WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Thanks for the plug, Jtl! I tried teaching you a little about thermodynamics in an earlier post, but it seems to have gone in one ear and out the other.

....

Like a hot neutrino through butter.
 
Last edited:
... That part of the debate would certainly be different today, as I've learned much since then!!!
That is part of the extra burden we debunkers carry. Our words written down reveal the state of our understanding when we wrote them and we do tend to improve understanding. So the risk of red face when we read something we wrote years ago before we reached our present level of understanding.

One minor example for me is from my first internet post explaining WTC Twin Towers collapse - posted 13/14 Nov 2007:
The block of top storeys starts to crush the remaining structure progressively from the top down until the damaged areas disappear into the resultant dust cloud.
(Emphasis added)
OUCH!! :o :o

No way would I use the word "crush" these days since I am now aware of the significant errors of explanation based on column 'crushing' i.e. buckling in axial compression.
 
Last edited:
My search for the World Trade Center debris (where maybe we can get a scraping of LaClede red primer paint) ended when I talked with someone at the Port Authority where the debis had been stored. If I understand correctly, the entire hangar has been cleared out and debris distributed to memorials around the country. She is not divulging the locations of these memorials for privacy reasons, but some 1500 places have been chosen to receive pieces of WTC debris, each piece identified as to which part of the WTC Buildings it originally came from.

So I typed in "World Trade Center Memorial Sites Colorado" into google to see if any such memorials exist near me. This article came up in the Denver Post: http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_18632607
I am guessing that this will not be a good source for LaClede primer from the trusses. However, I am confident that wherever you live, you can type in the same keywords and local newspaper articles from 2011 (when all this debris was distributed nationwide for memorials) will be easy to find.

I plan to visit the memorial in any case, just to pay tribute to the thousands who lost their lives that terrible day. If anyone else wants to take this up, it may well be possible to find trusses in the debris somewhere (where perhaps red LaClede primer paint can be found), and pretty easy to find these memorials popping up everywhere. Let's all be respectful but there may yet be a source for this primer.
 
I am also writing to chemists asking if they might be interested in giving an objective, unbiased look at the Bentham paper by Jones/Harrit/Ryan et al, as well as a look at Jim Millette's preliminary report. So far, several independent chemists have said very negative things about the Bentham paper but have not really looked at it. One chemist, however, has agreed to pass my email on to his grad students to see if any of them want to take it on as a research poject. Encouraged by this response, I just sent my info-request email out to ten more chemistry professors this morning!
 
I am also writing to chemists asking if they might be interested in giving an objective, unbiased look at the Bentham paper by Jones/Harrit/Ryan et al, as well as a look at Jim Millette's preliminary report. So far, several independent chemists have said very negative things about the Bentham paper but have not really looked at it. One chemist, however, has agreed to pass my email on to his grad students to see if any of them want to take it on as a research poject. Encouraged by this response, I just sent my info-request email out to ten more chemistry professors this morning!

This is all very interesting Chris Mohr, but if Millette is going to have the paper reviewed and published, don´t you think it is about time he does it? It´s been a year since you got the preliminary report, so it is looking less and less likely that this will ever become a reviewed paper.
 
This is all very interesting Chris Mohr, but if Millette is going to have the paper reviewed and published, don´t you think it is about time he does it? It´s been a year since you got the preliminary report, so it is looking less and less likely that this will ever become a reviewed paper.

Lol
What's the big rush.
 
This is all very interesting Chris Mohr, but if Millette is going to have the paper reviewed and published, don´t you think it is about time he does it? It´s been a year since you got the preliminary report, so it is looking less and less likely that this will ever become a reviewed paper.
I thought you'd be excited that other chemists will finally get to read and voice their opinions on the Harrit paper.

So far just about everyone that has was not impressed. In fact, didn't one group say they found paint?

How many chemists do you figure have come out in support of their paper?
 
publish the paper if you can, opinions are plentiful, actual research not so much. the hogwash on this forum is not presentable but a published paper would force harrit et al to respond, no matter how shoddy the paper is.
 
publish the paper if you can, opinions are plentiful, actual research not so much. the hogwash on this forum is not presentable but a published paper would force harrit et al to respond, no matter how shoddy the paper is.

If its all hogwash, why are you posting here ?
 
How many chemists do you figure have come out in support of their paper?

publish the paper if you can, opinions are plentiful, actual research not so much. the hogwash on this forum is not presentable but a published paper would force harrit et al to respond, no matter how shoddy the paper is.

Surely there must be plenty of chemists coming out in support of the paper. It's been out for years.

Is this another case where they can't because they might lose their jobs? :rolleyes:
 
This is all very interesting Chris Mohr, but if Millette is going to have the paper reviewed and published, don´t you think it is about time he does it? It´s been a year since you got the preliminary report, so it is looking less and less likely that this will ever become a reviewed paper.
? How many papers have you been part of and published? How long did it take? Why did Jones have to publish in a pay to publish Journal? Because real journals would not publish nonsense. The conclusion is nonsense based on cherry-picking BS they presented in Jones failed paper. The paper published in a vanity journal.

The preliminary report is out. But the need to publish a paper which replicates and refutes a paper of nonsense has no priority to be published in a academic paper. Refuting nuts like Harrit and Jones is not the purpose of science, of academia. The paper may never get published because it serves no purpose, academia does not usually make fun of nuts like Jones - his delusion on 911 is sufficient smack down. He is a failed man, pushing nonsense; is it sad to see such a personable man spread fantasy, and sad to see people fall for it, hook line and sinker.

publish the paper if you can, opinions are plentiful, actual research not so much. the hogwash on this forum is not presentable but a published paper would force harrit et al to respond, no matter how shoddy the paper is.
Harrit and Jones already respond to JREF claims. It is funny, they are so paranoid they make up more papers to counter claims made here; they are kind of nuts on 911. They made up a conclusion of thermite and fooled a fringe few. Who do you think inspired them to publish in a journal, forcing them to pay to publish their failed claim of thermite. It is pathetic.

Unlike Watergate, 911 truth has no evidence for the Big Lie of an inside job. 11 years of failure - 911 truth - Jones and Harrit. What conference did Jones present his paper of woo?
 
Last edited:
If its all hogwash, why are you posting here ?

Since you lot asked for and paid for Millette, you are the only ones in a position to make him deliver what you paid for. At this point, I do not believe he will deliver.
 
And Harrits fantasy thinking was exposed again this week when he thought he was part of a court case where the BBC were being taken to court. :rolleyes:
 
Since you lot asked for and paid for Millette, you are the only ones in a position to make him deliver what you paid for. At this point, I do not believe he will deliver.

And yet your the one worried about it ;)
 
Hi all,

I just talked with Jim Millette today. He had hoped to get back to the long-delayed dust experiments in January but his business got a slew of jobs he didn't expect. He welcomed my call and asked me to call him again in April. More WTC dust experiments and more data are hopefully eventually on the way, but he can't turn down business to do an unfunded project. Whatever we get from him at whatever point in time it arrives will be a welcome bonus. People on both sides are tossing out opinions, but his contractual agreement with me is fulfilled, and we will see how he chooses to spend his spare time on this project. For example, Beachnut, your assumption that "the need to publish a paper which replicates and refutes a paper of nonsense has no priority to be published in a academic paper. Refuting nuts like Harrit and Jones is not the purpose of science, of academia. The paper may never get published because it serves no purpose, academia does not usually make fun of nuts like Jones - his delusion on 911 is sufficient smack down" -- is not quite accurate. Forensic scientists and grad students have been following Millette's progress on this study, not just JREFers and 9/11 Truth folks. If Millette produces a paper (and he is under no obligation to do so), I'd say chances of it getting published are high because it teaches the readers a lot about chemical forensics. Specifically, it can be seen as an object lesson in the technique of looking for thermitic materials, which is occasionally investigated by forensic scientists.
 
Mohr: He welcomed my call and asked me to call him again in April.

In other words, the same bs you have been given for a whole year. Call back in April and he will tell you to call back in September...and the same until you figure it out and give up.

If Millette produces a paper (and he is under no obligation to do so)

But given your iffy response it seems you have realized there won´t be any paper. When you raised money for the study, did you promise that it would actually become a paper along with your promise of replicated tests?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom