Why I despise the Truthers

Please explain, in detail, your false statement. You clearly made a false statement and you want me to explain your false statement? Please present the facts on why you imputed Robertson the way you did?

I would expect Robertson to be on the side of truth. Why is it he understands why his building fell, and the 9/11 truth "expert" are just making up lies and false information?


You brought up Robertson. You asked me what he had to say about 9-11.

When?
 
http://www.studyof911.com/

Recent Studyof911 Articles

Seismic Proof - 9/11 Was An Inside Job (Updated Version II)
PDF Version DOC Version
Author(s): Craig T. Furlong & Gordon Ross (Members, Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice)
Statement by Craig T. Furlong and Article Discussion Thread


You don't have the slightest idea of how thoroughly this bogus article was DEMOLISHED, DESTROYED, DISCREDITED, DEBUNKED by R. Mackey, do you?
 
Please explain, in detail, your false statement. You clearly made a false statement and you want me to explain your false statement? Please present the facts on why you imputed Robertson the way you did?

I would expect Robertson to be on the side of truth. Why is it he understands why his building fell, and the 9/11 truth "expert" are just making up lies and false information?


http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/entity.jsp?entity=leslie_robertson

However, O’Sullivan consults “one of the trade center’s original structural engineers, Les Robertson, on whether the towers would collapse because of a bomb or a collision with a slow-moving airplane.” He is told there is “little likelihood of a collapse no matter how the building was attacked.”

In 2002, though, Robertson will write, “To the best of our knowledge, little was known about the effects of a fire from such an aircraft, and no designs were prepared for that circumstance.”
 
a whole pile of BS, thanks

http://www.studyof911.com/

Recent Studyof911 Articles

Seismic Proof - 9/11 Was An Inside Job (Updated Version II)
PDF Version DOC Version
Author(s): Craig T. Furlong & Gordon Ross (Members, Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice)
Statement by Craig T. Furlong and Article Discussion Thread



Calculation of World Trade Center Building 7 Collapse Acceleration
Author(s): "Winston Smith" of Studyof911.com
Article discussion thread



Debunking the WTC1 Main Freight Fireball Myth
PDF Version
Author(s): "bsbray" of Studyof911.com
Article discussion thread



Photographic Analysis of Damage to WTC7 and Critical Errors in NIST's Estimations
Author(s): "Winston Smith" of Studyof911.com
Article discussion thread



Addressing Faulty Assumptions of Greening and Others in WTC Momentum Transfer Calculations
PDF Version
Author(s): "bsbray" of Studyof911.com
Another Journal of WOO? And more woo stuff from woo land.

http://www.studyof911.com/articles/BsB092306/

Funny stuff. Did you really read this tripe?
On August 24th, 2006, Professor Jim Fetzer of the organization Scholars for 9/11 Truth interviewed
Wow, it goes on and tries to rip up Greening's model. But Greenings work is a model, not what happen on 9/11. A model to show it is true a gravity collapse can occur, and it did. You made the mistake of thinking this puts the stops on that paper, but as I look at BB paper, it sucks. I will leave the elegant critiques for this pile of BS for someone with extra time. But if you have any education at all, you can see this paper is junk. Can you?


This is great, a whole pile of woo to look at. How do you find the worse papers on 9/11? Just ask ZenSmack89. Thanks, I will look again, but I have seen most of these papers on the web, it all sucks. Not anything usable on 9/11. They debunk themselves quickly and without effort. Which is your favorite, we can save some time. Which one is a paper I have made a mistake labeling junk?
 
You don't have the slightest idea of how thoroughly this bogus article was DEMOLISHED, DESTROYED, DISCREDITED, DEBUNKED by R. Mackey, do you?
There was more then one article. I was responding to someone who asked abot Greening calcultions. No I don't know about the sesmic one being debunked but I'll be glad to happy it.
 
"I will leave the elegant critiques for this pile of BS for someone with extra time."

Good idea. Don't get in over your head with your big mouth.
 
http://www.cooperativeresearch.org/entity.jsp?entity=leslie_robertson

However, O’Sullivan consults “one of the trade center’s original structural engineers, Les Robertson, on whether the towers would collapse because of a bomb or a collision with a slow-moving airplane.” He is told there is “little likelihood of a collapse no matter how the building was attacked.”

In 2002, though, Robertson will write, “To the best of our knowledge, little was known about the effects of a fire from such an aircraft, and no designs were prepared for that circumstance.”
Robertson was correct. The 1993 bomb proves his bomb assessment correct (small bombs), and the building would survive a slow-moving airplane. FACTS Thank you.

But on 9/11 the planes were not moving slow, they imparted 7 to 11 times the kinetic energy than the design Leslie Robertson had made.
Leslie E. Robertson, , said: on being hit by a commercial jet -
" It appears that about 25,000 people safely exited the buildings, almost all of them from below the impact floors; almost everyone above the impact floors perished, either from the impact and fire or from the subsequent collapse. The structures of the buildings were heroic in some ways but less so in others. The buildings survived the impact of the Boeing 767 aircraft, an impact very much greater than had been contemplated in our design (a slow-flying Boeing 707 lost in the fog and seeking a landing field). Therefore, the robustness of the towers was exemplary. At the same time, the fires raging in the inner reaches of the buildings undermined their strength. In time, the unimaginable happened . . . wounded by the impact of the aircraft and bleeding from the fires, both of the towers of the World Trade Center collapsed."

http://www.nae.edu/nae/bridgecom.nsf/weblinks/CGOZ-58NLCB?OpenDocument
 
Robertson was correct. The 1993 bomb proves his bomb assessment correct (small bombs), and the building would survive a slow-moving airplane. FACTS Thank you.

But on 9/11 the planes were not moving slow, they imparted 7 to 11 times the kinetic energy than the design Leslie Robertson had made.
“little likelihood of a collapse no matter how the building was attacked.” - Les Robertson 1964

FACTS Thank you.

Now how would I know which statement from Robertson you were originally looking for?
 
why are eating peaches off the tree better than looking up woo?

"I will leave the elegant critiques for this pile of BS for someone with extra time."

Good idea. Don't get in over your head with your big mouth.
You already blew it, the paper/s have been debunked already. Your list is from truthers with no integrity and not very good at 9/11 topics. Not talk, just facts. Show me the great facts you think are there? You have to be kidding me, this junk is believed to be true by you? Do you even read it? If you had studied 9/11, and understood 9/11, you would be able to see your posted papers as junk. I am sorry you think I am just talking, but if you had read the papers and understood them you would agree with me. If you lack the ability to understand why the papers suck, you either do not care, or you are one of the sad authors of woo.
 
People are still debating these things you claim don't exsist. There videos on YOUTUBE that claim it.
1) The above in no way addresses the "totality of the evidence" point I had made.

2) Supply one video of the collapses which have the distinct sounds of explosive charges going off. Either such sounds are there or they are not. If they were indeed present that day then virtually every video of the collapses, especially those close to the towers, should have such sounds on the audio track, so finding numerous examples should be easy. If it is not that should tell you something.
 
Last edited:
Me said:
Which is not a yes or no to my specific question above. So let's try it this way:

A) A "plane alone" brought down each of the Twins.
B) A series of interconnected events*, including the initial damage created by each airplane, brought down both towers.

Please choose A or B.



*The events not to include unsupported speculation such as space beam weapons, nukes, or controlled demolition.
When I said plane only I meant the plane and what is claimed that the plane caused or triggered. It's the same thing to me. I wasn't trying to claim the plane and what it initiated caused no damage. I was drawing a comparison between people who believe one thing or the other.

From the following I believe "B)" the most. I would say you believe "A)" the most. I would then claim if "A)" can do it then "B)" can do it even better.

A) The Planes (and whatever the planes initiated)

B) Planes plus explosive devices.

c:)no planes at all just explosives.

Isn't "A)" what you believe the most out of all these choices? That's all I'm saying.
No. I am of the mind that each airplane's impact initiated a series of events which, together, contributed to the destruction of each tower. You were the one who repeatedly claimed "plane alone" did the deed.

I've engaged you in order to determine with more precision what you think happened. One descriptive phrase or another may all be the "same to [you]," but it simply isn't. While the failures of the Twins were straightforward, the process was not simple.
 
I believe Robertson didn't account the jet fuel and fires afterward.

More info: http://www.911myths.com/html/wtc_707_impact.html
I think the design impact of a slow moving aircraft would have survived, the fire system working, and no major damage past the shell. An impact of 9/11 was 1300 to 2200 pounds of TNT, the impact Robertson expected in the design would be 200 pounds of TNT. Most the plane would fall to the ground.
 
Here are some of my favorites from NIST that I found on

http://www.physics911.net/stevenjones

The focus of the Investigation was on the sequence of events from the instant of aircraft impact to the initiation of collapse for each tower. For brevity in this report, this sequence is referred to as the “probable collapse sequence,” although it does not actually include the structural behavior of the tower after the conditions for collapse initiation were reached…(NIST, 2005, p. 80, fn. 12)

The results were a simulation of the structural deterioration of each tower from the time of aircraft impact to the time at which the building became unstable, i.e., was poised for collapse. …(NIST, 2005, p. 142)


Review of videotape recordings of the collapse taken from various angles indicates that the transmission tower on top of the structure began to move downward and laterally slightly before movement was evident at the exterior wall. This suggests that collapse began with one or more failures in the central core area of the building. (FEMA, 2002, chapter 2) NIST does not comment on this.

“The jet fuel probably burned out in less than 10 minutes.” –Sunder NIST

Then…

NIST notes that office materials in an area burn for about 15-20 minutes, then are consumed away (NIST, 2005, pp. 117, 179).


Of the more than 170 areas examined on 16 perimeter column panels, only three columns had evidence that the steel reached temperatures above 250ºC… Only two core column specimens had sufficient paint remaining to make such an analysis, and their temperatures did not reach 250 ºC. … Using metallographic analysis, NIST determined that there was no evidence that any of the samples had reached temperatures above 600 ºC. (NIST, 2005, pp. 176-177;.)


Both WTC 1 and WTC 2 were stable after the aircraft impact, standing for 102 min and 56 min, respectively. The global analyses with structural impact damage showed that both towers had considerable reserve capacity. This was confirmed by analysis of the post-impact vibration of WTC 2… where the damaged tower oscillated at a period nearly equal to the first mode period calculated for the undamaged structure. (NIST, 2005, p. 144)



At any given location, the duration of [air, not steel] temperatures near 1,000oC was about 15 min to 20 min. The rest of the time, the calculated temperatures were near 500oC or below.” (NIST, 2005, p. 127)

The Investigation Team then defined three cases for each building by combining the middle, less severe, and more severe values of the influential variables. Upon a preliminary examination of the middle cases, it became clear that the towers would likely remain standing. The less severe cases were discarded after the aircraft impact results were compared to observed events. The middle cases (which became Case A for WTC 1 and Case C for WTC 2) were discarded after the structural response analysis of major subsystems were compared to observed events. (NIST, 2005, p. 142)


The more severe case (which became Case B for WTC 1 and Case D for WTC 2) was used for the global analysis of each tower. Complete sets of simulations were then performed for Cases B and D. To the extent that the simulations deviated from the photographic evidence or eyewitness reports [e.g., complete collapse occurred], the investigators adjusted the input, but only within the range of physical reality. Thus, for instance,…the pulling forces on the perimeter columns by the sagging floors were adjusted… (NIST, 2005)

the pulling forces on the perimeter columns by the sagging floors were adjusted” (NIST, 2005, p. 142)

NIST contracted with Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. to conduct tests to obtain information on the fire endurance of trusses like those in the WTC towers…. All four test specimens sustained the maximum design load for approximately 2 hours without collapsing… The Investigation Team was cautious about using these results directly in the formulation of collapse hypotheses. In addition to the scaling issues raised by the test results, the fires in the towers on September 11, and the resulting exposure of the floor systems, were substantially different from the conditions in the test furnaces. Nonetheless, the [empirical test] results established that this type of assembly was capable of sustaining a large gravity load, without collapsing, for a substantial period of time relative to the duration of the fires in any given location on September 11. (NIST, 2005, p. 141
 
I think the design impact of a slow moving aircraft would have survived, the fire system working, and no major damage past the shell. An impact of 9/11 was 1300 to 2200 pounds of TNT, the impact Robertson expected in the design would be 200 pounds of TNT. Most the plane would fall to the ground.
Just pointing out he revised his statement from “little likelihood of a collapse no matter how the building was attacked.”

no matter how
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom