LashL; said:This is flatly wrong. There have been many cases of libel adjudicated and damages awarded for defamatory material posted on the internet.
http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onca/doc/2004/2004canlii12938/2004canlii12938.html
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/Jdb-txt/SC/07/00/2007BCSC0049.htm
http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/doc/2006/2006canlii20852/2006canlii20852.html
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/jdb-txt/sc/06/11/2006bcsc1131.htm
http://www.albertacourts.ab.ca/jdb/2003-/qb/civil/2006/2006abqb0198.pdf
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/Jdb-txt/SC/06/00/2006BCSC0065.htm
See also: Ager v. Canjex Publishing Ltd., 2005 CarswellBC 2219 (C.A.), and
Barrick Gold Corp. v. Lopehandia, 2004 CarswellOnt 2258 (C.A.)
There are many more, but those will get you started.
Why do you keep talking about an issue that is unrelated to the issue at hand. Again, nobody is talking about "blogging" or whether blogging constitutes "broadcasting" but about whether posting words on a discussion board or a website constitutes publication. There is no doubt whatsoever that, for purposes of the law of defamation, written words posted on a discussion board or on a blog are "published" for purposes of libel laws. The "broadcast" issue is an entirely separate issue with entirely different legal ramifications, wholly unrelated to the discussion at hand.
Again, we are not talking about "blogging" - this is a red herring that you plunked into the discussion quite some time ago. I asked you several times to read the words that were actually written instead of interchanging them with words that were not written but you seem unwilling or unable to recognize how you first went off-track.
What we are talking about is written words on a discussion board or a website, and whether they are "published" for purposes of the libel law. They are.
This is what I have been told. I discussed this in regards to a camp ground owner and derogatory blog about said campground. I was told that merely a blog would not suffice. If someone set up a web site aimed at "The Worst Campsites Ever" and made false accusations, or emailed this would be grounds. If you had these, and you included blogs all would go towards proving "libel", but on its own it was still fuzzy in the eyes of the law. He did say you may be able to proceed with slander. As of now I don't see much to the contrary, and certainly not enough to warrant a reprisal for using the term "slander" by a member of the bar.
I do however find this an interesting subject and I appreciate your input on the subject matter.
Gravy: I was just going with the old adage: You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar.
There is of course a point where you give this up in exchange for a flyswatter.
Edited by chillzero:Removing uncivil remark
I find it hard to believe you know so little about common law as a self professed student. This has happened many times where the law fails to keep up with technology. If you are so well versed in the law, then a simple "No, I'm afraid the law has recently included "blogging" in it's defintion, as per this case on such and such a day in such and such a place" That's what a lawyer would do. That's what any professional would do to offer constructive criticism or clarification. You on the other hand did not, you attacked me and my ability to understand the issue. This is typical, and another example of totally unacceptable behaviour.
As far as the context of the statement, and Mr. Rodriguez's subsequent posting. I still think it was taken out of context and I think exactly what pomeroo said about him working the room. It looked like he deliberately lead the forum on to continue the childish behaviour, at a gain to himself.
Yes, thank you Gumboot I understand what has been addressed in these cases. It doesn't however directly address my issue of "blogging". In each of these cases there were emails sent, or web pages hosted clearly for the intent to defame. I still maintain that there have been no rulings on "blogging" that I am aware of. The law is not clear on this, at least not in Canada (it appears that Australia has addressed this directly in a 1992 Act) Surely you can see how a third party being able to change, delete, modify the content of a message presents a problem in the case of libel. This really comes down to nit picking, which is really what application of the law is about. Technicalities.
Gravy: I was just going with the old adage: You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar.
It's really annoying when I have to do a person's research for them.
And here is his website.
3bodyproblem, with all due respect, you are incorrect. Defamation on the internet, by Canadian common law, is libel, not defamation.
-Gumboot
I think you meant, "...libel, not slander."?
Thank you for your patience, and not attacking me or my intelligence in this post. I sincerely wish to understand this issue. Please understand that I have spoke about this before with a legal professional and I was told something a little different.
The only way for "blogging" to be libel it must be a "broadcast". If it is not considered a broadcast, then it is not libel. Correct?
If it is not a "broadcast" and hence not considered "published" does it make it not defamatory?
If it is defamatory, but not considered published, is it considered slander or libel?
LashL I am simply stating that I was told by a lawyer, that currently "blogging" has not been upheld as an internet publication, hence it has yet, on its own to be considered "libel". It can still however be considered "slander".
In the cases you have cited, they all contain numerous forms of defamation. As a whole they were considered by the court as defamatory. None of them explicitly state that "blogging" was the sole means of making defamatory statements. In fact, most of them were posted on websites. There is mention in one case where in addition to emails, and a libelous website, a woman made statements in a chat room. This would certainly go towards proving libel in the case of "blogging" but it is not stand alone.
In short, I have yet to see where "blogging" on its own has been ruled as a form of "broadcasting" and hence libel.
This is what I have been told. I discussed this in regards to a camp ground owner and derogatory blog about said campground. I was told that merely a blog would not suffice. If someone set up a web site aimed at "The Worst Campsites Ever" and made false accusations, or emailed this would be grounds. If you had these, and you included blogs all would go towards proving "libel", but on its own it was still fuzzy in the eyes of the law. He did say you may be able to proceed with slander. As of now I don't see much to the contrary, and certainly not enough to warrant a reprisal for using the term "slander" by a member of the bar.
I do however find this an interesting subject and I appreciate your input on the subject matter.
Just offering something up... could it be that a "blog" is automatically assumed to be opinion, rather than an expression of fact, thus if the blogger is making a legitimate comment about their opinion of something, it's not defamation.
For example if I went to a camp, didn't like it, and post on my blog about how I didn't like it, I wouldn't think that would constitute defamation.
Would this be correct, Lash?
-Gumboot
LashL; said:Written words posted to an internet website are "published" for purposes of the law of defamation and there is no question that they can, therefore, constitute libel. A blog is an internet website, after all.
The lawyer I spoke with said that this is not really true, it has not been defined within the law as of yet. Currently there is only case law to support this, and the case law has relied on a loose interpretation of "broadcasting" to allow it to be considered published. He said "website" and "blog" or "board" have different connotations under the law at this time. He said this is why no one has successfully been charged for libel with only defamatory posts on a "blog". He said in order to successfully charge someone you really have to prove some intent to defame and deliberation? I forget, but he basically said you can't just blog some thing and consider it libel, even if it is defamatory. He also said that libel and slander are hardly ever uttered on their own. They are both presented as defamation and a judge would make the distinction. He also said this was stupid (a little more colourful than that) and if I ask him an more questions he's going to start billing me at $300/hr.
Mobyseven; said:Tell you what - I'll refrain from pointing out that you're wrong, if you stop being wrong. If you post things on a public forum that are incorrect, and you refuse to change your position after being shown exactly why they are incorrect, and you accuse others who have more knowledge that you in the relevant areas of being ignorant, then you can bet your mother that I'm going to call you on it. Capisci?
Mobyseven; said:You've had explained to you multiple times now why things written on the internet constitute libel, and you continue to ignore them.Edited by chillzero:Removing uncivil remark
Mobyseven; said:Also, what is it with your constant harping on about 'blogging'? For one, we aren't talking about blogging, and on top of that no court needs to specifically say in a judgment, "Blogging on the internet can be considered libel," especially when it has already been determined that posting something on the internet constitutes publishing it.
Mobyseven; said:Okay - you still think it was taken out of context?
Mobyseven; said:Evidence??? You seem to have trouble grasping that just because you say it was taken out of context doesn't make it so. You need to support your claim with evidence.
Mobyseven; said:So there you go. If you think the quote was taken out of context, it should be simple to prove - I've even given you a list of how to prove it!
Mobyseven; said:If, on the other hand, you cannot justify your claim, I would suggest manning up and apologising.
Mobyseven; said:As has been explained to you already, 'blogging' doesn't matter. Blogging is just another form in which someone can publish something on the internet. Insisting that someone rule specifically on 'blogging' is like insisting that someone make a law specifically to cover 'bludgeoning someone with a waffle iron', because you don't think it should fall under the definition of 'murder'.
Mobyseven; said:Also, for yet another swing and a miss, there is no such Commonwealth Act in Australia defining blogging as either libel or slander. I say this with supreme certainty, because slander and defamation are covered by state legislation and jurisdiction. It is most definately NOT legislated for in Victoria.
Mobyseven; said:The only way something could apply Australia wide (at this present time) is if it were to be appealed all the way to the High Court of Australia - I have not checked on whether there have been any such court cases, because quite frankly I don't have the time right now to do your homework for you.
?????????????????????????????????????????????? I could post eh? now since you claim to not know how to report things...so eh?I have no idea how to report a thread to a mod either, so I choose to respond..
~enigma~; said:?????????????????????????????????????????????? I could post eh? now since you claim to not know how to report things...so eh?
Since this post has been up for so long I can only assume it has been read by the moderators and is OK. I have no idea how to report a thread to a mod either, so I choose to respond.
You bet your mother, you lost, she's mine. Capisci?![]()
Mobyseven said:May I suggest showing:
- The quote as it was presented here;
- The quote in its original context; and
- An explanation as to how it was taken out of context and what effect that had on the meaning of the quote. It would also be wise to include an explanation as to William Rodriguez's repeating himself word for word on this very forum in this very thread.
Edited by chillzero:Removing quoted remark
Who's we? You don't count OK, your opinion means nothing to me.
I know it was. There was little or no context provided.
Who said he was exploiting 9/11?
Why did they say that?
When did this happen?
Where was this said?
What does he mean by that?
Was he drunk?
Was he really pissed off because people on a forum where attacking him again?
This is the context I would like to have before I pass judgment.
See above
See above
No, See above
Wrong. He came at me with a knife so I bludgeoned him with a waffle iron. That ain't murder. See how it works?
Cool. Thanks for the info. You've finally made yourself worthwhile.
Great, that's fascinating.
Sorry, I don't have any homework right now, I've already graduated from "logic study".
Mobyseven; said:Asking questions does not constitute proof.
If you have the proof for that, I suggest you present it rather than just saying, "I have the proof!"
Mobyseven; said:We is everybody in this thread except for you. That is because everybody else in this thread knows that blogging has nothing to do with the topic at hand, and quite aside from that because even though blogging is irrelevant, the claim you have made that a blog does not constitute libel is false, and you have been shown this numerous times now.
Mobyseven; said:Now, before I answer the following questions, I would like to make clear that the reason that these questions were not answered in the OP of this thread is because they are not necessary. It is assumed that the people who read the OP will either 'get it' because they have prior knowledge of William Rodriguez, or they will ask questions about William Rodriguez. You did neither of those things.
Mobyseven; said:This forum is a place to discuss issues. Not every thread is going to have an FAQ attached for your benefit - if you don't understand what is going on in a thread, either ask a question or do some damn research. Don't burst in with a poor understanding of the situation and start making claims and accusations, it's damn poor ettiquette, and it's why you've received such a poor welcome in this thread.
Mobyseven; said:Well, for one a great number of us on this forum believe that his actions since 9/11 constitute exploitation of 9/11.
Mobyseven; said:Big-noting himself, doing speaking tours that often misrepresent aspects of 9/11, profiting from 9/11, along with his ever changing story are the main reasons I can think of regarding this.
Mobyseven; said:Couldn't tell you exactly when all this happened. It has certainly come to light with the release of Mark Robert's paper about William.
Mobyseven; said:I'm also going to assume that English is not your first language, due to the ambiguous and confusing nature of the questions you just asked.
Mobyseven; said:Well, the one problem with that I can see is that the questions you just asked have nothing, repeat, nothing to do with the context of the quote in the OP!
If you want the details of the quote in the OP:
It was posted originally by William Rodriguez.
It was posted on the Loose Change Forum.
It was posted on Jun 5 2007, 11:01 PM (Australian EST, GMT +10hrs).
Do you know how I know those details?
Because I followed the link in the OP, post number ONE, that was included so that William's post could be seen in its original context! That's how.
Mobyseven; said:So, now that I have shown you that you were wrong (yet again) are you going to admit that you were wrong and apologise?
Mobyseven; said:The point of my analogy was that there doesn't have to be legislation, or even a ratio, that says, "Things posted on a blog can be considered libel," especially as it has already been pointed out to you that information posted on the internet is considered published and can therefore be considered libel (if, or course, it is untrue and defamatory).
Mobyseven; said:No problem. A question though - does the fact that you were staggeringly wrong about this not even give you the slightest bit of pause that you might be wrong about the other stuff as well?
Mobyseven; said:I would be willing to bet money that you haven't studied formal logic in your life, or that if you did, you didn't pass the subject. Your grasp of even basic principles of logic seems to be lacking, quite frankly.
Removing further bickering. Stop it now.Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic Posted By: chillzero
The the answers to those questions would give context to the quote. Without them there is very little context.
"I have the proof" is a strawman, I never said that about this quote.
"Some say I am exploiting this thread. I am this thread!" At least in the absence of Mr. Rodriguez, and in regards to the question of "blogging". Statements made on the internet can certainly be considered libelous. It would appear however that it is a little harder to prove than if it were published in a newspaper.
Wrong. Look back at the threads Mr. Rodriguez posted in. Did you? If you did you would see I was part of some of the discussions you claim I have no knowledge of. You will also note that even then I was told of Mr. Rodriguez's prior comments. You've assumed a lot of things that aren't true.
Wrong again. If the issue was being discussed this would not have been a problem. I've stated that repeatedly.
I tend to agree.
I tend to agree. I am curious what his response to this statement would be.
William Rodriguez said:7. Why I do not answer Mark Roberts? because it is a compendium of personal speculations on his part and an effort destroy my efforts. I received more support after his piece, and engagements from all over. As a matter of fact, we are putting many of his things on a new video. In a way he made the work easier because we can adress them directly on my presentations. I just booked the WHOLE summer in EUROPE and I am leaving this Friday. If I spent my time answering every attacker, it will stop me from doing the amount of work I do out there and the outreach. You remember in this forum the efforts from a looser with a 2 cents TV show to engage me one way or the other. I do not need anybody making a name for themselves with me. I do that on my own.
William Rodriguez said:9. Many accused me of exploting 9/11. I am 9/11! Those idiots have not researched that I was in fact homeless, after helping so many victims. I survive on donations and tthe sale of the dvd on my presentations. Barely making a living.
Tell that to Giuliani who's firm and him made over 100 million dollars.
Yes, I agree and Mr. Rodriguez agrees as well. According to Mr. Rodriguez the paper and the actions of this forum have endeared him to a larger audience than ever before.
Wrong. English is my first language, I speak french poorly, and my italian is even poorer (as you can probably tell) You keep assuming things. And the answers to those questions have given context to the quote, certainly something more than prior.
Yes well done. Did you assume again that everyone followed the link and read all the comments? I bet you have.
Why was the thread labeled such that it is? As someone pointed out, he's not 9/11 he's like 5'10".
No, I won't, at least not to you. To LashL maybe, if she does as well. This is the last post I'm going to make on this thread until then.
Your analogy is flawed. Not all bludgeoning constitutes murder. Not all statements on the internet constitute "libel".
When I am proven to be wrong I am the first to apologize. You expect to to merely accept the statements of two people who have called me names, insult my language skills and insult my intelligence in general, over someone I know and respect? Do you see how you diminish your credibility when you resort to poor tactics such as this?
Another veiled attempt at an insult? Well you are wrong again, so it can't be considered an insult to me.
Moby, I appreciate your input to this discussion. I am glad this has finally ended. Good Luck in your studies.
Really, Swingie? Conspiracy liars are still peddling the falsehood that "pull it" means "blow up the building." I'm looking at my notes and I see that I've made phone calls to fourteen different demolition companies in three states. All of them deny that the phrase has any meaning apart from describing the act of attaching cables to a small structure to pull it, literally, off its center of gravity.
Are you prepared to acknowledge that this myth is dead and buried? Are the fantasists who persist in trotting out this fabrication ignoring the "research"?
Incidentally, how did you manage to defend your fantasy about a basement bomb? You don't have a shred of actual evidence to support your erroneous claim.
Source: Implosion WorldDID YOU KNOW that only a small percentage of explosive demolition jobs are true 'building implosions'?
Webster’s Dictionary defines implosion as "a violent collapse inward". In the demolition industry, a blaster is usually trying to pull a structure away from adjacent exposures and towards an area large enough to contain the debris. Therefore, the only time a building is truly 'imploded' is when exposures (other structures or areas of concern) completely surround it. When this situation exists, the blaster has no choice; he must make the building collapse in on itself. This is by far the trickiest type of explosive demolition project, and there are only a handful of blasting companies in the world that possess enough experience—and insurance—to perform these true building implosions.
Source: http://www.uga.edu/gm/399/FeatImp.htmlJack brought a basic knowledge of construction, engineering, and physics to his new science of implosion. More important, though, he brought the fascination and conviction of a true believer. Long before anyone else, he had faith in the power of explosives to help gravity do what it wants to do anyway: pull things down.
Source:http://www.ulm.edu/universityrelations/news/sept04/dust.htmlImplosion is a process where a small amount of explosives is used to disrupt selected supports in a building. This allows gravity to pull the structure down in a controlled manner.
CDI planned theto the southeast and away from the intersectionimplosion to pull the
building
of SW 9th and Mulberry Streets.
Source: PBSNOVA: A common misconception is that you blow buildings up. That's not really the case, is it?
Stacy Loizeaux: No. The term "implosion" was coined by my grandmother back in, I guess, the '60s. It's a more descriptive way to explain what we do than "explosion." There are a series of small explosions, but the building itself isn't erupting outward. It's actually being pulled in on top of itself. What we're really doing is removing specific support columns within the structure and then cajoling the building in one direction or another, or straight down.
I really can't believe your revisiting this issue.
As far as the "pull it" issue, I didn't think that it was Larry S. originally thought until I read this:
Source: Implosion World
Source: http://www.uga.edu/gm/399/FeatImp.html
Source:
I'm revisiting the issue because conspiracy liars persist in recycling it.
Source:The Front Line
Source: PBS
In summary Pom, I find it highly unlikely that Larry S. admitted to CD'ing WTC 7 on national television, however, the term "pull" is used in conjunction with explosives and gravity as well as the use of cables to pull a building.
No, you're lying again. You are one of the more egregious liars in the fantasy movement and you frequently display the gall to challenge the rationalists who call you on your falsehoods. Let me state this as plainly as I can:
NO demolition experts use "pull it" to mean "blow up the building." NONE! Show us the name of a single demolition expert who regards "pull it" as industry jargon.
Well on the thread where I defended the explosive device in the basement of WTC: North theory, I noticed you bailed out as soon as I pointed out NIST's calculation of remaining fuel. Any reason why you didn't return?![]()
The usual reason: you were exposed as an ignorant fraud by numerous posters.
Second, early in that thread, everyone agreed there is no empirical evidence to support either theory, hence the empirical method.