Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

I'm not the one pretending to analyse the IDF based on how little I know. You are.

Of course I try to analyse the situation, including the actions and behaviour of both the IDF and the Hezbollah, based on what the limited knowledge I have.

How else is anyone supposed to build an opinion on what's happening in the world? The alternative would be to lock oneself in a room, refuse to read news and succumb to apathy. Maybe you're willing to do that, but I am not.
 
varwoche, you actually said "I have noticed that a great many of your posts are not based on facts and credible evidence but rather wishful thinking of a high order."

OK, so now you are backtracking to indicate ONE posting where you had a problem with my 'evidence' ---
Post #175
which was not you doing any "debunking" at all but rather you just denying that photos of young kids participating in Hezbollah would constitute 'evidence' of young kids participating in Hezbollah fighting.

I know it is not definitive proof of kids being combatants in Lebanon today.
However, it is credible evidence that Hezbollah has no problem with training and indoctrinating kids to their cause.
BTW, there are essentially NO photos of Hezbollah combatants in this current war (besides a few "smuggled" images that appeared recently showing a rocket-firing team, and one of those guys looked to be around 15 --- the guy in black holding the AK47 in the upper left on the truck).

For the record -- varwoche, in my post #235 which you say is 'debate by rorsach' I specifically mentioned the part of this thread where I offered evidence of the kids in Hezbollah. So you are incorrect by saying:
(webfusion) fails to explain the very post that I commented on

My comment within #235 was thus:
Post #163 -- Some photos of youngsters parading for Hezbollah.
Offered as illustrative of the participation of kids in the "jihad."
The challenge was made by Dustin that no evidence exists of kids firing AK-47's at IDF soldiers. While not absolute proof that they are doing so, it certainly is Evidence that it might be happening.


So, I did make reference to it --- and you now are trying to present this as your best example of "a great many of (webfusion's) posts are not based on facts and credible evidence" ??

Sorry, varwoche. It's just not happening. Go sell your feeble story to someone who cares.
 
Of course I try to analyse the situation, including the actions and behaviour of both the IDF and the Hezbollah, based on what the limited knowledge I have.

How else is anyone supposed to build an opinion on what's happening in the world? The alternative would be to lock oneself in a room, refuse to read news and succumb to apathy. Maybe you're willing to do that, but I am not.

Hey, the bottom line is that I originally disagreed with the implied conclusion of your analysis. You are now analysing the discussion process, not the issue at hand.
 
Hey, the bottom line is that I originally disagreed with the implied conclusion of your analysis. You are now analysing the discussion process, not the issue at hand.

Go ahead and disagree with my views and opinions, by all means, but don't drag out that tired old "you're nothing but an armchair analyst" tripe.
 
Apollyon:
"Actually, I believe the onus is on you to back up your statement. You made the observation of "...the Israeli way of war which does not seem to have changed very much."
I have pointed out one glaring difference that does demonstrate change from the past - the use of flyers dropped in the area to warn civilians of impending attack. Doing that would also imply that Israel is not merely giving lip service about avoiding innocent civilian deaths, but are proactively making the effort.
So do you still stand by the claim that it's business as usual for Israel as per the statements you cited by Gur?"

What the hell are you talking about? Israel dropped leaflets in the 1982 invasion. Many accounts mentions this. In fact, some commentators have cited this as a grim parallel between the 2006 invasion and the slaughter 24 years ago. This is not a kindler, gentler Israeli army -- nor, by the way, is the IDF even trying to look like one.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/07/18/AR2006071800400.html
http://angryarab.blogspot.com/2006/07/israels-false-assumptions-about.html
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/1987/SGC.htm
http://www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6453/pfg.html
http://observer.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,,1821769,00.html

As As'ad AbuKhalil put it, "Israel (just as in 1982) assumed that its silly flyers over South Lebanon will be seen as witty and smart. Instead; they are seen as dumb and foolish, and badly crafted."
Giving someone a flyer that says, "I'm about to bomb your home" doesn't make it right to bomb their home. Nor can anyone seriously claim that Israel is trying to protect civilians. Countless articles including the words of Israeli leaders themselves, prove that beyond dispute.

"What we should do in southern Lebanon is employ huge firepower before a ground force goes in. Everyone in southern Lebanon is a terrorist and is connected to Hizbollah." etc etc ad nauseum.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/07/28/wmid28.xml

These flyers are psyops -- designed to psychologically manipulate the population, just as in 1982. Fortunately, they're failing.
It`s the same tactic as used in Falluja - get out, or don't blame us if you lose your legs and your children.


So do I stand by my claim of business as usual? Yes, totally. The leaflets, text messages and cold-calling (in Gaza too)
(http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/Sto...832183,00.html)

serve two devious purposes:
1) they add to the terror of the population, as Arab commentators have pointed out
2) they maintain the necessary - for people like you, anyway - pretence that they are not targeting civilians. All the evidence however supports the admission by IDF commanders that they regard civilians as legitimate targets.

It's beyond f*cking satire that people believe dropping leaflets shows a "good" side to what's happening.

Do try to keep up.
 
Apollyon:
"Actually, I believe the onus is on you to back up your statement. You made the observation of "...the Israeli way of war which does not seem to have changed very much."
I have pointed out one glaring difference that does demonstrate change from the past - the use of flyers dropped in the area to warn civilians of impending attack. Doing that would also imply that Israel is not merely giving lip service about avoiding innocent civilian deaths, but are proactively making the effort.
So do you still stand by the claim that it's business as usual for Israel as per the statements you cited by Gur?"

What the hell are you talking about? Israel dropped leaflets in the 1982 invasion. Many accounts mentions this. In fact, some commentators have cited this as a grim parallel between the 2006 invasion and the slaughter 24 years ago. This is not a kindler, gentler Israeli army -- nor, by the way, is the IDF even trying to look like one.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/07/18/AR2006071800400.html
http://angryarab.blogspot.com/2006/07/israels-false-assumptions-about.html
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/1987/SGC.htm
http://www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6453/pfg.html
http://observer.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,,1821769,00.html

As As'ad AbuKhalil put it, "Israel (just as in 1982) assumed that its silly flyers over South Lebanon will be seen as witty and smart. Instead; they are seen as dumb and foolish, and badly crafted."
Giving someone a flyer that says, "I'm about to bomb your home" doesn't make it right to bomb their home. Nor can anyone seriously claim that Israel is trying to protect civilians. Countless articles including the words of Israeli leaders themselves, prove that beyond dispute.

"What we should do in southern Lebanon is employ huge firepower before a ground force goes in. Everyone in southern Lebanon is a terrorist and is connected to Hizbollah." etc etc ad nauseum.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/07/28/wmid28.xml

These flyers are psyops -- designed to psychologically manipulate the population, just as in 1982. Fortunately, they're failing.
It`s the same tactic as used in Falluja - get out, or don't blame us if you lose your legs and your children.


So do I stand by my claim of business as usual? Yes, totally. The leaflets, text messages and cold-calling (in Gaza too)
(http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/Sto...832183,00.html)

serve two devious purposes:
1) they add to the terror of the population, as Arab commentators have pointed out
2) they maintain the necessary - for people like you, anyway - pretence that they are not targeting civilians. All the evidence however supports the admission by IDF commanders that they regard civilians as legitimate targets.

It's beyond f*cking satire that people believe dropping leaflets shows a "good" side to what's happening.

Do try to keep up.

Palestinians who fled in the first war still aren't allowed back to their homes.

Convoys of people who do flee have been attacked.
 
http://www.theage.com.au/news/world/israeli-cluster-bomb-probe/2006/08/26/1156012780706.html

The United States is investigating Israel's use of US-made cluster bombs in its blitz on southern Lebanon, after warnings that the devices, which sow mini-minefields, are still killing civilians.
Confirmation of the investigation came after the United Nations sounded alarms about what it said was a growing emergency, saying cluster munitions were reaping a bloody toll among returning refugees.
"We have heard of the allegation, and we are looking into it," said Gonzo Gallegos, a State Department spokesman.
"What we are looking to see is if they were used. We are looking to see if there is evidence of that.
"Once we determine that, we look to see how they were used, who were the targets."
The United Nations Mine Action Coordination Centre in Tyre, Lebanon raised a new alarm this week over cluster bombs, nearly two weeks after a ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah came into force.
"Every day we hear about casualties - it's a large number," said Dalya Farran, media officer for the centre in southern Lebanon.
"We're in an emergency situation," she said.
Lebanese military figures put the toll from cluster bombs to 11 killed and 43 wounded, including several children, since the ceasefire began on August 14.
On Wednesday, three Lebanese bomb disposal experts were killed by a cluster bomb in the village of Tebnin, 15kms from the Israeli border.
The Israeli military today said "all the weapons and munitions used by the IDF (Israel Defence Force) are legal and under international law, and their use conforms with international standards".
The New York Times, which first reported the probe, said Washington would be investigating whether Israel had infringed secret rules which restrict where cluster bombs can be used

Cluster bombs in civilian areas will produce civilian casualties, even after war ends.
 
did
Well if the Age says so, it must be true... :rolleyes:

Did they ever retract their fraudulent story about the Israeli missile hitting the ambulance? Admit they were played for suckers and fools? What are they doing now to avoid being fooled again?

When did it become fraudulent?

I saw on the news journalists going through a village with cluster bombs scattered around,and children injured.

http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/meast/08/26/reuters.israel.ap/index.html

GAZA CITY, Gaza (AP) -- Two missiles fired by Israeli aircraft early Sunday morning hit an armored car belonging to the Reuters news agency, moderately wounding two television cameramen and three bystanders, Palestinian witnesses and hospital officials said.
The Israeli army said it was checking the report.
According to witnesses, a Reuters cameraman and a freelance cameraman working for an Arabic network were standing outside the vehicle in the Shajaiyeh neighborhood of Gaza filming a nearby Israeli raid when the missiles hit the car. (Watch as bloodied victims are rushed to the hospital -- :43)
The white sports utility vehicle was emblazoned with the Reuters logo and had "TV" written on it in English, Arabic and Hebrew, witnesses said.
 
Seems to me that everything that the US and Israel impute to their enemies are in fact really object-inhibited admissions of precisely what it is they are doing.
"They are using human shields" = "We are using human shields."
"Hezbullah is a terrorist organization that has no respect for life" = "We are a terrorist organization... etc etc"

There's a remarkable symmetry to all the vicious little settler state`s pronouncements. The guilty always confess.
 
The great and powerful South African Defence Force was beaten in Cuito Cuanavale in Angola in 1988. It was a seminal moment in the history of that continent.
This victory was more than a military one, it destroyed the invincibility myth surrounding Apartheid.
Maybe Hezbollah`s victory in Lebanon can be their Cuito Cuanavale moment.
Namibia gained much within one year, Nelson Mandela was freed the following year and the vicious South African form of Apartheid fell in the next three years.
Here`s to the death knell of Apartheid Zionism.
 
The great and powerful South African Defence Force was beaten in Cuito Cuanavale in Angola in 1988. It was a seminal moment in the history of that continent.
This victory was more than a military one, it destroyed the invincibility myth surrounding Apartheid.
Maybe Hezbollah`s victory in Lebanon can be their Cuito Cuanavale moment.
Namibia gained much within one year, Nelson Mandela was freed the following year and the vicious South African form of Apartheid fell in the next three years.
Here`s to the death knell of Apartheid Zionism.
Hezbollah didn't win a damn thing, Israel lost it due to Olmert's reluctance to commit forces until it was too late. The next PM won't make that mistake.

Sorry demon, your dreams of a second holocaust won't come to fruition.
 
Wildcat:
"Sorry demon, your dreams of a second holocaust won't come to fruition."

Well, as if to prove a point!

I`d say your wet dreams of the perpetuation of a vicious little apartheid state and its fondness for ethnic cleansing and the continuation of the terrorism that gave birth to it from a poisonous womb might not come true.

As I said a few posts back, there's a remarkable symmetry to all the vicious little settler state`s (I should have added their vicious little supports too) pronouncements. The guilty always confess.

(According to you Zionist ass lickers, one minute I`m a holocaust denier, the next minute I`m calling for a second one in which case how am I a holocaust denier? Makes about as much sense as your purile and ill researched garbage about Afghanistan. You twats really ought to get your act together)
 
Last edited:
Wildcat:
"Sorry demon, your dreams of a second holocaust won't come to fruition."

Well, as if to prove a point!

I`d say your wet dreams of the perpetuation of a vicious little apartheid state and its fondness for ethnic cleansing and the continuation of the terrorism that gave birth to it from a poisonous womb might not come true.

As I said a few posts back, there's a remarkable symmetry to all the vicious little settler state`s (I should have added their vicious little supports too) pronouncements. The guilty always confess.

(According to you Zionist ass lickers, one minute I`m a holocaust denier, the next minute I`m calling for a second one in which case how am I a holocaust denier? Makes about as much sense as your purile and ill researched garbage about Afghanistan. You twats really ought to get your act together)
Considering the over 1 million Arab muslim citizens of Israel, they're doing a pretty piss-poor job of ethnic cleansing and apartheid.

But reality is foreign to you, isn't it?
 
"But reality is foreign to you, isn't it?"

Says the guy who supports a war based on lies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom