Why I despise the Truthers

Which is not a yes or no to my specific question above. So let's try it this way:

A) A "plane alone" brought down each of the Twins.
B) A series of interconnected events*, including the initial damage created by each airplane, brought down both towers.

Please choose A or B.



*The events not to include unsupported speculation such as space beam weapons, nukes, or controlled demolition.
When I said plane only I meant the plane and what is claimed that the plane caused or triggered. It's the same thing to me. I wasn't trying to claim the plane and what it initiated caused no damage. I was drawing a comparison between people who believe one thing or the other.

From the following I believe "B)" the most. I would say you believe "A)" the most. I would then claim if "A)" can do it then "B)" can do it even better.

A) The Planes (and whatever the planes initiated)

B) Planes plus explosive devices.

c:)no planes at all just explosives.

Isn't "A)" what you believe the most out of all these choices? That's all I'm saying.
 
Its what he believes, what I believe, what the MAJORITY of the world believes, what a group of PhDs in civil engineering, physics, etc.. believe, it is what the majority of the scientific and engineering community believe.

How about you?

TAM:)
 
When I said plane only I meant the plane and what is claimed that the plane caused or triggered. It's the same thing to me. I wasn't trying to claim the plane and what it initiated caused no damage. I was drawing a comparison between people who believe one thing or the other.

From the following I believe "B)" the most. I would say you believe "A)" the most. I would then claim if "A)" can do it then "B)" can do it even better.

A) The Planes (and whatever the planes initiated)

B) Planes plus explosive devices.

c:)no planes at all just explosives.

Isn't "A)" what you believe the most out of all these choices? That's all I'm saying.

Yes, a plane with explosives most likely would have brought down the towers also. The problem is that it would have looked totally different, and there's no evidence for it.
 
When thousands of tons of steel is in motion it's going to just keep going til it hits something solid to stop it. Since the WTC's were "tubes within tubes" & basically "hollow" there was just some resistence to the structure. But that little bit of resistence helped make the collaspe go on for about 20 seconds.
Isn't that sort of a contridiction? The towers fell on themselves. How could it be something solid or greater falling on something hollow or less if it's all from the same building. If anything the falling mass is broken up tower falling on still intact tower made of the same tons of steel you speak of. I think I even read that the top floors were lighter then the lower floors but I'll have to check on that.
 
I'd just like to take a time out here, and say that for stating NIST's theory of collapse initiation I've gained a ton of new respect for Zen. Not being sarcastic or derogatory here, I'm 100% honest. Now that we've established this foundation of what he believes and what he thinks is wrong with the report we can really get a good discussion going.
Thank you.
 
knowledge and judgment

Isn't that sort of a contridiction? The towers fell on themselves. How could it be something solid or greater falling on something hollow or less if it's all from the same building. If anything the falling mass is broken up tower falling on still intact tower made of the same tons of steel you speak of. I think I even read that the top floors were lighter then the lower floors but I'll have to check on that.
You are not able to comprehend simple things, you twist the facts to fit your world of CT. Good luck, you take ideas and twist them to fit your own views. You remind me of the anti-intellectual sites of PrisonPlanet and Inforwars, web sites for real dumb people who believe lies and propaganda spewed by real dumb guys.

Yes the top floor are lighter than the lower floors. Different steel grades and types were used as needed to ensure strength of the WTC. But you must get your mind straight and use real experts who understand the collapse and see what they think. You need to get away from asking dumb questions and being able to answer the tough questions.

Do you know what Leslie Robertson, the chief structural engineer of the WTC, said about 9/11 and his building collapsing?
 
Last edited:
I don't know if I did this right.

Was that supposed to be an argument ?

No it was a question.

Indeed.

Indeed? This isn't Esnir is it?

Not exactly. It took four years. Didn't you read the posts, yet ?

Ii wasn't taking about NIST there. I was talking about people like Hauer.

What the hell are you talking about ? Learn to use the quote function.

NIST contracted with Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. to conduct tests to obtain information on the fire endurance of trusses like those in the WTC towers…. All four test specimens sustained the maximum design load for approximately 2 hours without collapsing… The Investigation Team was cautious about using these results directly in the formulation of collapse hypotheses. In addition to the scaling issues raised by the test results, the fires in the towers on September 11, and the resulting exposure of the floor systems, were substantially different from the conditions in the test furnaces. Nonetheless, the [empirical test] results established that this type of assembly was capable of sustaining a large gravity load, without collapsing, for a substantial period of time relative to the duration of the fires in any given location on September 11. (NIST, 2005, p. 141

Yes, that is very unfortunate. Tragic. But it doesn't mean squat.

It means more then squat.

You ARE making things up. You think his snap interpretation of the even is the same as NIST's conclusion four years later.

He came pretty close and then weighed in on the Anthrax that afternoon and hit the bullseye again.

THAT IS A STRAWMAN, Zen. Give it up. Nobody's saying it became shotgun-pellet sized fragments except you.

Actually NIST did a shotgun test to simulate the palne crash effet on the fire proofing .



How would YOU have done it ? Crash an airliner into a similar building and see what happens ?

Just asking someone who seems to think they have it all figured out.

I'll spell it out for you: removing the fireproofing will not make the temperature higher. What it will do is raise the temperature OF THE STEEL.

That's what I was.. never mind

No, the entire world is claiming that because we SAW the plane crash into it, the jet fuel DID start fires, the exterior columns DID buckle and the building THEN collapsed. There is NO need to add more speculation to this.

Yeah that's what I said you believe. The plane.

Let's stick to 9/11, shall we ?

The Cipro was given out to the White House on 9-11

They can guess, but without actual analysis their opinions are tentative.

I agree. The opinions are still tentative.

That's because their job is to go inside the buildings, stop the fires and save people's lives.

What is it you debunkers claim "Pull" means?

That's not what the "official" story says. Try again.

Well I don't believe it. Sorry.

Now you're just playing silly juvenile games. Either debate honestly or not at all.

honestly? geez

You can't read minds. You should stop trying. No one's my hero, here.
I can be your hero. lol

My point stands. From what I've seen he keeps his cool in those situations. Prove me wrong.
I think theres a clip on YouTube that does just that and there's nothing cool about it.



That's possible. What of it ?

What of it. I think you claimed an explosive device would have to leave behind traces of itself. No some would claim it did like Steven Jones. I would claim that because of everything that was never found traces of the explosive device are possible to also not be found. That's all I meant.
 
You are not able to comprehend simple things, you twist the facts to fit your world of CT. Good luck, you take ideas and twist them to fit your own views. You remind me of the anti-intellectual sites of PrisonPlanet and Inforwars, web sites for real dumb people who believe lies and propagate spewed by real dumb guys.


"real dumb people" lol classic

Yes the top floor are lighter than the lower floors. Different steel grades and types were used as needed to ensure strength of the WTC. But you must get your mind straight and use real experts who understand the collapse and see what they think. You need to get away from asking dumb questions and being able to answer the tough questions.


I didn't bring it up. Get away? You mean from you? Not a problem.

Do you know what Leslie Robertson, the chief structural engineer of the WTC, said about 9/11 and his building collapsing?

In his 1964 building analysis or his revisionism after 9-11?
 
II would claim that because of everything that was never found traces of the explosive device are possible to also not be found. That's all I meant.
But remember the official verison of events does not rest on one particular piece of evidence or another, it rests on the totality of the evidence. That is, all the evidence taken together, in which one piece reinforces what is found in another piece.

Consider that, if explosives were used to bring the WTC buildings down, explosives, particularly ones powerful enough to do the job, would make very loud, distinct noises. These noises would have been recorded on all of the great many videos there are of the collapses, especially those videos taken close to the towers.

No video shows any signs of such distinctive sounds on the audio track. This piece of evidence reinforces the fact that no physical traces of explosives were found after the collapses. These pieces put together reinforce each other and when taken together point towards no explosives being used.

This is how cases are built, with layers of individual pieces of evidence reinforcing and supporting each other, with the totality all pointing to one conclusion.
 
Why not?

Just to clarify, I'm not being glib. I'm seriously asking. And the reason is because as someone completely ignorant in the fields of advanced science and mathematics, it seems to me that a phenomenon such as this is not open to opinion. I would posit that there are hard numbers behind it that provide an irrefutable answer one way or the other.

You have taken a position, based on what I can tell, merely on unqualified opinion. If I am wrong, then please enlighten me with the calculations you have done to support your conclusion and I'm sure some of our more qualified forum members will proof them for the benefit of us uneducated folk.
I didn't do calculations of my own. I am basing my opinion on reading both sides of the issue. Some papers I've read have done calculations and disputed findings of researchers like Greening. There's a lot of stuff out there and I try to read up on as much as possible and in doing do don't buy the official version.

What reading, evidence, or calculations, have you found that support your belief in the official version?
 
I didn't do calculations of my own. I am basing my opinion on reading both sides of the issue. Some papers I've read have done calculations and disputed findings of researchers like Greening. There's a lot of stuff out there and I try to read up on as much as possible and in doing do don't buy the official version.

What reading, evidence, or calculations, have you found that support your belief in the official version?
There are too many independent source for the "official" story. The 9/11 truth story does not even exist. Can you point to a single coherent story by 9/11 truth? Space beams, thermite (made up out of the blue by Jones in 2005), what do you have to show the "official" story is wrong besides PrisonPlanet tripe and infowars junk? Start here since http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/home

Please list the papers that effectively, or otherwise, dispute the Greening paper. Sources?
 
Once the collapse was over, which shape did the wreckage pile have? Was it:

1) A mound?

2) A crater?

To save time, I'll answer for you. As anybody can ascertain from countless pictures, it took the shape of a mound. Even though much of each building collapsed down into multiple storeys of basement, the wreckage formed a mound.

Why is this important? - Because if most of the material had fallen out to the side, we would have seen a crater. We did not see a crater, and this means most of the material fell on the floors below the collapse zone.

Since you onserve that even the minority part of the mass which fell on the adjacent buildings was enough to destroy several of them, it follows that the majority of material which impacted on the lower floors was clearly also enough to destroy them.

OK?

Hans

The point I was making about the part of the tower that fell on WTC is that it fell across the street to do so not straight down the middle part of a conservation of momentum collapse. It also truly would have met with no resistance and fell at freefall until it hit WTC7 which would have been different if it had fell straight down the middle. I think it's Judy Wood who has pictures of the towers underground after the collapse where the path trains and some of the shops were still much intact. Much more so then anything at ground level. It would appear that whatever crushed 110 stories didn't continue through all of the underground floors to the the same extent it demoliished the floors above ground.

http://janedoe0911.tripod.com/StarWarsBeam1.html

No I don't endorse the Starwars theory. Just though the pictures were interesting.
 
But remember the official verison of events does not rest on one particular piece of evidence or another, it rests on the totality of the evidence. That is, all the evidence taken together, in which one piece reinforces what is found in another piece.

Consider that, if explosives were used to bring the WTC buildings down, explosives, particularly ones powerful enough to do the job, would make very loud, distinct noises. These noises would have been recorded on all of the great many videos there are of the collapses, especially those videos taken close to the towers.

No video shows any signs of such distinctive sounds on the audio track. This piece of evidence reinforces the fact that no physical traces of explosives were found after the collapses. These pieces put together reinforce each other and when taken together point towards no explosives being used.

This is how cases are built, with layers of individual pieces of evidence reinforcing and supporting each other, with the totality all pointing to one conclusion.
People are still debating these things you claim don't exsist. There videos on YOUTUBE that claim it.
 
There are too many independent source for the "official" story. The 9/11 truth story does not even exist. Can you point to a single coherent story by 9/11 truth? Space beams, thermite (made up out of the blue by Jones in 2005), what do you have to show the "official" story is wrong besides PrisonPlanet tripe and infowars junk? Start here since http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/home

Please list the papers that effectively, or otherwise, dispute the Greening paper. Sources?
FEMA and NIST don't even concur on what type of collapse happened and how it happened. What's your point?
 
There are too many independent source for the "official" story. The 9/11 truth story does not even exist. Can you point to a single coherent story by 9/11 truth? Space beams, thermite (made up out of the blue by Jones in 2005), what do you have to show the "official" story is wrong besides PrisonPlanet tripe and infowars junk? Start here since http://wtc7lies.googlepages.com/home

Please list the papers that effectively, or otherwise, dispute the Greening paper. Sources?
http://www.studyof911.com/

Recent Studyof911 Articles

Seismic Proof - 9/11 Was An Inside Job (Updated Version II)
PDF Version DOC Version
Author(s): Craig T. Furlong & Gordon Ross (Members, Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice)
Statement by Craig T. Furlong and Article Discussion Thread



Calculation of World Trade Center Building 7 Collapse Acceleration
Author(s): "Winston Smith" of Studyof911.com
Article discussion thread



Debunking the WTC1 Main Freight Fireball Myth
PDF Version
Author(s): "bsbray" of Studyof911.com
Article discussion thread



Photographic Analysis of Damage to WTC7 and Critical Errors in NIST's Estimations
Author(s): "Winston Smith" of Studyof911.com
Article discussion thread



Addressing Faulty Assumptions of Greening and Others in WTC Momentum Transfer Calculations
PDF Version
Author(s): "bsbray" of Studyof911.com
 
Robertson

He's made lot's of statements over the years regarding the towers. Which one are you refering to?
Please explain, in detail, your false statement. You clearly made a false statement and you want me to explain your false statement? Please present the facts on why you imputed Robertson the way you did?

I would expect Robertson to be on the side of truth. Why is it he understands why his building fell, and the 9/11 truth "expert" are just making up lies and false information?
 
I accept those testimonies.
Excellent. You're one of the first conspiracists to do so.

But now what you have to do, is tell me why you dont accept the testimonies of the 1st responders who state that 7 was going to be blown up.
Please provide me with the testimony of any first responder who state they knew that WTC 7 was going to be blown up. These testimonies can be from before, during, or after 9/11.

Do it or shut your mouth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom