Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

Loughner did't kill anyone by accident.

Yeah, you're right. He actually chose to become insane and slaughter 8 people.

what a strange analogy.

Again, you're right. A better analogy would be to drop a guy who unknowingly infected eight people with a disease that killed them into a meat grinder.
 
Excuse me?

Ever do volunteer work with the mentally ill, Parky? have any relatives with schizophrenia?

He is still too focused not to be considered able to form the idea of murder in his mind. The crazy piece of crap knew what he was doing. A real schizo doesn't. He is repeating almost flawlessly the same crap that the Freemen on the land crowd spew.

The Rushblob has been squawking since this started that the left wants Loughner to get off. Looks to me like the more extreme right-wingers are calling him too crazy to try.

I can see why they would not want him to be forced to tell us what he really believes.
 
Not necessarily. Having a mental illness does not in and of itself absolve one from legal responsibility.

It can be a mitigating factor, however.

No judge who is not himself insane is going to give him the needle.
 
At least one well known psychiatrist, Dr. Charles Krauthammer, agrees with me.

This was the act of a probably paranoid schizophrenic. There’s no question he was acting under mental illness.

Krauthammer: "This was the act of a probably paranoid schizophrenic"

and nowhere in the article does Krauthammer say that Loughner is not
legally culpable for his crimes.

such decisions can ONLY be made by a judge and a pyschiatrist, not JREF members.

try again. ;)
 
Last edited:
Krauthammer: "This was the act of a probably paranoid schizophrenic"

and nowhere in the article does Krauthammer say that Loughner is not
legally culpable for his crimes.

such decisions can ONLY be made by a judge and a pyschiatrist, not JREF members.

try again. ;)

Apparently I copied too much of the quote because you went and quote-mined it for your own benefit.

This is Dr. Krauthammer:

He later moved to the United States, where he attended Harvard Medical School. Suffering a paralyzing diving accident in his first year of medical school, he was hospitalized for a year, during which time he continued his medical studies. He graduated with his class, earning an M.D. from Harvard Medical School in 1975, and then began working as a psychiatrist at Massachusetts General Hospital. In October 1984, he became board certified in psychiatry by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology.

From 1975–1978, Krauthammer was a Resident and then a Chief Resident in Psychiatry at the Massachusetts General Hospital. During this time he and a colleague identified a form of mania resulting from a concomitant medical illness, rather than a primary inherent disorder, which they named "secondary mania" and published a second important paper on the epidemiology of manic illness. The standard textbook for bipolar disease (Manic Depressive Illness by Goodwin and Jamison) contains twelve references to his work.

In 1978, Krauthammer quit medical practice to direct planning in psychiatric research for the Jimmy Carter administration, and began contributing to The New Republic magazine.

This is Dr. Krauthammers qualified opinion on Loughner: "There’s no question he was acting under mental illness."

Are you understanding this now?
 
Last edited:
This is Dr. Krauthammers qualified opinion on Loughner: "There’s no question he was acting under mental illness."

when does Krauthammer agree with your post?

Originally Posted by Sword_Of_Truth
And you can't tell that this guy is legally not culpable for his actions?

He doesn't, and do you want to know why not?

Because he understands that this is a call only a judge can make.



..and yes, I have the right to wish him to be executed. Its not the same as making a call as to his legal status.
 
Did this doctor examine him?

No. Which would be why Dr. Krauthammer said that Loughner was "probably paranoid schizophrenic" but also that "there's no question he was acting under mental illness". Schizophrenia is not the only mental illness that can cause the symptoms seen in Loughner. But it is the one that most closely matches whet we have seen.
 
Because he understands that this is a call only a judge can make.

Just to be clear, while a judge can determine whether he is fit to stand trial, it will be up to a jury to decide whether he is legally responsible for his actions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom