Wikileaks publishes full cache of unredacted cables


IMHO, that Register story is a load of crap.

The survey asked people to "give away their password" in exchange for a pen. But unless the people running the survey asked for more than just a password, the information is useless.
  • They don't know the person's name, so they can't link that person to a computer on which the password would be used
  • They don't know which password was given away (although a surprisingly large number of people will use the same password for their personal banking and a porn site)
  • They don't even know if the person gave a real password. All the person gave them was a word or phrase. I wonder how many lied?
 
My point was mostly that Wikileaks does not serve any unique or irreplaceable role in providing oversight and transparency. The press has been fulfilling that very same role in a wider and, in my opinion, superior (but in no means flawless) manner for centuries.


There's a widespread feeling that they've been failing at that role fairly consistently over the past couple decades. Is it any surprise that some might be willing to accept a replacement for the task?

I hope your smug self-righteous satisfaction will be worth the price in blood that will be paid for this.


You act like Assange is the Anti-Christ...
 
Last edited:
Probably less. They'll probably be thinking, well if some Aussie New Age geek can arrange to get massive amounts of diplomatic cables so easily then what kind of information can professional spies from other states find out?

As I said earlier, this stuff is not and never was top secret. It's stuff every low-level analyst has free access to. It's meant to be secret from the taxpayer but it's not protected the way stuff that has to be secret from foreign enemies is protected.

So you're cool if your medical records show up on Wikileaks some day? I mean, how else are we to know if patients are treated properly by your government?

That seems to me like a total non sequitur. Do you want to take a shot at explaining why you think diplomatic cables and medical records are the same?
 
The information Wikileaks has released has, in all but volume, been underwhelming and has led to no investigations or changes save the tightening of restrictions on access to and interagency sharing of classified material.
 
That seems to me like a total non sequitur. Do you want to take a shot at explaining why you think diplomatic cables and medical records are the same?
Doesn't the public have a right to know how your medical conditions are being treated with public money? They might be doing something wrong! Why are they hiding this from the public?
 
Doesn't the public have a right to know how your medical conditions are being treated with public money? They might be doing something wrong! Why are they hiding this from the public?

No, sorry, I still don't get it. Why is that anything like diplomatic cables?
 
I thought that Assange is potentially innocent himself, and a victim of intrigue.

And yes, he has been named in the media, so the media didn´t care about his privacy.

Of course you would defend him... :rolleyes:

Were his alleged victims underaged?
 
Very interesting, thank you. I also did find Save the Children organization 2008 report titled "Under-reporting of child sexual exploitation ..." on the subject. Initially ignorant of the fact, I applaud them. But still, is it not a good thing that with the WL cables, the subject is getting more mainstream media attention with more up-to-date information (e.g. Beninese peacekeepers) and more insight from US diplomatic point of view?

Actually my point was exactly that : if all they are taking and putting out was old foreign news I would be fine. Even if it was new foreign news or foreign documents (except those of the major first world allies of ours- as I and, I would hope, no one wants our enemies/terrorists to have any real knowledge of what we know/are doing) I would not care.
 
IMHO, that Register story is a load of crap.

The survey asked people to "give away their password" in exchange for a pen. But unless the people running the survey asked for more than just a password, the information is useless.
  • They don't know the person's name, so they can't link that person to a computer on which the password would be used
  • They don't know which password was given away (although a surprisingly large number of people will use the same password for their personal banking and a porn site)
  • They don't even know if the person gave a real password. All the person gave them was a word or phrase. I wonder how many lied?

The reason most people do that is most people can't memorize more than 4 or 5 passwords easily - especially if they are the kind that make it much (by being harder to crack) harder to remember by being random strings of 8 or more letters, numbers and/or symbols. Which mean that to use them/"remember" them they have to write them down. Which can make getting them even easier.:)
 
Actually my point was exactly that : if all they are taking and putting out was old foreign news I would be fine. Even if it was new foreign news or foreign documents (except those of the major first world allies of ours- as I and, I would hope, no one wants our enemies/terrorists to have any real knowledge of what we know/are doing) I would not care.

Well, from Wikileaks' point of view, the US cables are foreign documents.
 
There's a widespread feeling that they've been failing at that role fairly consistently over the past couple decades. Is it any surprise that some might be willing to accept a replacement for the task?




You act like Assange is the Anti-Christ...
No, like me he acts like ASSange is a foolish, careless, selfaggrandizing mother raper who does not care for anything but being well known and well thought of by persons who actually do not think out things to the real conclusion. I admit that I am not certain he actually raped his mother, but I am certain about everything else.

Since there is neither christ or anti-christ - and if there was a christ I would love to know given a good bit of world conditions how the antichrist could be a crapload worse- I do not see ASSange as either - just an uncommon rectum eater.
 
The interesting part about the Wikileaks is that they showed that, on the whole, US ambassadors etc. were at most more polite to the dictators face to face, but hardly in the habit of doing dark and dirty secret opressions of the people with them (of course there was the occassional idiot diplomat, but that's always so). It hardly showed the US as some sort of evil opressive hypocrite.

That mearly shows that the CIA has better security and doesn't feel the need to keep ambassadors informed of its activities. One of the more ammusing bits was the ambassador who was clearly unaware that Noriega was about to be removed.
 
So you're cool if your medical records show up on Wikileaks some day? I mean, how else are we to know if patients are treated properly by your government?

The NHS database project is fortunately dead. As a result the various leaks of medical records continue to happen on a case by case basis rather than the whole lot in one go.
 
Of course you don't get it. Step back from the tree and look at the forest.

Your medical records are every bit my business as the diplomatic cables are your business.

You've asserted this three times now, but it still isn't making sense. I can see how it might be the business of the Tunisian people if the Tunisian government was up to no good, or the business of any citizen of a UN member nation if the US and UK governments were spying on the UN in violation of international treaties, or if Chevron was angling to invest in Iran despite UN sanctions, or of the Nigerians if Pfizer was trying to blackmail their attorney general to get him to drop charges against them for killing children in drug trials, at least potentially. I'm not saying you couldn't have an argument about those cases but there seems to be the real possibility that it's those people's business.

I still can't see how your private medical records are anybody's business but your own. If they can be anonymised and used for retrospective research that's great, of course, but insofar as they pertain to you or me personally they still don't seem like anyone else's business.
 
You've asserted this three times now, but it still isn't making sense. I can see how it might be the business of the Tunisian people if the Tunisian government was up to no good, or the business of any citizen of a UN member nation if the US and UK governments were spying on the UN in violation of international treaties, or if Chevron was angling to invest in Iran despite UN sanctions, or of the Nigerians if Pfizer was trying to blackmail their attorney general to get him to drop charges against them for killing children in drug trials, at least potentially. I'm not saying you couldn't have an argument about those cases but there seems to be the real possibility that it's those people's business.

I still can't see how your private medical records are anybody's business but your own. If they can be anonymised and used for retrospective research that's great, of course, but insofar as they pertain to you or me personally they still don't seem like anyone else's business.

It's really not that complicated. Those things you listed are relevant bits of information that people in a free world should want to know. But in the same cache of diplomatic cables were also things that are similar to medical records in a personal privacy regard. Reports of things like assault and rape are now in the open; names of people that went to the consulate for help.

But it's just so cool that you got to know the inner workings of government operations that you have no need to know, isn't it?
 
It's really not that complicated. Those things you listed are relevant bits of information that people in a free world should want to know. But in the same cache of diplomatic cables were also things that are similar to medical records in a personal privacy regard. Reports of things like assault and rape are now in the open; names of people that went to the consulate for help.

But it's just so cool that you got to know the inner workings of government operations that you have no need to know, isn't it?

"It's really not that complicated" is a bit like "It goes without saying that", "every rational person can immediately see" or "all right-thinking people believe". It's a construction that should be treated as a large, flashing neon sign that someone is about to try to pull a fast one on you and you need your ******** detector to be on high alert.

I think in the cases I listed for you there is at least an argument to be made that people should know ("need to know" is an incredibly high standard to arbitrarily apply - strictly speaking I don't need to know anything except information that will save my life if I know it).

Some information got out that should not have got out, to be sure. An awful lot of information that should have got out and would not otherwise have got out, got out.

Newspapers sometimes publish things they should not (in my opinion anyway), yet I still think that overall we are better off for the existence of newspapers than we would be in their absence. You can't make a safe move from "some parts of the Wikileaks cable affair turned out badly" (or, and I am not attributing this argument to you, "Assange is a douchebag") to "therefore we would all be better off without Wikileaks".

Sometimes it is just a little bit more complicated than some people try to paint it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom