in neutralization from carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. This is a very commonly known, well understood chemical reaction, described in high school chemistry textbooks, the NIOSH Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazards, old and new editions of the Merck Index,and other common technical resources. The ability of atmospheric carbon dioxide to acidify water over time would also be very well known to any scientist involved with air pollution research, because this is the basis for the formation of "acid rain" from excessive levels of carbon dioxide in the air.

In the second paper, a petition, submitted September 8th, 2011, she wants the EPA to correct the Corrosivity Characteristic regulation. Something she says has been falsified by the EPA since 1980.

EPA has reviewed and reassessed this falsified pH level over the years, perpetuating the fraud, and continues to this day to maintain the Corrosivity Characteristic regulation regulations which incorporate this unsafe pH level.

Millette was mentioned three times in this petition, but only for references as Chris Mohr has mentioned previously.
 
Charge of fraud does not mean the author is guilty of fraud, that has to be examined in each case. But Ryan did not say Millette is a fraud, he said Jenkins charged his studies with fraud, which is true.

jtl, Jenkins never once accused Dr. Millette of fraud. In a court of law, her statements would never even be allowed into court to impeach Dr. Millette, but Ryan's out of court statement that she did could probably be used against him to impeach his credibility as a witness. Perhaps JREF's own Goddess of Legaltainment, LashL, might wish to comment.
 
jtl, Jenkins never once accused Dr. Millette of fraud. In a court of law, her statements would never even be allowed into court to impeach Dr. Millette, but Ryan's out of court statement that she did could probably be used against him to impeach his credibility as a witness...
Step One: How does it even get into court? What is the basis of action? Who has standing to pursue it? :)
 
Originally Posted by Redwood
jtl, Jenkins never once accused Dr. Millette of fraud. In a court of law, her statements would never even be allowed into court to impeach Dr. Millette, but Ryan's out of court statement that she did could probably be used against him to impeach his credibility as a witness...

Step One: How does it even get into court? What is the basis of action? Who has standing to pursue it? :)

That IS a big hurdle, isn't it? ;) Maybe a court could have a special, one-time only offer to entertain goofball ideas, and jtl could file suit asking the court to rule that "Dr. James Millette is a poopy-head", with Kevin Ryan as star witness. :D
 
Just as an FYI, I have now added links from video to video for people who want to easily find their way through all my Gage rebuttal YouTube videos which start here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jC3JgWkNNIQ
...and include two whole videos dedicated to the "Thermites in the Dust" theory. Some day I will do a third video which will include important updates like Jim Millette's study. Also, I have pretty much completed my work on the 9/11 debate website (me vs several 9/11 Truth people):
http://911theories.org/ChrisMohr
It's a continuation of my debate with Richard Gage post-Blueprint for Truth and post-my-respectful-rebuttals, with hundreds of links for anyone who wants to do research on either side of this subject.
Speaking of Richard Gage, I will give him the last word on the subject being argued about here. Last time I visited with him in person I was driving him alone to a gathering here in Denver and I told him about Kevin Ryan's accusations against Jim Millette. His response was refreshing: "That's the good thing about science; in the end it's the science and not the personalities that matter."
 
Mohr: That's the good thing about science; in the end it's the science and not the personalities that matter.

Whoa, this is true, although it is easy to get the impression that your buddies on this forum do not agree given their endless mud slinging when it comes to Harrit et al.

BUT it is also true that Millette has been accused of fraud and you should not try to cover it up, it makes you look really bad. It is also a fact that a scientist with accusations of fraud on his back will be treated with more suspicion that others, and especially in this case since the fraud charges were about his previous studies on WTC dust.

And with "it´s the science that matters" in mind, it has been about one year now since the preliminary report but still not reviewed and published for some reason. Millette has some problems?
 
Whoa, this is true, although it is easy to get the impression that your buddies on this forum do not agree given their endless mud slinging when it comes to Harrit et al.

BUT it is also true that Millette has been accused of fraud and you should not try to cover it up, it makes you look really bad. It is also a fact that a scientist with accusations of fraud on his back will be treated with more suspicion that others, and especially in this case since the fraud charges were about his previous studies on WTC dust.

And with "it´s the science that matters" in mind, it has been about one year now since the preliminary report but still not reviewed and published for some reason. Millette has some problems?
I figure English is not your native language?
 
Whoa, this is true, although it is easy to get the impression that your buddies on this forum do not agree given their endless mud slinging when it comes to Harrit et al.

BUT it is also true that Millette has been accused of fraud and you should not try to cover it up, it makes you look really bad. It is also a fact that a scientist with accusations of fraud on his back will be treated with more suspicion that others, and especially in this case since the fraud charges were about his previous studies on WTC dust.

And with "it´s the science that matters" in mind, it has been about one year now since the preliminary report but still not reviewed and published for some reason. Millette has some problems?

Have you got any evidence to support any of your claims ?
 
Whoa, this is true, although it is easy to get the impression that your buddies on this forum do not agree given their endless mud slinging when it comes to Harrit et al.

BUT it is also true that Millette has been accused of fraud and you should not try to cover it up, it makes you look really bad. It is also a fact that a scientist with accusations of fraud on his back will be treated with more suspicion that others, and especially in this case since the fraud charges were about his previous studies on WTC dust.

And with "it´s the science that matters" in mind, it has been about one year now since the preliminary report but still not reviewed and published for some reason. Millette has some problems?

Unable to follow the conversation of the thread? He is still looking to add pieces to the paper before it is released. He's attempting to track down more paints to make sure the paper is as thorough as possible. Can you tell me how long it took to release the Bentham paper from start to finish?

The "fraud" charges don't hold water to anyone other than you. Millette has proven that he is a dependable, intelligent scientist. Your desire to muddy the water and paint him as otherwise are duly noted throughout the forum.

You speak as if Harritt et. al. have pristine records. Obviously the Millette study proves they are fraudulent, hiding relevant information, and possibly more.
 
Last edited:
Our efforts to find paint primer from a WTC truss is still being met with frustration... You may remember our attempts to get paint from the Red Knights, a motorcycle/firefighters' club who has a WTC memorial with the trusses. An FDNY first responder agreed to ask them personally for a small paint sample, giving us the maximum possible credibility for our request. Their response? "It's a no go. Their thinking is that they don't want to ligitimize any 911 truther arguments."

On reflection, it's probably a very wise move from the knights. It's only people like jtl, senenmut, and MM who are still convinced with the thermite thing and I guess they always will be. You only need to read their posts to see they are clutching at straws. None of them have the Balls to ask Jones & Co to give a detailed response to Millette's work.
 
BUT it is also true that Millette has been accused of fraud and you should not try to cover it up, it makes you look really bad. It is also a fact that a scientist with accusations of fraud on his back will be treated with more suspicion that others, and especially in this case since the fraud charges were about his previous studies on WTC dust.

And with "it´s the science that matters" in mind, it has been about one year now since the preliminary report but still not reviewed and published for some reason. Millette has some problems?

Jtl, to repeat: No one has ever charged Millette with fraud. This has been explained to you. Kevin Ryan, the charlatan, has falsely implied that a third party accused Millette of fraud. Serving as Ryan's unpaid parrot is only discrediting you. Ask yourself what you are accomplishing here. Do you think you have persuaded even one person?

One more time: Jtl, you seem to be of roughly high school age. Enroll in some freshman chemistry and physics classes at your local community college. You might also see if they have courses on standards of evidence. You'll get smarter. You might even go for a degree in science, or law. When you finish, there'll still be truthers around, spinning their wheels as they've been for almost a dozen years. Who knows? Maybe by then you can become a star of Trutherism, but I should hope that you'll look back and shake your head and smile about how young and foolish you once were.
 
By the way Mohr, maybe you should make some videos based on comments by Redwood et al. Really impressive stuff.:rolleyes:
 
By the way Mohr, maybe you should make some videos based on comments by Redwood et al. Really impressive stuff.:rolleyes:
:rolleyes:=all the evidence you will ever have to support your fantasy of thermite. cute

Millette found no thermite, Jones lied and said there was thermite. WTC steel says no thermite.

A video? There is no need to debunk the fantasy of thermite. Wait until you wake up and realize Jones' thermite claims are delusional ravings of personable old man who hates war, and his government. You are going to be upset, and wonder how you fell for fantasy. Good luck
 
Last edited:
By the way Mohr, maybe you should make some videos based on comments by Redwood et al. Really impressive stuff.:rolleyes:

Thanks for the plug, Jtl! I tried teaching you a little about thermodynamics in an earlier post, but it seems to have gone in one ear and out the other.

You really should consider my suggestion to enroll in some college chemistry and physics courses. You'll get thermo in your junior year.
 
Last edited:
Someone just reposted the audio of my 2011 debate with Richard Gage (video was never released). The debate around the "thermitic chips" is about 3/4 the way through the second part of these very long mp3s. That part of the debate would certainly be different today, as I've learned much since then!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom