Oh well you two, both of you, won't drop it so I gotta respond.
Moby: There was no strawman, it
was out of context. If it weren't, people wouldn't have been trying for the last day and a half to supplement the thread with context.
If you keep doing this
then you will fail
GONG (that means your time is up, off the stage)
ps- thanks for the kitten

pss- (it very well could be a false dilemma, I don't know what that is)
psss- what's a logic student?
Wrong. Rodriguez' post was not at all taken out of context. He even reposted it here, using only those three words (well, two words and one numerical reference).
LashL: You're way off base and I'll tell you why. I have looked up this stupid argument, and I do know the law.
Wrong. You have no idea what you're talking about. As I said above, the law is not a matter of looking up a single section of a single statute and declaring it to mean what you want it to mean. You are dead wrong in your interpretation as set out in your previous posts for the reasons I have elaborated on in my previous posts.
You have yet to show where the law has acknowledged "blogging" as a publication, making it libel.
This is just another example of your lack of comprehension and your failure to connect relevant law to relevant issues. The discussion is not about blogging. It is about posting written words on an internet discussion forum.
As I said before, you seem to have difficulty with comprehending what the issues actually are, and you conflate various unrelated issues with various unrelated statutory provisions and you seem to think they are interchangeable when they are not.
Most recently it was tried as "broadcasting" and shot down. As such, what I was referring to as "bordering on slander" is still "bordering on slander".
Again, you seem to have difficulty with comprehending what the issues actually are. As I set out above, you conflate various unrelated issues and you fail to understand how different they are. Your "bordering on slander" nonsense remains nonsense. Written words posted on a discussion forum are not slander. They may be libel, if certain criteria are met, but they are not slander.
As you are so stubborn, it is most likely that before you concede the law will be changed and "blogging" will be considered "publishing" or "broadcasting". At which point it will forever be considered libel. Until then it can only be considered "slander".
Again, you seem to have difficulty with comprehending what the issues actually are. We are not talking about blogging and we are not talking about "broadcasting". Once again, you conflate several issues and you erroneously think that they are interchangeable, and you erroneously think that individual sections of a statute relating to one issue, and individual judicial decisions about one particular issue, are somehow interchangeable and applicable to all other remotely related issues. They are not. For purposes of libel and slander law, "publishing" and "broadcasting" are not the same thing at all - as you have wrongly assumed above.
Please don't bother arguing this further until you have a case to cite which changes the Act. It was deliberate on my part when I used the term slander, as was the qualifier bordering.
If you were deliberate about being wrong, that just makes you deliberately obtuse and deliberately wrong. Not exactly something to brag about, 3B. You are, again, wrongly conflating unrelated issues and you are attempting to argue something that is not even the subject of discussion here. You don't realize that you do not even understand that you do not understand. And if you don't know what that means, it is the equivalent to saying that "You're not even wrong."
I've noticed you refuse to cite any case law, or proof to support you're argument.
I do not
refuse to cite case law. It is pointless to cite caselaw to someone who doesn't understand even the fundamental bases of the law at issue and who is so oblivious to his own ignorance. In addition, since you continue to misconstrue the issues, it is impossible to narrow down the relevant caselaw. You seem to be arguing (for want of a better word) make-believe issues that are not actually issues relevant to this thread, so what caselaw to cite? If you wish to actually discuss the relevant issues rather than ones that you erroneously get yourself sidetracked on due to your lack of understanding of the law, I would be happy to cite caselaw if I had any expectation whatsoever that you would understand it. As it stands, though, you have not demonstrated that you even understand what the issues in this thread are - you just seem to make up non-issues as you go along. It seems appropriate to direct to you a basic, introductory text to libel and slander law - try the Irwin Law introductory version. For an advanced, much more comprehensive text, try Brown.
"I'm a lawyer and I know" Doesn't cut it with me. I certainly don't know everything offhand in my profession, why do you presume you do?
I know libel and slander law intimately as it has been a significant part of my legal practice for several years, and it is incumbent upon me to keep abreast of developments in the areas of law in which I practice.
Do you think your cheerleader Moby will make me back off?
Moby is not a "cheerleader" for me or anyone else. Your silly assertion is duly noted, however. And as for you backing off, no, I'd rather that you stay right here and display your continuing ignorance for all to see.
Well you're wrong. Heck, you're wrong about a lot of things these days.
Name one.
I don't hold it against you. No one actually expects you to be versed in every Act in every section. What we do expect is that you can read the law and interpret it.
I can and do read and interpret statutes, regulations and laws regularly and appropriately. You, on the other hand, have not exhibited any ability to do so thusfar.
I n this case you jumped before you read and now you are sticking to it come hell or high water.
This is complete and utter nonsense. I am intimately familiar with the L&S Act, and have been for years. I have been very successful in defending media clients against numerous allegations of libel.
You have repeatedly, and continue to, misconstrue the subject matter, and you repeatedly and continue to fail to comprehend the words that you read and that has led you astray. You think that you are arguing a certain point without even realizing that the point you are attempting to argue is not the point at all. Once again, I ask that you go back and read the posts and try to address the
actual issues raised rather than the issues that you wrongly think have been raised.
Is there some rule that says a lawyer can't admit when they are wrong and walk away?
No, there is not. When I am wrong, I acknowledge that directly. There has been no reason for me to do so in this thread.
Or is it simply because I happen to know a little more than you and you can't handle it?
No. You are entirely, completely, and utterly wrong about your interpretation of the law of libel and slander as it relates to the posts in this thread and your assertion to the contrary is laughable.
because you know I'm leaning towards the latter, you have shown yourself deficient in understanding this particular act and how it applies to my comment.
Keep digging, 3B. It is not
my comprehension that is deficient.
Not a big deal LashL, let it go. You're wrong. It happens. I'm sorry that proving you wrong makes you feel slighted, i truly am.
Keep digging even further. As I said above, you are entirely, completely, and utterly wrong about your interpretation of the law of libel and slander as it relates to the posts in this thread and your assertion to the contrary is laughable.
I ask you again to read for comprehension. When you have figured out, as the vast majority of readers have, why and how you went astray on so many of your posts, please come back and we can discuss the details. As it stands, your posts opining on the state of the law of libel and slander as they relate to the posts in this thread are silly, meaningless, devoid of rational content, and purely WRONG in law.