Wikileaks publishes full cache of unredacted cables

The thing is, we can't actually exercise that oversight unless we know what they are doing, and we can't know what they are doing unless Wikileaks leaks it, so there's only a difference because Wikileaks exists.

Historically, newspapers have served this function quite well, and newspapers have both professional standards editorial oversight and process to help them decide what and how to publish to best serve the public.
 
Actualy wikileaks has done a fair bit of good. For US policy objectives. At least part of the cause of the arab spring was people discovering what US diplomats (rather than press spokesmen) really thought about various dictators.

The interesting part about the Wikileaks is that they showed that, on the whole, US ambassadors etc. were at most more polite to the dictators face to face, but hardly in the habit of doing dark and dirty secret opressions of the people with them (of course there was the occassional idiot diplomat, but that's always so). It hardly showed the US as some sort of evil opressive hypocrite.
 
Historically, newspapers have served this function quite well, and newspapers have both professional standards editorial oversight and process to help them decide what and how to publish to best serve the public.

And weren't they doing this with Wikileaks?

While I'm at it, there have been a lot of embarrassing leaks, for Australia as well as other nations. But where are the bombshell, national-security-damaging, society-endangering leaks? I can't recall seeing any. Where is the justification for some of the stupid suggestions in this thread that Assange and others should simply be killed?
 
Last edited:
The document is a .CSV file. Wikileaks told the Guardian that it was a temporary password that would be deleted within hours. Wikileaks then re-used said password. That makes Wikileaks a bunch of idiots.

IMNSHO it makes both a bunch of idiot, guardian for publishing the password , even if they thought it temporary, and wikileaks to even publish the whole shebang unredacted.

Bunch of ******.
 
And weren't they doing this with Wikileaks?

"It's complicated." Some newspapers did, others got access to the cables without any formal agreement with Wikileaks, and Wikileaks seemed both conflicted and iffy on the need for editorial oversight and redactions.

My point was mostly that Wikileaks does not serve any unique or irreplaceable role in providing oversight and transparency. The press has been fulfilling that very same role in a wider and, in my opinion, superior (but in no means flawless) manner for centuries.

I'll add that I have no confidence in Wikileaks' ability or commitment to handle and manage sensitive information in a responsible manner.

While I'm at it, there have been a lot of embarrassing leaks, for Australia as well as other nations. But where are the bombshell, national-security-damaging, society-endangering leaks? I can't recall seeing any. Where is the justification for some of the stupid suggestions in this thread that Assange and others should simply be killed?

There isn't any of either.

However, with the unredacted cables released, there has been done real damage the safety and security of some of the sources that were named in the cables. This is a genuine cause for concern.
 
But you want individuals to get killed?

As far as I can tell There hasn't been a properly documented individual killed after a leak. There has been a lot of alarmist "hoo people will get killed" OTOH, and a lot of useful idiot painting wikileaks as a bad thing.

I think in the line of complexity that governement have today much too much secret, are in reality classifying a lot to hide their own incompetence, and abuse secret agency for various nefarious purpose. See for example le monde journalist telephon list spied upon, to check who whistle blowed on the governement latest corruption with l'oreal affair in France. Since the governement don't seem to hold check and balance, and the public simply sleep, it is useful from time to time to have a kick in the anthill, no matter what the useful idiot crying end-of-the-world at each leaks thinks.

But here we have had a show of incompetence on the leakers really.
 
However, with the unredacted cables released, there has been done real damage the safety and security of some of the sources that were named in the cables. This is a genuine cause for concern.

People have been talking about "real damage" since the first Wikileaks cables, but the only damage I've seen has been to the reputation to various security services. Even Assange admits he does not have access to top secret information, and given the tendency of security services to classify petty cash expenditure as secret, I'm dubious about any danger these latest leaks will cause.
 
People have been talking about "real damage" since the first Wikileaks cables, but the only damage I've seen has been to the reputation to various security services.

Yes, and I agree this talk was overblown.

However, with the recent release of the unredacted cables, it seems realistic that there will be real damages done -- not to the USA but to some of the sources named in the cables. This doesn't necessarily mean disappearances and torture (but in some cases it could). Hopefully, the actual damage caused will be limited, but at the moment it's far too early to tell.
 
Edited by Gaspode: 
Removed breach of Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have.

There appear to be two or three posters in this thread who are quite giddy over Julie Assmunches latest dump.
 
I have.

There appear to be two or three posters in this thread who are quite giddy over Julie Assmunches latest dump.

Yeah? How about naming them.

While you're at it, how about recounting the real damage done by Wikileaks so far? Apart from to the self esteem of US and other security forces, that is.
 
Assange doesn't really care (...) since he's potentially an offender himself.
I thought that Assange is potentially innocent himself, and a victim of intrigue.

And yes, he has been named in the media, so the media didn´t care about his privacy.
 
Edited by Gaspode: 
Removed breach of Membership Agreement.

I'm not much of a fan of Wikileaks and think that the phenomenon that Wikileaks represents is more important than say, Julian Assange, because one way or another we're talking about a new way in which more data simply will get leaked by someone at some time and while you may disagree with this Assange might end up being someone at the responsible end of the spectrum.

I do find it more worrisome that there have been people calling for his head and exclaiming that what he hath wrought is wanton bloodshed when there has been no evidence of such a thing happening.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
And when national intelligence experts signify their endorsement of you by employing you in a national intelligence capacity, and when you submit your actions to review by the legislature's budgetary and intelligence oversight committees, and when you submit yourself to judgement by the duly-appointed courts for any crimes you may be accused of committing, I'll give serious consideration to your opinion about what does and does not constitute "super-duper top secret material".

Until that day, I'll give your opinions the same consideration I give those of Assange and his ilk, whom I never asked to assume national security duties, who has never proven his qualifications for the job, and who--most notably--has explicitly refused to submit himself to any democratic authority or oversight.

Technically 130000 were unclassified, 100000 confidential, 15000 secret and none top secret.

But go on rhapsodising about the awesomeness of national intelligence thingywhatsits and how I couldn't possibly know that because I haven't been knighted by the Pope in a secret ceremony in the Statue of Liberty or whatever it is you think these people do.
 
The thing is, we can't actually exercise that oversight unless we know what they are doing, and we can't know what they are doing unless Wikileaks leaks it, so there's only a difference because Wikileaks exists.

If it's a choice between unaccountable government secrecy and unaccountable Wikileaks openness, the lesser of two evils seems to me to have an unaccountable but otherwise powerless body leaking to keep the body with the power accountable.
So you're cool if your medical records show up on Wikileaks some day? I mean, how else are we to know if patients are treated properly by your government?
 
While you're at it, how about recounting the real damage done by Wikileaks so far? Apart from to the self esteem of US and other security forces, that is.
Do you think this will make foreign sources in oppresssive countries more or less likely to be candid with US diplomats?
 
Yes.

Anyone who base their security on people not making this kind of mistake is incompetent.

(For the record, and being less of a tangent than it might appear, in my opinion the real story about the diplomatic cables leak is the flawed security design of the SIPRNet.)

That I agree with - and no location having any kind of access to such system should have any possibility for a single person or collusion of persons to download any of that material - at most only be able to screen it and never more than a couple of KB before having to delete and reenter password before any more could be brought up. At a minimum.
 
Do you think this will make foreign sources in oppresssive countries more or less likely to be candid with US diplomats?

Probably less. They'll probably be thinking, well if some Aussie New Age geek can arrange to get massive amounts of diplomatic cables so easily then what kind of information can professional spies from other states find out?
 
Documented things tend to be legal and honest, a culture of leaking everything and anything more probably hurts the privacy of honest people than the undocumented secrets of most corrupt people.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom