William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

I think Gumboot answered this, and I agreed.


Did I? Where?

I think Mr Rodriguez's behaviour has been utterly disgusting and I have no respect for him whatsoever. I won't be posting my full opinion of him and his actions because it's a violation of the forum rules. But suffice to say I don't think much of him at all.

I encourage other posters here not to personally attack Mr Rodriguez. I do this only because I do not wish to see these posters suspended or banned for violating forum rules. This doesn't mean I personally disagree with what they're saying.

I respect the forum rules here, as I agreed to when I joined up. But outside these forums I will not hesitate to call someone a [rule8] if I believe they are acting like a [rule8].

-Gumboot
 
gumboot; said:
Did I? Where?

I think Mr Rodriguez's behaviour has been utterly disgusting and I have no respect for him whatsoever. I won't be posting my full opinion of him and his actions because it's a violation of the forum rules. But suffice to say I don't think much of him at all.

I encourage other posters here not to personally attack Mr Rodriguez. I do this only because I do not wish to see these posters suspended or banned for violating forum rules. This doesn't mean I personally disagree with what they're saying.

I respect the forum rules here, as I agreed to when I joined up. But outside these forums I will not hesitate to call someone a [rule8] if I believe they are acting like a [rule8].

-Gumboot

Again I agree with what you are saying. (You said the same thing last time too, a few pages back) I didn't disagree with what they were saying either per se, i just thought it was a little out of context and inappropriate. If it had been the SLC forum, well that would have been way different.
 
Again I agree with what you are saying. (You said the same thing last time too, a few pages back) I didn't disagree with what they were saying either per se, i just thought it was a little out of context and inappropriate. If it had been the SLC forum, well that would have been way different.


Ah, I see. My apologies. I misunderstood what you were saying. :)

-Gumboot
 
Proof? You're wrong. The internet is transient, and therefore can be considered slander. You cannot guarantee the statements will not be removed or deleted. Slander. <snip to remove the frivolous bits, the juvenile bits, and the misplaced attempts at condescension, and the foregoing is all that was left>

It appears that reading comprehension is not your strong suit. I really do wish that you would read more carefully. As I pointed out to you previously, words have meaning. Perhaps you can read what I wrote again, and try to respond to the words that I actually wrote instead of the ones you are wrongly substituting for those that I wrote. Go on, give it a shot.


For others, the written word may constitute libel; it does not constitute slander. The fact that those written words may subsequently removed from your field of vision does not morph the character of them from libel into slander.

To establish libel, a plaintiff would have to show:

1) that the material was defamatory (i.e. tends to lower the plaintiff in the estimation of right-thinking people generally; tends to cause the plaintiff to be shunned or avoided; tends to expose the plaintiff to hatred, ridicule or contempt; or is a false statement about the plaintiff to the plaintiff's discredit);

2) that the defamatory material refers to him and sufficiently identifies him; and

3) that the defamatory material about him was published.

The fact that the defamatory material is later removed from, say, a website, does not render it unpublished, nor does it change the characterization of the libel into slander.
 
3bodyproblem:

With no due respect, you have [rule8]-all knowledge of the law, and your arguments regarding libel and slander are nonsensical. See LashL's posts for an explanation of why this is so, and stop bugging us with strawman arguments.
 
Libel is the type of defamation with a permanent record

Slander is the type of defamation with no permanent record

However:

17. In an action for slander of title, slander of goods or other malicious falsehood, it is not necessary to allege or prove special damage,

(a) if the words upon which the action is founded are calculated to cause pecuniary damage to the plaintiff and are published in writing or other permanent form; or

(b) if the words upon which the action is founded are calculated to cause pecuniary damage to the plaintiff in respect of any office, profession, calling, trade or business held or carried on by the plaintiff at the time of the publication,

and the plaintiff may recover damages without averment or proof of special damage. R.S.O. 1990, c. L.12, s.17

Until a judgment is made on whether "blogging" constitutes a permanent record or "broadcasting" it can and will be tried as "Slander". You should know this LashL.
 
Mobyseven; said:
3bodyproblem:

With no due respect, you have [rule8]-all knowledge of the law, and your arguments regarding libel and slander are nonsensical. See LashL's posts for an explanation of why this is so, and stop bugging us with strawman arguments.

You wanna bet? Mind your business and please, look up strawman, you have no clue.
 
Last edited:
It appears that reading comprehension is not your strong suit. I really do wish that you would read more carefully. As I pointed out to you previously, words have meaning. Perhaps you can read what I wrote again, and try to respond to the words that I actually wrote instead of the ones you are wrongly substituting for those that I wrote. Go on, give it a shot.


For others, the written word may constitute libel; it does not constitute slander. The fact that those written words may subsequently removed from your field of vision does not morph the character of them from libel into slander.

To establish libel, a plaintiff would have to show:

1) that the material was defamatory (i.e. tends to lower the plaintiff in the estimation of right-thinking people generally; tends to cause the plaintiff to be shunned or avoided; tends to expose the plaintiff to hatred, ridicule or contempt; or is a false statement about the plaintiff to the plaintiff's discredit);

2) that the defamatory material refers to him and sufficiently identifies him; and

3) that the defamatory material about him was published.

The fact that the defamatory material is later removed from, say, a website, does not render it unpublished, nor does it change the characterization of the libel into slander.

Huh... Wait a minute...

Posting typed words on an internet discussion board cannot be slanderous, but they can constitute libel and that makes it OK? I'm not very familiar with the Canadian legal system and I'm not a native-speaker of the English language, but it sounds very similar for a layman, so thanks for the explanation. Besides, it's still basically very uncivil...

If you feel you can say and do anything to destroy someones name on an internet discussion forum, just because it's an internet discussion forum then someone should tell Randi. I remember reading about his legal actions against Winston Wu based on a similar claim. If this is just bunk, then similarly Randi may have no case or a very weak one. I don’t have the details of that case, but it’s rather disturbing.

I would regret to think that Randi doesn’t have a case and think we should at least be civil and open to arguments until they fail or remain unanswered. Coming to this forum is a fair opportunity to question WR, even if you don’t think it will render much information. Although I also think he's being used by the truth movement, I like to know what he thinks about that possibility. We have just missed that chance again...
Thanks a bunch...

SYL :)

PS. If you ever feel an uncontrollable urge to “assist” me, I recommend you don’t do it in the condescending way you seem to prefer. It’s offensive. Just friendly advice...
 
Last edited:
I've already been through this, I know the application of the law. Most likely, defamation on an internet blog will be deemed "libel". The law is just a little behind, I beleive it was last amended in 1980. They've tried to extend it to include the internet and blogging, but they haven't yet. E-mails incidentally have been deemed "libel". I'm done explaining the law to a lawyer. I am right.
 
By yon clock on the wall, it's getting nigh onto time to call in the kittens... ON OURSELVES!

This thread has totally departed its original topic and is now reduced to nitpicking.

I'm suffering a kitten shortage, so here's me and a couple of the girlz at our annual party. (I'm the idiot in the middle of the hottie sandwich with the stupid grin...)

 
Huh... Wait a minute...

Posting typed words on an internet discussion board cannot be slanderous, but they can constitute libel and that makes it OK? I'm not very familiar with the Canadian legal system and I'm not a native-speaker of the English language, but it sounds very similar for a layman, so thanks for the explanation. Besides, it's still basically very uncivil...

If you feel you can say and do anything to destroy someones name on an internet discussion forum, just because it's an internet discussion forum then someone should tell Randi. I remember reading about his legal actions against Winston Wu based on a similar claim. If this is just bunk, then similarly Randi may have no case or a very weak one. I don’t have the details of that case, but it’s rather disturbing.

I would regret to think that Randi doesn’t have a case and think we should at least be civil and open to arguments until they fail or remain unanswered. Coming to this forum is a fair opportunity to question WR, even if you don’t think it will render much information. Although I also think he's being used by the truth movement, I like to know what he thinks about that possibility. We have just missed that chance again...
Thanks a bunch...

SYL :)

PS. If you ever feel an uncontrollable urge to “assist” me, I recommend you don’t do it in the condescending way you seem to prefer. It’s offensive. Just friendly advice...

Of course, truth is a defense against libel, so I doubt LashL is worried.
 
By yon clock on the wall, it's getting nigh onto time to call in the kittens... ON OURSELVES!

This thread has totally departed its original topic and is now reduced to nitpicking.

I'm suffering a kitten shortage, so here's me and a couple of the girlz at our annual party. (I'm the idiot in the middle of the hottie sandwich with the stupid grin...)

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_11085464c774b635c0.jpg


I see you imported several of our local flora (the saguaro cacti) for your bash. Please be aware that drinking excessively and playing with guns while in proximity to these mammoth objects can be hazardous to your health. They have been known to fall on idiots who use them as target practice - a fate whose irony probably escapes the victim in his/her last moments.
 
Last edited:
I see you imported several of our local flora (the saguaro cacti) for your bash. Please be aware that drinking excessively and playing with guns while in proximity to these mammoth objects can be hazardous to your health. They have been known to fall on idiots who use them as target practice - a fate whose irony probably escapes the victim in his/her last moments.

Yeah, especially the ones like these - made of styrofoam. The set was done by a terrific local company; the "kids"(my staff) shopped the internet and market stalls for the costumes, and props.... The young lady on the left is actually one of my top managers. She was terrific - was the MC for the evening and stayed in character (Dance Hall Gal) for the entire five hour bash. (A humble affair for 700!)
 
Well William Rodriguez certainly isn't 9/11. There are many other heroes that remain in the shadows content with knowing what they did on that terrible day was the right thing to do. They are 9/11. Those that perished, they are 9/11. The men and women that rose to the occasion and saved many lives that day, they are 9/11. And so are the many others that weren't as directly affected, but their lives changed that day. They are 9/11. I don't believe there is any reason for William Rodriguez to claim he is any more important then all of others I have mentioned. Doing so diminishes him even further in my eyes. Why he would do so is beyond me, it makes no sense.




All right, send in the kittens.
 
Of course, truth is a defense against libel, so I doubt LashL is worried.

Great, let’s have some…
Get WR back and give him a fair chance to present his argument, in full. Maybe confront him first with the quotes, confirm he said it, ask why he said it, what he means by it, and then ask on what grounds me made his statements. Doesn't that sound fair?
Then present him with the possibility that the truth movement may well be using him to defend a position that is less then truthful.

Concerning the legal part. I sure hope Lashl is wrong about this, because Winston Wu is a slightly bigger fish then Willie. I couldn’t care much if Willie walks away without a scratch, I think he’s mostly played and misguided by truther admiration, but Winston Wu is another story.

SYL :)
 
William's in Europe for an extended tour. He won't address the issues, anyway, IMHO, as he's been caught out "embroidering" things and his best defence is to ignore the noise and hope it will go away.
Ironic that! His first two years of non-fame on the alternate media were all based on him complaining that the government was ignoring his inconvenient evidence. Now he's doing the same.

William's had ample opportunity to address Gravy's paper. He's also walked out on an opportunity to "debate" Gravy on Ron's show. He initially eagerly accepted. Ron thinks that was a ruse. I think he just typed before his brain clicked in, and when he realized that Gravy wasn't going to swoon in his presence he ran for cover.

There is no turning William back, I fear. If you go through the various sites where he posts, his opinions are somewhere between LIHOP and MIHOP. Or, I should say "the opinions he's expressing".... he's rather the chameleon.
 
Great, let’s have some…
Get WR back and give him a fair chance to present his argument, in full.


Perhaps we haven't made it sufficiently clear:

WILLIE AIN'T TALKING TO ANYONE WHOSE EYES AREN'T GLASSY AND WHOSE LIPS AREN'T FLECKED WITH FOAM.



Maybe confront him first with the quotes, confirm he said it, ask why he said it, what he means by it, and then ask on what grounds me made his statements. Doesn't that sound fair?
Then present him with the possibility that the truth movement may well be using him to defend a position that is less then truthful.


Please see my first sentence.



Concerning the legal part. I sure hope Lashl is wrong about this, because Winston Wu is a slightly bigger fish then Willie. I couldn’t care much if Willie walks away without a scratch, I think he’s mostly played and misguided by truther admiration, but Winston Wu is another story.

SYL :)


Willie is playing a game. He has learned how to work a room full of morons.
 
Libel is the type of defamation with a permanent record

Slander is the type of defamation with no permanent record

However:

17. In an action for slander of title, slander of goods or other malicious falsehood, it is not necessary to allege or prove special damage,

(a) if the words upon which the action is founded are calculated to cause pecuniary damage to the plaintiff and are published in writing or other permanent form; or

(b) if the words upon which the action is founded are calculated to cause pecuniary damage to the plaintiff in respect of any office, profession, calling, trade or business held or carried on by the plaintiff at the time of the publication,

and the plaintiff may recover damages without averment or proof of special damage. R.S.O. 1990, c. L.12, s.17

Until a judgment is made on whether "blogging" constitutes a permanent record or "broadcasting" it can and will be tried as "Slander". You should know this LashL.

A little knowledge is a dangerous thing. You have proven this old adage to be accurate. You are, quite simply, wrong in your interpretation of the law, 3B.

In addition, it would behoove you to read the words that I actually wrote and respond to those words instead of substituting words that I did not write and using them as though they are interchangeable, when they are not. As I have said before, words have meaning.

We were not talking about "blogging" or about whether "blogging" constitutes "broadcasting". Rather, we were talking about whether posting written words on the internet constitutes "publishing" for purposes of libel laws. The latter is beyond doubt.

The entirely separate issue of whether posting on the internet constitutes "broadcasting" for purposes of the Libel and Slander Act and for purposes of the concomitant limitation periods, etc., has nothing to do with the issue of whether posting on the internet constitutes publication for purposes of libel law.

And, as I said before, removing a published libel does not transform the libel into slander.
 
Yeah, especially the ones like these - made of styrofoam. The set was done by a terrific local company; the "kids"(my staff) shopped the internet and market stalls for the costumes, and props.... The young lady on the left is actually one of my top managers. She was terrific - was the MC for the evening and stayed in character (Dance Hall Gal) for the entire five hour bash. (A humble affair for 700!)

Impressive! The capacity of the young for splendid parties always astounds me. I've had to set up a few myself so I am well aware of the work that goes into one of these, and a 700 person affair is no small potatoes!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom