William Rodriguez: "I am 9/11!"

The vast majority of those who exhibited courage on September 11, 2001, however, have not made it their mission in life to try to become famous come hell or high water, for their actions on that day as Rodriguez has.


This is the Shaquille O'neil effect. O'neill generously funded ex-Laker player George Mikan's funeral when his family could not (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Mikan). Then he went to every media outlet he could find to tell them what a fine deed he did. Hey Shaq, did you do it because it was the right thing to do, or did you do it so everyone else could appreciate what you did? And really, is paying for a funeral as a multi-millionaire really all that philanthropic? I don't think my conscience would allow me to exploit an act of heroism in such a way. True heorism, what makes a true hero, is doing something brave and benevolent...silently, without expecting, or getting, acclaim or recompense. Shame on O'neill and Rodriquez, despite their seemingly unselfish acts.
 
I may be missing something here but I see no heroics in this account.

Just where does he go from survivor to hero?

I would never suggest you have not done you homework, your classwork and even extra-credit work.

If I ask it is because I do not know
Or was asleep when you gave the answer.
Then why are you suggesting that we're taking the word of a known liar?

William Rodriguez was a janitor, not an emergency first responder. He risked his life by returning to the north tower to help others, and narrowly escaped death.
 
I may be missing something here but I see no heroics in this account.

Just where does he go from survivor to hero?

I would never suggest you have not done you homework, your classwork and even extra-credit work.

If I ask it is because I do not know
Or was asleep when you gave the answer.


This page, that is one of the links from the main paper, describes WR's story, and which parts are true. I hope this helps.

ETA: Scroll down to the Saved Hundred of Lives section.
 
Taking a quote out of context...

Actually, the quote is much worse in its original context.

"I am 9/11" could mean a lot of things, including (charitably), "I, along with thousands of other victims and survivors, am a representative example of the pain and ruined lives caused by the 9/11 attacks, which should never be forgotten."

But preceded by "Many have accused me of exploiting 9/11,..." it can only have a different meaning, in order for it to make any logical sense at all. Consider:

"I can't betray the revolution, I am the revolution."

Such a claim can only mean that the person making it regards himself of so exclusively representing, and/or totally controlling, and/or owning, the thing in question that he cannot possibly do wrong by it. ("I can't rob the bank, I am the bank.")

Were James Randi to say "I am the JREF," everyone here would find it out of character but few could dispute his right to say it. It's his foundation. He and it are very much identified with one another in the public eye. But even so, if he were to say, "I can't exploit the JREF, I am the JREF," he would be disputed. It's his foundation, but not only or entirely his; many others feel part of it by virtue of having contributed to it in various ways. It's not him, or his, to such an extent that it would be impossible for him to mistreat it.

The alternative, as I said, is that the quote makes no logical sense at all, as in: "I've been accused of robbing the bank. [But those accusations are wrong because...] I'm an employee of the bank!" That is, if WR regards himself as one of many living representatives of the consequences of 9/11, then his implication that he therefore cannot be exploiting it simply doesn't follow.

A member of a group using that status to exploit the group (such as, an employee of a bank robbing the bank) is such a common occurrence that there's a special phrase for it. It's called an "inside job."

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:
This is the Shaquille O'neil effect. O'neill generously funded ex-Laker player George Mikan's funeral when his family could not (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Mikan). Then he went to every media outlet he could find to tell them what a fine deed he did. Hey Shaq, did you do it because it was the right thing to do, or did you do it so everyone else could appreciate what you did? And really, is paying for a funeral as a multi-millionaire really all that philanthropic? I don't think my conscience would allow me to exploit an act of heroism in such a way. True heorism, what makes a true hero, is doing something brave and benevolent...silently, without expecting, or getting, acclaim or recompense. Shame on O'neill and Rodriquez, despite their seemingly unselfish acts.
What is wrong with promotion, self promotion to celebrate good values? William is a good speaker on 9/11, he crossed the line by making up lies and changing his story. Shaq can brag all he wants, I see Shaq's gesture, even if he takes credit, as a homage to his roots of basketball. He revered the man, why not take credit in praising him for what he did to make Shaq's life possible.
 
This page, that is one of the links from the main paper, describes WR's story, and which parts are true. I hope this helps.

ETA: Scroll down to the Saved Hundred of Lives section.

Thanks for the link

After reading it still seems to me that WR's heroism is mainly in his own mind.

He is lying now we know that.

It seems he embellished the facts and his role on 911.

One goes hand in hand with the other.
 
Myriad; said:
Actually, the quote is much worse in its original context.

"I am 9/11" could mean a lot of things, including (charitably), "I, along with thousands of other victims and survivors, am a representative example of the pain and ruined lives caused by the 9/11 attacks, which should never be forgotten."

But preceded by "Many have accused me of exploiting 9/11,..." it can only have a different meaning, in order for it to make any logical sense at all. Consider:

"I can't betray the revolution, I am the revolution."

Such a claim can only mean that the person making it regards himself of so exclusively representing, and/or totally controlling, and/or owning, the thing in question that he cannot possibly do wrong by it. ("I can't rob the bank, I am the bank.")

Were James Randi to say "I am the JREF," everyone here would find it out of character but few could dispute his right to say it. It's his foundation. He and it are very much identified with one another in the public eye. But even so, if he were to say, "I can't exploit the JREF, I am the JREF," he would be disputed. It's his foundation, but not only or entirely his; many others feel part of it by virtue of having contributed to it in various ways. It's not him, or his, to such an extent that it would be impossible for him to mistreat it.

The alternative, as I said, is that the quote makes no logical sense at all, as in: "I've been accused of robbing the bank. [But those accusations are wrong because...] I'm an employee of the bank!" That is, if WR regards himself as one of many living representatives of the consequences of 9/11, then his implication that he therefore cannot be exploiting it simply doesn't follow.

A member of a group using that status to exploit the group (such as, an employee of a bank robbing the bank) is such a common occurrence that there's a special phrase for it. It's called an "inside job."

Respectfully,
Myriad

Thank you for your response Myriad. I believe what you are saying is very true, and I beleive you are very well spoken. As such, I think if you look back closely at what everyone has been attacking me with is CONTEXT. "Well if you consider these threads, and if you consider what he posted over here" etc. I have been presented with nothing but additional context to judge the statement by. I agree with the context that has been shoved down my throat for the last 24 hours.

What I didn't agree with is the quote being presented, and then they way the conversation proceeded. Not as constructive argument or debate, but as a personal attack. I thought it wasn't much better than what William had said.

Since then the calibre of conversation has been brought up a considerable amount, and I agree with most of what has been said. I'm not really sure why everyone is bent out of shape, or why I have been singled out for speaking my mind in this area.
 
Then why are you suggesting that we're taking the word of a known liar?

William Rodriguez was a janitor, not an emergency first responder. He risked his life by returning to the north tower to help others, and narrowly escaped death.

Because you are taking the word of a known liar.

He saved 15 lives.

names?
 
The regulars here will be familiar with this account of my attempt to interview Willie Rodriguez on 'Hardfire,' the cable show I occasionally host, but the newbies might learn something from it.

I was interested in his story, having been informed by Mike Newman of NIST that Willie had proved very elusive whenever that agency had tried to contact him to arrange a meeting. I had learned on this forum that his observations on the events of 9/11, dedicated to the greater glory of William Rodriguez, keep--how to put it?--evolving, knowledge that tends to reinforce the impression created by Newman.

When I invited Rodriguez to appear on 'Hardfire," I offered him a choice between debating Mark Roberts on the particulars of his account or simply providing me with a straightforward narrative. Here's where I came to understand the person I was dealing with.

He sent me an e-mail accepting my invitation, and twenty minutes later, sent me another e-mail withdrawing his acceptance. He explained his behavior by claiming that he was offended that I posted my invitation on the JREF (don't ask--you're not supposed to get it).

Much heated and extremely stupid wrangling ensued. On the LC forum, various fools sought to explain why it was a wonderful thing that he declined my invitation. All of them carefully avoided, or missed completely, the point that he had not declined it initially, but had accepted the invitation only to withdraw his acceptance immediately thereafter for a frivolous and transparently contrived reason. Willie's defenders find themselves in the fantasy movement's characteristic pose: their hero's mission is to spread "truth" by telling lies and hurling slanders, but under no circumstances should he subject himself to serious scrutiny. Da Twoof must be accepted, but may never be examined.

Willie, of course, acted very hurt when I labeled him a self-promoting phony. He was especially enraged at my suggestion that his fifteen minutes were almost over. In a moment of low comedy, he wrote in his disingenuous explanation of why he had changed his mind about appearing on the show that he admired Mark Roberts. Fine, I replied, if I'm the problem, I'll simply step aside and let Mark conduct the interview. How could he squirm away from this self-constructed snare without giving away his game?

It turns out that he couldn't--but it didn't matter. He is content to preach to the dumbest, most obstinately fact-free choir imaginable. He has no need to justify his actions: unless he commits the unpardonable sin of speaking the truth, his agenda-driven supporters will swallow anything. For the rest of us, his refusal to be interviewed by anyone other than a mindless tinfoil-hatter demonstrates clearly that he speaks with a forked tongue.

He claims that he will, in due course, comment on Mark's paper. Let me be the first to predict that his comments will be restricted to his trademark fabrications and ad hominem attacks. He is a self-promoting phony.
 
The regulars here will be familiar with this account of my attempt to interview Willie Rodriguez on 'Hardfire,' the cable show I occasionally host, but the newbies might learn something from it.

I was interested in his story, having been informed by Mike Newman of NIST that Willie had proved very elusive whenever that agency had tried to contact him to arrange a meeting. I had learned on this forum that his observations on the events of 9/11, dedicated to the greater glory of William Rodriguez, keep--how to put it?--evolving, knowledge that tends to reinforce the impression created by Newman.

When I invited Rodriguez to appear on 'Hardfire," I offered him a choice between debating Mark Roberts on the particulars of his account or simply providing me with a straightforward narrative. Here's where I came to understand the person I was dealing with.

He sent me an e-mail accepting my invitation, and twenty minutes later, sent me another e-mail withdrawing his acceptance. He explained his behavior by claiming that he was offended that I posted my invitation on the JREF (don't ask--you're not supposed to get it).

Much heated and extremely stupid wrangling ensued. On the LC forum, various fools sought to explain why it was a wonderful thing that he declined my invitation. All of them carefully avoided, or missed completely, the point that he had not declined it initially, but had accepted the invitation only to withdraw his acceptance immediately thereafter for a frivolous and transparently contrived reason. Willie's defenders find themselves in the fantasy movement's characteristic pose: their hero's mission is to spread "truth" by telling lies and hurling slanders, but under no circumstances should he subject himself to serious scrutiny. Da Twoof must be accepted, but may never be examined.

Willie, of course, acted very hurt when I labeled him a self-promoting phony. He was especially enraged at my suggestion that his fifteen minutes were almost over. In a moment of low comedy, he wrote in his disingenuous explanation of why he had changed his mind about appearing on the show that he admired Mark Roberts. Fine, I replied, if I'm the problem, I'll simply step aside and let Mark conduct the interview. How could he squirm away from this self-constructed snare without giving away his game?

It turns out that he couldn't--but it didn't matter. He is content to preach to the dumbest, most obstinately fact-free choir imaginable. He has no need to justify his actions: unless he commits the unpardonable sin of speaking the truth, his agenda-driven supporters will swallow anything. For the rest of us, his refusal to be interviewed by anyone other than a mindless tinfoil-hatter demonstrates clearly that he speaks with a forked tongue.

He claims that he will, in due course, comment on Mark's paper. Let me be the first to predict that his comments will be restricted to his trademark fabrications and ad hominem attacks. He is a self-promoting phony.

Once again we just have his word

Would you buy a used car from this man?

Just looking for facts

Finding emotion.
 
Last edited:
Because you are taking the word of a known liar.

He saved 15 lives.

names?
Are you unwilling or incapable of reading for comprehension? In my paper you will find the names of people who Rodriguez helped.Try starting with the first paragraph of the paper. You can read quotes of gratitiude to Rodriguez from people he helped. You can read transcripts of radio transmissions involving him helping and disobeying an order from his supervisor to leave the building. You can read about and view his reunion with one of the first responders he was with, who corroborates his story.

"Saved 15 lives" is his claim, not mine, which you would know if you paid attention.

Please stop this behavior.
 
I guess at this point WR should be able to prove that he even worked at the WTC.

Just looking for facts

Finding emotion.


It is a fact that Willie only pretended to accept my invitation to tell his story on 'Hardfire.' We understand that he was being insincere because he refused to be interviewed by Mark, the man he disingenuously claimed to admire.

You are not looking for facts.
 
I guess at this point WR should be able to prove that he even worked at the WTC.

Just looking for facts

Finding emotion.
No, you're making a fool of yourself. I showed you where to find facts. You've chosen to ignore them.
 
Thanks for the link

After reading it still seems to me that WR's heroism is mainly in his own mind.

He is lying now we know that.

It seems he embellished the facts and his role on 911.

One goes hand in hand with the other.


I know the entire site Gravy linked to initially is very large, but I would recommend exploring more of the links, not just the one summary page I referred to. The sources and information are there. It isn't a short read by any stretch, but once you have covered it all, I think you will understand this topic a little better. If you read it and still have questions, posting specific questions will help you find better answers.
 
No, you're making a fool of yourself. I showed you where to find facts. You've chosen to ignore them.

Only you can make a fool of yourself.

I did not see the links.

You may add tsig to your wall

OK

I was wrong!!
 
WOW, you argue for a living, I find that hard to believe. Show me exactly how I was wrong or retract your accusation. You can't and I'll tell you why. Notice the qualifier "bordered", good luck arguing around that LashL. Or are you seriously holding onto the assumption that these statements aren't in any way slanderous? Check the law and get back to me. You'll find both are equally acceptable in this case. Arguing semantics seems beneath you, but if you think its pertinent let's rock.

The qualifier was irrelevant. The relevant word was “slander”. I know the law of defamation very well, and I know the difference between libel and slander. Posting typed words on an internet discussion board is not and cannot be, by definition, slanderous. Written words can constitute libel but they cannot constitute slander. Furthermore, that which is true is neither libel nor slander. What you find “hard to believe” is of no consequence to me. I retract nothing. You were wrong.


You admitted that William Rodriguez has been offered specifically to present his side of the story and has refused and dodged the offer. As such, he has not even presented his "facts and evidence" contrary to your "facts and evidence". And yet you seem fit to label him as being libelous. Now isn't that a little presumptuous?

Rodriguez has refused to grace this forum to confront the distortions and outright falsehoods that he has written and spoken. That does not mean that he has not presented his distortions and outright falsehoods. He has presented them in all manner of places – he just won’t come here to do so, nor, apparently, will he do so in any setting that he perceives may be anything but sycophantic towards him. He has most certainly libeled and slandered many people in his various published words and writings, by making numerous outrageous, unsubstantiated, and wholly unfounded accusations of wrongdoing against dozens and dozens of people.

Ahh, an attack on my intelligence and an insinuation of my attempt to deceive. Is this how a lawyer makes her case? All I heard was "MEOW".

That was not an attack on your intelligence, nor was it an insinuation of any attempt to deceive on your part. I do not know how you read that into what I wrote. It appeared to me that either you had not read the threads I referred to or that you did not understand them. Thus, I was offering to assist you.


"Taking a quote out of context and then running a smear campaign with it seems below this forum. While some may not agree with what Mr. Rodriguez has said or done this thread is hardly above that."

Point out the error in this statement or retract your accusation.

The quote was not taken out of context. I retract nothing.

That's funny. You say you have no response to the rhetorical question, and then you proceed to respond to it. That kinda doesn't make it rhetorical now does it?

Actually, I did not say that I had no response to your rhetorical questions, nor did I answer them. Instead, I pointed out that the last paragraph of your post included rhetorical questions which required no response and did not answer the rhetorical questions. That I mentioned the rhetorical questions without answering them does not change their character as rhetorical questions.

Aww, you got all flustered and missed the whole point LashL. I believe the same thing as you, I just don't believe that this is the right way to go about it.
And of course, here is an unsolicited, just as genuine piece of advice for you: Your obsession with Willie is showing

I rarely, if ever, get flustered, and I certainly was not flustered while writing last night the post to which you responded. I harbour no obsession with Rodriguez. However, I see nothing wrong with pointing out and commenting upon his arrogance, self-aggrandizement, lies, shameless self-promotion, etc., and I will continue to do so.
 
Actually, the quote is much worse in its original context.

"I am 9/11" could mean a lot of things, including (charitably), "I, along with thousands of other victims and survivors, am a representative example of the pain and ruined lives caused by the 9/11 attacks, which should never be forgotten."

But preceded by "Many have accused me of exploiting 9/11,..." it can only have a different meaning, in order for it to make any logical sense at all. Consider:

"I can't betray the revolution, I am the revolution."

Such a claim can only mean that the person making it regards himself of so exclusively representing, and/or totally controlling, and/or owning, the thing in question that he cannot possibly do wrong by it. ("I can't rob the bank, I am the bank.")

Were James Randi to say "I am the JREF," everyone here would find it out of character but few could dispute his right to say it. It's his foundation. He and it are very much identified with one another in the public eye. But even so, if he were to say, "I can't exploit the JREF, I am the JREF," he would be disputed. It's his foundation, but not only or entirely his; many others feel part of it by virtue of having contributed to it in various ways. It's not him, or his, to such an extent that it would be impossible for him to mistreat it.

The alternative, as I said, is that the quote makes no logical sense at all, as in: "I've been accused of robbing the bank. [But those accusations are wrong because...] I'm an employee of the bank!" That is, if WR regards himself as one of many living representatives of the consequences of 9/11, then his implication that he therefore cannot be exploiting it simply doesn't follow.

A member of a group using that status to exploit the group (such as, an employee of a bank robbing the bank) is such a common occurrence that there's a special phrase for it. It's called an "inside job."

Respectfully,
Myriad

I concur. Very well said.
 
After extensive research, I think the war games served two purposes: removal of security which is a necessity in any type of assassination from an individual to a country's defense headquarters. Second, the war games served the very real necessity of plausible deniability if ever needed.



What wargames? Name them. I dare you.

-Gumboot
 
LashL; said:
The qualifier was irrelevant. The relevant word was “slander”. I know the law of defamation very well, and I know the difference between libel and slander. Posting typed words on an internet discussion board is not and cannot be, by definition, slanderous. Written words can constitute libel but they cannot constitute slander. Furthermore, that which is true is neither libel nor slander. What you find “hard to believe” is of no consequence to me. I retract nothing. You were wrong.
Proof? You're wrong. The internet is transient, and therefore can be considered slander. You cannot guarantee the statements will not be removed or deleted. Slander. Do you need someone to explain this to you?

LashL; said:
Rodriguez has refused to grace this forum to confront the distortions and outright falsehoods that he has written and spoken. That does not mean that he has not presented his distortions and outright falsehoods. He has presented them in all manner of places – he just won’t come here to do so, nor, apparently, will he do so in any setting that he perceives may be anything but sycophantic towards him. He has most certainly libeled and slandered many people in his various published words and writings, by making numerous outrageous, unsubstantiated, and wholly unfounded accusations of wrongdoing against dozens and dozens of people.
I agree. Do you need someone to explain this to you?


LashL; said:
That was not an attack on your intelligence, nor was it an insinuation of any attempt to deceive on your part. I do not know how you read that into what I wrote. It appeared to me that either you had not read the threads I referred to or that you did not understand them. Thus, I was offering to assist you.
I understood them. What then is left of your statement counselor? You're insulting us both. Do you need someone to explain this to you?



LashL; said:
The quote was not taken out of context. I retract nothing.
Then why do you continue to insist I look at the context of Mr. Rodriguez's other posts? Consider his other actions? What he has done in the past? Surely all the context is contained in the quote, I need not consider the other posts which you accuse me of not reading. The quote was taken out of context, the comments that followed it are the proof. Do you need someone to explain this to you?

LashL; said:
Actually, I did not say that I had no response to your rhetorical questions, nor did I answer them. Instead, I pointed out that the last paragraph of your post included rhetorical questions which required no response and did not answer the rhetorical questions. That I mentioned the rhetorical questions without answering them does not change their character as rhetorical questions.
It required no response but you kept talking about it. In fact we still are a day later. Do you need someone to explain this to you?

LashL; said:
I rarely, if ever, get flustered, and I certainly was not flustered while writing last night the post to which you responded. I harbour no obsession with Rodriguez. However, I see nothing wrong with pointing out and commenting upon his arrogance, self-aggrandizement, lies, shameless self-promotion, etc., and I will continue to do so.
You posts suggest otherwise.(the flustered part) I agree with the last part of this. You have that right, and you certainly know what you are talking about when it comes to this person. Do you need som... oh never mind, you get my point.
 
What wargames? Name them. I dare you.

-Gumboot
Swing is clearly one of these "Groundhog Day" truthers who starts with a clean slate every day.

Years ago Saturday Night Live did a series of sketches called "Mr. Short Term Memory" (written by Conan O'Brien).

Jingle:

"Mr. Short-Term Memory.
He shouldn't have stood under that pear tree.
Now there's just no remedy.
He'll frustrate you so
But he'll never know.
Because he's Mr. Short-Term Memory."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom