Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

When does that ever happen?

There is no such thing as "Legally Innocent". The legal term is "Not Guilty" which is not the same as Innocent.
God, if you watch enough "Law and Order" episodes you would know that........
 
"What else do I call someone who wants to kill what he knows are innocent people?"

I was unaware that Loughner has already gone to trial. Only a judge and jury can declare someone "innocent".

You made a definitive statement that Loughner was not guilty (you aren't a judge either), yet you still want to kill him.
 
I, you, my dad, President Ahmedinajad, the Pope, and Santa Claus, can call someone "innocent" all they like.

But until a judge and/or jury finds someone legally innocent of a crime, all other claims of "innocence" are just silly & useless.

One might think he is innocent, one might want him to be found innocent, but that's very different from him actually being innocent.

I want him found guilty and executed. But what I want and what will happen according to the legal system are two different things.

Not in this country, buddy. I don't know what sort of totalitarian wonder-land you live in, but in the USA an individual is innocent until proven otherwise. The burden of proof is on the accuser (that's you), not the defender.
 
I, you, my dad, President Ahmedinajad, the Pope, and Santa Claus, can call someone "innocent" all they like.

But until a judge and/or jury finds someone legally innocent of a crime, all other claims of "innocence" are just silly & useless.

One might think he is innocent, one might want him to be found innocent, but that's very different from him actually being innocent.

I want him found guilty and executed. But what I want and what will happen according to the legal system are two different things.

Not in this country, buddy. I don't know what sort of totalitarian wonder-land you live in, but in the USA an individual is innocent until proven otherwise. The burden of proof is on the accuser (that's you), not the defender.

Isn't it almost scary that there are actually people who live in this country who think the way Thunder does?

In his World, we are all guilty of rape and murder until we prove we are innocent!
 
Isn't it almost scary that there are actually people who live in this country who think the way Thunder does?

In his World, we are all guilty of rape and murder until we prove we are innocent!

why are you lieing about my views? that's not very nice.

"innocent" is not a legal status in the justice system. one is "guilty or "not guilty".

yes, we have the presumption of innocent until proven guilty, but when the judge asks you to make a plea at the grand jury, you cannot say "innocent". you say "not guilty".

when the jury decides the case, they call you "guilty" or "not guilty".

deal with it.
 
why are you lieing about my views? that's not very nice.

"innocent" is not a legal status in the justice system. one is "guilty or "not guilty".

yes, we have the presumption of innocent until proven guilty, but when the judge asks you to make a plea at the grand jury, you cannot say "innocent". you say "not guilty".

when the jury decides the case, they call you "guilty" or "not guilty".

deal with it.

ahem:

thunder said:
But until a judge and/or jury finds someone legally innocent of a crime, all other claims of "innocence" are just silly & useless.
 
you are very correct. I was in error.

"innocent" is not a legal status, as far as the justice system is concerned.

I and some other folks in this thread were clearly mistaken.

Who were the other folks?
 
Thing is, Loughner is mentally ill, crazy, unstable, crazy and particularly unusual, regardless of his political beliefs. In fact, I can't even tell you what his political beliefs were. The posts I read by the guy were so full of crazy that it was impossible to make any sense of them. Things like years being somehow infinite and something about the space shuttle being incompatible with human life.

For that matter, it doesn't matter what his particular beliefs were. He could have just as easily been an anti-capitalist nutbag and still done the same thing. It was the crazy that made him shoot people, not any particular view he had.

Yeah but when you take that point of view you can't exploit a tragedy to score cheap, pathetic political points.

Loughner is his name? I wasn't sure, I haven't heard anybody actually blame him for it yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom