Wikileaks publishes full cache of unredacted cables

Of course you don't get it. Step back from the tree and look at the forest.


Your medical records are every bit my business as the diplomatic cables are your business.

Umm... I have to wonder, here. Are you talking about Wikileaks, some hypothetical organization that's out to make ALL private or secret information public, or the general philosophy that all knowledge and information should be publicly available to all? I fully admit that I am only peripherally knowledgable about Wikileaks, and that you should take anything that I say on the matter, therefore, with that understanding. What I do think, however, is that in his appearance in one of the TEDtalks that I watched recently, which I don't think I can link to because I'm a new member here, the person in question directly addressed the concerns that you've repeatedly raised. You may want to look it up, just to hear what he says.

I also fully admit that I'm not remotely adverse to the philosophy of full disclosure of everything, everywhere, *if* it could be done for everyone.
 
Umm... I have to wonder, here. Are you talking about Wikileaks, some hypothetical organization that's out to make ALL private or secret information public, or the general philosophy that all knowledge and information should be publicly available to all? I fully admit that I am only peripherally knowledgable about Wikileaks, and that you should take anything that I say on the matter, therefore, with that understanding. What I do think, however, is that in his appearance in one of the TEDtalks that I watched recently, which I don't think I can link to because I'm a new member here, the person in question directly addressed the concerns that you've repeatedly raised. You may want to look it up, just to hear what he says.

I also fully admit that I'm not remotely adverse to the philosophy of full disclosure of everything, everywhere, *if* it could be done for everyone.

Straw man arguments have occasionally been sighted in the SI&CE forums, or so some have said.
 
Umm... I have to wonder, here. Are you talking about Wikileaks, some hypothetical organization that's out to make ALL private or secret information public,
Yes, and they are indistinguishable from an organization "that's out to make ALL private or secret information public".

Or are you under the delusion that wikileaks actually vets what they release?

Total scandals uncovered by wikileaks? 0

All they've done is shown that what is said by diplomats in public is far different than what is said in private, which anyone who ever reads a newspaper already knew anyway. Diplomacy is all about saying nice things in public about some truly awful people you are forced to work with.
 
Yes, and they are indistinguishable from an organization "that's out to make ALL private or secret information public".

Or are you under the delusion that wikileaks actually vets what they release?

Total scandals uncovered by wikileaks? 0

All they've done is shown that what is said by diplomats in public is far different than what is said in private, which anyone who ever reads a newspaper already knew anyway. Diplomacy is all about saying nice things in public about some truly awful people you are forced to work with.

So, its all much ado about nothing and all those idiot right wingers who said he should be executed are complete morons?

All he has done is bruise a few egos and not caused the spilling of any US blood despite SOT's hyperbole?
 
So, its all much ado about nothing and all those idiot right wingers who said he should be executed are complete morons?

All he has done is bruise a few egos and not caused the spilling of any US blood despite SOT's hyperbole?

In a nutshell.
 
So, its all much ado about nothing and all those idiot right wingers who said he should be executed are complete morons?

All he has done is bruise a few egos and not caused the spilling of any US blood despite SOT's hyperbole?
I see you're attempting to frame this as anyone who is against wiileaks wants Assange executed, and that it only matters if American blood is spilled. :rolleyes:

Your excluded middle fallacy aside, all wikileaks has done is make private diplomatic communications more difficult. Will Syrian dissidents, for example, be less liley to talk candidly to US diplomats knowing those conversations may end up on wikileaks some day? I think the answer is obvious that it will make such discussions more difficult. Fewer people will come forward with their candid observations. More communications will be more highly classified so fewer people have access to them, the government will get more secretive than it is.

What good has wikileaks done? None that I can see. It's a tool to massage the ego of Assange and his sycophants, and they care not about the damage they do.

Actual news reporters uncover real scandals all the time, wikileaks releases 1 million newspapers worth of material that uncovers no wrongdoing at all and accomplishes nothing but a chilling effect on diplomatic communications at a time we need more diplomatic communication. They've thrown tons of **** on the wall, and all we end up with is a pile of **** at the base of the wall.
 
I see you're attempting to frame this as anyone who is against wiileaks wants Assange executed, and that it only matters if American blood is spilled. :rolleyes:

Your excluded middle fallacy aside, all wikileaks has done is make private diplomatic communications more difficult. Will Syrian dissidents, for example, be less liley to talk candidly to US diplomats knowing those conversations may end up on wikileaks some day? I think the answer is obvious that it will make such discussions more difficult. Fewer people will come forward with their candid observations. More communications will be more highly classified so fewer people have access to them, the government will get more secretive than it is.

What good has wikileaks done? None that I can see. It's a tool to massage the ego of Assange and his sycophants, and they care not about the damage they do.

Actual news reporters uncover real scandals all the time, wikileaks releases 1 million newspapers worth of material that uncovers no wrongdoing at all and accomplishes nothing but a chilling effect on diplomatic communications at a time we need more diplomatic communication. They've thrown tons of **** on the wall, and all we end up with is a pile of **** at the base of the wall.

No, I am asking a pretty simple question and specified a quite distinct group. If you fail to answer one way or the other I couldn't care less. It would be telling though.

Seems you are an expert on the miltary and diplomatic relations now

What good has it done? Shown up some pretty major figures in the USA for the fools they are. However, I cannot stand Assange or wikileaks and I am in no way anti American just because I criticize a few right wingers over there OK?

Is what they have done any worse than the Scooter Libby stuff? Was he executed?
 
What good has wikileaks done? None that I can see. It's a tool to massage the ego of Assange and his sycophants, and they care not about the damage they do.

They've released a fair amount of stuff. Do you think maybe you should do some research first to see if any of it has done any good? Wikipedia might be a good place to start.
 
They've released a fair amount of stuff. Do you think maybe you should do some research first to see if any of it has done any good? Wikipedia might be a good place to start.
:rolleyes:

I'm not doing your research for you.
 
Last edited:
No, people secrets are bad. All secrets. Even medical record secrets. We must make sure all secrets are brought out in the open so that rabbits can dance with hunting dogs on top of a grassy hill.

Child logic, to be sure, but Assange and his idiot supporters have been operating off child logic from day one. I trust my own government in it's secret keeping duties a hell of a lot more then I'll ever trust some narcissistic Aussie and his brain dead cronies.
 
No, I am asking a pretty simple question and specified a quite distinct group. If you fail to answer one way or the other I couldn't care less. It would be telling though.

Seems you are an expert on the miltary and diplomatic relations now

What good has it done? Shown up some pretty major figures in the USA for the fools they are. However, I cannot stand Assange or wikileaks and I am in no way anti American just because I criticize a few right wingers over there OK?

Is what they have done any worse than the Scooter Libby stuff? Was he executed?
Unfortunately, no. Unfortunately neither were the people who were his handlers and actually at fault. But, they should have been.
 
:rolleyes:

I'm not doing your research for you.

So it was not a rhetorical question implying you knew something about the topic, but a genuine request for information on a topic you were utterly ignorant of? Sorry, I thought it was the other way around.

In that case, I'm not doing your research for you. :rolleyes:
 
So it was not a rhetorical question implying you knew something about the topic, but a genuine request for information on a topic you were utterly ignorant of? Sorry, I thought it was the other way around.

In that case, I'm not doing your research for you. :rolleyes:
You expect me to do research to discover what good you think wikileaks has done?
 
Your original statement was:

What good has wikileaks done? None that I can see.

I'm irresistibly reminded of this.

Reg: "All right but apart from exposing corruption in Tunisia, exposing US spying on the UN, exposing Chevron's attempts to get around sanctions against Iran, exposing Pfizer's attempts to dig up dirt on the Nigerian attorney general to blackmail them into dropping charges for killing children, etc., etc., what has Wikileaks ever done for us?"

Xerxes: "Brought openness?".

Reg: "Oh, openness? Shut up".
 
... ASSange ... ASSange ... just an uncommon rectum eater.


Whoops! It seems I've accidentally wandered on to a grade school playground. It's amazing how one man can bring out the inner juvenile in some of you. The power to turn your opponents into children is rather impressive.
 
Last edited:
Your original statement was:



I'm irresistibly reminded of this.

Reg: "All right but apart from exposing corruption in Tunisia, exposing US spying on the UN, exposing Chevron's attempts to get around sanctions against Iran, exposing Pfizer's attempts to dig up dirt on the Nigerian attorney general to blackmail them into dropping charges for killing children, etc., etc., what has Wikileaks ever done for us?"

Xerxes: "Brought openness?".

Reg: "Oh, openness? Shut up".
Except it exposed none of that old news. What next, will wikileaks expose corruption in Mexico? I'd be shocked, shocked, shocked! :rolleyes:
 
Except it exposed none of that old news. What next, will wikileaks expose corruption in Mexico? I'd be shocked, shocked, shocked! :rolleyes:

Mobile goalposts have also been seen from time to time in the SI&CE forums, or so some have said.
 
Mobile goalposts have also been seen from time to time in the SI&CE forums, or so some have said.
The original goalpost is right where it always has been. You can't claim wikileaks broke a story which was already known. They sure have broke alot of non-storys though.

"OMG, did you see the story wikileaks broke? A dog bit a man!!!1!1!!!!!!!!1!"
 
The original goalpost is right where it always has been. You can't claim wikileaks broke a story which was already known. They sure have broke alot of non-storys though.

"OMG, did you see the story wikileaks broke? A dog bit a man!!!1!1!!!!!!!!1!"

The argument that Wikileaks is outrageous because they release things they should not release, but everything they release is old news, but it's outrageous that they release this old news again, seems to me to have a flaw in it.

It seems to me that one of your two talking points must be wrong. We can't necessarily prove which yet, but they're contradictory. They can't both be right. Either something they released was news, or nothing they released was worth getting outraged about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom