LashL
Goddess of Legaltainment™
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2006
- Messages
- 36,711
<snip>Under US law anything written on the internet constitutes publication, and is thus libel, not slander.
This is also true of Canadian law.
3B is conflating "publication" with "broadcasting" and erroneously thinking that the two are synonymous. They are not.
Under US law (which is what is relevant here) the comments could be considered libel. They cannot be considered slander. And frankly Mr Rodriguez would have a very hard time proving libel.
This is also true of Canadian law. While there are differences in the elements required to be established to prove libel in Canadian law and U.S. law, even under the more lenient Canadian provisions, Rodriguez would have a very, very hard time sustaining a case for libel. Some of those whom Rodriguez has libeled probably have a stronger case than he does but they, too, would have a hard time sustaining a case for libel against him.
Finally, I seriously cannot understand how anyone could interpret Lash's assertions that posted comments are libel rather than slander as meaning that Lash is saying libel is okay!
Me, neither.
I suspect that perhaps that was just a language barrier issue.
Indeed, most people would agree that libel is worse than slander.
Agreed.