Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

My first two posts.

Please note that this post is a response about rape which I categoricaly state that I find repugnant.

(emphasis mine)


I do too. However, I'm curious, do I find it [rape] repugnant because:
  1. I reason it so?
  2. I share societal norms that view rape as repugnant?
  3. The suffering of others disturbes me and my evolved natural inclination to procreate and pass on my genes pales compared to my evolved natural inclination to feel empathy during times of plenty and social cohesion?
  4. All of the above?
IMHO, it's a bit simplistic to focus, in a vacuum, on a single variable (a single evolved natural desire). Our sense of right and wrong is a very complex dynamic of a number of variables including natural compulsions and drives. It's important to note that many of these are often in some degree of conflict.


For example:
  1. I want to live.
  2. I want my associates to live.
  3. I don't want to be hungry.
  4. I don't want my associates to be hungry.
During times of plenty and even during times of some famine all of these will guide my behavior. If resources are reduced sufficently and social cohesion breaks down #4 might become rather trite and #2 might become a liability.

In fact, if history is a guide, given desperate times, most of us would kill others to live.

We have the luxury to set aside many of our natural desires in our attempts to fashion a moral guide and we even reason fallacious any appeal to our nature in framing our morality. However we lie to ourselves if we honestly think that we truly can divorse our natural desires and inclinations from our sense of morality.

"Evolution is cleverer than you are." Orgel's Second Rule

But what does make rape wrong? Doesn't our natural ability to feel empathy figure into it?

If you took away the human ability to feel empathy and the evidence showed that rape was good for the human species then I can see how social norms could evolve for a society to see rape as moral.

You have a problem. By what measure are you declaring rape immoral in the first place? Morality is not a priori. So there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).

Cain, will you have the decency to admit the following?

  1. I make it clear that I find rape repugnant.
  2. I state that the suffering of those who are raped disturbs me.
  3. I have formulated an argument for why rape should be wrong.
  4. Your signature does not represent my position and is in effect a lie since it is quoted out of context.
Oh, and finally, can you identify what is so crazy about my ideas?
 
Last edited:
So no, we actually can't supply them.

This is just a myth! 'We're trying as hard as we possibly could, but we just cannot get it out to the poor people in need of it.'
People tend to starve in third-world countries for the same reason people tend to starve in the US: The food exists, a record crop globally, but the starving people don't have the money to buy it.
Very recent report from FAO:
The Director of FAO's Agricultural Development Economics Division, Kostas Stamoulis, said it is the first time in human history that there are so many hungry people in the world.
(…)
"We want to reduce this number, we can eliminate hunger in the world, we have the resources: the food is there. It's not lack of food. This year we have almost the record crop globally so it is not lack of food, it is lack of access to food by those that are hungry," he said.
http://www.voanews.com/english/2009-06-19-voa22.cfm


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4829338#post4829338
 
...the same reason people tend to starve in the US: The food exists, a record crop globally, but the starving people don't have the money to buy it.
I don't think many people starve in the US. According to the CDC the only diseases that result from starvation occur in children who are being neglected.
 
Thank you.

Of course the question of the hypo was people but that's perfectly fine because you get the point.

Great answers. Let me add or amend and tell me what you think.
  • They are making the best of the situation. No "bad". Bad requires an a priori assesment.
  • Morality to the degree that we enjoy is a luxury afforded us by our ability to produce a surplus of resources.
  • If we evolved to require the death of a sibling we might not view death the way we do now. We might not have evolved a moral sentiment that death is a bad thing.
Would you agree that if we were all socio-paths lacking any empthy or compassion our morality would likely be very different?

To 1. well, I still think it's a bad situation, in that it would be better if they didn't have to kill their sibling. I understand your point, that bad requires an a priori assessment. That's actually what's under discussion, right? Am I correct to say its bad?
2. Sort of. It certainly makes it easier to care about morality when the stakes aren't as steep. And I agree that our evolved sense of how we behave, if it evolved in that sort of environment, would be unlikely to coincide with the ideas of morality that I'm espousing. On the other hand, I still think those ideas would be correct.
3. Is agreed to, at least to some extent. I think it might be a little different: we'd likely still find our own deaths to be bad, and even the deaths of parents or other loved ones that happen at times that, in our evolutionary past, we might have been able to affect in some way. But certainly regarding the "sibling in the nest" we would not likely have qualms about killing it. Eventually some people might come along and look back and feel remorse and even question the morality of the act, but that would require that "abundance of resources" that you talked about.

To your final question, yes, definitely, I think our moral ideas would be very different if we were all sociopaths. I just think that shows that sociopaths, rather than us, are lacking in something.
 
Shermer, Dawkins et al raise an important point.

Do humans act morally because of moral philosophy? The answer is yes, to a degree. Formally, moral philosophy informs our legal system and ethics and helps mold the zeitgeist.

However, by and large, people don't reason their morality and we are as likely to act because of adaptive traits as we are because of laws and ethics.
I agree that this is an important point, and I also think it's correct.

On the other hand, I also think that we can go beyond that and, for instance, say, "while I recognise that my moral viewpoint is deeply influenced by my evolutionary history, I want to rise above that and try to find the errors in my intuitive morality and correct them."
 
I'm sorry for interpreting the following as having something to do with me:
Cain's technique for 'consistency' being a form of Tu Quoque as well as equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something.

Well, I forgive you, but mostly because your fault is in reading comprehension. For example, you obviously cut the full sentence, since my actual statement was "Indeed, on both counts-- Cain's technique for 'consistency' being a form of Tu Quoque as well as equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something." That was in response to RandFan addressing someone else (meaning not you).

Lika I said earlier, Cain, you're just looking for a fight at this point and are taking ridiculously dishonest measures to continue it. Which means, just like in the last thread, the point beyond any meaningful conversation with you has long since passed.
 
I agree that this is an important point, and I also think it's correct.

On the other hand, I also think that we can go beyond that and, for instance, say, "while I recognise that my moral viewpoint is deeply influenced by my evolutionary history, I want to rise above that and try to find the errors in my intuitive morality and correct them."
Absolutely. I agree. Which is why I have always maintained that what "is" shouldn't be confused with what "ought" to be.
 
To 1. well, I still think it's a bad situation, in that it would be better if they didn't have to kill their sibling. I understand your point, that bad requires an a priori assessment. That's actually what's under discussion, right? Am I correct to say its bad?
2. Sort of. It certainly makes it easier to care about morality when the stakes aren't as steep. And I agree that our evolved sense of how we behave, if it evolved in that sort of environment, would be unlikely to coincide with the ideas of morality that I'm espousing. On the other hand, I still think those ideas would be correct.
3. Is agreed to, at least to some extent. I think it might be a little different: we'd likely still find our own deaths to be bad, and even the deaths of parents or other loved ones that happen at times that, in our evolutionary past, we might have been able to affect in some way. But certainly regarding the "sibling in the nest" we would not likely have qualms about killing it. Eventually some people might come along and look back and feel remorse and even question the morality of the act, but that would require that "abundance of resources" that you talked about.

To your final question, yes, definitely, I think our moral ideas would be very different if we were all sociopaths. I just think that shows that sociopaths, rather than us, are lacking in something.
Hmmm....

Evolution has no goals. There is no evolutionary ideal. From an evolutionary perspective a species lacks something only if it is incapable of survival.

However, given that humans are a social species and given social norms I would have to agree that a sociopath is demonstrably lacking something very significant for his or her functioning in human society.
 
I would like to add to my list Frans de Waal.

A Dutch psychologist, primatologist and ethologist. He is the Charles Howard Candler professor of Primate Behavior in the Emory University psychology department in Atlanta, Georgia, and director of the Living Links Center at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center[1] and author of numerous books including Chimpanzee Politics and Our Inner Ape. His research centers on primate social behavior, including conflict resolution, cooperation, inequity aversion, and food-sharing. In 1993, he was elected to the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences, to the United States National Academy of Sciences in 2004, and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, in 2008.

...

"The possibility that empathy resides in parts of the brain so ancient that we share them with rats should give pause to anyone comparing politicians with those poor, underestimated creatures."[2]

"I've argued that many of what philosophers call moral sentiments can be seen in other species. In chimpanzees and other animals, you see examples of sympathy, empathy, reciprocity, a willingness to follow social rules. Dogs are a good example of a species that have and obey social rules; that's why we like them so much, even though they're large carnivores."[3]

"To endow animals with human emotions has long been a scientific taboo. But if we do not, we risk missing something fundamental, about both animals and us."[4]
 
Here's some for you. Don't commit Tu Quoque fallacy.

Doesn't fly. At best your "important considerations" can only serve to minimize by comparison which is exactly what you do.

The problem is you have not a clue what you're talking about.

Description of Ad Hominem Tu Quoque

This fallacy is committed when it is concluded that a person's claim is false because 1) it is inconsistent with something else a person has said or 2) what a person says is inconsistent with her actions. This type of "argument" has the following form:

1. Person A makes claim X.
2. Person B asserts that A's actions or past claims are inconsistent with the truth of claim X.
3. Therefore X is false.

As I said, even if he fails to apply the same scrutiny to other situations, it does not invalidate his concerns with regard to eco-terrorism. Speaking of fallacies of irrelevance, let's move to this is-ought business:

So please, Cain, if you've any sense of integrity, quote the specific "crazy views"?

I have traded well over one-hundred posts over your nonsense. From "ESS" to "social cohesion" to "memes" to your "feelings" to "what make rape wrong" to the notion that if society democratically votes to oppress a minority- then-it's-moral. You speak out of both sides of your mouth, and make stuff up as you go along. Most of this is documented in the 700 post long thread "Admit it, you believe in Animal Rights." (the voting to oppress-minorities-cultural-relativism nonsense came at the end of an earlier animal rights thread).

An above example on siblicide is similar to stuff you've posted in the past (paraphrasing): "If we evolved to kill our brothers, then killing our brothers would be moral." Maybe that would be regarded as moral but it does not tell us how we should act. And this is what Kevin attempts to get at over the 10+ pages.

Yep, that's what I've been saying all along. Nothing more nothing less. Kevin on the other hand has said over and over that what is natural (science) has nothing to do with morality. He was very specific in his claim.

The discussion between you and Kevin sounds familiar to ones from before between you and multiple people. Someone attempts to establish an is-ought, descriptive-prescriptive/normative distinction, you claim to agree in principle, and then immediately spout B.S. contrary to it. When people then point out that you're not observing the gap you quickly go back and quote yourself saying something characteristically duh-faced like "I recognize the is-ought gap."

Your signature is a lie without context and in your heart of hearts you know that.

As for my signature, again, I am limited to six lines and I can only give you one of them. Your (laughable) four point replies only support the idea you don't know "what make rape wrong." If it makes you feel any better, the main reason I quoted it -- and the main reason anyone quotes anything -- is for style rather than content. It has an "is our children learning" quality to it.

You wrote:
"I share societal norms that view rape as repugnant?"

So? What if society viewed rape as good thing, especially when it came to, say, killing all the men in a neighboring tribe and seizing their husbandless women? Let's say this also promotes social cohesion.

"The suffering of others disturbes me and my evolved natural inclination to procreate and pass on my genes pales compared to my evolved natural inclination to feel empathy during times of plenty and social cohesion?"

So let's suppose you're a sadist and rape scenes excite you. As I've no doubt said to you before, evolution may tell us why we like X or Y, but it does not tell us if X and Y are either moral or immoral, so spare me the point-inflation-all-of-the-above nonsense. Fact is we can bracket that stuff out and you are left with what exactly...?

there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).

And this is what's commonly termed the naturalistic fallacy. Your views are schizophrenic.
------------------
GreNME writes:
Well, I forgive you, but mostly because your fault is in reading comprehension. For example, you obviously cut the full sentence, since my actual statement was "Indeed, on both counts-- Cain's technique for 'consistency' being a form of Tu Quoque as well as equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something." That was in response to RandFan addressing someone else (meaning not you).

Hah, you are so full of it. A total weasel. I especially like the part about "forgiv[ing]" me (you have such an impressive track record for getting things right). Here you take two things that are technically true but irrelevant and twist them around. Yes, I did not quote the ENTIRE sentence. Yes, it was technically a "response" to RandFan even though you were commenting on me. Please, 1000 humble pre-emptive apologies for my poor reading comprehension but who is "equivocating with the likes of suicide bombers or something"? At best that's sloppy writing and the "as well as" connector...? You're such a joke.
 
The problem is you have not a clue what you're talking about.

Person A: The behavior of X is repugnant.
Person B: Y does it also and it is worse.

You can flail your hands about all that you want but no one ever says, X does it to THEREFORE it's ok. Heres a hint: any abuse caused by factory farming doesn't tell us whether or not the actions of the animal right wing nuts is moral or not.

"If we evolved to kill our brothers, then killing our brothers would be moral." Maybe that would be regarded as moral but it does not tell us how we should act.
Which IS all that I have said.

And this is what Kevin attempts to get at over the 10+ pages.
Demonstrable dishonest BS.

Your (laughable) four point replies only support the idea you don't know "what make rape wrong."
Dishonest and demonstrably so. I explain exactly why rape is wrong.

Your sig is a lie and you know it.

So? What if society viewed rape as good thing, especially when it came to, say, killing all the men in a neighboring tribe and seizing their husbandless women? Let's say this also promotes social cohesion.
"So?" So I might, AS YOU SAY, regard it as moral. However, to demonstrate your dihonesty, I have made the point over and over that what society regards as immoral is but one aspect of what we regard as moral.


So let's suppose you're a sadist and rape scenes excite you. As I've no doubt said to you before, evolution may tell us why we like X or Y, but it does not tell us if X and Y are either moral or immoral, so spare me the point-inflation-all-of-the-above nonsense. Fact is we can bracket that stuff out and you are left with what exactly...?
Again with your dishonesty.
  1. I've noted time and again that "is" does not make for "ought".
  2. You are arguing in a vacuum and ignoring EVERYTHING else that I've said. I've NEVER argued that morality is simply what an individual feels is moral.
So spare me your lies.
 
Last edited:
And this is what Kevin attempts to get at over the 10+ pages.
That is a demonstrable lie. Kevin criticized me for suggesting that adaptive behavior or nature has anything to do with morality.

That is a fact.

You've now demonstrated that you agree with me and disagree with Kevin but you haven't the intellectual honesty to admit it.
 
there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).
And this is what's commonly termed the naturalistic fallacy. Your views are schizophrenic.
And I've told you a hunderd times that assertion is not argument.

Shermer, Dawkins, de Waal, Wright et al agree with me. Empathy is A.) an innate feeling and B.) a necassary component of morality.


No naturalistic fallacy. As Shermer said to you. The science informs our morality.
  1. Suffering (by definition) is bad.
  2. I suffer when others suffer (see mirror neurons).
QED.

ETA: No, not the only basis or means to determine that rape is bad. Your strawman is getting awfully damn lame.
 
Last edited:
Hah, you are so full of it. A total weasel. I especially like the part about "forgiv[ing]" me (you have such an impressive track record for getting things right). Here you take two things that are technically true but irrelevant and twist them around. Yes, I did not quote the ENTIRE sentence. Yes, it was technically a "response" to RandFan even though you were commenting on me. Please, 1000 humble pre-emptive apologies for my poor reading comprehension but who is "equivocating with the likes of suicide bombers or something"? At best that's sloppy writing and the "as well as" connector...? You're such a joke.

You're really a joke at this point. Read the post just above the one you misquoted to begin with. RandFan was addressing dudalb's statements (to you) about allegedly making excuses for terrorists, chiding the obvious hyperbole. You're being so ridiculously bull-headed at this point that you can't even parse parts of a conversation that actually defended you, and are trying to lash out at anything you can.

You're perfectly free to shoot yourself in the foot as you see fit, but don't get mad at me for telling you that you're pointing your attacks at your own feet.

Seriously, man, if you're so worked up that you're warping anything you can into some attack against you, perhaps you should take five breaths and a walk around the house before pressing "Submit Reply" next time. I'm willing to accept that it was an honest mistake on your part, but if you insist on trying to claim I was claiming you said something you didn't you're just going to continue to make yourself seem the fool.
 
Some quotes on empathy.

P.Z. Myers.

Empathy. It is both an extremely useful skill for navigating the complex social landscapes of human culture (so useful that it is taken for granted), and it is easily displaced onto nonhuman entities or objects. Most significantly, we have evidence from the neurophysiology of mirror neurons that empathy is to some extent hardwired into the brain. At least, it’s a better-documented biological property than obedience (which, as I recall from raising my own children, was not particularly reliable).

Pinker

In addition, our brains have been evolving in a social context, so computations necessary for social living take place in various modules. For example, the brain has modules for "empathy, foresight, and self-respect."33 Our brains also have a "system for inhibition" which responds to such feedback as disapproval, moral suasion, punishment, and other types of social "influence."34 It is these mechanisms, plus "the universal pleasures and pains that make [the individual see] some kinds of change [as] desirable."35

"Mirror neurons had an inconspicuous start, says Daniel Dennett, director of the Center for Cognitive Studies at Tufts University and the author of "Darwin's Dangerous Idea," and other books about evolution. "All evolutionary innovation begins with a mistake," he says. Some genetic mutation may have led to a misfiring set of neurons that enhanced hand-eye coordination. This "programming bug," as Dennett calls it, must have conveyed an advantage amplified by natural selection. And once simple mirror-neuron networks were established, he says, "they may well have played a big role in the evolution of empathy, and imitation, and social understanding."
 
These are important considerations. Now import the same type of reasoning to the slaughterhouse and the factory farm, where you have documented mistreatment (not at all surprising given the billions of animals processed each year). An unnecessary exercise but, if you want, compare this to the number of people eco-terrorists have actually hurt or killed.

This is Osama Bin Ladens thinking in a nutshell.

It's ok to knock over buildings full of innocent people because they don't live they way you want them to, therefore they must all die in the name of Allah animal liberation.

FULL DISCLOSURE: I'm typing this with one finger as I am finishing off the rack of pork ribs from Montana's that I had doggie-bagged after taking my dad out for fathers day last night.
 
Last edited:
This is Osama Bin Ladens thinking in a nutshell.

It's ok to knock over buildings full of innocent people because they don't live they way you want them to, therefore they must all die in the name of Allah animal liberation.

FULL DISCLOSURE: I'm typing this with one finger as I am finishing off the rack of ribs that I had doggie-bagged after taking my dad out for fathers day last night.

Southern style ribs? :)
 
Southern style ribs? :)

Texas Bold.

Dad and I both had the full rack of ribs. My brother couldn't stand the thought of the pigs suffering alone, so he had 3 or 4 chickens tortured and murdered for the wing & rib combo while mom had a cow sent to the death chamber along with a dozen shrimp.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom