Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

Sigh.

Bundy was judged fit to be tried. Your point is that Loughner should be tried (and executed) regardless of his fitness to plead.

Glad we have sorted that out.

Strawman.

And assuming the judge rules he is fit to stand trial, would that alleviate your concerns?
 
Steve Striffler, Truthout: "Contrary to the prevailing wisdom, however, holding muddled political views does not in and of itself necessarily make Loughner mentally ill, unstable, crazy, or even particularly unusual.


That isn't the popular view.

So by your reading of "the popular view" the person holding the sign in the picture below is mentally ill? ;)

 
And where does it stop? Ted Bundy (and probably most serial killers) was mentally ill. Should he have been saved the chair?

very good point.

David Berkowitz is in prison for life even though he is clearly insane.

Jeffrey Dahmer was also sentenced to life in prison.

I bet there are a couple more extremally mentally ill serial killers who were sent to prison and not a mental institution.
 
I didn't work my way through the entire thread here, so forgive if anyone brought this up. NPR reported the other day on an FBI study of assasins and would-be assasins.
This had been conducted over a period of years and included interviews with individuals, study of their writings, and so forth.
They found that though mental illness was certainly present in a large percentage of these individuals, it was not the overriding factor in their decision to kill or attempt to kill someone famous. (or to commit large-scale mass murder)
Rather, it was overall feelings of failure, inadequacy, and powerlessness. They almost all felt that their "act" would gain them fame/notoriety.
One fellow, who had plotted to attack vice-president Biden, went on and on as to how attacking a vice-president was unprecidented, and would gain him "a whole page" in history books.
If the FBI's conclusions are correct, it's obvious that political rhetoric is not a factor in most of these cases; or even politics at all. Rather the delusions of the individual who might fixate on anyone for any reason.
 
Bikewer- what are your thoughts on clearly mentally ill individuals going to prison and/or being executed for their crimes?

The fact is that many mentally ill killers have indeed been sent to life in prison.
 
I am against the death penalty in all cases. ALL cases. I believe that every person who kills is mentally ill. (Exceptions for war, police.) No sane person comes to the conclusion that it's OK to kill somebody. And the idea that knowing right from wrong defines insanity baffles me. If you know that it's wrong and you still kill, you're even MORE insane. IMO.

Carry on...
 
Steve Striffler, Truthout: "Contrary to the prevailing wisdom, however, holding muddled political views does not in and of itself necessarily make Loughner mentally ill, unstable, crazy, or even particularly unusual.

No, but his other behaviors sure suggest he was. He showed all the classic signs of a paranoid schizophrenic. He was even seen around town having conversations with voices. For example, Linda McKinley, a neighbor who lived down the street, said that when she was outside watering plants, she would see Jared talking to himself or yelling out to people who were not there. He often spoke of "lucid dreaming". He became paranoid about mind control. His thought processes were clearly chaotic. And he showed a dozen other symptoms. What to do about people who suffer from this awful affliction really should be the topic of discussion here … not trying to blame republicans for causing this incident or thinking the solution is to simply try him for murder, execute him, then move on.
 
Steve Striffler, Truthout: "Contrary to the prevailing wisdom, however, holding muddled political views does not in and of itself necessarily make Loughner mentally ill, unstable, crazy, or even particularly unusual.

no one has suggested that his book list or even his thoughts about monetary policy, is what makes him clearly insane.

this is a strawman by Mr. Stiffler. he is trying to suggest that America is now in the mood to call all CTists "insane" and will soon wish to lock em' all up.
 
And assuming the judge rules he is fit to stand trial, would that alleviate your concerns?

No, it would only be the start of my concerns.

You're probably confusing the judges ruling of fit to stand trial with the jury ruling of guilty/not guilty by way of mental disease or defect. They are separate and distinct issues.

In the case of schizophrenics, once properly medicated, they can be surprisingly lucid and often very intelligent. An inexperienced observer will have difficulty telling a schizophrenia patient on anti-psychotics and a normal person who has been up all night long (the fatigue and drowsiness reported by schizophrenics on most anti-psychotics is the chief cause of their chronic non-compliance with taking their medications).

While Loughner was undoubtedly extremely ill in the days before and during the shooting incident, he will likely be forced to take medication while in custody and when his trial comes around will be quite aware of his surroundings and able to assist his attorney in his own defense.
 
Ooo
No, it would only be the start of my concerns.

You're probably confusing the judges ruling of fit to stand trial with the jury ruling of guilty/not guilty by way of mental disease or defect. They are separate and distinct issues.

I am aware of the distinction. If you read the exchange, it should be clear why I asked the question.


Sent from my Samsung Epic 4G using Tapatalk
 
No it is cause they are CrAzIeS.

And some cRaZiEs enjoy killing. Some keep killing. I should know from my unfortunate run-ins with some high levels way back in HS. I had some CrAzIeS try to chop my head off 3 weeks after they were arrested chasing another young man from a different town with shotguns. They made him crash and he broke his back but lived.

They got out on bond on both incidents and faced no jail time other than a holding tank. They had to pay my med bills. That's it.

Utter BS it was. He needs to be punished to set an example to dissuade others. Otherwise more cRaZiEs will come out the wood works and kill since they know they won't suffer any stiff punishment.

I appreciate your carefully considered nuanced analysis of this topic. Do you often find the term "cRaZiEs" used in the scientific literature on this subject, Doctor?
 
What to do about people who suffer from this awful affliction really should be the topic of discussion here … not trying to blame republicans for causing this incident or thinking the solution is to simply try him for murder, execute him, then move on.

Two "blood-and-guts" right wingers calling for mercy.

This must be the opening of the Sixth Seal in Revelations or something. ;)
 
So by your reading of "the popular view" the person holding the sign in the picture below is mentally ill? ;)

Wow, did you misread my response. In fact, you misread it so completely I'm not even sure how you got there, and so I'm at a bit of a loss as to how to respond in a way that would avoid you repeating your mistake.
 
Alright darn it, if no one else is gonna bring this thread back to the OP, then I guess it will just have to be me, pilgrim. :)

Why the heck should I give a damn about Loughners politics, now that it is clear that he acted as a result of his mental issues and not politics?

The article in the OP clearly wants us to pay attention to the politics of a nut, as if nuts have the right to be heard.

No, Truthout, nuts do not have the right to be heard. And frankly, their use of violence to express their sense of anger and powerlessness makes their views even less worth listening to.

I agree with the critics of the author of the OP. We have no reason to take anything that this child-murderer says, as far as politics is concerned, seriously.


...and by the way, Sword of Truth, please do not lie about my posts. To do so is very childish.

I fully support the execution of Loughner if he is indeed found guilty of murder.
 
Last edited:
Again, I fully support the execution of Loughner if he is indeed found guilty of murder.

Jeffrey Dahmer was sentenced to life in prison, as is David Berkowitz.

Colin Fergeson was sentenced to more than 300 years in prison.

All three of them were certainly mentally disturbed.
 
Last edited:
Why the heck should I give a damn about Loughners politics, now that it is clear that he acted as a result of his mental issues and not politics?

There is no reason to.

Just like there was no reason to give a damn about Palin's map. And yet....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom