Why I despise the Truthers

I already said that. I don't believe a dynamic mass falling over the sides enough to destroy other buildings could leave enough of a dynamic mass to fall down the center pulverizing floors in mid air all the way down at the speed that it did.


Why not?

Just to clarify, I'm not being glib. I'm seriously asking. And the reason is because as someone completely ignorant in the fields of advanced science and mathematics, it seems to me that a phenomenon such as this is not open to opinion. I would posit that there are hard numbers behind it that provide an irrefutable answer one way or the other.

You have taken a position, based on what I can tell, merely on unqualified opinion. If I am wrong, then please enlighten me with the calculations you have done to support your conclusion and I'm sure some of our more qualified forum members will proof them for the benefit of us uneducated folk.
 
Last edited:
When thousands of tons of steel is in motion it's going to just keep going til it hits something solid to stop it. Since the WTC's were "tubes within tubes" & basically "hollow" there was just some resistence to the structure. But that little bit of resistence helped make the collaspe go on for about 20 seconds.
 
I've read it. Parts of it more then once.

Well that's probably more than 90% of the truth movement has.

I also look to the outside experts and what they think of it and how they agree independently from each other in what’s right with it and what’s wrong.

Useful, if you make sure that those you are holding up as experts are actually experts.

While they all seem to have different ideas about NIST, FEMA, or even the 9-11 commission there are the flaws that they all seem to independently find. To me that’s the key. Independent research that forms a consensus. Not a bunch of people working together backwards towards the same predetermined conclusion.

It again depends on who you mean when you say experts. I can tell you right now that the leaders of the so called truth movement are far from independant of each other and far from being experts in the required fields.

What good is it? When there are people who feel the Gov was at least negligent in what happened on 9-11 and feel there is an interest in covering up that negligence then what good is a Gov report on it? Controlled and censored Gov reports.

Well it depends on if we're talking negligence/incompetence or if we're talking hiding explosives in the towers and blowing them up. If it's the former, then a report about how the towers came down isn't going to be affected, no matter how negligent or incompetent the Governemt was, it wouldn't affect how the towers came down. If you're going after the second, then first you need to show some evidence that it occured, you can't just write off a report because the Government might be trying to cover something unproven up.

It’s like if the Germans won WWII and they had Hitler and the Nazi’s investigate the Holocaust. I’m sure they could have presented what they would have claimed was proof and evidence that it never happened and it would have been good enough of an explanation for most Germans.

But what about most non-Germans? Take look at the debunkers on this board. 50% of us are non-Americans, so there is no sense of loyalty to the US Government there. We look at the reports, weigh up the evidence presented and have come to the conclusion that the Offical claim is currently the best theory out there, that it might not be 100% correct and on occasions it does have to make assumptions, but that those assumptions are logical considering the situation, and are smaller than the assumptions required by the competing theories. We also don't judge the events of 9/11 in a vaccum. We realise that 9/11 is linked to numerous other events and learn about them too. The CT mindset requires an ever increasing Conspriacy that infects the entire planet, manipulating all of science and politics, pulling the strings to make everything happen to some strangely irrational script. Otherwise it falls apart. The offical claims don't need that at all, it just needs a bunch of extremists that are willing to kill themselves to make a point, and that is something we can easily prove exists, unlike the neferious shadowy web that the CT world requires for their reality.

The NIST theory claims the force of the planes damaged or destroyed columns and sheered off fireproofing. Jet fuel though burning up in 10 to 20 minutes ignited building contents and weakened the steel that the fire proofing was sheered off of. The sheered off fire-proofing also allowed the fires to spread. Some have claimed the asbestos fireproofing that was in the lower floors of WTC1 would have done a better job. This all led to sagging which pulled inward thus according to NIST caused collapse initiation. This theory though different from the FEMA findings which blamed the fire more then the structural damage in my opinion is more in line with the original Bazant findings as stated in “Why did the World Trade Center towers collapse?”

That's probably the best I have seen from a CT, so you do get bonus points for that. Things I'd note is that 10 minutes is well and truely enough time to start the office contents on fire, 1 minute would have done it, likely less. Also the Office contents burned hotter then the jet fuel, they have more energy in them that can be released and it was that fire that weakened the steel, not the jet fuel fire. It is different to FEMA and Bazant's intial papers, however at the same time, Bazant published his paper within about a month of the collapse, and FEMA didn't do a structional analysis on the building, whivch is why there were calls for a better investigation, and NIST was charged with doing that report. The fact they disagreed with FEMA is to me evidence that they didn't just "toe the party line." If they had, they would have just rubber stamped FEMA's claim that the floors started to collapse and thus started a pancaking effect, instead they determined that this wasn't true, and come to the conclusion that it was the exterior columns that gave way, not the floor.

I don’t believe any of it because although the planes and the structural damage were severe I don’t feel the collapse itself or the way the collapse occurred is sufficiently explained by any of this.

What don't you think has been explained sufficently? And do you treat the alternatives to the same level of proof? If you problem is that you are unsure of the claim that much of fire proofing was removed in the impact, do you treat the claims that the concrete was totally pulverised in exactly the same manner? If you aren't sure about the claims that the fires weren't hot enough, do you feel the same way about claims that three entire office buildings could be wired with explosives without a single person noticing?

Do you agree that the floor trusses sagged? Have you seen the pictures showing that they did? Do you agree that the columns bowed inwards? Have you seen the pictures showing them bowing it, and the video that shows them giving way?

To me it’s always been a contradiction to say that the buildings fell mostly just outside their footprint pretty evenly over all four sides causing enough damage to say WTC7 to cause it to collapse also, but then also claim a kind of sustained conservation of momentum type collapse building kinetic energy, mass, and velocity down the center to come down at the speed it was witnessed to. The collapse of the WTC though many things was not a newly discovered source of energy. In other words it’s my opinion it should have stopped somewhere on the way down considering the loss of mass over the sides. That is if it should have started at all.

Well let's look at this shall we. Most of the material that was located about the outside, including the huge chunk that slammed into WTC 7 (there are photos of the debris hitting 7) were from the exterior of the buildings. Once the collapse had initiated, the floors, including the trusses and much of the concrete just pancaked one on top of the other and fell directly down onto the floor below. Is this not enough mass to carry on the collaspe? Most of the dust was comprised of the drywall and glass from the ceiling tiles and windows, so while concrete was certainly crushed and part of it, much of the concrete ended up in the middle of the pile packed so tightly together that one of the FRs noted that they could count at least 20 floors packed togther in just 8 feet of debris. All of that mass was falling down onto the building below, and worse than that, onto the floor trusses of the building below, trusses that were never designed or able to handle those forces. The falling floors from above were colliding into the next one with forces an order of magnitude greater then they could survive. How could they possible have slowed it down, or stopped it, we're talking tens or thousands of tons travelling at speed slamming into a truss that spans sixty feet between its ends, and is only being held up by a few bolts at one end, and a U shaped seat at the other. What possible mechanisim would possibly prevent those trusses from becoming added mass when the falling debris above hits it? We're talking sledge hammer hits pane of glass stuff here, it's not going to pause and think about it, it's going to smash though it and keep going and what didn't get crunched and spat out the sides is just added to the falling mass.

The problem I think is that you are concentrating too much on the exterior columns. As the floors decended, without the support and with the debries pushing out as it piled up, the exterior columns simply peels off, then broke apart as they extended beyond the steels limit to hold them togther. When you consider that parts started started 400 metres above the ground, with it being forced outwards at 1 metre laterally for every one down, you can easily have debris landing 300-400 m away. Over all however, the collapse after initiation was driven by the floors themselves, the trusses and concrete making up the mass that become the hammer that crushed the building below. Of course the very fast moving massively heavy exterior and also later core beams would do a huge amount of damage to other buildings simply because they are so heavy and fast moving that their energy is far too much for any building to handle.
 
Most of the concrete that moved outward was dust. It is possible to form that much dust and for there still to be big honking chunks and slabs of concrete falling on the lower floors. The steel pans and the trusses supporting them all fell into the footprint. It was only parts of the outer walls that crossed the street to hit WTC 7. The force of all that material pushing in three dimensions propelled the walls outward with a lot of force. Even the most casual examination of the aerial views shows that something hella powerful and heavy skimmed the roof of WTC 6 on its way to WTC 7.

To get an idea of how much outward pressure the falling mass produced, one need only examine the sections of the bottoms of the walls that were shoved, still in their proper orientation, into WTC 6. In order to produce this much lateral force, there had to be horrendous force coming down from the top.
 
I already said that. I don't believe a dynamic mass falling over the sides enough to destroy other buildings could leave enough of a dynamic mass to fall down the center pulverizing floors in mid air all the way down at the speed that it did.

Once the collapse was over, which shape did the wreckage pile have? Was it:

1) A mound?

2) A crater?

To save time, I'll answer for you. As anybody can ascertain from countless pictures, it took the shape of a mound. Even though much of each building collapsed down into multiple storeys of basement, the wreckage formed a mound.

Why is this important? - Because if most of the material had fallen out to the side, we would have seen a crater. We did not see a crater, and this means most of the material fell on the floors below the collapse zone.

Since you onserve that even the minority part of the mass which fell on the adjacent buildings was enough to destroy several of them, it follows that the majority of material which impacted on the lower floors was clearly also enough to destroy them.

OK?

Hans
 
Please address all these quotes:

Eyewitness accounts of WTC 7 fires
Eyewitness accounts of WTC 7 damage
Eyewitness accounts of withdrawal and hold back from WTC 7 due to danger

Take your time. I look forward to your assessment of WTC 7's condition after reading these accounts.

Since we're keeping track, this is the first time I am making this request.

Good. And it will be the last.

I'm going to address these testimonies, and then I will ask you why you will not address, for the 7th time now, mine. And we can put this to bed.

To start of with the 1st link, I will list all the quotes in bold:

"The building was fully involved in fire."
All forty-seven stories were on fire. It was wild.
with fire on nearly all floors
fully involved in flames
fire was going virtually on every floor
All morning I was watching 7 World Trade burn
When the building came down it was completely involved in fire, all forty-seven stories
Seven was free burning
building 7 was really roaring.
Seven World Trade was going heavy
Everybody was expecting that to come down
. At this point there were a couple of floors burning on Seven World Trade Center. Chief McNally wanted to try and put that fire out
It really was in complete disarray. We never really got an operation going at Seven World Trade Center
Building #7 was still actively burning and at that time we were advised by a NYFD Chief that building #7 was burning out of control and imminent collapse was probable
7 WTC was ablaze and damaged
The flames were coming out of every window of that building
When that started coming down you heard that pancaking sound again
Because it really got going, that building Seven, saw it late in the day and like the first Seven floors were on fire. It looked like heavy fire on seven floors. It was fully engulfed, that whole building.
you could see the flames going straight through from one side of the building to the other, that’s an entire block
firemen said building number 7 was going to collapse,
And there's so little they can do to try to fight the fires in these buildings, because the fires are so massive. And so much of the buildings continues to fall into the street. When you're down there, Dan, you hear smaller secondary explosions going off every 15 or 20 minutes, and so it's an extremely dangerous place to be."
Well, they said that's (7) fully involved at this time. This was a fully involved building
heard on the handy talky that we are now fighting a 40-story building fully involved.
7 World Trade was burning up at the time
the fire at 7 World Trade was working its way from the front of the building northbound to the back of the building.
Building #7 was still standing but burning. ...We spoke to with a FDNY Chief who has his men holed up in the US Post Office building. He informed us that the fires in building 7 were uncontrollable and that its collapse was imminent. There were no fires inside the loading dock (of 7) at this time but we could hear explosions deep inside
and it's engulfed in flames and starting to collapse
We couldn't even go that way, that's how bad the fire was, but by the time I was coming back it was rolling, more than a couple of floors, just fully involved, rolling.
things were just crackling, falling and whatnot.
he said that building was rolling on top of the building that we were passing. That building was on fire and likely to collapse more too.
"7 has got fire on several floors."
They had three floors of fire on three separate floors, probably 10, 11 and 15 it looked like, just burning merrily
No. 7, aflame, was about fifteen to twenty feet ahead of him
They are worried that number 7 is burning
they were waiting for 7 World Trade Center to come down as it was on fire. It was too dangerous to go in and fight the fire
beginning to attempt to fight the fire at 7 WTC
Building 7 was on fire. That was ready to come down
and there was fire on every floor
At that point, Seven World Trade had 12 stories of fire in it.
The 7 World Trade Center was roaring
Almost every window has fire. It is an amazing site
7, was fully involved
7 World Trade was burning from the ground to the ceiling fully involved. It was unbelievable
7 World Trade, which is above the ramp, was now fully engulfed.
No. 7 World Trade Center and No. 5 World Trade Center were immediately adjacent to us and they were roaring, they were on fire.
No. 7 World Trade Center were roaring. They were on fire

Excellent. So what we have is firefighters stating that from their POV, 7 was fully aflame. I do not dispute that they saw this.

We have some claiming that they thought it was going to collapse. I do not dispute that they thought this.

Let's move on to the next link, dealing with damage:

The major concern at that time was number Seven, building number Seven, which had taken a big hit from the north tower. When it fell, it ripped steel out from between the third and sixth floors across the facade on Vesey Street. We were concerned that the fires on several floors and the missing steel would result in the building collapsing
We were unaware of the damage in the front of 7, because we were entering from the northeast entrance. We weren't aware of the magnitude of the damage in the front of the building
I remember standing there looking over at building 7 and realizing that a big chunk of the lower floors had been taken out on the Vesey Street side.
A few minutes after that a police officer came up to me and told me that the façade in front of Seven World Trade Center was gone and they thought there was an imminent collapse of Seven World Trade Center
I think they said they had seven to ten floors that were freestanding and they weren't going to send anyone
but then you looked on the south side of 7 there had to be a hole 20 stories tall in the building, with fire on several floors. Debris was falling down on the building and it didn’t look good
this other officer I’m standing next to said, that building doesn’t look straight. So I’m standing there. I’m looking at the building. It didn’t look right,
nobody’s going into 7, there’s creaking, there are noises coming out of there, so we just stopped. And probably about 10 minutes after that, Visconti, he was on West Street, and I guess he had another report of further damage either in some basements and things like that, so Visconti said nobody goes into 7, so that was the final thing and that was abandoned.
There was a huge gaping hole and it was scattered through there. It was a huge hole. I would say it was probably a third of it, right in the middle of it
"I looked around, the lobby was gone. It looked like hell,"
I was looking at WTC7 and I noticed that it wasn’t looking like it was straight. It was really weird. The closest corner to me (the SE corner) was kind of out of whack with the SW corner
7 World Trade Center was badly damaged on the south side and definitely in danger of collapse.
The next thing that I remember was that I was covered in some glass and some debris. Everything came crashing through the front of number 7. It was totally pitch black.
You could see the damage at 7 World Trade Center
the whole corner of the building was missing.at 7 World Trade Center, they got trapped in there and had to like climb in and out and get out because that building also became very damaged supposedly and they were there
apparently there was a lot of debris and part of 7 down already
the door obviously had shifted or something
The whole south side of Seven World Trade had been hit by the collapse of the second Tower.
At that point, they said that Seven World Trade had no face and it was ready to collapse
t's definitely going. There's no way to stop it. 'Cause you have to go up in there to put it out, and it's already, the structural integrity is not there.
Seven World Trade Center was teetering on collapse

Okay. So here we have accounts of firefighters stating that from what they saw, the building had been severely damaged in part, and some of them thought it could collapse.

I dont disagree that they thought the building had been severly damaged; I dont disagree that they thought it could collapse.

Onto the final line of kook defense, the accounts of withdrawal. The smarter of you will know whats coming here:

They backed me off the rig because Seven was in dead jeopardy, so they backed everybody off and moved us to the rear end of Vesey Street. We just stood there for a half hour, 40 minutes, because Seven was in imminent collapse and finally did come down
We were very concerned with the collapse potential there, and to do whatever I could do to ensure site safety in that no additional people became injured
We were concerned that the fires on several floors and the missing steel would result in the building collapsing
Some Deputy arrived at the scene and thought that the building was too dangerous to continue with operations, so we evacuated number 7 World Trade Center
wanted everybody away from 7 because 7 was definitely going to collapse, they don't know when, but it's definitely going to come down,
Early on, there was concern that 7 World Trade Center might have been both impacted by the collapsing tower and had several fires in it and there was a concern that it might collapse.
Q. A collapse zone?

A. Yeah -- be set up and maintained so that when the expected collapse of 7 happened, we wouldn't have people working in it. There was considerable discussion with Con Ed regarding the substation in that building and the feeders and the oil coolants and so on. And their concern was of the type of fire we might have when it collapsed
We heard reports all day long of 7 World Trade possibly coming down. ...We heard that all day long, all the warnings."
It could have been an hour, hour and a half we were doing that before we were ordered to move away from that part of Tower No. 1 because there was an imminent danger of collapse of World Trade Center No. 5 and 7.
It was 4:45 p.m., and all the firemen and rescue workers were evacuating Ground Zero after word came that a third building -- WTC 7 -- was ready to fall.”
Keep your eye on that building, it'll be coming down soon."
Building 7 was going to collapse. That appears to be what has happened now
A: Yes, so basically they measured out how far the building was going to come, so we knew exactly where we could stand.

Q: So they just put you in a safe area, safe enough for when that building came down?

A: 5 blocks. 5 blocks away. We still could see. Exactly right on point, the cloud just stopped right there. Then when that building was coming down, that same rumbling.
We were inside the perimeter, more or less -- that's where the car was -- of where Seven World Trade Center was. We started back going east, I guess it is. ...We were inside this perimeter although we didn't realize it at the time
we were ordered—well, we were ordered several times, but the Captain of, I think it was a rescue company or a squad refused to leave. Finally he gave up, he said there was nothing he could do and we all left that area. This is in the collapse zone of tower 7.
We waited until tower 7 collapsed and at this point, we went into the area and assessed the damage that was done to the buildings and to see if we could control the fires that resulted from the collapse of tower 7
...I guess it was a Chief was saying clear the area, because they were worried about number Seven World Trade Center coming down and burying guys who were digging. So basically we went back to the rig because they were clearing that area out. It took about three hours for Seven World Trade Center to actually come down
remember later in the day it was getting close that they were more concerned about Seven coming down. I remember later on in the day as we were waiting for Seven to come down, they kept backing us up Vesey, almost like a full block. They were concerned about Seven coming down, and they kept changing us, establishing a collapse zone and backing us up.
Eventually they had ordered everybody away from the area again because of building 7.
they were telling us 7 is going to go, 7 is going to go, so we kind of backed away.
but we were told 5 minutes [to cease rescue operations on the pile], I don't know how many times.
I would say approximately maybe 2:00 roughly, where we started to operate and then they asked us to fall back again due to the potential of 7 World Trade Center collapsing.
They were worried about 7 at the time. The decision was made not to do it, not to get anybody else hurt. That's when we backed up and they said let's wait for this other building before we continue any work
they had no idea which way it was going to collapse and they just knew it was going to collapse and they positioned us outside of it.
They made us evacuate due to the fear of 7 coming down.
The concern there again, it was later in the afternoon, 2, 2:30, like I said. The fear then was Seven. Seven was free burning. Search had been made of 7 already from what they said so they had us back up to that point where we were waiting for 7 to come down to operate from the north back down
they were worried about Building 7 because when the second tower came down, they were worried about parts of – actually, when the first tower came down, they were worried about parts of Building 7 collapsing, so I remember getting into Building 7 and searching.
I remember coming out of the building now because they were afraid of Building 7 coming down, and all the other buildings around it getting knocked down. So they took us out of the building. –
Then we found out, I guess around 3:00 o'clock, that they thought 7 was going to collapse. So, of course, we've got guys all in this pile over here and the main concern was get everybody out, and I guess it took us over an hour and a half, two hours to get everybody out of there. So it took us a while and we ended up backing everybody out, and that's when 7 collapsed. Basically, we fell back for 7 to collapse, and then we waited a while and it got a lot more organized, I would guess. –
But anyway, more to the point, a rumor started to develop that tower 7 was going to fall on us or nearby us
His name is Chief Haring. Great guy. But he said, you know, it's not going to be a problem. Tower 7 may collapse. It's not going to be anywhere near here
He basically was incredulous and said: "What are you crazy? You've moved into the collapse zone, and if this collapse occurs, the dust cloud is going to knock out that entire park.
Then we were just hanging out watching building 7 ready to go
7 World Trade Center? I couldn’t even watch that. I said that’s enough. I refused to watch that. I took R-and-R. I said you guys can watch that one. But they got streams and they contained the fire. I mean, the objective was nobody else got killed, the fire did not jump the street.
We heard a mayday for everybody to get out of the building (Verizon Bldg., next to WTC 7) -- no, I'm sorry, an "urgent," three "urgents," and we came out of the building. I'd say that was like an hour and a half, two hours later. We were then positioned on Vesey Street between North End and the West Side Highway because there was an imminent collapse [warning] on 7 World Trade, and it did collapse.
The only thing that had me really frustrated was they wasn't really trying to let us go back down there. (After the collapse of the second building). I understand after it was unsafe.
“Someone from the city's Office of Emergency Management” told him that building 7 was “basically a lost cause and we should not lose anyone else trying to save it," after which the firefighters in the building were told to get out
While we were searching the subbasements (of building 6) they decided that Seven World Trade Center which was across the street was going to collapse, so they called us out. We were so far down we couldn’t hear them, but we came out after we searched the subbasements. Actually we came out on the Seven World Trade Center parkway street when came out they were calling us on the radio to tell us to get out. I then reported that the search was negative and then they wouldn’t let anybody near the site pretty much because Seven World Trade Center was going to come down
...And that was one of the directions from the command post, to make sure we clear the collapse zone from 7 and this is a 600-foot-tall building, so we had to clear a 600-foot radius from that building
All later attempts to return to the WTC were stopped by the pending, and eventual collapse of Building 7 and the uncontrolled fires
Several attempts were made to assist the trapped, but we were kept out due to the uncontrolled fires and other building collapsing around us. Returned to the site on 2-3 occasions...in an effort to help with evacuation but was stopped due to the imminent collapse of 7 WTC.
So we were doing searches, stretching lines, we were doing everything that we could possibly do. We were kind of overwhelmed at the task at hand. Like I said we operated for about three and half hours and then we went to take breather, and as we moved out of the area we weren’t permitted back in the area by that time by a number of Chiefs that were in charge. –
But they weren’t really getting [sic] guys get too deep into it because of the possible pending collapse of Seven World Trade. ...We were staged there a good part of the afternoon until Seven finally did collapse.
At 5:20, No. 7 finally falls. They've been waiting for it to go so they can move the firemen and search-and-rescue teams in
a stampede over pickaxes and oxygen tanks. They head out toward the crushed fire trucks. "They're looking for their brothers," says an ambulance driver.
He answered, 7 World Trade Center, imminent collapse, we've got to get those people out of there
Because they were just adamant about 7 coming down immediately. I think we probably got out of that rubble and 18 minutes later is when 7 came down.
'We had cleared an enormous collapse zone for that, and it still wasn't big enough. When the thing came down, the rubble and the dust came across the West Side Highway, over and past the rubble from the towers that was there.'"
was the one calamity that was not a surprise. Police had evacuated the area hours ago, fearful building number 7 would indeed fall down
'That building is coming down,' he said with a drained casualness. 'Really?' I asked. At 47 stories, it would be a skyscraper in most cities, centerpiece of the horizon. But in New York, it was nothing but a nondescript box with fire coming out of the windows. 'When?' 'Tonight ... Maybe tomorrow morning.' This was around 5:15 p.m. I know because five minutes later, at 5:20, the building, 7 World Trade Center, crumbled."
And I remember Chief Nigro coming back at that point saying I don't want anybody else killed and to take everybody two blocks up virtually to North End and Vesey
We were all pretty much on board that tower 7 was going to fall. We just didn't know when and in what direction

Took a little longer than I thought. But good. So we have a list of testimonies illustrating that some firefighters were pulled back to a security perimeter, because it was suspected that 7 might collapse. Good. I do not doubt for one second these testimonies.

In short, I have no doubt that from the pov of the FFs who have stated so, that 7 was fully aflame. I have no doubt that some FFs thought it might collapse. I accept those testimonies. But now what you have to do, is tell me why you dont accept the testimonies of the 1st responders who state that 7 was going to be blown up. Because the fact that some FFs thought the building was heavily aflame doesnt mean that it wasnt blown up. The fact that some FFs thought the building was going to collapse due to fire, doesnt mean it wasnt blown up. But the fact that you have several 1st responders on video testifying to the fact that they were told that 7 was going to be blown up/brought down/taken down, is illustrative of the fact, almost certainly that it was, or that at the very least, contingencies were in place to facilitate its implosion, else such order would neve have been issued..

It is this aspect of mutual exclusivity that the kook brigade, in thei myopic zeal, fail to notice. Your testimonies exist perfectly happily with mine. I can accept them. Mine however, cannot exist inside your world, hence why we have had 15 pages of posts without one serious attempt at addressing them.

So I will ask again, for the 7th time. Anyone who gives a good answer can have the other chaps bell.

Boy do i love this forum!
 
Last edited:
Good. And it will be the last.

I'm going to address these testimonies, and then I will ask you why you will not address, for the 7th time now, mine. And we can put this to bed.

To start of with the 1st link, I will list all the quotes in bold:



Excellent. So what we have is firefighters stating that from their POV, 7 was fully aflame. I do not dispute that they saw this.

We have some claiming that they thought it was going to collapse. I do not dispute that they thought this.

Let's move on to the next link, dealing with damage:



Okay. So here we have accounts of firefighters stating that from what they saw, the building had been severely damaged in part, and some of them thought it could collapse.

I dont disagree that they thought the building had been severly damaged; I dont disagree that they thought it could collapse.

Onto the final line of kook defense, the accounts of withdrawal. The smarter of you will know whats coming here:



Took a little longer than I thought. But good. So we have a list of testimonies illustrating that some firefighters were pulled back to a security perimeter, because it was suspected that 7 might collapse. Good. I do not doubt for one second these testimonies.

In short, I have no doubt that from the pov of the FFs who have stated so, that 7 was fully aflame. I have no doubt that some FFs thought it might collapse. I accept those testimonies. But now what you have to do, is tell me why you dont accept the testimonies of the 1st responders who state that 7 was going to be blown up. Because the fact that some FFs thought the building was heavily aflame doesnt mean that it wasnt blown up. The fact that some FFs thought the building was going to collapse due to fire, doesnt mean it wasnt blown up. But the fact that you have several 1st responders on video testifying to the fact that they were told that 7 was going to be blown up/brought down/taken down, is illustrative of the fact, almost certainly that it was, or that at the very least, contingencies were in place to facilitate its implosion, else such order would neve have been issued..

It is this aspect of mutual exclusivity that the kook brigade, in thei myopic zeal, fail to notice. Your testimonies exist perfectly happily with mine. I can accept them. Mine however, cannot exist inside your world, hence why we have had 15 pages of posts without one serious attempt at addressing them.

So I will ask again, for the 7th time. Anyone who gives a good answer can have the other chaps bell.

Boy do i love this forum!
Between the typos and bizarre wording you use here, I can't for the life of me discern a coherent idea. So, maybe you need to go back and work on your communication skills, because this makes no sense whatsoever.
There's a few other skills you need to work on as well, but we'll start there.
 
*snip*

It is this aspect of mutual exclusivity that the kook brigade, in thei myopic zeal, fail to notice. Your testimonies exist perfectly happily with mine. I can accept them. Mine however, cannot exist inside your world, hence why we have had 15 pages of posts without one serious attempt at addressing them.

So I will ask again, for the 7th time. Anyone who gives a good answer can have the other chaps bell.

Boy do i love this forum!
Already answered. Perhaps you would love this forum even more if you actually read some of the posts in answer to your questions. But we're a patient bunch (well some of us, heheh), so I'll repeat:

The sounds that come from the breaking up of the structural elements of a huge building can easily be mistaken for explosions. Also, when a huge fire is raging (and you just acknowledged that one did), things do in fact explode. Lots of things that are commonly found in office buildings can explode in a fire, this is one of the hazards of being a fire-fighter.

So there is absolutely nothing odd about people reporting explosions. In fact, it would be more odd if ppeople had reported the whole thing to be silent.

Since, as you also acknowledge, WTC7 was in jeopardy, being deemed so unstable that fighting the fires inside it was abandoned, it would probably have been neccessary to bring it down, had it not collapsed on its own. So there might have been talks of bringing it down. Other reasons for such statements could of course be misunderstandings during the general confusion on a very chaotic day. I don't think the people ordering others to withdraw behind the safety-line took much care to explain exactly what was happening (if they knew), I think they were just busy chasing people away, so shouts of "its coming down", "it will be taken down", or "it's going to blow" cannot be taken as exact descriptions of any particular plans.

Hans
 
Between the typos and bizarre wording you use here, I can't for the life of me discern a coherent idea. So, maybe you need to go back and work on your communication skills, because this makes no sense whatsoever.
There's a few other skills you need to work on as well, but we'll start there.
Jim:
I agree with you, What he seems to want is us to ignore all the other evidence and concentrate on the few witnesses that he believes. In other words try to falsify their beliefs.
 
I don't believe a dynamic mass falling over the sides enough to destroy other buildings could leave enough of a dynamic mass to fall down the center pulverizing floors in mid air all the way down at the speed that it did.

So how long should it have taken for 50,000 and 120,000 ton masses to smash their way through the towers? 30 seconds? A minute?

I don't think you're comprehending just how much weight we're talking about here. The Titanic was 46,000 tons. The USS Ronald Reagan aircraft carrier is 105,000 tons.

When that kind of mass finds itself in a dyanamic state against a building that is 95% air it isn't going to be significantly slowed down.
 
I remember some USAR guys talking about the pancake collapse of a concrete parking garage, and how struck they were (not literally! fortunately) by the rapidity of the event. "It was just BoomBoomBoom", as one of them said. Not that I am directly comparing it to WTC; I'm just illustrating how our Hollywood-condition expectation of such events is out of line with reality.

I was wondering about the following by ZENSMACK89:

I didn't have any access to any physical evidence so I couldn't perform much of my own investigation.

What would you do with the physical evidence?
What qualifications do you have to perform such an investigation?

Seriously. You know, as an engineer I deal with some materials science issues and as a (volunteer) firefighter I have training in building construction and fire behavior. But I freely admit that I am not qualified to perform a useful investigation myself.
 
“He did. He was on the 78th floor, BELOW the impact point.”
So it never occurred to him that there might… what? WHAT?

Was that supposed to be an argument ?

No one who saw this coming could get in touch with how many... 300 Fire fighters in time?

Indeed.

But they knew it was coming and knew exactly what happened a moment after the collapse.

Not exactly. It took four years. Didn't you read the posts, yet ?

Some of it? What happened to NIST in their fire test with only some of it removed? Better yet what still didn’t happen after 2 hours with all of it removed?

What the hell are you talking about ? Learn to use the quote function.

“Didn't they order the evacuation of the building?”
Evidently not soon enough.

Yes, that is very unfortunate. Tragic. But it doesn't mean squat.

I not make anything up. Look up Jerome Hauer.

You ARE making things up. You think his snap interpretation of the even is the same as NIST's conclusion four years later.

The plane hits the building and fragments into millions of shotgun sized pellets shearing off the fire proofing.

THAT IS A STRAWMAN, Zen. Give it up. Nobody's saying it became shotgun-pellet sized fragments except you.

Then what…? It carries on and takes out the support columns? Did NIST have a test and shoot one of the columns with a shotgun also? How scientific.

How would YOU have done it ? Crash an airliner into a similar building and see what happens ?

“The temperature has nothing to do with the fireproofing.”
If you want it to compromise the Steel it has everything to do with it.

I'll spell it out for you: removing the fireproofing will not make the temperature higher. What it will do is raise the temperature OF THE STEEL.

Why don’t you tell me? You’re the one claiming the plane took out the building.

No, the entire world is claiming that because we SAW the plane crash into it, the jet fuel DID start fires, the exterior columns DID buckle and the building THEN collapsed. There is NO need to add more speculation to this.

The Anthrax article was a reply to someone who asked. Try to follow along.

Let's stick to 9/11, shall we ?

Yes but structural Engineers can tell you what happen inside a building from video of outside the building.

They can guess, but without actual analysis their opinions are tentative.

You keep saying they knew but 300 fire fighters obviously didn’t know or have a clue and no one filled them in.

That's because their job is to go inside the buildings, stop the fires and save people's lives.

“No, we don't believe your silly caricature of the events.”
Then you don’t believe the official caricature.

That's not what the "official" story says. Try again.

“And AGAIN you show that you don't understand ANYTHING. They KNEW pretty much WHY it had collapsed, but it took TIME to determine the exact forces and mechanics at work.” “Geez.”

You said it. Geez

Now you're just playing silly juvenile games. Either debate honestly or not at all.

“Funny you should say that, since what I've seen of Gravy shows he keeps his cool, unlike the fanatic CTers.”
Excuse me for being disrespectful to your hero. I’ll try to behave myself.

You can't read minds. You should stop trying. No one's my hero, here.

My point stands. From what I've seen he keeps his cool in those situations. Prove me wrong.

“Not really. It IS, however, considered to be something that leaves evidence.”
Aren’t there thousands of people whose remains were never found? Didn’t one firefighter describe the biggest piece he found was a 4 inch piece of telephone keypad?

That's possible. What of it ?
 
I'd just like to take a time out here, and say that for stating NIST's theory of collapse initiation I've gained a ton of new respect for Zen. Not being sarcastic or derogatory here, I'm 100% honest. Now that we've established this foundation of what he believes and what he thinks is wrong with the report we can really get a good discussion going.
 
Much like the blind faith followers of the religious right, this present administration, lies about WMD's, and lies about 9-11.

Open wide and swallow.

Are you going, at ANY point, to present the evidence that you think is compelling about 9/11 being an inside job ? Or are you just going to continue insulting people for no reason ?

There is no proof that the plane, could and did knock the towers down on its own.

Of course there is.

But hey, let's look at this from another angle, shall we ? Why don't you tell me what you THINK should've happened following the plane impact, and why ?

Science is real. Just not present in any official explanation.

Very well. Please explain why the official reports are unscientific. And if you're going to say they "omitted" certain things, don't forget to list those.

Why would they want to get me banned? And so quickly? Are they already all out of their scary facts? Well now they really showed me huh? This is a real disappointment anyhow. They've shown me nothing so far. Trying to get me banned is just a copout.

See, Zen ? This is typical truther mentality, right there. Rev tells you something, and you simply believe him. You don't bother to check, hear other people out, or think about it for yourself. You just gulp it down.

Truther my eye.

I didn't have any access to any physical evidence so I couldn't perform much of my own investigation.

And yet you claim that the people who did botched their investigation ? How would you know, now ?

Truther my left, grazed eye.
 
"according to NIST"

Yers, contrary to truther belief, adults tend to trust people with expertise in various fields when they don't have that expertise themselves. Blindly doubting everything doesn't bring knowledge, but ignorance.

No I don't believe the official version.

Quite evidently. But WHY you don't believe it is also important. Just taking this position and defending it against all opposition is silly.

I know what he's doing. I know what you're all doing. How do you all assume to know or to have read more then anyone else? Bare assertions on everything from what I understand to how old I am. You’re all full of it. Bare assertions and hand waving is all any of you have because you support an official version which is nothing more then just that.

I guess now we know what YOU'RE doing.

None of you have shown anything so how do I know you read it or understand it? Understand what? Understand its bull?

And here you expose it quite succintly: you have DECIDED that the "official" story is false. You didn't check any facts, you didn't read and try to understand the report, and yet you critisize it. Why ? Because your "conclusion" is actually a premise upon which you base your entire case. That's called circular reasoning, by the way, and it is a logical fallacy of the worst order.

To me that’s the key. Independent research that forms a consensus. Not a bunch of people working together backwards towards the same predetermined conclusion.

:i:

I don’t believe any of it because although the planes and the structural damage were severe I don’t feel the collapse itself or the way the collapse occurred is sufficiently explained by any of this.

Zen, what you "feel" is irrelevant. All you've shown, here, is that you are using an argument from incredulity. Basically, it isn't true because you can't bring yourself to believe it.

The collapse of the WTC though many things was not a newly discovered source of energy. In other words it’s my opinion it should have stopped somewhere on the way down considering the loss of mass over the sides.

That's a reasonable assumption until you learn about the forces involved. Tell you what: why don't you do a little research about thoe forces and then see how the bottom, undamaged part of the WTC towers could never, ever stop that falling mass.
 
Zensmack do not allow yourself to be goaded. They want to get you banned and they will queue up to report every breach of the rules in your posts. Just ignore them and report their attacks on you.

No, we don't want anyone banned, here. Unlike people at LC, we don't kick people away just because we don't like their opinions.
 
Me said:
Once again, ZENSMACK89:

Do you maintain that a "plane alone" brought down each of the Twin Towers? Yes or no.

You are interested in the "truth," correct?
No I don't believe the official version.
Which is not a yes or no to my specific question above. So let's try it this way:

A) A "plane alone" brought down each of the Twins.
B) A series of interconnected events*, including the initial damage created by each airplane, brought down both towers.

Please choose A or B.



*The events not to include unsupported speculation such as space beam weapons, nukes, or controlled demolition.
 
But now what you have to do, is tell me why you dont accept the testimonies of the 1st responders who state that 7 was going to be blown up. Because the fact that some FFs thought the building was heavily aflame doesnt mean that it wasnt blown up. The fact that some FFs thought the building was going to collapse due to fire, doesnt mean it wasnt blown up. But the fact that you have several 1st responders on video testifying to the fact that they were told that 7 was going to be blown up/brought down/taken down, is illustrative of the fact, almost certainly that it was, or that at the very least, contingencies were in place to facilitate its implosion, else such order would neve have been issued..


I'll just quote myself here:


What you need to realize is that people don't speak with absolute precision.

When speaking aloud, people make mistakes all the time - they stutter, say "uhm" a lot, they backtrack, repeat words, use the wrong words, use the right words in the wrong order, and a host of other problems. Even intelligent, experienced speakers make these mistakes when speaking extemporaneously. It takes practice to deliver a speech smoothly.

So when transcribed into text, it looks like there are a lot of problems, because people expect text to have been edited; but live speaking isn't edited, it's just out there.

Ask any journalist, and most will tell you, the easiest way to make someone look like an idiot in print is to transcribe their spoken answers exactly as they spoke them.



So, yes, you have a few guys, out of hundreds, who used words like "blow up". But they were speaking casually, in a very stressful situation, while trying to get a bunch of journalists and what not to get the **** out of the way of the big burning building that was about to fall on them. Why is it so hard to believe they may have used a bit of hyperbole in order to get their point across? It's not like they were expecting people to be going over their words with a magnifying glass six years later!



It is this aspect of mutual exclusivity that the kook brigade, in thei myopic zeal, fail to notice. Your testimonies exist perfectly happily with mine. I can accept them. Mine however, cannot exist inside your world, hence why we have had 15 pages of posts without one serious attempt at addressing them.


But that's a point CTists refuse to acknowledge - your ideas cannot coexist "perfectly happily" with the (now acknowledged by you!) testimony that the building was fully involved with fire. The explosives and wiring needed to bring down the building in a CD could not have survived for hours in such an envirionment. They are mutually exclusive. You can't just wave your hands and make this go away.


So I will ask again, for the 7th time. Anyone who gives a good answer can have the other chaps bell.

Boy do i love this forum!


So, where's my bell?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom