Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

Interesting post, we tend to hear more about NZs lack of military strength in terms of running down the NZAF and backing out of ANZUS then we do about the actual commitments of NZ. That said, I do remember hearing about the NZ SAS being on the ground in Afghanistan.


Things are not great. :) Defence spending is incredibly low (less than 1% GDP) and because things are quite good here (lowest unemployment in decades) the armed forces can't actually fill the few positions they have (Our Maritime Patrol Squadron has only six aircraft, but only three sets of aircrew!)

It's not so much to do with the quality of our forces, but the complete absence of essential elements.

Our SAS is considered exceptional - it has been widely accepted for years that we produce the best combat trackers in the world, making us very useful in Afghanistan.

Our light infantry, likewise, are considered amongst the best in the world (but they only consist of two battalions)

Our strike pilots, when we had them, pulled off exceptional performance despite ageing equipment. (Our ancient A4s got through the USN's advance defences time and time again in our last exercise :p)

Our problem is more the things we don't have at all - like air strike capabilities (God help us if we have to deal with a 9/11), or reliable helicopters, or decent anti-armour abilities, or sufficient ships to protect our enormous coastline and exclusive economic zone (we have only two frigates (no larger ships) but the 4th largest EEZ in the world!).

ANZUS is a sticking point here in New Zealand, and it's something I could see changing. To be fair, New Zealand never pulled out of ANZUS. The policy of our government (refusing entry of US ships) resulted in the US suspending its obligations to New Zealand until such time as we let them back in.

It's a bit of a tragic mythology here - the Labour Party that created the policy claimed they won the election based on their nuclear-free stance, however this is complete fiction. In fact at the time the majority of NZers were opposed to banning US Ships.

But over the years it has become a sort of urban legend here, and the younger generations genuinely believe we "stood up to the US".

But New Zealand is facing an energy crisis, and more and more people are quietly whispering "nuclear" so I am hopeful that in my lifetime the ANZUS Treaty can be revived.

-Andrew
 
When they start whispering, "nucular," you have my permission to do all the standing-up-to-the-US you want.
 
Is Hydro not enough for you?


Nope. :( We've run out of rivers, and they're in the driest part of the country. Low rainfall = low power. A few years ago we had rolling blackouts in our largest city as a result.

The problem is all the "eco" solutions actually have a worse impact on the environment than a nuclear power station.

-Andrew
 
Will Hezbollah or Lebanon be mourning innocents killed in Israel?

Not the innocent Jews, because they're infidels and are supposed to die, according to Allah. Lebanon's PM has already publicly expressed regret and mourning for the Arab Muslim children killed in the attacks on Israel.

And how come all the outrage when Israel accidentally kills innocents, but none when Hezbollah on purpose kills innocents.

Come on. Hezbollah is only fulfilling Allah's mandate that faithful Muslims show no mercy on and destroy all infidels. They befriend them not. Why in Allah's name would they mourn the deaths of infidels? They eat, live, and breathe to see those deaths come about. Their status as children means nothing. They are infidels.

Please understand that there is no such thing as human rights in radical Islam. There is only Allah's will. He's a mean son of a bitch. He's meaner than the Old Testament God, and that's saying a hell of a lot.

AS
 
The topic is misleading.
If Israel is targeting civilians, then it should happen on daily basis not once in a while.
Look at the effect world wide, If Israel wants to carry out their offencives, they better try to stay out of this.
For Hezballa it is a trick to get free of heavy attacks, just remember that.
 
varwoche -- whatever...
:confused:

It's not my mission to become a fulltime webfusion debunker, however I have noticed that a great many of your posts are not based on facts and credible evidence but rather wishful thinking of a high order.
 
So, where was the ourage about thousands of civilian dead in Kosovo? Surely we expected better from our friends?

If you're thinking of the NATO air campaign there were at the time certainly both vocal opposition to the attacks when they occured and considerable concern about the civilian casualties they caused.

There were also significantly less civilian casualties in the NATO air campaign than in the current Israeli attack on Southern Lebanon, and NATO made a much better job of explaining to the purpose of their attacks and regretting the civilan casualties to the public then than the IDF is doing now-- a not insignificant factor in preventing outrage. (One of the main reasons why I am so concerned about Israel's behaviour in Lebanon is that I fail to see any direct military value of many of the Israeli attacks, and the IDF is not talking. Where NATO during the Kosovo campaign seemed genuinely concerned about civilian casualties, the IDF appears entirely defensive on the subject.)
 
(Leif)

There is an issue of magnitude -- Israel's recent actions has caused much greater civilian suffering than Hezbollah's.

(New Ager)

Over the years, I don't know that's true, but again, their's was an accident and Hezbollah targets innocents.
 
If you're thinking of the NATO air campaign there were at the time certainly both vocal opposition to the attacks when they occured and considerable concern about the civilian casualties they caused.


I believe Skeptic was responding to the lack of outrage against attacks by Hizbollah and Hamas... Someone responded by saying Israel was a modern western state so they should behave better.

So Skeptic brought up the ethnic clensing in Kosovo.

I'd like to point out that during the Bosnian war both Muslims and Croats were carrying out massacres, but the western media focused on the acts carried out by the Croats, preferring to portray Muslims as innocent victims. It was very biased.

-Andrew
 
I thought it was the serbs doing most of the massacring, with the croats and muslims also rans.


I'm not sure what the "tallies" for who did the most, I just know at the time massacres by muslims were ignored, but massacres against muslims were covered well.

The muslims even caught onto this and would shell their own people when the UN were around.

-Andrew
 
:confused:

It's not my mission to become a fulltime webfusion debunker, however I have noticed that a great many of your posts are not based on facts and credible evidence but rather wishful thinking of a high order.


Debunker?

Let's go to the videotape.

Page 1
Post #12 --- some cynical humor.

Post #14 --- Link, with a factual statement. (A reference to the investigative method of James Randi).

Post #39 -- Quoted a major media source quoting Israeli soldiers on the ground complaining about not enough IAF force being utitlized.

Page 2

Post #43 - I offered an unsubstantiated note about the 'modus operandi' of Hezbollah transferring munitions and their fighters in vehicles within the fleeing convoys. My statement here would seem to be a credible evaluation of the facts, even though I offered no links, or sources. Oh well...

Then, my reply to TF asking: "what level of lebanese deaths would cause you to say stop?"

  • 48,217.
    (For good measure, I'll go ahead and make that to include Palestinians in Gaza)

    The combat action against Hezbollah and HAMAS will continue until the release of Goldwasser, Regev and Shalit.

Seemed to me a fair reply. It follows the known facts...

Post #46, a brief exchange with a_u_p:
You know there is no chance they will be released now.
webfusion: How do I know this?

(no answer)

Post #50 -- Facts, links and quotes.

Post #52 -- Introduced the Code Name of the renewed IDF ops in gaza: Samson's Pillars. Brought forward a quote by Saeb Erekat.
(failed to include a Reuters link -- my bad?)

Post #72 -- Clarified a misconception about who attacked whom on July 12th.

I also made this statement:
It has all been coordinated and planned from Damascus and Tehran.
Not my opinion. This is something that is voiced and repeated from the White House to Downing Street London. Debunk those sources, varwoche.

Post #81 -- pictures of Islamic fundamentalists in action. Hard reality.

Post #86 -- some levity and some beauties.

Post #96 -- Reply to A-U-P's remark that "The Lebanese are not Hezbollah" -- I made a (linked) reference to a poll conducted by the Beirut Center for Research and Information. This brought about a few juicy exchanges on page three of this thread about the scientific methodology and even the existence of such a poll (by Pardalis)

I finally brought that sidetrack to a happy conclusion in Post # 126 -- "Why you would not be perfectly satisfied with the source I offered is a mystery to me. Am I well-known to just make stuff up here on JREF? No. I'm probably one of the more scrupulous providers of sources and website links to almost every piece of information I provide. You will notice that a large percent of my posts have blue links in them."
That was my remark at the time.

Oh, BTW, at the top of page 4 --
A fact and a link.

Post #131 -- A semi-rant. Nothing to 'debunk' here.
"Israel will win. No matter what the cost to Lebanon's or to Gaza's populations --- that is the bottom line."

Post #135 -- A comment about what is commonly perceived to be true:
"The road to a cease-fire and the return of Goldwasser, Regev (and Shalit) leads through ----- Damascus." and I offered a link to a report which lends credibility to this!
  • Abu Marzuk participated in a meeting Wednesday in Damascus between leaders of Hamas and Islamic Jihad with Iranian chief nuclear negotiator Ali Larijani.

Post #138 -- Continuation of that point.

Post # 151 -- Some personal insights (in response to AmateurScientist).
Nothing to 'debunk' here, either.

Post # 157 --- Introduced the first mention here on the thread of Qana tragedy. Offered link:
Defense Minister Amir Peretz has ordered an investigation of the incident.

Page 5.

Post #163 -- Some photos of youngsters parading for Hezbollah.
Offered as illustrative of the participation of kids in the "jihad."
The challenge was made by Dustin that no evidence exists of kids firing AK-47's at IDF soldiers. While not absolute proof that they are doing so, it certainly is Evidence that it might be happening.

This whole sidetrack went on for a while longer... with me being flamed (by Dustin, no less) as 'delusional'
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1805927&postcount=165

and

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1805980&postcount=167

and varwoche coming to his "rescue", leading to my singular note:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1806215&postcount=177
"whatever"

Then before leaving Page 5, I posted a rebuttal to Pardalis in #180
which contained facts and cites (w/ links) and a bit of educated opinion.

And my opinion was disagreed with by Pardalis, but my offering it was appreciated and I made note of that...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1806344&postcount=186

Which concluded my series of posts here in this thread.

Now, on Page 6.
varwoche throws in :
Post #229
It's not my mission to become a fulltime webfusion debunker, however I have noticed that a great many of your posts are not based on facts and credible evidence but rather wishful thinking of a high order.

Is there any possible singular for me to write which is more appropriate than:
"whatever..." ???


============

eta fixing some links
 
Last edited:
Is there any possible singular for me to write which is more appropriate than:
"whatever..." ???


Evidence(s)?:p

Btw--You musn't let facts get in the way of a good story! AKA--deliberate propaganda designed to justify the continued appeasement of terrorists to and end that remains completely incomprehensible to me.:boggled:
 
(One of the main reasons why I am so concerned about Israel's behaviour in Lebanon is that I fail to see any direct military value of many of the Israeli attacks, and the IDF is not talking.

You share that opinion with many indignant armchair analysts, but if you thought about it instead of emoting (if that's a word), you would realize that a civilian population that allows its "soldiers" to bunker in their homes, while they feed them, is inevitably going to have casualties. As we have heard many times, they value their so called honor more than their children.

If you also paid more attention to the news you would hear plenty from the IDF, via their government, but you do what the so called Muslim world does. I'm sure you know what I mean.
 
Let's go to the videotape.
Interesting, the "videotape" fails to explain the very post that I commented on -- your post that links to an uncommented image from an unheard of website as if it constitutes credible evidence. Sort of like debate via rorschach.
 
You share that opinion with many indignant armchair analysts, but if you thought about it instead of emoting (if that's a word), you would realize that a civilian population that allows its "soldiers" to bunker in their homes, while they feed them, is inevitably going to have casualties. As we have heard many times, they value their so called honor more than their children.

And you share that opinion with many indignant armchair analysts.

Of course I'm an armchair analyst. This is a political discussion forum. We're all armchair analysts here.
 
And you share that opinion with many indignant armchair analysts.

Of course I'm an armchair analyst. This is a political discussion forum. We're all armchair analysts here.

I'm not the one pretending to analyse the IDF based on how little I know. You are.

It's obvious that Israel could have leveled all civilian area in Beirut and elsewhere if that was their objective. No doubt mistakes happen, no doubt some targets are sending a message, like the power station, but there is also no doubt that:

A) Israel doesn't want to invade and occupy and annex Lebanon.

B) It could all stop tomorrow if Hezbullah agreed to live in peace with Israel.

I feel sorry for all the Lebanese who didn't want this, but I also think they had to know it was coming one day and did nothing about it. The same goes for the do-nothing UN that have been there for how long?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom