Wikileaks publishes full cache of unredacted cables

The argument that Wikileaks is outrageous because they release things they should not release, but everything they release is old news, but it's outrageous that they release this old news again, seems to me to have a flaw in it.

It seems to me that one of your two talking points must be wrong. We can't necessarily prove which yet, but they're contradictory. They can't both be right. Either something they released was news, or nothing they released was worth getting outraged about.

Unless names and/or identifying information about informants and other persons who could be subject to reprisals was released along with the old news, in which case both points would be correct.
So I sure hope that never happens. :duck:
 
Unless names and/or identifying information about informants and other persons who could be subject to reprisals was released along with the old news, in which case both points would be correct.
So I sure hope that never happens. :duck:

Previous releases had the names and identifying details removed, but people sure did get irate about those previous releases too, so I think the point holds.
 
The argument that Wikileaks is outrageous because they release things they should not release, but everything they release is old news, but it's outrageous that they release this old news again, seems to me to have a flaw in it.

It seems to me that one of your two talking points must be wrong. We can't necessarily prove which yet, but they're contradictory. They can't both be right. Either something they released was news, or nothing they released was worth getting outraged about.
You think it's news if an informant contacts a diplomat about government abuses/corruption in some totalitarian country? No, it's not news. But then wikileaks publishes a summary of the conversation, along with the informants name, and now you've put him at risk. And you've made it less likely that future informants will ever come forward with their information. You haven'ty uncovered any US scandal, you just put an innocent life at risk and restricted future information channels. Congratulations Kevin! Good job!

That's what the outrage is about.
 
Previous releases had the names and identifying details removed, but people sure did get irate about those previous releases too, so I think the point holds.
Nonsense. Wikileaks has been careless from the beginning about releasing names, for example of Taliban informants. Remember Kevin? Then wikileaks said it was the fault of the US, since the US government didn't help them redact the names.

But hey, so what if a few informants end up getting tortured to death. You got a few tidbits that made some US official look silly! So, it evens out. :rolleyes:
 
Nonsense. Wikileaks has been careless from the beginning about releasing names, for example of Taliban informants. Remember Kevin? Then wikileaks said it was the fault of the US, since the US government didn't help them redact the names.

But hey, so what if a few informants end up getting tortured to death. You got a few tidbits that made some US official look silly! So, it evens out. :rolleyes:

I'd swear we had this exact conversation a long time ago, and it turned out that there was absolutely zero evidence anyone got tortured to death or harmed in any way whatsoever in Afghanistan as a result of those releases and that US officials on the ground in Afghanistan stated this.

(As I recall the general response was "What would they know? Can they prove nobody was hurt? Absence of evidence is license to speculate, and speculation is close enough to fact for our purposes!").

However I can't stop you simultaneously believing that nothing Wikileaks has ever released was news (despite the fact that you admit you haven't even looked into the matter and want someone else to be your unpaid research assistant), that nobody was ever outraged about previous Wikileaks leaks, and that Wikileaks are terrible people for releasing all that non-news.

All I can do is point out the self-proclaimed, deliberate ignorance and internal contradictions in the beliefs you have espoused in this thread and move on.
 
I'd swear we had this exact conversation a long time ago, and it turned out that there was absolutely zero evidence anyone got tortured to death or harmed in any way whatsoever in Afghanistan as a result of those releases and that US officials on the ground in Afghanistan stated this.

(As I recall the general response was "What would they know? Can they prove nobody was hurt? Absence of evidence is license to speculate, and speculation is close enough to fact for our purposes!").

However I can't stop you simultaneously believing that nothing Wikileaks has ever released was news (despite the fact that you admit you haven't even looked into the matter and want someone else to be your unpaid research assistant), that nobody was ever outraged about previous Wikileaks leaks, and that Wikileaks are terrible people for releasing all that non-news.

All I can do is point out the self-proclaimed, deliberate ignorance and internal contradictions in the beliefs you have espoused in this thread and move on.
Name one single actual story that wikileaks broke, I seem to have missed the headlines. Are you going to ask me to research it myself again? :rolleyes:

Remember the "collateral murder" video purported to show the murder of an innocent unarmed reporter, except what it actually showed was reporters embedded with heavily armed insurgents during a firefight?

Oops!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom