Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

Where he says "There’s no question he was acting under mental illness."

yeah, see now you are putting words in his mouth.

Depression is a mental illness. That doesn't mean you can't go to trial and be convicted of murder, even though you suffer from depression.
 
Last edited:
here is a list of mental illnesses. please tell us which ones disqualify the accused from trial.

None of them. Or all of them.

It appears you know as little about how the law works as you do about psychiatry and mental illness.
 
Last edited:
You've already stated that he should be executed even if insane. Why should it matter to you whether Krauthammer examined him or not?

I said I don't care if he is executed.

Whether he is legally insane or not is a different question. And I have not offered an opinion on that.
 
You never met Trochmann, I take it.

Dude is whacked-out.

I never met Ted Bundy either.;)

With that (jokingly) low blow out of the way, I get what you're saying about Trochmann and Jones. What I'm saying is that when he spouts his ideas, we can at least understand him to the point where we can either agree or disagree. You can't do that with Loughner's incoherence, as Gabrielle Giffords found out herself. How do you respond to, "What is government if words have no meaning?" What indication does that give of his politics?

And as far as I know, Trochmann has never gone on an indiscriminate shooting spree. He at least knows where the boundaries of social behaviour are drawn in a way that Loughner obviously doesn't.
 
Whether he is legally insane or not is a different question. And I have not offered an opinion on that.

Do you know of any psychiatrists with Dr. Krauthammers qualifications who has reviewed the available material on the Loughner case and has rendered a differing opinion?

If you do, please let us know?
 
Do you know of any psychiatrists with Dr. Krauthammers qualifications who has reviewed the available material on the Loughner case and has rendered a differing opinion?

If you do, please let us know?

I don't care what doctors who have not examined him say.

I'm sure that the US Attorney will present an expert with impeccable credentials who examined Loughner and will say he knew what he was doing. The defense, will, I am sure, present a similar expert saying the opposite. The jury then decide if he is guilty or not guilty by reason on insanity. And if the former, if he gets the needle.
 
I don't care what doctors who have not examined him say.

as you shouldn't.

I'm sure that the US Attorney will present an expert with impeccable credentials who examined Loughner and will say he knew what he was doing. The defense, will, I am sure, present a similar expert saying the opposite. The jury then decide if he is guilty or not guilty by reason on insanity. And if the former, if he gets the needle.

firing squad would be more appropriate in this case.

and probably more humane, as a bullet in the heart causes instant death.
 
Last edited:
firing squad would be more appropriate in this case.

and probably more humane, as a bullet in the heart causes instant death.

Un-frakking-believable.

Dtugg is correct about one thing, the vast majority of schizophrenics are non-violent.When they are in a lucid state, and they know what's going on around them, they tend to hide their conditions as much as they are able to. They live in fear of the general publics ignorance and prejudice.

The hatred and blood-thirst in your posts are why.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom