Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

And where does it stop? Ted Bundy (and probably most serial killers) was mentally ill. Should he have been saved the chair?
Got any evidence of Bundy being mentally ill?

He was a sadistic killer, but he wasn't mentally ill AFAIK.
 
Do you understand that schizophrenia is different from bipolar disorder?

Do you understand that schizophrenia has different symptoms from bipolar disorder and it affects its victims in different ways?
 
I was responding to Wildcat's question:

"Got any evidence of Bundy being mentally ill?

He was a sadistic killer, but he wasn't mentally ill AFAIK."


The evidence has been provided. Bundy was indeed mentally ill.
 
I was responding to Wildcat's question:

"Got any evidence of Bundy being mentally ill?

He was a sadistic killer, but he wasn't mentally ill AFAIK."


The evidence has been provided. Bundy was indeed mentally ill.

I think the point was that they were mentally ill in very different ways. Schizophrenia is closely associated with delusions and disorganized thoughts while bipolar disorder is associated with mood.

The former suggests Loughner could not understand what he was doing but the latter suggests Bundy could. Whether or not that matters, I leave to you.

FWIW, I am anti-capital punishment.
 
Last edited:
The real blame—according to several sources—is Sarah Palin, who singlehandedly created an atmosphere of hate and vitriol that forced Mr. Loughner to carry out his crime.

forced?

why don't you show us who at JREF suggested that Palin's rhetoric FORCED Loughner to kill innocent human beings. this sounds like "mind-control". :)



..this should be good.
 
I think the point was that they were mentally ill in very different ways. Schizophrenia is closely associated with delusions and disorganized thoughts while bipolar disorder is associated with mood.

The former suggests Loughner could not understand what he was doing but Bundy could. Whether or not that matters, I leave to you.

FWIW, I am anti-capital punishment.

He knew exactly what he was doing.

Jared Lee Loughner's eyes look "dead -- he's pure evil," one prison worker told a visitor.

 
Yep, he shot Giffords because she was covering up the government's mind control of the people through grammar and currency.

Nothing at all schizophrenic about that...

I still want him executed for his crimes. Regardless of his mental illness.

Why? Cause he killed a child. Its that simple.
 
I understand WANTING it. That doesn't mean it is right or a good idea.

"Right" and "legal" aren't always the same thing.

I want him dead. But if a judge and jury feels otherwise, that's fine.

I personally believe that all serial killers, especially those who kill children, have forfeited their right to live.

As have murdering war-criminals, such as Hitler, Stalin, Mao, Pinochet, etc etc.
 
Last edited:
"Right" and "legal" aren't always the same thing.

I want him dead. But if a judge and jury feels otherwise, that's fine.

I personally believe that all serial killers, especially those who kill children, have forfeited their right to live.

Just making sure we are making that distinction. Carry on.
 
Just making sure we are making that distinction. Carry on.

And just for the sake of further clarification, I do not support a lynch mob breaking this guy out of jail and hanging him in the town square.

I support our justice system and its decisions 100%.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom