Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

bikerdruid

Philosopher
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
7,361
Location
North Peace Bioregion of theGreat Boreal Forest
i think this article describes the political climate that breeds violent, confused and limited understanding of reality (often evidenced in radical right wing thinking, like we find in most american conservatives.:D)

Steve Striffler, Truthout: "Contrary to the prevailing wisdom, however, holding muddled political views does not in and of itself necessarily make Loughner mentally ill, unstable, crazy, or even particularly unusual. It makes him American and peculiarly so. In the college classroom, at political events and in grassroots organizing meetings, it does not take long to find many young (and not so young) people who hold what many of us consider to be an oddly contradictory collection of political views.... In a world where fragments of information come from so many sources, it often leads them to the odd place where any explanation of the world is as good as any other, where there is no conceptual rudder for judging one theory or idea against another."
http://org2.democracyinaction.org/dia/track.jsp?v=2&c=7qBmKs9tM8Fte0C32+IT24uzTEXiAaJB
 
Thing is, Loughner is mentally ill, crazy, unstable, crazy and particularly unusual, regardless of his political beliefs. In fact, I can't even tell you what his political beliefs were. The posts I read by the guy were so full of crazy that it was impossible to make any sense of them. Things like years being somehow infinite and something about the space shuttle being incompatible with human life.

For that matter, it doesn't matter what his particular beliefs were. He could have just as easily been an anti-capitalist nutbag and still done the same thing. It was the crazy that made him shoot people, not any particular view he had.
 
I don't think it was politics that was the direct cause. However, it's obvious that such things can have an effect on somebody who is already unstable. What I want to know is how his parents didn't know there was something wrong with the kid and why they didn't do anything.
 
Why Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

i think this article describes the political climate that breeds violent, confused and limited understanding of reality (often evidenced in radical right wing thinking, like we find in most american conservatives.:D)

You have your Marius van der Lubbe.
 
Thing is, Loughner is mentally ill, crazy, unstable, crazy and particularly unusual, regardless of his political beliefs. In fact, I can't even tell you what his political beliefs were. The posts I read by the guy were so full of crazy that it was impossible to make any sense of them. Things like years being somehow infinite and something about the space shuttle being incompatible with human life.

For that matter, it doesn't matter what his particular beliefs were. He could have just as easily been an anti-capitalist nutbag and still done the same thing. It was the crazy that made him shoot people, not any particular view he had.

He was right about the space shuttle!
 
i think this article describes the political climate that breeds violent, confused and limited understanding of reality (often evidenced in radical right wing thinking, like we find in most american conservatives.:D)

No it doesn't. The article is garbage. And the fact that you think such garbage is somehow insightful is sadly not surprising.

Steve Striffler, Truthout: "Contrary to the prevailing wisdom, however, holding muddled political views does not in and of itself necessarily make Loughner mentally ill, unstable, crazy, or even particularly unusual.


That isn't the popular view. The popular view is that he was a complete nutjob because he had no grasp on reality. And that looks pretty much correct. For example, this video tour he gives of his college campus shows not a muddled political view, but a completely incoherent mind.

The fact that you're still continuing to try to associate this lunatic with the right, even after his complete insanity has been made so public, is rather pathetic.
 
first
I just started reading Age of American Unreason, which is not the first book on the topic of discussing just how uneducated and childish America as a whole is politically.

There is a reason why Ayn Rand is still held in such high regards and why Limbaugh is still brainwashing people. I think this has been ever present -at least in the 20th century - in US politics but it has been growing at a much higher pace since the Reagan.
unfortunately I really don't see a way out of this downward spiral in any other way but very painfull. Short term long term will depend on how fast the standards of living in this country go down the toilet while the rich steel as much as they can.



Second,

I was listening to a story on NPR about political assassinations. According to the story 99% are NOT politically motivated!? According to the storey there have been dozens off legit attempts that never made the news, but the Secret service has done extensive interviews and reviews. Mostly it's about getting notoriety according to this story.

It is still odd that the rhetoric from the right seems to inspire so many to pic up the gun.
 
Thing is, Loughner is mentally ill, crazy, unstable, crazy and particularly unusual, regardless of his political beliefs.
Well said.

I don't think it was politics that was the direct cause. However, it's obvious that such things can have an effect on somebody who is already unstable.

But so can anything--anything at all--not just politics.

It could be a crush on a celebrity, it could be what the person thinks his dog wants him to do, it could be lyrics from rock songs, it could be what the person thinks his teeth are telling him to do.

Not only was actual political speech acts not the "direct cause"--they weren't causes at all--no more than the Beatles caused the Manson Family murders, no more than Jodie Foster caused Hinckley to shoot Reagan, and so on.
 
It is still odd that the rhetoric from the right seems to inspire so many to pic up the gun.

I know of at least one left-winger on these boards who boasts that he has thousands of rounds of ammo in his garage.
 
If the story is suggesting that Loughner wouldn't have done it if he was politically astute, it's just plain silly. First, he targeted Giffords not because of her politics but because of a chance encounter with her a few years ago that didn't go well for him. If that chance encounter had been with a Republican Representative or a sports star or the pope, Giffords would be out riding her motorcycle today. It was completely personal and had nothing to do with politics.

Second, Loughner's brain was incapable of the coherence needed to formulate a political ideology, however muddled. The best political tutoring in the world would have been wasted on him.

I'm not saying the article isn't right, or wrong, about the current socio/political climate in the U.S. I'm just saying it has nothing to do with an irrational mind like Jared Loughner's.
 
Second, Loughner's brain was incapable of the coherence needed to formulate a political ideology, however muddled. The best political tutoring in the world would have been wasted on him.

Some people confuse "delusions" with "politics".
 
Second, Loughner's brain was incapable of the coherence needed to formulate a political ideology, however muddled. The best political tutoring in the world would have been wasted on him.

I'm not saying the article isn't right, or wrong, about the current socio/political climate in the U.S. I'm just saying it has nothing to do with an irrational mind like Jared Loughner's.

Loughner is an extreme anarchist with slightly right wing orientation. What coherent thought processes he displays follow roughly the same line as the Freeemen on the land philosophy, which, when you break it down into specifics, comes closer to the "conservative" philosophy, every man for himself.
 
Loughner is an extreme anarchist with slightly right wing orientation. What coherent thought processes he displays follow roughly the same line as the Freeemen on the land philosophy, which, when you break it down into specifics, comes closer to the "conservative" philosophy, every man for himself.

How can you pigeonhole him into any political ideology when he didn't have an ideology to begin with? He bounced all over the place. You might as well label him a Christian just because he was once caught for writing Christian graffiti.
 
I know of at least one left-winger on these boards who boasts that he has thousands of rounds of ammo in his garage.

That's a lot of wasted money. He must have more money than sense. Why do they do it? How do they get all that money? I've always had to work hard for money, and sure as hell didn't want to waste it on a bullet collection. The way I see it, anyone who has more ammo than it takes to off a few thugs is either a potential mass murderer or a hoarder.

Does he know exactly how many bullets he has? Does he periodically buy more bullets to add to his collection?
 
You can discount the Tucson shooter, since he was out of his mind.

Which can be said of anyone who draws a weapon, aims into a crowd and pulls the trigger.

But if we set aside the Tuscon shooter, we still have Richard Poplawski, John Patrick Bedell and James Von Brunn.

Gideon Polyas propaganda is killing people, and yet I've seen nothing from Bikerdruid wherein he apologizes for promoting it.
 
Some people confuse "delusions" with "politics".

Not sure if you're referring to Loughner or some posters here, so I'll elaborate on my point. Not everything can be explained in political terms. He didn't go after Giffords because he thought "I'm striking a blow for freedom!" He went after her because he had a confused personal grudge against her.
 
Not sure if you're referring to Loughner or some posters here, so I'll elaborate on my point. Not everything can be explained in political terms. He didn't go after Giffords because he thought "I'm striking a blow for freedom!" He went after her because he had a confused personal grudge against her.

I'm sorry for the confusion, I was referring to the OP's article. Obviously, Loughner didn't quite have "political" views, he rather had delusions. The article's author seems to confuse Loughner's delusions for political views, which makes it kind of ironic, since he claims he is a teacher. One would expect a teacher to distinguish between genuine political views and the disorganised incoherent ramblings of a schizophrenic.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom