Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

Your bigotry against the mentally ill has been dominating the thread for the last 3 and a half pages.

"The lady doth protest too much".

#1. My opinions on the death penalty do not dominate this thread. But thanks for the compliment.

#2. I am not "bigoted" against the mentally ill. I spent 5 summers busting my ass helping mentally ill children, even when they spat at me, threw wood at me, kicked me, bit me, and punched me. And I loved that job and loved those kids. Those are the greatest memories of my life.

I do however feel that mental illness should not absolve a murderer from being punished for their crimes. Our justice system punished many mental ill individuals for murders and other crimes. Do you consider the United States judicial system to be "bigoted" against the mentally ill.

I have nothing but sympathy for the mentally ill, and wish our government would spend billions more dollars to help them get the treatment that they need. But some consider that "Socialism", and therefore prevent this from happening. So many mentally ill go untreated..and some of them commit crimes and even murders.
 
"The lady doth protest too much".

She projects a lot too.

it is clear that he acted as a result of his mental issues... I fully support the execution of Loughner...
I still want him executed for his crimes. Regardless of his mental illness.

You know that Loughner isn't criminally liable for his actions. You said so in very specific terms.

Yet you want to kill him anyway.

What else do I call someone who wants to kill what he knows are innocent people?
 
She projects a lot too.




You know that Loughner isn't criminally liable for his actions. You said so in very specific terms.

Yet you want to kill him anyway.

What else do I call someone who wants to kill what he knows are innocent people?

i dont think innocent is the proper word to use here.
do to my lousy english a can't tell you which one it is, but i am pretty sure he is not innocent even if he is not "accountable"? for his deed.
 
i dont think innocent is the proper word to use here.
do to my lousy english a can't tell you which one it is, but i am pretty sure he is not innocent even if he is not "accountable"? for his deed.

In federal court, he could be found "not guilty by reason of insanity," but the defense would have to prove that. It is not the same thing as innocent, which implies that he didn't do anything and is not something courts find anyway.

Arizona could find him "guilty but insane."
 
You know that Loughner isn't criminally liable for his actions. You said so in very specific terms.


Actually, none of us know this. That will be for the legal system to decide, and it has not yet done so.

Nevertheless, the rest of your criticism is valid. Regardless of what the judge and jury finally decide, your criticism is of one who has already concluded that Laughner is mentally-ill, to the degree that he could not be criminally liable for his actions; and yet who wants to hold him criminally liable for his actions.


Yet you want to kill him anyway.

What else do I call someone who wants to kill what he knows are innocent people?
 
has loughner's mental illness been conclusively determined to make him unfit for trial, yet?
tell us, doctor s of t.....:rolleyes:
Have you been able to determine what Loughners "politics" are yet and why we should take them seriously?
 
folks, a co-worker of mine committed suicide on Saturday, so can we please just lay off all these personal attacks dealing with mental illness?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom