William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

<snip>Under US law anything written on the internet constitutes publication, and is thus libel, not slander.

This is also true of Canadian law.

3B is conflating "publication" with "broadcasting" and erroneously thinking that the two are synonymous. They are not.

Under US law (which is what is relevant here) the comments could be considered libel. They cannot be considered slander. And frankly Mr Rodriguez would have a very hard time proving libel.

This is also true of Canadian law. While there are differences in the elements required to be established to prove libel in Canadian law and U.S. law, even under the more lenient Canadian provisions, Rodriguez would have a very, very hard time sustaining a case for libel. Some of those whom Rodriguez has libeled probably have a stronger case than he does but they, too, would have a hard time sustaining a case for libel against him.

Finally, I seriously cannot understand how anyone could interpret Lash's assertions that posted comments are libel rather than slander as meaning that Lash is saying libel is okay!

Me, neither.

I suspect that perhaps that was just a language barrier issue.

Indeed, most people would agree that libel is worse than slander.

Agreed.
 
LashL, you keep making false statements about the law and refuse to provide any evidence to support your case. Cite one Canadian case to support your argument.
 
LashL; said:
This is also true of Canadian law.
3B is conflating "publication" with "broadcasting" and erroneously thinking that the two are synonymous. They are not.

Wrong, this is an outright lie. I clearly pointed out to you they were not synonymous, where they are defined, and what is included in the definition. HOW DARE YOU LIE LIKE THIS!

please end this now before it becomes personal.
 
Last edited:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I imagine Canada shares the same defamation common law that is shared by the UK and other commonwealth nations, yes? In which case an internet message board post is indeed publication, and is indeed libel, not slander.

In regards to specific cases, I refer you to Keith-Smith Vs Williams (2006). This was a British case in which a person was sued for liable after making remarks about the plaintiff in a Yahoo discussion group with about 100 members.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff on the grounds that the remarks were published and accessible to the entire world.

Thus, this case is part of British common law on defamation, and therefore part of Canadian common law.

-Gumboot
 
There are also specfic examples of Candian law (which differs in Quebec from Commonwealth nations.)

http://www.dba-oracle.com/internet_laws_message_boards_forums_blogs_personal_liability.htm
International Cyber Libel Laws

Canadian courts have ruled that the Internet is a "Broadcast medium" subject to the same rules of libel as traditional broadcast media such as TV and radio. This ruling has far-reaching impact for cyber libel


And, interstingly, spoken words on tv/radio are considered libel.
 
Me, neither.

I suspect that perhaps that was just a language barrier issue.

Thank you for granting the benefit of the doubt, although I feel there shouldn't be any doubt about the sincerity of my comments. I almost feel I have to thank you now for not attacking my question. However, there is no need to ponder on Gumboot's comment, since I have anticipated and explained a possible reason for my possible confusion in a previous post, and in the original post. I also think it's more then a language barrier issue. Unless you are convinced that this is such a simple legal issue that anyone should understand this immediately even outside of the US or Canada. Furthermore, I don't think I'm a complete illiterate dunce, but I am aware that I may be easily confused regarding the meaning of all the terms in a legal context. It seems rather strange to require an elaborate explanation for a question mark three times in a row, but I hope and think I've been sufficiently clear about it's purpose.

SYL :)
 
Last edited:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I imagine Canada shares the same defamation common law that is shared by the UK and other commonwealth nations, yes? In which case an internet message board post is indeed publication, and is indeed libel, not slander.

In regards to specific cases, I refer you to Keith-Smith Vs Williams (2006). This was a British case in which a person was sued for liable after making remarks about the plaintiff in a Yahoo discussion group with about 100 members.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff on the grounds that the remarks were published and accessible to the entire world.

Thus, this case is part of British common law on defamation, and therefore part of Canadian common law.

-Gumboot


I read the reference you made and it made me think about an internet discussion forum where girls post their experiences with men after a date. One of the guys tried to sew the owner of the website. The website was www.dontdatehimgirl.com
The problem was that all the girls were anonymous, the guys were identifiable and although they could post a comment after having registered, the moderator would decide whether a comment could get posted. The decision by the moderator made it a publication, at least that was the argument. I don’t know what happened to that dispute. Since this is not the case in JREF, that argument doesn’t apply. So I think you’re reference still stands.

In most of Europe the legal system is quite different from both the US and Canada, many laws are national and others are European. I think defamation law is regulated nationally in European countries, so the UK could have very different laws from the rest of Europe and I think they do. I don’t know about the commonwealth.

SYL :)
 
In most of Europe the legal system is quite different from both the US and Canada, many laws are national and others are European. I think defamation law is regulated nationally in European countries, so the UK could have very different laws from the rest of Europe and I think they do. I don’t know about the commonwealth.

SYL :)


Both commonwealth (including Canada) and USA law is based on English common law. That is, any previous case in the body of English common law, dating back centuries, can be brought up in a current case as an established precedent.

If a case occurs in, say, New Zealand, which sets a precedent in interpreting a specific law, a case at the same or lower level in Canada, or the UK, etc. will be bound by the same precedent until overturned by a higher court.

Full common law states include:

Canada - Federal law and provincial law except for Quebec civil law
USA - Federal law and all state laws except Louisiana
Australia - Federal and State
New Zealand
Republic of Ireland
United Kingdom - excluding Scotland

-Gumboot
 
Both commonwealth (including Canada) and USA law is based on English common law. That is, any previous case in the body of English common law, dating back centuries, can be brought up in a current case as an established precedent.

If a case occurs in, say, New Zealand, which sets a precedent in interpreting a specific law, a case at the same or lower level in Canada, or the UK, etc. will be bound by the same precedent until overturned by a higher court.

Full common law states include:

Canada - Federal law and provincial law except for Quebec civil law
USA - Federal law and all state laws except Louisiana
Australia - Federal and State
New Zealand
Republic of Ireland
United Kingdom - excluding Scotland

-Gumboot

Er...are you sure about that? Here in Australia, precedents are set by the High Court of Australia, and are binding to all lower Australian courts. They have no legal effect on anything in the UK or anywhere else though, just as decisions in the UK have no effect on common law in Australia - it's been that way since the Australia Act 1986, which abolished the right to appeal to privy council (among other things).

Decisions from other countries might be persuasive, but they do not set any precendents in Australia.
 
Er...are you sure about that? Here in Australia, precedents are set by the High Court of Australia, and are binding to all lower Australian courts. They have no legal effect on anything in the UK or anywhere else though, just as decisions in the UK have no effect on common law in Australia - it's been that way since the Australia Act 1986, which abolished the right to appeal to privy council (among other things).

Decisions from other countries might be persuasive, but they do not set any precendents in Australia.


Sorry, yes you're right. Interpretations in other common law countries are not binding but they do set a precedent which can be persuasive (to use your word).

In other words, if an issue has not been raised before in Australia, but has been raised in the UK, USA, and New Zealand (for example) the lawyers can raise these previous cases as being in support of a finding the same way.

-Gumboot
 
I read the reference you made and it made me think about an internet discussion forum where girls post their experiences with men after a date. One of the guys tried to sew the owner of the website. The website was www.dontdatehimgirl.com
The problem was that all the girls were anonymous, the guys were identifiable and although they could post a comment after having registered, the moderator would decide whether a comment could get posted. The decision by the moderator made it a publication, at least that was the argument. I don’t know what happened to that dispute.

Who would think that the Online Dating Industry would have their own journal? Well they do, and the lawsuit in question was dismissed. Here's the details:

http://onlinedating.typepad.com/industry/2007/04/dont_date_him_g.html
 
gumboot; said:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I imagine Canada shares the same defamation common law that is shared by the UK and other commonwealth nations, yes? In which case an internet message board post is indeed publication, and is indeed libel, not slander.

In regards to specific cases, I refer you to Keith-Smith Vs Williams (2006). This was a British case in which a person was sued for liable after making remarks about the plaintiff in a Yahoo discussion group with about 100 members.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff on the grounds that the remarks were published and accessible to the entire world.

Thus, this case is part of British common law on defamation, and therefore part of Canadian common law.

-Gumboot

No, the libel and slander act can change from province to province. But they are all relatively the same. I'm not really sure what is so hard to fathom. The law was obviously written before the internet, so it obviously wasn't written to cover the internet. People have tried to bring actions against another based on something that was said or posted on the internet. Statements on the internet were deemed not libelous for the purposes or the act and the case was dismissed. Unless a new ruling overturns that, or the law has been rewritten, it is considered slander. This is why I have said show me a case which confirms this or relent.

(I beleive the case Tokorna is referring to was overturned in a higher court)
 
Last edited:
Great, let’s have some…
Get WR back and give him a fair chance to present his argument, in full.


We have already given him plenty of chances, how many more would you have us give?


Maybe confront him first with the quotes, confirm he said it, ask why he said it, what he means by it, and then ask on what grounds me made his statements. Doesn't that sound fair?


We already know what he said, he repeated it in this very thread!


I know you dislike WR and as it seems most of the forum does. You agree that this thread is leading nowhere and serves no purpose? The mods closed it down once already and only reopened it to see where this was going. Since everyone has taken a cynical approach to this rather then a skeptic one, I think this thread has run it's course...


No one has taken a cynical approach (with the possible exception of tsig). You are not familiar with our previous encounters with WR that have defined our current approach


Oh well you two, both of you, won't drop it so I gotta respond.

Moby: There was no strawman, it was out of context. If it weren't, people wouldn't have been trying for the last day and a half to supplement the thread with context. If you keep doing this then you will fail GONG (that means your time is up, off the stage)
ps- thanks for the kitten :)
pss- (it very well could be a false dilemma, I don't know what that is)
psss- what's a logic student?


You're supposed to add extra Ps not extra Ss.
 
Mobyseven; said:
You're right. Calling somebody a cheerleader is totally impersonal. :rolleyes:

Care to explain how the quote was taken out of context yet?

Edited by chillzero: 
Removing uncivil remark


I find it hard to believe you know so little about common law as a self professed student. This has happened many times where the law fails to keep up with technology. If you are so well versed in the law, then a simple "No, I'm afraid the law has recently included "blogging" in it's defintion, as per this case on such and such a day in such and such a place" That's what a lawyer would do. That's what any professional would do to offer constructive criticism or clarification. You on the other hand did not, you attacked me and my ability to understand the issue. This is typical, and another example of totally unacceptable behaviour.

As far as the context of the statement, and Mr. Rodriguez's subsequent posting. I still think it was taken out of context and I think exactly what pomeroo said about him working the room. It looked like he deliberately lead the forum on to continue the childish behaviour, at a gain to himself.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's really annoying when I have to do a person's research for them.

OTTAWA --The rapid rise of amateur commentators mounting the soapbox of Internet blogs has led to a small, but growing number of online libel cases.

It used to be that only established media and publishing organizations had to worry about libel, but now anyone with web access and a quick temper can find themselves facing a lawsuit.

"The Internet is the single most important reason for the increase in the number of libel lawsuits in this country," says Roger McConchie, a Vancouver-based Internet and libel lawyer.

...

On his website, McConchie maintains a database of the Internet libel cases in which damages are awarded in Canada, but he says the list is only "the tip of the iceberg," because the vast majority of cases are resolved before they ever reach a courtroom.

According to his statistics, damages have been awarded in two Internet libel cases so far in 2006, as compared to three traditional libel suits. Last year, only one of the 22 libel cases in which damages were awarded involved Internet material, which McConchie attributes to the slow and sometimes uneven progress of the court system.

In 2004, eight cases of Internet libel ended with damages being awarded, while five Internet cases resulted in damages in 2003.

By contrast, a total of just five Internet libel cases were brought to verdict in the four years before that.

Source

And here is his website.

3bodyproblem, with all due respect, you are incorrect. Defamation on the internet, by Canadian common law, is libel, not defamation.

-Gumboot
 
Who would think that the Online Dating Industry would have their own journal? Well they do, and the lawsuit in question was dismissed. Here's the details:
I see, is that what happened,… Not really a victory is it,… He is in the wrong court. :D
Thanks for the link :)

We have already given him plenty of chances, how many more would you have us give?
We already know what he said, he repeated it in this very thread!
No one has taken a cynical approach (with the possible exception of tsig). You are not familiar with our previous encounters with WR that have defined our current approach.

Wow, OK

I feel a bit embarrassed doing this, but here goes… The dictionary:
Cynical
Cynic
Skeptical
Skeptic

Now which one do you feel applies to the statements above. I think everyone already made up his/her mind before hearing him and in select cases even without hearing the issue, don’t you agree? Not much doubt there…

You may be right, but I feel a bit uncomfortable looking at the reactions. I agree that it may be very frustrating to hear twoofers speak, but we give them a chance anyway and are often more patient then this. Especially when you consider that someone is misguided in some way, rather than being a true fraud, giving up is not really something I and 3bodyproblem like to do. If it hadn’t been for 3bodyproblem’s patience and relentless support in reaching a better understanding, I might have been a tinfoil hatter by now… A good one too. Information and an alternative perspective combined with a patient explanation of the events made me see the twoofers had no unsolved questions and made up my mind. So I’m more inclined to give 3bodyproblem the benefit of the doubt.

The ex-CT thing is not something I’m proud of, but certainly a reason not to give up on people very easily. People change their mind, sometimes even slightly, but you have to give them an honest chance to do so. Changing your mind and being a true skeptic is not always easy and takes some courage to do when you have to oppose your friends in the process. Willie is in a situation he almost can’t get out of. You have to consider that too when you decide to give someone a chance to present their argument. Looking at the EPA and the health issues involved, I wouldn't be too quick to judge and say it's all bunk. Careful examination is never a bad thing and really does not imply any support for a conspiracy idea either. True skeptics are in some way, to some level, really fencesitters in my opinion, as apposed to a true cynic. Hence the million dollar challenge... Yes, I know twoofers are extremely frustrating...

I have been confronted by this argument for the third time now, I think. I understand your feelings and respect them. Now understand mine, I feel skepticism implies evaluation of arguments. Let him present his or stop the discussion. After all that has been said, this thread is rather pointless now. So I stand by my proposal to close this thread.

So much pointless bickering. This thread would have been better left closed.
I agree

SYL :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom