Ed Why [you] Should Take Jared Loughner's Politics Seriously

You know that Loughner isn't criminally liable for his actions. You said so in very specific terms.

What else do I call someone who wants to kill what he knows are innocent people?

#1. Only a judge can determine that he is not criminally liable for his actions. You may WANT him to be ruled not criminally liable, but only a judge can make such a determination. Respect the justice system.

#2. Innocent? Innocence of a crime can only be determined if he infact goes to trial. So now you DO want him to go to trial?

And again, if he goes to trial only a jury of his peers can decide that he is infact innocent and not guilty of murder.

Let the legal process run its course. Making declarations of his innocense and not being criminally liable, simply due to his mental illness, is meaningless.
 
what possible relevance can that question have in this thread?
if you would like to address the topic, please do so.
if not, your derail is noted.
I thought the topic was about thinking and the mentally ill.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to hear that Thunder. Hopefully you, everyone else you work with, and your co-worker's family is doing ok. Me and others will put you guys in our prayers for sure.
 
Sorry to hear that Thunder. Hopefully you, everyone else you work with, and your co-worker's family is doing ok. Me and others will put you guys in our prayers for sure.

i hope soo too. i just wish the guy had been able to get the help that i he needed and was entitled too. another sad commentary on the state of mental health in the USA.

..but thats for another thread.
 
folks, a co-worker of mine committed suicide on Saturday, so can we please just lay off all these personal attacks dealing with mental illness?
“If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.”
— popularly attributed to Harry Truman, but more likely originated by Eugene “Buck” Purcell​
Mental illness is germane to this discussion. There's no reason any of us should be expected to avoid the subject, just to avoid hurting your delicate feelings. If you can't stand the topic, get out.
 
Mental illness is germane to this discussion. There's no reason any of us should be expected to avoid the subject, just to avoid hurting your delicate feelings. If you can't stand the topic, get out.

Or.. you know... stop calling for people you've already stated you don't believe are guilty of anything to be killed.
 
The thread was about why we should take Jareh Loughner's politics seriously. Personally I have not seen any reason too.
I think it's reasonable for those involved in adjudicating this case to understand more about why he did it. With all do respect, of course, to the massive intellect of the posters in this forum who've already reached their conclusion ;)
 
I think it's reasonable for those involved in adjudicating this case to understand more about why he did it. With all do respect, of course, to the massive intellect of the posters in this forum who've already reached their conclusion ;)

Loughner is most likely mentally ill. However, he does appear to be very high functioning.

Of course, he should appear before a judge, and psychiatrists for the defendant and the plaintiff should plead their case as to his mental ability to stand trial.

if they find him unable to go to trial, then he will be treated hopefully for the resr of his life.

if he does go to trial, and does not get acquited due to insanity, I hope that he gets the death penalty and NOT just life in prison.

but of course, if he is merely sentenced to life in prison, I would accept that ruling.

.....but I bet street justice would have its say in the prison yard.

would I support that? I don't know. I really don't know.


I just really hate this man for killing an innocent child.
 
The silver lining with the Jared Loughner is that we will be able to stop free speach and further push our liberal agenda unchallenged.
 
No, you don't.

That numb nuts (loughner's)politics are not worth considering, no less taking seriously.

Just because some piece of flesh breathes air does not mean I have to respect said piece of flesh's political views.

Goes for him as well as you, sport.
 
No, you don't.

That numb nuts (loughner's)politics are not worth considering, no less taking seriously.

Just because some piece of flesh breathes air does not mean I have to respect said piece of flesh's political views.

Goes for him as well as you, sport.

yet another that never read the article and has to result to rudeness.
the article is not about his politics.
but, please...contnue to wallow in ignorance.
 
yet another that never read the article and has to result to rudeness.
the article is not about his politics.
but, please...contnue to wallow in ignorance.

It appears to me that the article is trying to insinuate in a round about way that since his political views were a mix of right/left combined w/CT stuff that it is some sort of weird mixture pushing him over the edge into some form of "new type" of homegrown terrorist.

A new type that does not follow any particular ideology.

Would that be a valid assumption on your interpretation also, bikerdruid?

That was what I got out of it anyways. I read it multiple times to try to understand what the author was getting at.

Only thing that baffles me was why he didn't just come out and say that. My logical guess would be maybe so "most haters" of that assumption would totally not get where he was going w/it unless they intently concentrated.
 
yet another that never read the article and has to result to rudeness.
the article is not about his politics.
but, please...contnue to wallow in ignorance.

So why does the OP have the title it does?

A non-snarky response would be appreciated.
 
it was the title that i linked to.
the article is not about his politics, but the environment that created his political and social confusion.
i think it is meant ironically.
I don't think the political environment can cause schizophrenia in a person. The author of the article makes no attempt at all to illustrate such a link.

IOW, I'm rejecting his entire premise.
 
it was the title that i linked to.
the article is not about his politics, but the environment that created his political and social confusion.
i think it is meant ironically.

I say his confusion has more to do with the fact that he was suffering from schizophrenia.

But that's just me.
 
I say his confusion has more to do with the fact that he was suffering from schizophrenia.

Again, for the 800th time, he has yet to be diagnosed by a licensed physician.

How about we let a psychiatrist make an official diagnosis before we declare him schizophrenic or legally not liable for his crimes?

..its just a thought.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom