No, the libel and slander act can change from province to province. But they are all relatively the same.
This is correct, although there are some very important differences among the various provincial statutes which result in some provinces treating as "slander" that which other provinces treat as "libel".
The law was obviously written before the internet, so it obviously wasn't written to cover the internet.
Of course. However, the law evolves, although perhaps not as quickly as technology. "The law" was written before fax machines, telephones and automobiles, but it adapts to encompass reality, even before specific laws are amended or repealed to deal with specific circumstances.
People have tried to bring actions against another based on something that was said or posted on the internet. Statements on the internet were deemed not libelous for the purposes or the act and the case was dismissed. Unless a new ruling overturns that, or the law has been rewritten, it is considered slander. This is why I have said show me a case which confirms this or relent.
This is flatly wrong. There have been many cases of libel adjudicated and damages awarded for defamatory material posted on the internet.
http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onca/doc/2004/2004canlii12938/2004canlii12938.html
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/Jdb-txt/SC/07/00/2007BCSC0049.htm
http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/doc/2006/2006canlii20852/2006canlii20852.html
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/jdb-txt/sc/06/11/2006bcsc1131.htm
http://www.albertacourts.ab.ca/jdb/2003-/qb/civil/2006/2006abqb0198.pdf
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/Jdb-txt/SC/06/00/2006BCSC0065.htm
See also: Ager v. Canjex Publishing Ltd., 2005 CarswellBC 2219 (C.A.), and
Barrick Gold Corp. v. Lopehandia, 2004 CarswellOnt 2258 (C.A.)
There are many more, but those will get you started.
Edited by chillzero:
Removing uncivil remark
I find it hard to believe you know so little about common law as a self professed student. This has happened many times where the law fails to keep up with technology. If you are so well versed in the law, then a simple "No, I'm afraid the law has recently included "blogging" in it's defintion, as per this case on such and such a day in such and such a place" That's what a lawyer would do. That's what any professional would do to offer constructive criticism or clarification. You on the other hand did not, you attacked me and my ability to understand the issue. This is typical, and another example of totally unacceptable behaviour.
Why do you keep talking about an issue that is unrelated to the issue at hand. Again, nobody is talking about "blogging" or whether blogging constitutes "broadcasting" but about whether posting words on a discussion board or a website constitutes
publication. There is no doubt whatsoever that, for purposes of the law of defamation, written words posted on a discussion board or on a blog are "published" for purposes of libel laws. The "broadcast" issue is an entirely separate issue with entirely different legal ramifications, wholly unrelated to the discussion at hand.
Yes, thank you Gumboot I understand what has been addressed in these cases. It doesn't however directly address my issue of "blogging". In each of these cases there were emails sent, or web pages hosted clearly for the intent to defame. I still maintain that there have been no rulings on "blogging" that I am aware of. The law is not clear on this, at least not in Canada (it appears that Australia has addressed this directly in a 1992 Act) Surely you can see how a third party being able to change, delete, modify the content of a message presents a problem in the case of libel. This really comes down to nit picking, which is really what application of the law is about. Technicalities.
Again, we are not talking about "blogging" - this is a red herring that you plunked into the discussion quite some time ago. I asked you several times to read the words that were actually written instead of interchanging them with words that were not written but you seem unwilling or unable to recognize how you first went off-track.
What we are talking about is written words on a discussion board or a website, and whether they are "published" for purposes of the libel law. They are.
Is knowledge of the law inherent or learned? If it's inherent, then surely this is self defeating. If it can be learned then perhaps you are mistaken.
Either "blogging" has been ruled as a "broadcasting" and deemed a "publication" for intent of the law, or it hasn't. I maintain it hasn't. I also maintain that this argument is ridiculous, because in any event it can be considered defamation.
You are conflating the issues again. Posting words on the internet is publication, although it may not be "broadcasting" for purposes of the limitation periods in the statutes. One issue has naught to do with the other, and you are wrongly conflating them, and consequently misinterpreting the body of defamation law as a whole.
The law of defamation is very technical and precise. I have spent years learning the intricacies of it, and successfully practicing it. You cannot simply pluck one section from one statute and wrongly apply it to the body of law as a whole. Words have meaning, and in law, their meaning is important, as is their proper application.
I would suggest that you read an introductory text on media law, an introductory text on defamation law, and then read the McConchie & Potts text and the Brown looseleaf service,
The Law of Defamation in Canada