Why I despise the Truthers

And why would he ask according to me? I'm not the one who believes it.

He's trying to find out if you understand the NIST report, Zen - not whether you support it.

Are you just avoiding the challenge or do you honestly not understand what is being asked?

If you don't know what the NIST report says then just say so.

It's OK for you to admit that you don't even know what it is you oppose, Zen. Trust me - you're not the only truther in that boat.
 
Once again, ZENSMACK89:

Do you maintain that a "plane alone" brought down each of the Twin Towers? Yes or no.

You are interested in the "truth," correct?
 
He's trying to find out if you understand the NIST report, Zen - not whether you support it.

Are you just avoiding the challenge or do you honestly not understand what is being asked?

If you don't know what the NIST report says then just say so.

It's OK for you to admit that you don't even know what it is you oppose, Zen. Trust me - you're not the only truther in that boat.
ZEN, I asked you to tell me why the towers collapsed, according to NIST, because I don't believe you're capable of stating the reasons. You replied with this:

Originally Posted by ZENSMACK89
NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition” theory since there is conclusive evidence that:

• the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC towers and nowhere else, and;

• the time it took for the collapse to initiate (56 minutes for WTC 2 and 102 minutes for WTC 1) was dictated by (1) the extent of damage caused by the aircraft impact, and (2) the time it took for the fires to reach critical locations and weaken the structure to the point that the towers could not resist the tremendous energy released by the downward movement of the massive top section of the building at and above the fire and impact floors.

That is incorrect. I'm sorry to see that you are incapable of simple honesty. You have severely embarrassed yourself with the adults here. Goodbye.


Gravy re-qualified his question after I answered his first one in exactly NIST's words. If I don't understand it then how did I find the answer so fast? One of you even replied "sounds correct" or something to that effect.

It doesn’t even look like knew it was from NIST because he didn't claim that I copied it he claimed it was incorrect. When I showed him I got it right from the NIST site he threw a hissy fit and asked for it in my own words. He's a waste of time. I hope he keeps ignoring me.
 
He's trying to find out if you understand the NIST report, Zen - not whether you support it.

Just to clarify this even further. He's trying to figure out if you understand it enough to objectiviely disagree with it, or if you simply are disagreeing with it because it says the Governement didn't do it. Most Truthers only know the bits of the NIST report they have read on Anti-Government sites and are really good at parroting them. Understand them is a rather different matter, so he wants you to prove that you actually know what the NISDT says and what it means by saying it in your own words rather than linking to or copying and pasting it. It's exactly the same as a Proffessor at University does when he gets his class to read up on a topic and then write a 200 word essay on it. To do that you have to know what the topic is about, else you just end up mindlessly following the crowd. See this is the problem. While the CT crowd throw in the "close minded" and "Sheeple" titles at the drop of a hat, if I had a dollar for every time I have seen a CT unthinkingly just post a link to a CT site as an answer to a question, or give a bottled reply, ask a straight off a webpage qquestion, or just cut and paste huge amounts of text, I'd be a very, very, very, very, very rich man.
 
Zen, the NIST report does not say that a "plane alone" brought down each of the Twin Towers.

Understand?

The NIST report does not say that a "plane alone" brought down each of the Twin Towers.

Your belief that is does shows that you don't even understand what you're arguing against.
 
So after all that you answer is "No, I have no idea what the NIST report says. But I still know it's wrong."

Way to go, Zen.
I not getting sucked into some semantic debate about if the plane and the things the plane supposedly caused are different causes. Give it up.
 
I not getting sucked into some semantic debate about if the plane and the things the plane supposedly caused are different causes. Give it up.

And we aren't going to get sucked into a conversation with someone who is intentionally using misleading language in an attempt to poison the well and invoke various other logical fallacies.

Either you can be intellectually honest, or you can't. If you can't have enough respect to adequately state other people's ideas as opposed to creating strawman to beat on, you likely fall on the latter half of that scale.
 
ZEN, I asked you to tell me why the towers collapsed, according to NIST, because I don't believe you're capable of stating the reasons. You replied with this:

Originally Posted by ZENSMACK89
NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition” theory since there is conclusive evidence that:

• the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC towers and nowhere else, and;

• the time it took for the collapse to initiate (56 minutes for WTC 2 and 102 minutes for WTC 1) was dictated by (1) the extent of damage caused by the aircraft impact, and (2) the time it took for the fires to reach critical locations and weaken the structure to the point that the towers could not resist the tremendous energy released by the downward movement of the massive top section of the building at and above the fire and impact floors.

That is incorrect. I'm sorry to see that you are incapable of simple honesty. You have severely embarrassed yourself with the adults here. Goodbye.


Gravy re-qualified his question after I answered his first one in exactly NIST's words. If I don't understand it then how did I find the answer so fast? One of you even replied "sounds correct" or something to that effect.

It doesn’t even look like knew it was from NIST because he didn't claim that I copied it he claimed it was incorrect. When I showed him I got it right from the NIST site he threw a hissy fit and asked for it in my own words. He's a waste of time. I hope he keeps ignoring me.

read this very carefully. Gravy asked you to explain how the collapses occured. You posted why they said it wasn't a Controlled Demolition. He didn't ask you for that, how is it the answer to his question? If you asked me what colour the sky was, and I replied that Clouds are white because of the way light refracts through the water dropets, is that answering you question? No. And giving the reasons that NIST states that the collapse was not a CD is NOT, repeat, NOT explaining what NIST said WAS the cause of the collapse. How about you answer that question?
 
I not getting sucked into some semantic debate about if the plane and the things the plane supposedly caused are different causes. Give it up.

No one is trying to sucker you into anything, we just are trying to find out if you actually know and understand what you disagree with or if you just disagree for the sake of disagreeing. If you don't know the answer, just say so, at least we know where you stand and what to do to try and educate you, as long as you play this stupid game, all you are doing is trolling and making us guess at how ignorant you really are. Ignorance is an acceptable and changable condition, we're all ignorant about something and can learn to fix it. Willful ignorance is not. Which catogory do you fall into ZENSMACK?
 
I know what he's doing. I know what you're all doing. How do you all assume to know or to have read more then anyone else? Bare assertions on everything from what I understand to how old I am. You’re all full of it. Bare assertions and hand waving is all any of you have because you support an official version which is nothing more then just that. None of you have shown anything so how do I know you read it or understand it? Understand what? Understand its bull? I don't even care I especially don't want to here it in your own words. Who the heck are you? Point to where it proves it. Quote it. Copy it. Plagiarize it where it proves it. Can you? I'm not walking in here like I need to prove anything to any of you. You got it backwards.
 
No one is trying to sucker you into anything, we just are trying to find out if you actually know and understand what you disagree with or if you just disagree for the sake of disagreeing. If you don't know the answer, just say so, at least we know where you stand and what to do to try and educate you, as long as you play this stupid game, all you are doing is trolling and making us guess at how ignorant you really are. Ignorance is an acceptable and changable condition, we're all ignorant about something and can learn to fix it. Willful ignorance is not. Which catogory do you fall into ZENSMACK?
"the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC"

Did NIST have a theory at the end of their report for collapse or collapse initiation?

Did you read it?
 
I know what he's doing. I know what you're all doing. How do you all assume to know or to have read more then anyone else? Bare assertions on everything from what I understand to how old I am. You’re all full of it. Bare assertions and hand waving is all any of you have because you support an official version which is nothing more then just that. None of you have shown anything so how do I know you read it or understand it? Understand what? Understand its bull? I don't even care I especially don't want to here it in your own words. Who the heck are you? Point to where it proves it. Quote it. Copy it. Plagiarize it where it proves it. Can you? I'm not walking in here like I need to prove anything to any of you. You got it backwards.

You came here, to a discussion board, if you want a discussion then it's up to you to prove that we're going to be talking about the same thing. If you can't show that you actually know what the NIST claims are, but you just call them bull, why should we accept that you know what you're talking about? If we came to your playground then it's fair enough that we'd have to show that we were able to understand what you have there, but here the rules are stupport your arguments. Just claiming that something is bull isn't going to fly. Now you have three choices. Show you know the subject, talk to yourself because we're all sick of your evasiness, dodging and trolling, or go back where you came from where you can expound your nonsense to your heart's content.
 
"the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC"

That is where it happened

Did NIST have a theory at the end of their report for collapse or collapse initiation?

It's in the report, remarkabling near the front as well as other places. That's generally how a report works.

Did you read it?

I've ready about 60% and skimmed another 15-20% of it. There are a numberof people here that have ready 100%. How much have you read?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom