Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Yet another Clinton supporter that doesn't know her position on the second Amendment. Review the Clinton recording above for enlightenment.

You guys didn't know this? Really? Chris B.

Yep, I do, and did before listening to that: She thinks the Supreme Court is wrong in its interpretation of the Second Amendment -- what's Constitutional and what's not when it comes to sensible gun control. I do too, and it's ironic to see you bragging about your knowledge of the subject.
 
Last edited:
Yet another Clinton supporter that doesn't know her position on the second Amendment. Review the Clinton recording above for enlightenment.

You guys didn't know this? Really? Chris B.
I knew she was critical of the Heller decision, but I actually hadn't heard this clip. It's too bad because this is the kind off the record, fire-in-her belly Hillary that would've been much more motivating to the Democratic base.

So when comes the part about her seeking to repeal the 2nd Amendment? I listened to the entire clip and heard her supporting responsible gun ownership, talking tough about the stranglehold the NRA has on Washington, and then taking a shot at (presumably) the Heller decision.

Is this one of those "there's a bigfoot 15 feet away in this photo" things?
 
Excuse me for specifying you supported Hillary, I assumed since you supported Bernie, you would had voted for Clinton in the general election. I would have been more accurate to have specified your Liberal view of the 2nd. If you didn't vote for Hillary, congratulations there may be hope for you yet. Chris B.

Of course I voted for Hillary. You people didn't give me a choice. I wanted a traditional option of conservative vs. liberal.
Instead you provided insanity vs. sanity.

Trump was an insane choice, and now we all get to suffer together. Won't that be fun!
 
Quote please. I want a verbatim quotation of exactly what you're refering to. Asking me to check somewhere on the recording risks me picking the wrong sentence and you dodging around the point. Either make your case or retract it.

What I see is her saying that the SCOTUS' interpretation is wrong. That's not what you're claiming.

“We’ve got to go after this,” Clinton continued. “And here again, the Supreme Court is wrong on the Second Amendment. And I am going to make that case every chance I get.”

Starts at the 58 second mark. Chris B.
 
Of course I voted for Hillary. You people didn't give me a choice. I wanted a traditional option of conservative vs. liberal.
Instead you provided insanity vs. sanity.

Trump was an insane choice, and now we all get to suffer together. Won't that be fun!

So you voted for Hillary, but you didn't support her........um how does that work exactly? You either voted for her or not. So in effect, your statement accusing me of lying is indeed false. Chris B.
 
I knew she was critical of the Heller decision, but I actually hadn't heard this clip. It's too bad because this is the kind off the record, fire-in-her belly Hillary that would've been much more motivating to the Democratic base.

So when comes the part about her seeking to repeal the 2nd Amendment? I listened to the entire clip and heard her supporting responsible gun ownership, talking tough about the stranglehold the NRA has on Washington, and then taking a shot at (presumably) the Heller decision.

Is this one of those "there's a bigfoot 15 feet away in this photo" things?

Yes, in the context of the whole passage, her advocacy for responsible gun ownership and dislike of the Heller decision is most likely about the safe storage aspects. Heller threw out safe storage regulations for domestic weapons within the region of discussion (federal enclaves?). I don't hear anything in there that suggests she thinks people shouldn't own these weapons. Just that a house with toddlers is an unsafe place for a loaded unlocked weapon to be accessible.
 
“We’ve got to go after this,” Clinton continued. “And here again, the Supreme Court is wrong on the Second Amendment. And I am going to make that case every chance I get.”

Starts at the 58 second mark. Chris B.

That quote makes her sound like she supports the Second Amendment but thinks SCOTUS misinterpreted it. She's a lawyer, right?
 
I disagree with one part of District of Columbia v. Heller: it struck down the portion of the Regulations Act that requires all firearms including rifles and shotguns be kept "unloaded and disassembled or bound by a trigger lock" and since I'm leaning strongly toward the conclusion that guns lying around the house ready to fire the moment you grab em do more harm than good I am strongly in favor of local governments being allowed to decide to require a gun safe/trigger lock for guns kept at home.

So I am a liberal who doesn't want to take anybody's guns and has no ill will towards the second amendment but who does not agree with 100% of DC v Heller and who could say that I think the SC made a poor ruling on that point.
 
You guys are not even being honest about Liberal base goals. I need to explain why I think Liberals are against the Second Amendment? That's easy, everything they do to undermine it is self explanatory as it demonstrates their opposition to it. You never bother to ask yourselves why the NRA does not support Liberals? Really?

Of course it must be another Right Wing conspiracy right? The assault weapons ban put in place by Bill Clinton didn't happen? You guys are deluding yourselves. Chris B.
 
You guys are not even being honest about Liberal base goals. I need to explain why I think Liberals are against the Second Amendment? That's easy, everything they do to undermine it is self explanatory as it demonstrates their opposition to it. You never bother to ask yourselves why the NRA does not support Liberals? Really?

Most people think about exactly that question. Why is the NRA partisan?

I'm pretty sure it's because the NRA is a gun industry lobbying group, and they don't like any regulation of guns at all, because it reduces sales.


Of course it must be another Right Wing conspiracy right? The assault weapons ban put in place by Bill Clinton didn't happen? You guys are deluding yourselves. Chris B.

The assault weapons ban did happen. This is the "well regulated" part of the 2nd Amendment.

In fact: anybody who objects to any regulation of guns a priori, is rejecting the 2nd Amendment, since it's integral. What's the NRA's stance on regulation? If they're entirely against it, they're at war with the 2nd Amendment.
 
Another distinction is that a Liberal will forgo some medical treatment of themselves to help a needy family get some that otherwise would have received none.

A conservative will refuse medical treatment of themselves if it prevents a needy family from getting any treatment because they just can't stand the idea of others not being miserable and in pain.
OK now you are posting unsupportable things about conservatives. It doesn't even make any sense.
 
Perhaps you should also listen to the Clinton recording I linked above. Chris B.

You do know the 2nd Amendment is not an all or none issue, right? Your link is exactly the kind of propaganda that distorts the facts, making the BS accusation that gun regulation is the same as the liberals coming for your guns.
 
So you voted for Hillary, but you didn't support her........um how does that work exactly? You either voted for her or not. So in effect, your statement accusing me of lying is indeed false. Chris B.

It's a little nuanced.

Since you're incapable of understanding nuance in your black and white world, you wouldn't get it.
 
Most people think about exactly that question. Why is the NRA partisan?

I'm pretty sure it's because the NRA is a gun industry lobbying group, and they don't like any regulation of guns at all, because it reduces sales.




The assault weapons ban did happen. This is the "well regulated" part of the 2nd Amendment.

In fact: anybody who objects to any regulation of guns a priori, is rejecting the 2nd Amendment, since it's integral. What's the NRA's stance on regulation? If they're entirely against it, they're at war with the 2nd Amendment.

The problem is in the regulation. If you cannot remove the 2nd Amendment, you can undermine it with regulation to the point it doesn't exist. And hence the plan.

This has been the worry on the Right. The Left uses terms like "military style" to describe a whole host of weapons that they want eliminated. In fact any firearm can be eliminated by using that descriptive term. It's all in how you view a certain firearm. I have a few 22 rifles that are "military style" they have pistol grips, magazines, etc, so they're likely candidates for elimination as well.

Besides, the questions the Left tends to ask about guns and eliminating certain types are similar to: "Why on Earth does anyone need with an AK-47?" From their point of view it's ridiculous to own one. However, that's a personal choice and right of every American. If "they" don't want one, by all means "they" can refrain from buying one. One may as well say "Why on Earth does anyone need a trout fishing rod and reel?" It really has nothing to do with need, it has to do with want. One person may want something completely different than another, great, that's America. It should never be that a few take a stand against owning trout fishing rods and reels, so it becomes illegal for anyone to own one. no no no.
Chris B.
 
I need to explain why I think Liberals are against the Second Amendment?
Yes, please. You haven't yet.

I would campaign with equal vehemence for legislation that made it more difficult to acquire firearms and against legislation that made it illegal to acquire firearms.

What part of this is too subtle for you?
 
OK now you are posting unsupportable things about conservatives. It doesn't even make any sense.

Well, we know there's a punitive sacrifice phenomenon out there, which has always surprised me (eg: people are willing to earn 10% less, as long as their peers earn 20% less, for example). So that part makes sense.

But I haven't seen evidence that it aligns with political spectrum, so aligning it with a political aspect doesn't make sense to me either.

Here's a ref to the research I'm thinking of: [Is more always better?: A survey on positional concerns]
 
"Why on Earth does anyone need with an AK-47?"

Replace AK-47 with grenade launcher, bazooka, Howitzer - wherever it happens to be that you draw the line - then ask yourself why you drew that line.

"Why on Earth does anyone need a trout fishing rod and reel?" It really has nothing to do with need, it has to do with want.
What if millions of people want not to be killed by a fool with an AK? If I'm in a big crowd and some nut wants to go out in a blaze of glory, I'd much rather he was armed with a rod and reel than with an AK.
 
The problem is in the regulation. If you cannot remove the 2nd Amendment, you can undermine it with regulation to the point it doesn't exist. And hence the plan.

This has been the worry on the Right. The Left uses terms like "military style" to describe a whole host of weapons that they want eliminated. In fact any firearm can be eliminated by using that descriptive term. It's all in how you view a certain firearm. I have a few 22 rifles that are "military style" they have pistol grips, magazines, etc, so they're likely candidates for elimination as well.

Besides, the questions the Left tends to ask about guns and eliminating certain types are similar to: "Why on Earth does anyone need with an AK-47?" From their point of view it's ridiculous to own one. However, that's a personal choice and right of every American. If "they" don't want one, by all means "they" can refrain from buying one. One may as well say "Why on Earth does anyone need a trout fishing rod and reel?" It really has nothing to do with need, it has to do with want. One person may want something completely different than another, great, that's America. It should never be that a few take a stand against owning trout fishing rods and reels, so it becomes illegal for anyone to own one. no no no.
Chris B.

This is a logical fallacy called slippery slope - the claim that we should bar something reasonable because it might lead to something unreasonable. The reality here on planet earth is that sometimes you need to decide about things that don't have a clear cutoff point. We all have a right to freedom, but what's a safe driving speed? What's an appropriate driving age? These regulations are not a war against driving. They're a balance to make the world a safer place.

Likewise, the regulation being discussed in the recording you quoted was about leaving guns unlocked an loaded laying around the house. Seems like something a reasonable person would want prohibited, in the same category as driving at 110kph through school zones and four year old drivers. These regulations do not constitute a war on driving. Removing automatic weapons with high magazines from ciculation is not a war on the 2nd Amendment.

The other related one is the fallacy of the corrupt continuum, The Shrike asks the obvious question: where do you draw the line? Can your neighbour own a nuke?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom