William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

I see you imported several of our local flora (the saguaro cacti) for your bash. Please be aware that drinking excessively and playing with guns while in proximity to these mammoth objects can be hazardous to your health. They have been known to fall on idiots who use them as target practice - a fate whose irony probably escapes the victim in his/her last moments.

Did someone call for a

from Arizona? (I forget where, exactly)
​
 
Ron gave William a perfectly reasonable opportunity to lay out his thoughts and opinions on camera. However, William declined knowing that his audience wouldn't be pre-brainwashed.
 


It hails from outside of Quartzsite, apparently.

While it doesn't appear to be the tallest recorded instance of the species, it definitely is a monster example of a saguaro cactus.

I would like to reiterate my warning from above - do not shoot the cactus. Not only is it against the law, but these things weigh a considerable amount and do not fall in their own footprints!
 
Willie is playing a game. He has learned how to work a room full of morons.


Fine, I give up. I may be a skeptic but I’m not cynical… Not enough anyway. If this is the feeling of the forum, then there is no point in discussing him or his statements either and therefore no point to this thread. I vote for a shutdown.

3bodyproblem and foolmewunz got the right idea, kittens sounds good.

SYL :)
 
LashL; said:
A little knowledge is a dangerous thing. You have proven this old adage to be accurate. You are, quite simply, wrong in your interpretation of the law, 3B.
No I am right, or cite a case that disproves me.

LashL; said:
In addition, it would behoove you to read the words that I actually wrote and respond to those words instead of substituting words that I did not write and using them as though they are interchangeable, when they are not. As I have said before, words have meaning.

I have no idea what you are referring to. Could you please clarify this for me? This is a little cryptic.


LashL; said:
We were not talking about "blogging" or about whether "blogging" constitutes "broadcasting". Rather, we were talking about whether posting written words on the internet constitutes "publishing" for purposes of libel laws. The latter is beyond doubt.
The entirely separate issue of whether posting on the internet constitutes "broadcasting" for purposes of the Libel and Slander Act and for purposes of the concomitant limitation periods, etc., has nothing to do with the issue of whether posting on the internet constitutes publication for purposes of libel law.

Check out the definition of "broadcasting" as it pertains to the Act. Blogging is neither broadcasting or publishing. Cite the case you are referring to or give up. I am right.

LashL; said:
And, as I said before, removing a published libel does not transform the libel into slander.

Yes, I agree. What I was saying is the law has not yet established if "blogging" constitutes publication for the purposes of "libel" mostly because of its transient nature, in so far as it can be deleted or modified. Until it does, it is "Slander". Check out section 16 for clarification and publishing and slander.
 
Huh... Wait a minute...

Posting typed words on an internet discussion board cannot be slanderous, but they can constitute libel and that makes it OK? I'm not very familiar with the Canadian legal system and I'm not a native-speaker of the English language, but it sounds very similar for a layman, so thanks for the explanation. Besides, it's still basically very uncivil...

No, nobody said "that makes it OK." There is a difference between libel and slander, but they are sub-sets of defamation.

If you feel you can say and do anything to destroy someones name on an internet discussion forum, just because it's an internet discussion forum then someone should tell Randi. I remember reading about his legal actions against Winston Wu based on a similar claim. If this is just bunk, then similarly Randi may have no case or a very weak one. I don’t have the details of that case, but it’s rather disturbing.

Nobody said that they can say and do anything to destroy someone's name on an internet discussion forum. I'm afraid you have misunderstood.

I would regret to think that Randi doesn’t have a case and think we should at least be civil and open to arguments until they fail or remain unanswered.

I have not personally read Mr. Randi's case so I cannot comment on it, but I agree with you that we should be civil and open to arguments until they fail or remain unanswered. In Rodriguez' case, his claims have failed and/or remained unanswered.

Coming to this forum is a fair opportunity to question WR, even if you don’t think it will render much information. Although I also think he's being used by the truth movement, I like to know what he thinks about that possibility. We have just missed that chance again...
Thanks a bunch...

Rodriguez has been questioned here and he has refused to respond here to legitimate inquiries and criticisms of his varying and inconsistent accounts of events, and his unfounded, outrageous, and unsubstantiated accusations against dozens of people. It is entirely up to him whether he wishes to address these points, and he has failed to do so repeatedly. There is no need to point fingers at me or others for his failure to do so - it is Rodriguez' own doing. I agree with you that he is being used by the "truth" movement but, in my opinion, he is using them just as much as they are using him.

PS. If you ever feel an uncontrollable urge to “assist” me, I recommend you don’t do it in the condescending way you seem to prefer. It’s offensive. Just friendly advice...

I rarely, if ever, have "uncontrollable urges" over the internet so you need not worry about that.

I do try not to come across as condescending as that is not my nature, although I acknowledge that I can become annoyed when someone purports to have knowledge and expertise that he does not possess, and when that someone purports to lecture me on the very knowledge and expertise that I do possess. If you find that "offensive", well, there is little that I can do about that.
 
I did my best to get to the truth. And now I'm thinking what pomeroo is saying so...

LashL can we please just drop this whole thing? I apologize for somehow slighting you. I'm really tired of slander and libel, but I did say I would argue it too the end so either we agree to disagree or we keep going until I am right. How about we just ro-sham-bo?
 
No I am right, or cite a case that disproves me.



I have no idea what you are referring to. Could you please clarify this for me? This is a little cryptic.




Check out the definition of "broadcasting" as it pertains to the Act. Blogging is neither broadcasting or publishing. Cite the case you are referring to or give up. I am right.



Yes, I agree. What I was saying is the law has not yet established if "blogging" constitutes publication for the purposes of "libel" mostly because of its transient nature, in so far as it can be deleted or modified. Until it does, it is "Slander". Check out section 16 for clarification and publishing and slander.

:bwall

Good Dog, talking to you is hopeless, 3B.

You need to read for comprehension.

Until you do, it is impossible to have a rational conversation with you. There is nothing "cryptic" at all about my posts, if you would just read for comprehension.

I implore you to go back and read - for comprehension - my previous posts. Your interpretation of the law of libel and slander is wrong as it relates to my posts. Moreover, you cannot simply select a single section of a single statute and make sweeping generalizations about the body of law of libel and slander on the basis of that single section. You have to understand how it interacts with other sections - or not - and you have to understand how it is applied by courts, and you have to understand which issues it is relevant to and which issues it is completely irrelevant to.

Section 16 of the Ontario Libel and Slander Act is wholly, completely, and entirely irrelevant to this discussion, and you are wholly, completely, and entirely wrong in your interpretation of the law of libel and slander as it pertains to the posts in this thread.

But this has become way off topic from the original thread and I agree with those who have opined that it is time for kittens.
 
You wanna bet? Mind your business and please, look up strawman, you have no clue.

Mind my business? You want to have a private discussion with LashL, then PM her. You're on a public forum, and I'll reply if I see fit.

Also, I am fully aware of what a strawman is: Your argument that our treatment of WR is unfair because we presented his statement out of context is a strawman argument, because his statement was not presented out of context. I have yet to see you acknowledge that.

I cannot help but reflect on the irony inherent in telling a logic student and a practising trial lawyer that they are clueless about logic and the law respectively.

I did my best to get to the truth. And now I'm thinking what pomeroo is saying so...

LashL can we please just drop this whole thing? I apologize for somehow slighting you. I'm really tired of slander and libel, but I did say I would argue it too the end so either we agree to disagree or we keep going until I am right. How about we just ro-sham-bo?

You are a real piece of work, you know that?

By the way, what you just did there is called a false dilemma, and it is yet another type of logical fallacy. But then I suppose I'm wrong about that too?
 
I did my best to get to the truth. And now I'm thinking what pomeroo is saying so...

LashL can we please just drop this whole thing? I apologize for somehow slighting you. I'm really tired of slander and libel, but I did say I would argue it too the end so either we agree to disagree or we keep going until I am right. How about we just ro-sham-bo?

I would be content to drop it on the basis that it is quite off-topic, and your apology is accepted.

However, you should have left it at that rather than adding the part about "we keep going until [you] are right" because you are not right at all about the issues that are actually germane to this thread, and you don't seem to comprehend that you are conflating numerous issues and misinterpreting the law on one issue and wrongly applying it to entirely separate issues.

So, while I would be content to drop it and accept your apology as set out above, I do not accept your proviso. Thus, unless and until we resolve the issue of your wrongheaded proviso, it really isn't dropped at all, is it?

And...

thum_11103466b968ed0fae.jpg


thum_11103466b982687b22.jpg
 
Last edited:
Please people...

Let's not forget this forum is a US website and Mr Rodriguez is an American citizen. Under US law anything written on the internet constitutes publication, and is thus libel, not slander. Furthermore US law has addressed the matter specifically in regards to internet forums/bulletin boards through 47 U.S.C. § 230 which indemnifies any website against liability due to material posted at their site by a third party.

Under US law (which is what is relevant here) the comments could be considered libel. They cannot be considered slander. And frankly Mr Rodriguez would have a very hard time proving libel.

Finally, I seriously cannot understand how anyone could interpret Lash's assertions that posted comments are libel rather than slander as meaning that Lash is saying libel is okay! Indeed, most people would agree that libel is worse than slander.

-Gumboot
 
Oh well you two, both of you, won't drop it so I gotta respond.

Moby: There was no strawman, it was out of context. If it weren't, people wouldn't have been trying for the last day and a half to supplement the thread with context. If you keep doing this then you will fail GONG (that means your time is up, off the stage)
ps- thanks for the kitten :)
pss- (it very well could be a false dilemma, I don't know what that is)
psss- what's a logic student?

LashL: You're way off base and I'll tell you why. I have looked up this stupid argument, and I do know the law. You have yet to show where the law has acknowledged "blogging" as a publication, making it libel. Most recently it was tried as "broadcasting" and shot down. As such, what I was referring to as "bordering on slander" is still "bordering on slander". As you are so stubborn, it is most likely that before you concede the law will be changed and "blogging" will be considered "publishing" or "broadcasting". At which point it will forever be considered libel. Until then it can only be considered "slander". Please don't bother arguing this further until you have a case to cite which changes the Act. It was deliberate on my part when I used the term slander, as was the qualifier bordering.
I've noticed you refuse to cite any case law, or proof to support you're argument. "I'm a lawyer and I know" Doesn't cut it with me. I certainly don't know everything offhand in my profession, why do you presume you do? Do you think your cheerleader Moby will make me back off? Well you're wrong. Heck, you're wrong about a lot of things these days. I don't hold it against you. No one actually expects you to be versed in every Act in every section. What we do expect is that you can read the law and interpret it. I n this case you jumped before you read and now you are sticking to it come hell or high water. Is there some rule that says a lawyer can't admit when they are wrong and walk away? Or is it simply because I happen to know a little more than you and you can't handle it? I'm leaning towards the latter, you have shown yourself deficient in understanding this particular act and how it applies to my comment. Not a big deal LashL, let it go. You're wrong. It happens. I'm sorry that proving you wrong makes you feel slighted, i truly am.
 
gumboot; said:
Please people...

Let's not forget this forum is a US website and Mr Rodriguez is an American citizen. Under US law anything written on the internet constitutes publication, and is thus libel, not slander. Furthermore US law has addressed the matter specifically in regards to internet forums/bulletin boards through 47 U.S.C. § 230 which indemnifies any website against liability due to material posted at their site by a third party.

Under US law (which is what is relevant here) the comments could be considered libel. They cannot be considered slander. And frankly Mr Rodriguez would have a very hard time proving libel.

Finally, I seriously cannot understand how anyone could interpret Lash's assertions that posted comments are libel rather than slander as meaning that Lash is saying libel is okay! Indeed, most people would agree that libel is worse than slander.

-Gumboot

Good point. I don't know what the American law has determined to constitute libel. I'm leaving it at that.
 
Please people...

Let's not forget this forum is a US website and Mr Rodriguez is an American citizen. Under US law anything written on the internet constitutes publication, and is thus libel, not slander. Furthermore US law has addressed the matter specifically in regards to internet forums/bulletin boards through 47 U.S.C. § 230 which indemnifies any website against liability due to material posted at their site by a third party.

Under US law (which is what is relevant here) the comments could be considered libel. They cannot be considered slander. And frankly Mr Rodriguez would have a very hard time proving libel.

Finally, I seriously cannot understand how anyone could interpret Lash's assertions that posted comments are libel rather than slander as meaning that Lash is saying libel is okay! Indeed, most people would agree that libel is worse than slander.

-Gumboot

I'm glad someone with knowledge about US law stepped up. I think you were referring to me in your last paragraph. I have no idea what Lashl is going on about, but then again I don't have knowledge about Canadian or US law. Where I come from you get convicted for both types of publication, for any type of broadcast even for just spreading rumors. The ground for conviction is whether it's true or not and the damage you inflict to someones reputation. My question mark at the end of the sentence you refer to is not an accident, but merely an expression of complete failure to understand the argument.

I always thought that libel was worse too, at least something that was decided in court. Then again English is not my first language, so I try to be careful when I interpret the posts.

The legal reference that you mention would also clear any accusation WR could make to JREF, but now I'm worried how Mr. Randi wants to sew Winston Wu. I guess there must have been other publications as well, outside of a discussion forum. I would have to look into the case...

Thanks Gumboot, that reference cleared up a lot of this fringe discussion.

I know you dislike WR and as it seems most of the forum does. You agree that this thread is leading nowhere and serves no purpose? The mods closed it down once already and only reopened it to see where this was going. Since everyone has taken a cynical approach to this rather then a skeptic one, I think this thread has run it's course...

Shutdown... You agree?

SYL :)
 
Oh well you two, both of you, won't drop it so I gotta respond.

Moby: There was no strawman, it was out of context. If it weren't, people wouldn't have been trying for the last day and a half to supplement the thread with context. If you keep doing this then you will fail GONG (that means your time is up, off the stage)
ps- thanks for the kitten :)
pss- (it very well could be a false dilemma, I don't know what that is)
psss- what's a logic student?

Wrong. Rodriguez' post was not at all taken out of context. He even reposted it here, using only those three words (well, two words and one numerical reference).

LashL: You're way off base and I'll tell you why. I have looked up this stupid argument, and I do know the law.

Wrong. You have no idea what you're talking about. As I said above, the law is not a matter of looking up a single section of a single statute and declaring it to mean what you want it to mean. You are dead wrong in your interpretation as set out in your previous posts for the reasons I have elaborated on in my previous posts.

You have yet to show where the law has acknowledged "blogging" as a publication, making it libel.

This is just another example of your lack of comprehension and your failure to connect relevant law to relevant issues. The discussion is not about blogging. It is about posting written words on an internet discussion forum.

As I said before, you seem to have difficulty with comprehending what the issues actually are, and you conflate various unrelated issues with various unrelated statutory provisions and you seem to think they are interchangeable when they are not.

Most recently it was tried as "broadcasting" and shot down. As such, what I was referring to as "bordering on slander" is still "bordering on slander".

Again, you seem to have difficulty with comprehending what the issues actually are. As I set out above, you conflate various unrelated issues and you fail to understand how different they are. Your "bordering on slander" nonsense remains nonsense. Written words posted on a discussion forum are not slander. They may be libel, if certain criteria are met, but they are not slander.

As you are so stubborn, it is most likely that before you concede the law will be changed and "blogging" will be considered "publishing" or "broadcasting". At which point it will forever be considered libel. Until then it can only be considered "slander".

Again, you seem to have difficulty with comprehending what the issues actually are. We are not talking about blogging and we are not talking about "broadcasting". Once again, you conflate several issues and you erroneously think that they are interchangeable, and you erroneously think that individual sections of a statute relating to one issue, and individual judicial decisions about one particular issue, are somehow interchangeable and applicable to all other remotely related issues. They are not. For purposes of libel and slander law, "publishing" and "broadcasting" are not the same thing at all - as you have wrongly assumed above.

Please don't bother arguing this further until you have a case to cite which changes the Act. It was deliberate on my part when I used the term slander, as was the qualifier bordering.

If you were deliberate about being wrong, that just makes you deliberately obtuse and deliberately wrong. Not exactly something to brag about, 3B. You are, again, wrongly conflating unrelated issues and you are attempting to argue something that is not even the subject of discussion here. You don't realize that you do not even understand that you do not understand. And if you don't know what that means, it is the equivalent to saying that "You're not even wrong."

I've noticed you refuse to cite any case law, or proof to support you're argument.

I do not refuse to cite case law. It is pointless to cite caselaw to someone who doesn't understand even the fundamental bases of the law at issue and who is so oblivious to his own ignorance. In addition, since you continue to misconstrue the issues, it is impossible to narrow down the relevant caselaw. You seem to be arguing (for want of a better word) make-believe issues that are not actually issues relevant to this thread, so what caselaw to cite? If you wish to actually discuss the relevant issues rather than ones that you erroneously get yourself sidetracked on due to your lack of understanding of the law, I would be happy to cite caselaw if I had any expectation whatsoever that you would understand it. As it stands, though, you have not demonstrated that you even understand what the issues in this thread are - you just seem to make up non-issues as you go along. It seems appropriate to direct to you a basic, introductory text to libel and slander law - try the Irwin Law introductory version. For an advanced, much more comprehensive text, try Brown.

"I'm a lawyer and I know" Doesn't cut it with me. I certainly don't know everything offhand in my profession, why do you presume you do?

I know libel and slander law intimately as it has been a significant part of my legal practice for several years, and it is incumbent upon me to keep abreast of developments in the areas of law in which I practice.

Do you think your cheerleader Moby will make me back off?

Moby is not a "cheerleader" for me or anyone else. Your silly assertion is duly noted, however. And as for you backing off, no, I'd rather that you stay right here and display your continuing ignorance for all to see.

Well you're wrong. Heck, you're wrong about a lot of things these days.

Name one.

I don't hold it against you. No one actually expects you to be versed in every Act in every section. What we do expect is that you can read the law and interpret it.

I can and do read and interpret statutes, regulations and laws regularly and appropriately. You, on the other hand, have not exhibited any ability to do so thusfar.

I n this case you jumped before you read and now you are sticking to it come hell or high water.

This is complete and utter nonsense. I am intimately familiar with the L&S Act, and have been for years. I have been very successful in defending media clients against numerous allegations of libel.

You have repeatedly, and continue to, misconstrue the subject matter, and you repeatedly and continue to fail to comprehend the words that you read and that has led you astray. You think that you are arguing a certain point without even realizing that the point you are attempting to argue is not the point at all. Once again, I ask that you go back and read the posts and try to address the actual issues raised rather than the issues that you wrongly think have been raised.

Is there some rule that says a lawyer can't admit when they are wrong and walk away?

No, there is not. When I am wrong, I acknowledge that directly. There has been no reason for me to do so in this thread.

Or is it simply because I happen to know a little more than you and you can't handle it?

No. You are entirely, completely, and utterly wrong about your interpretation of the law of libel and slander as it relates to the posts in this thread and your assertion to the contrary is laughable.

because you know I'm leaning towards the latter, you have shown yourself deficient in understanding this particular act and how it applies to my comment.

Keep digging, 3B. It is not my comprehension that is deficient.

Not a big deal LashL, let it go. You're wrong. It happens. I'm sorry that proving you wrong makes you feel slighted, i truly am.

Keep digging even further. As I said above, you are entirely, completely, and utterly wrong about your interpretation of the law of libel and slander as it relates to the posts in this thread and your assertion to the contrary is laughable.

I ask you again to read for comprehension. When you have figured out, as the vast majority of readers have, why and how you went astray on so many of your posts, please come back and we can discuss the details. As it stands, your posts opining on the state of the law of libel and slander as they relate to the posts in this thread are silly, meaningless, devoid of rational content, and purely WRONG in law.
 
Last edited:
Oh well you two, both of you, won't drop it so I gotta respond.

Moby: There was no strawman, it was out of context. If it weren't, people wouldn't have been trying for the last day and a half to supplement the thread with context. If you keep doing this then you will fail GONG (that means your time is up, off the stage)
ps- thanks for the kitten :)
pss- (it very well could be a false dilemma, I don't know what that is)
psss- what's a logic student?

Then you should have no problem demonstrating how it was taken out of context and how that affected the meaning of what was said. Take careful note of the fact the William Rodriguez repeated himself verbatum on this very forum in this very thread.

Go on. You've yet to actually mount any argument that amounts to more than a 'nuh uh' contradiction. This is your chance.

False dilemma is characterising a situation as having a certain number of choices when in fact there are alternatives not mentioned. Usually (as in your case) this takes the form of a false dichotomy, where two options are provided and a third (or more) option excluded.

So yes, it is a false dilemma.

LashL: You're way off base and I'll tell you why. I have looked up this stupid argument, and I do know the law. You have yet to show where the law has acknowledged "blogging" as a publication, making it libel. Most recently it was tried as "broadcasting" and shot down. As such, what I was referring to as "bordering on slander" is still "bordering on slander". As you are so stubborn, it is most likely that before you concede the law will be changed and "blogging" will be considered "publishing" or "broadcasting". At which point it will forever be considered libel. Until then it can only be considered "slander". Please don't bother arguing this further until you have a case to cite which changes the Act. It was deliberate on my part when I used the term slander, as was the qualifier bordering.
I've noticed you refuse to cite any case law, or proof to support you're argument. "I'm a lawyer and I know" Doesn't cut it with me. I certainly don't know everything offhand in my profession, why do you presume you do? Do you think your cheerleader Moby will make me back off? Well you're wrong. Heck, you're wrong about a lot of things these days. I don't hold it against you. No one actually expects you to be versed in every Act in every section. What we do expect is that you can read the law and interpret it. I n this case you jumped before you read and now you are sticking to it come hell or high water. Is there some rule that says a lawyer can't admit when they are wrong and walk away? Or is it simply because I happen to know a little more than you and you can't handle it? I'm leaning towards the latter, you have shown yourself deficient in understanding this particular act and how it applies to my comment. Not a big deal LashL, let it go. You're wrong. It happens. I'm sorry that proving you wrong makes you feel slighted, i truly am.

I've ever so much wanted to be a cheerleader, but unfortunately for you I'm not siding with LashL because I think I'd look good in a miniskirt (I wouldn't) but because she is correct.

By the way, a logic student is one who studies logic. This logic student also just happens to be a law student.

I certainly hope that if you are ever taken to court, you do not decide to act as your own attorney!
 
I've already been through this, I know the application of the law. Most likely, defamation on an internet blog will be deemed "libel". The law is just a little behind, I beleive it was last amended in 1980. They've tried to extend it to include the internet and blogging, but they haven't yet. E-mails incidentally have been deemed "libel". I'm done explaining the law to a lawyer. I am right.

Oh, I missed this post of yours earlier.

You most assuredly do not know the application of the law of libel and slander, and it would be a good thing for you to refrain from trying to explain the law to a lawyer as you are hopelessly ill-equipped to do so.

You repeatedly fall into serious error when you conflate various terms as though they are interchangeable when they are not.

:bwall
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom