RandFan
Mormon Atheist
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2001
- Messages
- 60,135
My first two posts.
Please note that this post is a response about rape which I categoricaly state that I find repugnant.
Cain, will you have the decency to admit the following?
Please note that this post is a response about rape which I categoricaly state that I find repugnant.
(emphasis mine)
I do too. However, I'm curious, do I find it [rape] repugnant because:IMHO, it's a bit simplistic to focus, in a vacuum, on a single variable (a single evolved natural desire). Our sense of right and wrong is a very complex dynamic of a number of variables including natural compulsions and drives. It's important to note that many of these are often in some degree of conflict.
- I reason it so?
- I share societal norms that view rape as repugnant?
- The suffering of others disturbes me and my evolved natural inclination to procreate and pass on my genes pales compared to my evolved natural inclination to feel empathy during times of plenty and social cohesion?
- All of the above?
For example:During times of plenty and even during times of some famine all of these will guide my behavior. If resources are reduced sufficently and social cohesion breaks down #4 might become rather trite and #2 might become a liability.
- I want to live.
- I want my associates to live.
- I don't want to be hungry.
- I don't want my associates to be hungry.
In fact, if history is a guide, given desperate times, most of us would kill others to live.
We have the luxury to set aside many of our natural desires in our attempts to fashion a moral guide and we even reason fallacious any appeal to our nature in framing our morality. However we lie to ourselves if we honestly think that we truly can divorse our natural desires and inclinations from our sense of morality.
"Evolution is cleverer than you are." Orgel's Second Rule
But what does make rape wrong? Doesn't our natural ability to feel empathy figure into it?
If you took away the human ability to feel empathy and the evidence showed that rape was good for the human species then I can see how social norms could evolve for a society to see rape as moral.
You have a problem. By what measure are you declaring rape immoral in the first place? Morality is not a priori. So there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).
Cain, will you have the decency to admit the following?
- I make it clear that I find rape repugnant.
- I state that the suffering of those who are raped disturbs me.
- I have formulated an argument for why rape should be wrong.
- Your signature does not represent my position and is in effect a lie since it is quoted out of context.
Last edited: