Wikileaks publishes full cache of unredacted cables

Because of the information that's now public, a lot of people are going to be killed.

I doubt it. Assuming the US goverment is halfway competent they knew that

1)if they couldn't keep the info secret it was likely wikileaks couldn't either
2)If wikileaks had got hold of the info then so had russia and china who might well pass some of it on to people the US doesn't like
3)If wikileaks had got hold of the info then in all likehood the taliban and the like would sooner or later

As a result the US should have alreadly extracted everyone extractable.
 
IIRC, much of what was published was not exactly top secret, just mildly embarrassing in a lot of cases. But a blanket release without protecting the vulnerable is not going to win them any new converts.
 
I see the following failures:
  • In addition to encrypting the file, Wikileaks should have put a password on the difficult-to-find directory, which would have prevent recursive website retrieval programs from getting it
  • Wikileaks should have been more proactive in deleting the encrypted file
  • David Leigh should not have published the true encryption key in his book, even if he believed the file no longer existed.

Wikileaks has been trying to put the blame of this on Guardian and Leigh, but in my opinion that's unwarranted. While what Leigh did -- publishing a (to him) no longer relevant password -- is poor security practice (as amply demonstrated by this case), it's the kind of security error that real users will commit, and your security protocols have to be robust enough to stand up to them. The culpability thus lies with the people responsible for the security protocols -- in other words Wikileaks.
 
I refer to an old post of mine:

I think this is a relevant question.

Government Intelligence Agency | Wikileaks
Acquires "secret" information | Acquires "secret" information
Disseminates some of this secret information | Disseminates some of this secret information
Keeps some of the information secret to use as leverage | Keeps some of the information secret to use as leverage
Decides what is and isn't dangerous or relevant based on an unknown set of criteria | Decides what is and isn't dangerous or relevant based on an unknown set of criteria
Withholds knowledge of certain criminal acts | Withholds knowledge of certain criminal acts
Does it bother anyone else that an organization dedicated to ending "secrecy" has this supposed monster file that contains information of illegal conduct by major banks but is not sharing it so it can use that "information" to it's own benefit?

Also, how can they even hope to accomplish their goals through their current tactic? If there is something you want kept secret and you find out someone in the room is telling everyone things they learn that are secrets are you more likely to just spill everything or would you clam up and be much more selective in who you talk to?
We can now add that, like a large governmental intelligence agency, Wikileaks has now been compromised by it's own bureaucracy.
 
I refer to an old post of mine:


​
We can now add that, like a large governmental intelligence agency, Wikileaks has now been compromised by it's own bureaucracy.

Nicely done!
 
Wikileaks has been trying to put the blame of this on Guardian and Leigh, but in my opinion that's unwarranted. While what Leigh did -- publishing a (to him) no longer relevant password -- is poor security practice (as amply demonstrated by this case), it's the kind of security error that real users will commit, and your security protocols have to be robust enough to stand up to them. The culpability thus lies with the people responsible for the security protocols -- in other words Wikileaks.

You can also say, Guardian has been trying to put the blame of this on Wikileaks.

I don't get your point. You first say Leigh shouldn't have the blame, then say Leigh's security practice is poor, then say it's all Wikileaks fault. By the same logic I would say it is all USA government fault because they were the first to be responsible for the security of the files (which , I believe one of the points geni made above). But then you can also argue that the diplomats should have never gave away then names of the informants in their cables because there is always a risk that somebody will make a mistake somewhere and make the cables public...
 
Last edited:
By good I understand acces to information such as

"Oil giant Shell claiming to have inserted staff and fully infiltrated Nigeria's government"

or

"UN peacekeepers in Ivory Coast traded food for sex with underage girls"

and hundreds of more ...

Weirdly, neither of your two examples were unknown - by anyone who keeps up with the news . I have been aware by news magazines, TV news and occasional newspapers as well as PBS of the specifics of the second and the generality of the first (please note that unless it is quoting what is clearly a news report no secret communique is going to say "Oil giant Shell" - that is pure news-speak, not gov't-speak). Those aren't the type of items I am speaking of/concerned with. If w.l. had stuck to old and foreign news, I simply would not have cared about them at all.
 
By the by, both of those stories were out at least 3-4 years ago - possibly as long ago as 7.
 
By the by, both of those stories were out at least 3-4 years ago - possibly as long ago as 7.

Obviously those are not last weeks news. So?

Are you saying that you honestly knew about those stories before WL? If yes, I would be very interested if you can please give me a pre-wikileaks link or a reference (in english) where I can access to the information about those two stories?
 
Last edited:
The wikileaks cables are not any kind of super-duper top secret material: there is absolutely no doubt that any foreign power that really wanted to get access to them could have done so as easily as wikileaks, and it's a virtual certainty that China, Russia, Israel and so on have access to far more important things as well.
 
Obviously those are not last weeks news. So?

Are you saying that you honestly knew about those stories before WL? If yes, I would be very interested if you can please give me a pre-wikileaks link or a reference (in english) where I can access to the information about those two stories?

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/article4012013.ece Hard to find (took me almost 45 seconds to locate - and, yes, I tend to be snarky when people want something they can find on their own in under a minute . As you may note, 3 years ago. I'll let you find oil companies affecting the Nigerian gov't.
 
Last edited:
But, the basics could be far earlier on that (it has been common knowledge for over ten years)
 
Hard to find (took me almost 45 seconds to locate - and, yes, I tend to be snarky when people want something they can find on their own in under a minute. As you may note, 3 years ago. I'll let you find oil companies affecting the Nigerian gov't.

Very interesting, thank you. I also did find Save the Children organization 2008 report titled "Under-reporting of child sexual exploitation ..." on the subject. Initially ignorant of the fact, I applaud them. But still, is it not a good thing that with the WL cables, the subject is getting more mainstream media attention with more up-to-date information (e.g. Beninese peacekeepers) and more insight from US diplomatic point of view?
 
While what Leigh did -- publishing a (to him) no longer relevant password -- is poor security practice (as amply demonstrated by this case), it's the kind of security error that real users will commit [...].


Real users publish passwords in books they write?
 
I refer to an old post of mine:


​
We can now add that, like a large governmental intelligence agency, Wikileaks has now been compromised by it's own bureaucracy.

One major difference between the two is that western intelligence agencies are subject to oversight by voting citizens. It's obviously not an ideal solution, but it's a lot more than what Wikileaks has to offer people.
 
One major difference between the two is that western intelligence agencies are subject to oversight by voting citizens. It's obviously not an ideal solution, but it's a lot more than what Wikileaks has to offer people.

The thing is, we can't actually exercise that oversight unless we know what they are doing, and we can't know what they are doing unless Wikileaks leaks it, so there's only a difference because Wikileaks exists.

If it's a choice between unaccountable government secrecy and unaccountable Wikileaks openness, the lesser of two evils seems to me to have an unaccountable but otherwise powerless body leaking to keep the body with the power accountable.
 
The wikileaks cables are not any kind of super-duper top secret material: there is absolutely no doubt that any foreign power that really wanted to get access to them could have done so as easily as wikileaks, and it's a virtual certainty that China, Russia, Israel and so on have access to far more important things as well.

And when national intelligence experts signify their endorsement of you by employing you in a national intelligence capacity, and when you submit your actions to review by the legislature's budgetary and intelligence oversight committees, and when you submit yourself to judgement by the duly-appointed courts for any crimes you may be accused of committing, I'll give serious consideration to your opinion about what does and does not constitute "super-duper top secret material".

Until that day, I'll give your opinions the same consideration I give those of Assange and his ilk, whom I never asked to assume national security duties, who has never proven his qualifications for the job, and who--most notably--has explicitly refused to submit himself to any democratic authority or oversight.
 
Real users publish passwords in books they write?

Yes.

Anyone who base their security on people not making this kind of mistake is incompetent.

(For the record, and being less of a tangent than it might appear, in my opinion the real story about the diplomatic cables leak is the flawed security design of the SIPRNet.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom