I love these diarrhetic posts. Lots of rapid-fire little bits of nonsense before the *********.
Person A: The behavior of X is repugnant.
Person B: Y does it also and it is worse.
You can flail your hands about all that you want but no one ever says, X does it to THEREFORE it's ok. Heres a hint: any abuse caused by factory farming doesn't tell us whether or not the actions of the animal right wing nuts is moral or not.
The irony here is that you're committing a fallacy of irrelevance while trying to frame me up for it. And you seem to be flailing, so I guess you'll try to impute that onto me as well.
So let's take a concrete example from my main man Don Rumsfeld. When American soldiers were captured by Iraqis and put on television, Rumsfeld said, quite rightly, that it violated the Geneva Conventions. Very good, Don. They did violate the Geneva Conventions. You committed a dozen other war crimes -- which do NOT excuse their crimes -- but you did violate Geneva Conventions, and if you're willing to impose those rules on others, then you should abide by them yourself.
Techno's point about taking into consideration the full consequences is important whether or not he sincerely believes it. It's also important regardless of what eco-terrorists do. I am not attempting to invalidate the reasoning, as I agree with it.
I like when you get all into a tizzy and start squirting out "demonstrably"s without ever, you know, demonstrating anything.
"So?" So I might, AS YOU SAY, regard it as moral. However, to demonstrate your dihonesty, I have made the point over and over that what society regards as immoral is but one aspect of what we regard as moral.
There's a difference between what
is moral and what we
regard as moral.
You are arguing in a vacuum and ignoring EVERYTHING else that I've said. I've NEVER argued that morality is simply what an individual feels is moral.
Of course not, you have your four bullet points, one of which redundantly includes "all of the above." And myself and others point to situations where human feelings lead to wrong conclusions, so then what's our guide?
What's sort of laughable is that you're replicating the behavior documented above. You make inconsistent statements and then point to them with pride, too dim to understand your own basic errors. Hell, you even repeated the is-ought mantra, a post-Kaufmanesque bit of self-mockery.
That is a demonstrable lie. Kevin criticized me for suggesting that adaptive behavior or nature has anything to do with morality.
That is a fact.
You've now demonstrated that you agree with me and disagree with Kevin but you haven't the intellectual honesty to admit it.
You poor thing. I repeated Shermer's claim in the sense that it's trivially true; science can inform moral decision-making -- for example, staging a dangerous rescue mission in outer space. Is it physically possible? What are the odds of success? What can we reasonably expect to happen if things go wrong? Almost everyone can agree with that idea, but no one says OMFG, F=ma is directly relevant to our ethical outlook on life. When you start talking about adaptive behavior, then you're venturing off into lala land. Vampires are adapted to eat human beings, but that does not mean feasting on human blood is OK. We might be adapted (or indoctrinated) to find rape revolting, but rape is good or bad regardless of how it makes you or society feel.
On your naturalistic fallacy:
And I've told you a hunderd times that assertion is not argument.
Shermer, Dawkins, de Waal, Wright et al agree with me. Empathy is A.) an innate feeling and B.) a necassary component of morality.
You know what, I doubt they would agree if they knew we were speaking in a normative context. But please, feel free to e-mail Shermer or Wright. They're available on the Internet. (Wright's at bloggingheads.tv and engages with his viewers. Shermer, we know, answers his e-mail. I don't know about Dawkins or de Waal.)
And your quotes from P.Z. Myers and others are irrelevant.
No naturalistic fallacy. As Shermer said to you. The science informs our morality.
1. Suffering (by definition) is bad.
2. I suffer when others suffer (see mirror neurons).
QED.
You don't have the faintest idea what you're talking about. Let's imagine vampires come along and murder a dozen human beings. This orgy of violence does not make them feel bad at all; it's a lovely, exciting experience. Now you're in a position of species-relativism. What vampires did is not immoral to vampires, but it is immoral to us. So how do you arbitrate right from wrong?
What I said in my Shermer post, what has been said before, is that adaptations are not a reliable guide and must be rejected just like the Bible.
------------------------
Sword of Truth:
This is Osama Bin Ladens thinking in a nutshell.
It's ok to knock over buildings full of innocent people because they don't live they way you want them to, therefore they must all die in the name of Allah animal liberation.
This is incorrect in its comparisons and content.
------------------------
GreNME:
You're being so ridiculously bull-headed at this point that you can't even parse parts of a conversation that actually defended you, and are trying to lash out at anything you can.
I ignored most of the rest of your post, as it did not interest me. What did interest me was "consistency" -- in scare quotes regarding a mistaken tu quoque "as well as" a bit of nonsense about suicide bombers.