Why I despise the Truthers

I know what he's doing. I know what you're all doing. How do you all assume to know or to have read more then anyone else? Bare assertions on everything from what I understand to how old I am. You’re all full of it. Bare assertions and hand waving is all any of you have because you support an official version which is nothing more then just that. None of you have shown anything so how do I know you read it or understand it? Understand what? Understand its bull? I don't even care I especially don't want to here it in your own words. Who the heck are you? Point to where it proves it. Quote it. Copy it. Plagiarize it where it proves it. Can you? I'm not walking in here like I need to prove anything to any of you. You got it backwards.

The lyrics to a certain song by The Kinks comes to mind with this post.
 
How do you all assume to know or to have read more then anyone else?

This is an easy question to answer. Because we can instantly recognize someone who very obviously doesn't understand the NIST theory that he claims he disagrees with.

That's why we keep telling you to read it. It's -obvious- you don't know what it says. Therefore it's -obvious- that we have read "more" about it than you have. Similarly, it's -obvious- that your objections to it are fundamentally flawed on the grounds that you are objecting to something you don't understand.
 
Seeing how I created this thread, Yes.

Did you read the original post and the first few pages before this thread went off subject?

I'd also point out that while NYCEMT86 now has 157 posts to his name, that OP of this thread was his first on the board, thus it was done at a time when he was not a regular here. To suggest that this thread is a reflection on the board because a newbie created a thread with his first post that might have an inappropriate title but one that declared his frustrations, is beyond credulous and somewhere near sublimely ridiculous.
 
BTW, instead of changing the subject, again, hold about just answering the question, or is "I don't know" not in your vocabulary?
 
I'd also point out that while NYCEMT86 now has 157 posts to his name, that OP of this thread was his first on the board, thus it was done at a time when he was not a regular here. To suggest that this thread is a reflection on the board because a newbie created a thread with his first post that might have an inappropriate title but one that declared his frustrations, is beyond credulous and somewhere near sublimely ridiculous.

I did post a few other thread, but this is actually my first thread that has taken off to 14 pages.



Edited: Corrections
 
Last edited:
I've read it. Parts of it more then once. I also look to the outside experts and what they think of it and how they agree independently from each other in what’s right with it and what’s wrong. While they all seem to have different ideas about NIST, FEMA, or even the 9-11 commission there are the flaws that they all seem to independently find. To me that’s the key. Independent research that forms a consensus. Not a bunch of people working together backwards towards the same predetermined conclusion.

What good is it? When there are people who feel the Gov was at least negligent in what happened on 9-11 and feel there is an interest in covering up that negligence then what good is a Gov report on it? Controlled and censored Gov reports.

It’s like if the Germans won WWII and they had Hitler and the Nazi’s investigate the Holocaust. I’m sure they could have presented what they would have claimed was proof and evidence that it never happened and it would have been good enough of an explanation for most Germans.

BTW

The NIST theory claims the force of the planes damaged or destroyed columns and sheered off fireproofing. Jet fuel though burning up in 10 to 20 minutes ignited building contents and weakened the steel that the fire proofing was sheered off of. The sheered off fire-proofing also allowed the fires to spread. Some have claimed the asbestos fireproofing that was in the lower floors of WTC1 would have done a better job. This all led to sagging which pulled inward thus according to NIST caused collapse initiation. This theory though different from the FEMA findings which blamed the fire more then the structural damage in my opinion is more in line with the original Bazant findings as stated in “Why did the World Trade Center towers collapse?”

I don’t believe any of it because although the planes and the structural damage were severe I don’t feel the collapse itself or the way the collapse occurred is sufficiently explained by any of this. To me it’s always been a contradiction to say that the buildings fell mostly just outside their footprint pretty evenly over all four sides causing enough damage to say WTC7 to cause it to collapse also, but then also claim a kind of sustained conservation of momentum type collapse building kinetic energy, mass, and velocity down the center to come down at the speed it was witnessed to. The collapse of the WTC though many things was not a newly discovered source of energy. In other words it’s my opinion it should have stopped somewhere on the way down considering the loss of mass over the sides. That is if it should have started at all.
 
This is an easy question to answer. Because we can instantly recognize someone who very obviously doesn't understand the NIST theory that he claims he disagrees with.

That's why we keep telling you to read it. It's -obvious- you don't know what it says. Therefore it's -obvious- that we have read "more" about it than you have. Similarly, it's -obvious- that your objections to it are fundamentally flawed on the grounds that you are objecting to something you don't understand.
Yup it's all obvious to you. How old I am. What I've read and what I haven't. How the official version is the truth.

It must be nice for everything to be so obvious.
 
Why do you assume that because NIST modelled an approximation of the impact by using a shot gun and a small amount of fireproofing as a test bed, that they believed that it was a 100% perfectly accurate simulation of what happened? This belief ranks right up along side the person on another board that came to the conclusion that since a program was tested by impacting a can of coke into a test structure of steel and concrete, that the testers though the coke can was a perfect model of a 767.
Why do I assume this? I don't. But NIST is practically basing their entire collapse initiation on the fireproofing initially being dislodged. Doesn't it have to be calculated pretty close? Could their theory of collapse initiation work without this fireproofing dislodged? How little of it could be removed and still have this theory work?
 
It’s like if the Germans won WWII and they had Hitler and the Nazi’s investigate the Holocaust.
The only problem with that analogy is that once Germany invaded Russia, they had virtually no chance of winning the war. Invading a country with as many as 35 million men of military age is not a good idea.

I know, not exactly germane to your point, but it's that I can't resist having the occasional WWII-themed discussion.
 
*snip*
I don’t believe any of it because although the planes and the structural damage were severe I don’t feel the collapse itself or the way the collapse occurred is sufficiently explained by any of this. To me it’s always been a contradiction to say that the buildings fell mostly just outside their footprint pretty evenly over all four sides causing enough damage to say WTC7 to cause it to collapse also, but then also claim a kind of sustained conservation of momentum type collapse building kinetic energy, mass, and velocity down the center to come down at the speed it was witnessed to. The collapse of the WTC though many things was not a newly discovered source of energy. In other words it’s my opinion it should have stopped somewhere on the way down considering the loss of mass over the sides. That is if it should have started at all.

So you are really saying that you don't understand how the buildings collapsed and you feel they should have behaved differently. And because of this you assume that thousands of specialists must be wrong, and demand that the whole thing be researched once more?

Hans
 
So you are really saying that you don't understand how the buildings collapsed and you feel they should have behaved differently. And because of this you assume that thousands of specialists must be wrong, and demand that the whole thing be researched once more?

Yeah. Only with the right conclusion this time!
 
So you are really saying that you don't understand how the buildings collapsed and you feel they should have behaved differently. And because of this you assume that thousands of specialists must be wrong, and demand that the whole thing be researched once more?

Hans
No I'm saying I don't believe it. Read it again slower.
 
You didn't answer the question.

What is it exactly that you don't believe?
I already said that. I don't believe a dynamic mass falling over the sides enough to destroy other buildings could leave enough of a dynamic mass to fall down the center pulverizing floors in mid air all the way down at the speed that it did.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom