William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

You may be right, but I feel a bit uncomfortable looking at the reactions. I agree that it may be very frustrating to hear twoofers speak, but we give them a chance anyway and are often more patient then this. :)


I told you, we have been far more courteous toward William than average twoofer, and have repeatedly asked him to explain his position and engage us in reasoned debate. He has refused to do so.
 
Last edited:
gumboot; said:
It's really annoying when I have to do a person's research for them.



And here is his website.

3bodyproblem, with all due respect, you are incorrect. Defamation on the internet, by Canadian common law, is libel, not defamation.

-Gumboot

Yes, thank you Gumboot I understand what has been addressed in these cases. It doesn't however directly address my issue of "blogging". In each of these cases there were emails sent, or web pages hosted clearly for the intent to defame. I still maintain that there have been no rulings on "blogging" that I am aware of. The law is not clear on this, at least not in Canada (it appears that Australia has addressed this directly in a 1992 Act) Surely you can see how a third party being able to change, delete, modify the content of a message presents a problem in the case of libel. This really comes down to nit picking, which is really what application of the law is about. Technicalities.
 
I feel strongly compelled to post, albeit briefly, in this thread. I accept Gravy's assertion that the record shows Mr. Rodriquez as a hero on that terrible day. But I also proffer that speaking of the day, in detail, is most distasteful. There are others who were at the attacks that day who choose to not tell their stories, recognizing that those who perished can not tell theirs. There is no dignity in boasting about what small service one might have performed, the dignity lies in quietly remembering those we have lost, that which we lost.

there is no dignity in braggadocio, we all failed that day, to do all that should have been done.
 
Surely you can see how a third party being able to change, delete, modify the content of a message presents a problem in the case of libel.


Yes it present a problem in terms of proof. But it is in no way unique to internet postings. There are many instances of publication or broadcast in which a third party is capable of deleting, manipulating or modifying a statement or piece of content. This does not prevent the instance from being libel.

Indeed, were a third party, for example, to modify something I had posted so that it altered the meaning, I could potentially sue them for misrepresentation.

-Gumboot
 
As I follow this discussion between a lawyer experienced in libel/slander, and another poster untrained in law and apparently basing their argument on what they think something they looked up means, I keep hearing this sound in my head:

Doink...doink...doink...

The world -- and, I suspect, the law...isn't all just a big matter of opinion, where every person's view is of equal merit, regardless of training or background. Arguing your untutored opinion against an expert specifically experienced in the field strikes me as a particularly self-defeating form of narcissism.
 
Close the thread.
The bickering about slander and libel an be addressed in another forum/thread if needed. I had my reasons for saying what I said and they go well beyond defining defamation.

peace, i'm going sailing :)
 
As I follow this discussion between a lawyer experienced in libel/slander, and another poster untrained in law and apparently basing their argument on what they think something they looked up means, I keep hearing this sound in my head:

Doink...doink...doink...

The world -- and, I suspect, the law...isn't all just a big matter of opinion, where every person's view is of equal merit, regardless of training or background. Arguing your untutored opinion against an expert specifically experienced in the field strikes me as a particularly self-defeating form of narcissism.

Well let's not bring psychiatry or psychology into this because I'm pretty sure that is not your area of expertise... I can vouch for 3bodyproblem, (and I do know what I'm talking about.)
Your comment and the banner have been noted. I wouldn't discuss narcissism if I were you... :D

SYL :)
 
Stellafane; said:
As I follow this discussion between a lawyer experienced in libel/slander, and another poster untrained in law and apparently basing their argument on what they think something they looked up means, I keep hearing this sound in my head:

Doink...doink...doink...

The world -- and, I suspect, the law...isn't all just a big matter of opinion, where every person's view is of equal merit, regardless of training or background. Arguing your untutored opinion against an expert specifically experienced in the field strikes me as a particularly self-defeating form of narcissism.

Is knowledge of the law inherent or learned? If it's inherent, then surely this is self defeating. If it can be learned then perhaps you are mistaken.
Either "blogging" has been ruled as a "broadcasting" and deemed a "publication" for intent of the law, or it hasn't. I maintain it hasn't. I also maintain that this argument is ridiculous, because in any event it can be considered defamation.
 
I think everyone already made up his/her mind before hearing him and in select cases even without hearing the issue, don’t you agree? Not much doubt there…
No, I don't agree, and there is much doubt there. Perhaps you missed Rodriguez's past participation here, where he registered to tell us that he would not be answering questions. This is his first post:

Yes, I am here and I will not answer any questions until I see a change of atittude to open a discussion. The personal attacks that I saw in other threads prevented me to outreach and answer your questions. I joined out of respect to my friendship with Randi and he is aware that I am here. Maybe in a fututre when I see more respectful approach. Later.
William Rodriguez

He then stated that he would answer our questions if James Randi organized an "event" for that purpose:
I will wait until Randi put an event together were I can meet personally with all of you and answer your questions face to face. God bless you all.

This was my reply:
William, I'm glad I got to meet you when I did. It is highly unlikely that a face-to-face meeting is going to happen with a group of JREF forum members who have questions for you. Members here are from around the world.

I respectfully suggest that the internet is by far the easiest and most efficient way to relay your story to skeptics here, if that is your desire. Is it?

SYLVESTER1592 said:
You may be right, but I feel a bit uncomfortable looking at the reactions. I agree that it may be very frustrating to hear twoofers speak, but we give them a chance anyway and are often more patient then this.
Rodriguez has stated that he won't answer our questions here, that he won't participate in a televised discussion, and that he won't address the specifics in my paper except in a video he's working on, which no doubt will be for sale.

I'm not interested in Rodriguez's rationalizations. I want to know how his behavior is going to change. He's under no obligation to put that in writing, but I'm certainly going to keep track of his public statements.
 
Gravy: I was just going with the old adage: You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar.

There is of course a point where you give this up in exchange for a flyswatter.
 
Gravy: I was just going with the old adage: You catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar.

There is of course a point where you give this up in exchange for a flyswatter.
Since he chose to dismiss the people like myself who were polite and respectful, I chose to look into why he was being evasive. He sees that as an attack. I see it as gathering and organizing facts related to his story. I didn't expect to find what I did. The whole thing makes me sad, but if he continues his behavior, I'm going to keep calling him on it.
 
No, I don't agree, and there is much doubt there. Perhaps you missed Rodriguez's past participation here, where he registered to tell us that he would not be answering questions. This is his first post:



He then stated that he would answer our questions if James Randi organized an "event" for that purpose:


This was my reply:


Rodriguez has stated that he won't answer our questions here, that he won't participate in a televised discussion, and that he won't address the specifics in my paper except in a video he's working on, which no doubt will be for sale.

I'm not interested in Rodriguez's rationalizations. I want to know how his behavior is going to change. He's under no obligation to put that in writing, but I'm certainly going to keep track of his public statements.

Thank you Gravy,

Basically you have presented him with an opportunity to defend himself, but in a format you have already established to be unacceptable. Then the forum confirms his reasons not to participate. Nevertheless, he still shows up and tries to participate. Reaction: "He 's playing a game". Maybe true, but labeling him as insincere right of the bat is enough reason to end the discussion.

You consider this to be fair? Especially when you consider that the total blame and responsibility for this result is placed on WR?

I am interested in his rationalizations, even though I'm pretty sure I won't agree with it. This discussion could be of some use.
There may be very strong reasons that oppose a change of opinion by Mr. Rodriguez, which have very little to do with the arguments he presents even if he might not be consciously aware of them. Peer pressure may be a powerful factor. I have also looked at the EPA documents and read about some of the medical studies performed on the 911 rescue workers. I believe a careful evaluation of his arguments is not a waste of time. Regardless of past experiences, a presentation at this time should be viewed on it's own merits as well as in relation to past experiences. In short: listen first, judge later.

I think you have been one of the minority to give this a real chance with some honesty and I respect that. Since only few have taken the task to point out the arguments I present, I have done so myself. I think it's only decent...

Having said that, the discussion in this thread have taken such a turn that any unbiased evaluation of WR's arguments are now impossible. Furthermore there seems to be no reason left to talk to him anymore, because all the opinions have been formed and seem unable to change. WR is not regarded as a suitable participant in a discussion by this forum, which also disqualifies this forum to have a discussion with him. Regretably, the unwillingness to expose oneself to this is regarded as proof that the opinions are well founded. As a result the discussion is now about him. So ending this thread is the only sensible thing to do, in my opinion.

SYL :)
 
Thank you Gravy,

Basically you have presented him with an opportunity to defend himself, but in a format you have already established to be unacceptable.
No, Rodriguez was invited to participate in three different formats: here, on television, and in writing in response to my paper. He has declined each invitation. And if he expects to post on a skeptics' forum and not be asked tough questions, he's being very, very naive. When you use your hero's status to excuse terrorists and falsely accuse people of involvement in mass murder, you shouldn't expect to be handled with kid gloves. Rodriguez can sure dish it out, but he can't take it at all.

ETA: only forum moderators can close threads, and they rarely do. This is a discussion forum that's open to all. If you feel this thread is in violation of the membership agreement, please report it to the mods.
 
Last edited:
Nevertheless, he still shows up and tries to participate. Reaction: "He 's playing a game". Maybe true, but labeling him as insincere right of the bat is enough reason to end the discussion.



Off the bat?

This isn't the first time ever that Mr Rodriguez claim has been raised in this subforum. Mr Rodriguez has been viewed by myself and some others the way he has because of his previous behaviour. His opinions on 9/11 have not been dismissed out of hand. They have been dismissed for good reason; they are unreliable, they are inconsistent, they are grossly flawed, and they betray a specific agenda. All of these conclusions have been reached (by myself at least) for very good reason, and after significant exposure to the various versions of events.

-Gumboot
 
No, the libel and slander act can change from province to province. But they are all relatively the same.

This is correct, although there are some very important differences among the various provincial statutes which result in some provinces treating as "slander" that which other provinces treat as "libel".

The law was obviously written before the internet, so it obviously wasn't written to cover the internet.

Of course. However, the law evolves, although perhaps not as quickly as technology. "The law" was written before fax machines, telephones and automobiles, but it adapts to encompass reality, even before specific laws are amended or repealed to deal with specific circumstances.

People have tried to bring actions against another based on something that was said or posted on the internet. Statements on the internet were deemed not libelous for the purposes or the act and the case was dismissed. Unless a new ruling overturns that, or the law has been rewritten, it is considered slander. This is why I have said show me a case which confirms this or relent.

This is flatly wrong. There have been many cases of libel adjudicated and damages awarded for defamatory material posted on the internet.

http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onca/doc/2004/2004canlii12938/2004canlii12938.html

http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/Jdb-txt/SC/07/00/2007BCSC0049.htm

http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/doc/2006/2006canlii20852/2006canlii20852.html

http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/jdb-txt/sc/06/11/2006bcsc1131.htm

http://www.albertacourts.ab.ca/jdb/2003-/qb/civil/2006/2006abqb0198.pdf

http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/Jdb-txt/SC/06/00/2006BCSC0065.htm

See also: Ager v. Canjex Publishing Ltd., 2005 CarswellBC 2219 (C.A.), and
Barrick Gold Corp. v. Lopehandia, 2004 CarswellOnt 2258 (C.A.)

There are many more, but those will get you started.

Edited by chillzero: 
Removing uncivil remark

I find it hard to believe you know so little about common law as a self professed student. This has happened many times where the law fails to keep up with technology. If you are so well versed in the law, then a simple "No, I'm afraid the law has recently included "blogging" in it's defintion, as per this case on such and such a day in such and such a place" That's what a lawyer would do. That's what any professional would do to offer constructive criticism or clarification. You on the other hand did not, you attacked me and my ability to understand the issue. This is typical, and another example of totally unacceptable behaviour.

Why do you keep talking about an issue that is unrelated to the issue at hand. Again, nobody is talking about "blogging" or whether blogging constitutes "broadcasting" but about whether posting words on a discussion board or a website constitutes publication. There is no doubt whatsoever that, for purposes of the law of defamation, written words posted on a discussion board or on a blog are "published" for purposes of libel laws. The "broadcast" issue is an entirely separate issue with entirely different legal ramifications, wholly unrelated to the discussion at hand.

Yes, thank you Gumboot I understand what has been addressed in these cases. It doesn't however directly address my issue of "blogging". In each of these cases there were emails sent, or web pages hosted clearly for the intent to defame. I still maintain that there have been no rulings on "blogging" that I am aware of. The law is not clear on this, at least not in Canada (it appears that Australia has addressed this directly in a 1992 Act) Surely you can see how a third party being able to change, delete, modify the content of a message presents a problem in the case of libel. This really comes down to nit picking, which is really what application of the law is about. Technicalities.

Again, we are not talking about "blogging" - this is a red herring that you plunked into the discussion quite some time ago. I asked you several times to read the words that were actually written instead of interchanging them with words that were not written but you seem unwilling or unable to recognize how you first went off-track.

What we are talking about is written words on a discussion board or a website, and whether they are "published" for purposes of the libel law. They are.

Is knowledge of the law inherent or learned? If it's inherent, then surely this is self defeating. If it can be learned then perhaps you are mistaken.

Either "blogging" has been ruled as a "broadcasting" and deemed a "publication" for intent of the law, or it hasn't. I maintain it hasn't. I also maintain that this argument is ridiculous, because in any event it can be considered defamation.

You are conflating the issues again. Posting words on the internet is publication, although it may not be "broadcasting" for purposes of the limitation periods in the statutes. One issue has naught to do with the other, and you are wrongly conflating them, and consequently misinterpreting the body of defamation law as a whole.

The law of defamation is very technical and precise. I have spent years learning the intricacies of it, and successfully practicing it. You cannot simply pluck one section from one statute and wrongly apply it to the body of law as a whole. Words have meaning, and in law, their meaning is important, as is their proper application.

I would suggest that you read an introductory text on media law, an introductory text on defamation law, and then read the McConchie & Potts text and the Brown looseleaf service, The Law of Defamation in Canada
 
Last edited by a moderator:
OK I'll accept that. Now what is the point of this thread...

Close it.



The point of this thread was to inform people that William Rodriguez said "I can't exploit 9/11. I am 9/11."

As for closing the thread;

Only moderators can close threads. If you have an issue with this thread take it up in Forum Management. The repeated demands that posters close this thread are utterly pointless and frankly boring.

Why don't you stop posting in it?

-Gumboot
 
...Your comment and the banner have been noted. I wouldn't discuss narcissism if I were you... :D

SYL :)

Not my banner (nice try though). They automatically stick that announcement under your name whenever you win the TLA award, and it stays there for a month, until the next winner is voted in. (Not that I object, mind you.)

If this is indicative of how willing you are to post a comment without knowing all the facts, well, it doesn't give one a whole lot of confidence in your other pronouncements, does it?

ETA: Oh and for what it's worth, I majored in psych in college (although I ended up getting my degree in another subject). Can't really say how much "expertise" the experience conferred on me, but I like to think it's a bit more credible than "I looked something up once and this is what I think it means." And in any case, I wouldn't presume to challenge a trained psychology professional unless I had a lot more than my own opinion to back it up.
 
Last edited:
Not my banner (nice try though). They automatically stick that announcement under your name whenever you win the TLA award, and it stays there for a month, until the next winner is voted in. (Not that I object, mind you.)

If this is indicative of how willing you are to post a comment without knowing all the facts, well, it doesn't give one a whole lot of confidence in your other pronouncements, does it?

ETA: Oh and for what it's worth, I majored in psych in college (although I ended up getting my degree in another subject). Can't really say how much "expertise" the experience conferred on me, but I like to think it's a bit more credible than "I looked something up once and this is what I think it means." And in any case, I wouldn't presume to challenge a trained psychology professional unless I had a lot more than my own opinion to back it up.
Your comment and the banner...

Pretty sure about my statements, thank you

I'll follow Gumboot's advice.

I guess you have to add one more post

SYL :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom