Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

You are still ducking my "wiped off the map" post, it is one that is researched and substantiated, you owe it a decent reply.

I dont deny steroetypes exist, but where we seem to differ id that they exist on both sides.

Now, kindly address some of the points I have raised.
You are talking a lot about Hezbollah, and you are obviously following this thread right now so tell me, without any googling etc, what do you really know about them, let`s cut the propaganda...do you know any Lebanese? Any Palestinians? Do you know anything abut the daily life of a Palestinian?

You said in another post:

"Israel wants to stop the threat of being destroyed... "

Then continuing to steal a people's land and resources while holding them under lock and key is presumably just a reflection of that desire?

Just think about it.
 
I reposted where and when about the "wiping off the map thing". Why have you ignored it??

Quote:
Iran leader defends Israel remark

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4384264.stm
Quote:
Shouting "Death to Israel, death to the Zionists", the protesters dragged Israeli flags along the ground and then set them on fire.
Many carried posters and placards sporting the slogan "Israel should be wiped off the map".

Everyone knows this is preached to people over and over again. Do you deny that?

Why do you keep harping about "land stealing" when there are much bigger issues at hand? If people could live with each other, then they wouldn't care that they live beside each other.

I don't accuse neighbours who come from other countries of stealing land. I don't care where they came from, where they now live, or what dirt they occupy while they live.

This fixation on who is on what dirt is only part of the issue. The fixation is part of the scapegoating.

Jews steal land. Jews rape children. Jews are sons of dogs. Keep chanting these hate causing statements demon. You become part of the problem.
 
Last edited:
"You figure Bin Laden is a cute putty tat"

Evidence for that?
Can you at this moment repeat anything I`ve ever said about bin Laden?

Stop the crap and give us the evidence ok?
 
"Everyone knows this is preached to people over and over again. Do you deny that?"

Oh for crying out loud, I addressed this exact point in my prevoius post, with special referenece to the BBC...did you even bother to read it? Or did you just decide to ignore it because it cuts through the propaganda you are so concerned with?
Why won`t you address my post about the "wiped off the map" issue.
Quoting yet another BBC report about it is purile until you address my post, surely you can see that?
 
Last edited:
"Everyone knows this is preached to people over and over again. Do you deny that?"

This is getting very tedious...you gonna have to supply evidence for that claim...I just crucified Jocko on a similar claim when he said 99% of the world believed Iraq was a nuclear threat, at least he said 99%, you are saying "Everyone"...go read it and learn something about making generalizations.
 
do you know any Lebanese? Any Palestinians? Do you know anything abut the daily life of a Palestinian?


Keep denying what they are taught. Keep denying that they celebrated in the streets and burned the American flag when the two towers came down. Keep denying why Westerners and Jews are scapegoats.

I'm saying the wars wouldn't happen if the people weren't preached hate. I'm not saying ALL of them eat up the propanda. The ones that publicly state it IS propoganda get hunted down. That's sad.

My point is there will be no peace while hate is preached & taught and their own citizens cannot publicly denounce it. My point is that there is enough people who do believe the propaganda, and there are Bin Ladens out there, there are Mahmoud Ahmadinejads out there, and they have enough followers to keep causing needless war and deaths.

Nothing I've posted is untrue.

I'm just hoping that the folks that are my neighbours (and my son has a Pakastani Muslim friend who cannot eat pork and believes that a comatose pregnant mom kept alive on life support until the child is ready to be taken from the womb is horrific) are not disdainful of me for being a "westerner". My son's friend KNOWS he is more pious because he is not a pork eater and follows the other rules of his religious teachings.
 
Last edited:
"Everyone knows this is preached to people over and over again. Do you deny that?"

This is getting very tedious...you gonna have to supply evidence for that claim...I just crucified Jocko on a similar claim when he said 99% of the world believed Iraq was a nuclear threat, at least he said 99%, you are saying "Everyone"...go read it and learn something about making generalizations.


I already did. Just look up any muslim text or read the Koran. You just have to go into a mosque. Look at the links I already provided.

You haven't crucified anyone. You're just sitting there with your fingers in your ears and your eyes squeezed shut.
 
Are you ever going to supply any evidence?
So you are now claiming that Jocko was right too in his claim?
 
"I already did. Just look up any muslim text or read the Koran."

Tell me where in the Quran it says that all Americans and Jews or Israelis must die.
"Any muslim text"...unlike you, I have quite a few "muslim texts" (I prefer to call them books actually), sitting on my book shelves right now, that I`ve actually taken the time to read...none of them call for the killing of jews, Israelis or Americans.
Which ones have you read? Titles, authors...all would be helpful at this point...shouldn`t be hard for you since "any muslim text" and the Quran state it right?
You have read the Quran I take it?
Put up or shut up.
 
I have held the Koran, and read parts of it. You apparently haven't. The jews are "unbelievers". The christians are "unbelievers". Keep that in mind when you read it.

You also aren't aware of all the hoop jumping Bin Laden, the Iranian leader and the Hezbollah leader have jumped through to justify their actions with the help and guidance of their esteemed clerics. Bin Laden has publicly issued his warning for unbelievers to convert to Islam. He now can say whatever we have coming to us is our own fault.

You haven't put up anything to actually prove that the Iranian leader and Hezbollah are full of good intentions.

Go ahead, your turn to put up or shut up.
 
Last edited:
One thing at a time.
"All muslim texts" and the Quran...call for the deaths of all Americans, Jews and Israelis if I remember your claim correctly.

Now, be so good as to provide evidence of that and then we can move on.

"The jews are "unbelievers". The christians are "unbelievers"."

That sort of don`t cut it if you know what I mean. That`s not calling for the deaths of anyone.
Forget about "pork eaters" and your son`s Pakistani friends who believe horrific things, I have western friends who believe going to war based on lies is a good thing so let`s leave that out of the equation.

You have made some very specific claims...now whenever you are ready, some evidence would be nice.
 
One thing at a time.
"All muslim texts" and the Quran...call for the deaths of all Americans, Jews and Israelis if I remember your claim correctly.

Now, be so good as to provide evidence of that and then we can move on.

"The jews are "unbelievers". The christians are "unbelievers"."

That sort of don`t cut it if you know what I mean. That`s not calling for the deaths of anyone. Forget about "pork eaters" and your son`s Pakistani friends who believe horrific things, I have western friends who believe going to war based on lies is a good thing so let`s leave that out of the equation.

You have made some very specific claims...now whenever you are ready, some evidence would be nice.
Why are you shooting yourself in the foot? Unbelievers can be treated as second class citizens, and pay an extra tax, under some Muslim legal prededents. Apostates apparently can't. Between theory and practice, however, there are plenty of parties, Muslim Brotherhood for example, who don't mind killing unbelievers at all if it furthers their ends. Whether or not their decision to do so is doctrinally pure has less to do with Islam, and Holy Texts, than their using the banner of Islam as their banner in whatever political struggle they are undertaking.

Al Quran was published long before there was an America, or a recreated state of Israel, so your strawman of seeking confirmation of your opponents argument in a Muslim text -- the primal Muslim Holy Book (doctrinal manual if you will) -- is displaced in time, and a waste of an argument.

The key matter of the last 50-60 years regarding Israel and the Muslim world is the proclamation and commentaries of a variety of Muslim Leaders, Islamic Scholars, jurists and commentators -- to include the Ayatollah Khomeni -- as well as political leaders. Also, the actions of the Arab League must be taken into account.

A modest example: In the mid 1980's, there was a Morrocan junior officer on our ship for some training exercises. He was not allowed to leave the ship when in port in Israel, due to his nation still being in a state of war with Israel. (This came to us from USDAO at the time.)

The 1973 Yom Kippur War was an attempt to over run Israel, not merely "restore occupied terriroty from 1967." That latter was a subordinate goal to the former. That was was a case study we did in Staff College about 12 years ago, back when people used paper and books to do research, and Mosaic was a very new search engine. Ya know, the stone ages.

Is the rhetoric from Teheran playing to the home crowd, hot air, playing to the Muslim street, the Arab street, or is it a statement of policy? Given the political nature of any of these utterances, I'd take any assessment with a grain of salt and answer "all of the above." The wiped off the map sound byte article you posted was most interesting, thanks.

President Ahmadinejad's interview with the German Stern Magazine was enlightening: he returned to this point once or twice: if the State of Israel was set up in recompense for the Holocaust, (a debatable point) or other European actions against Jews, why wasn't it set up somewhere in Europe? Sounds like an interesting point to argue, but it is irrelevant, since the world moves forward with time.

But the same question President A asked was being asked by local Arab leaders in the 1920's and 1930's, before there was any WW II and Jews-in-the-oven-action. The simple answer was that the parcel of land was seen as the property of an Imperium, Ottoman, and having lost it to other Iimperial bodies -- French and Brit -- the new owners could dispose of it as they chose to. So, the Brits disposed of it as they saw fit, and it led them to much heartache.

Given a considerable antipathy to Jews in much of Europe, this approach was likely seen as a rational way to purge their societies of Jews without pogroms and genocide, at the policy level. Funny old thing, though, a lot of European Jews didn't want to move back to "mother Israel." So, President A's rhetorical question goes back to the historical irriation at the existence of Israel in what is selectively portrayed as Arab land. OK, given that it was the property of the Ottomoan Empire for some 400 years or so . . . whose calendar do we need to use to give Israel back to Turkey? :D

DR
 
Do you know anyone living along the seaboard in Lebanon right now? I do. A beautiful coastline...the ecological disaster that Isreal has let loose on that part of the Mediterranean is awful. It`s a disaster down there and who gives a ****? No one `cause it`s Isreal..
If Hezbollah had blown up those power stations we would never have heard the end of it....now that would not be a mistake.

I-S-R-A-E-L.

If you are gonna spend so much time bashing us, at least learn to spell it correctly.

BEIRUT, 22 August (IRIN) - Israeli assurances of safe passage to representatives of the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) on Monday mean work can finally begin on clearing up a massive oil spill along 150km of Lebanon's 225km coastline.

The Israelis are doing something.
The UNEP is doing something.
At an international meeting in Greece convened by the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) and UNEP on 17 August, a plan was agreed to clean up the oil spill.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/5260186.stm

So, your remark that "no one" gives a **** is baseless, demon.


As for the idea that the President of Iran is not a proponent of 'destroying Israel' -- well, I think that it would be most unwise, at this point, to give him any opportunity at all. I do not really wish to to discover if he does mean what he says. By the time his words are put into actions, it will be too late.
http://www.jewishmag.com/104mag/iran/iran.htm
In an interview with Iranian state television's Arabic-language satellite channel, Al-Alam, on December 8, 2005, Ahmadinejad referred to Israel as a "tumor"

and

Ali Ramim, a senior advisor to Ahmadinejad, told students during a visit to the town of Rasht in Iran that, "Jews are a filthy people, and that is why they have been accused throughout history of spreading deadly disease and plagues."


Now, your main point in this thread, demon, has been to say the islamic jihadists and their supporters, are anomalies.

Wish it were so.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I-S-R-A-E-L.
Now, your main point in this thread, demon, has been to say the islamic jihadists and their supporters, are anomalies.

Wish it were so.
"Being an anomaly" is irrelevant. It only took a few dedicated lads to pull off a rather spectacular set of aircraft crashes. Some anomalies are more troubling than others. A vigorous minority tends to pull a majority along with it. Lenin comes to mind.

That Tsunami that hit Indonesia was an anomaly too. Wow, a few hundred thousand worth of anomaly. :eek:

DR
 
Apologies for mispelling Israel Web.

You call "allowing safe passage" to the required workers clearing up the oil spill as "doing something"? According to your BBC link Israel weren't even at the IMO meeting in Pireas. Under international law the poluter should pay for the damage but this looks like the rest of the international community is going have to stump up the £34M.
 
Lebanon: Destruction of civilian infrastructure

First-hand information gathered by recent Amnesty International research missions to Lebanon and Israel points to an Israeli policy of deliberate destruction of Lebanese civilian infrastructure during the recent conflict.

Destruction
The long-term impact of the destruction of Lebanon’s infrastructure on the lives of the country’s men, women and children is incalculable. Many have lost their homes while having to cope with the deaths of loved ones or struggling to overcome severe injuries. Many more have lost their livelihoods. Records showing home and property ownership have been destroyed, adding to the difficulties of rebuilding lives.
...
Civilian victims
Entire families were killed in air strikes on their homes or in their vehicles while fleeing the aerial assaults on their villages. Scores lay buried beneath the rubble of their houses for weeks, as the Red Cross and other rescue workers were prevented from accessing the areas by continuing Israeli strikes. The hundreds of thousands of Lebanese who fled the bombardment now face the danger of unexploded munitions as they head home.

The Israeli Air Force launched more than 7,000 air attacks on about 7,000 targets in Lebanon between 12 July and 14 August, while the Navy conducted an additional 2,500 bombardments. The attacks, though widespread, particularly concentrated on certain areas. An estimated 1,183 people died, about one third of whom have been children, 4,054 people were injured and 970,000 Lebanese people have been displaced.
http://web.amnesty.org/pages/lbn-230806-feature-eng

0.86E%21OpenElement&FieldElemFormat=jpg
 
Web, your "Jewishmag" link contains a picture of Ahmadinejad in a Nazi uniform. Are we really meant to take it seriously? I`m sure if I put up a link with a picture of Bush or Blair or Olmert in a Nazi uniform it would be disregarded immediately.

Here is more from Fern Sidman:
Disregard world opinion and crush Lebanon by Fern Sidman
http://cc.msnscache.com/cache.aspx?q=3909885513617&lang=en-GB&mkt=en-GB&FORM=CVRE3
(Voice of Judea)

Also from the Voice of Judea, a petition:

"We the udersigned urge the Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmart to remove the Kahane organizations from Israel's list of terrorist groups. Noble Jewish defenders who have never been involved with terrorism should be rewarded and not punished."

(Note, the mispelling of Olmert`s name is not mine!)

The Kahane organisations are terrorist by offical designation (US and Israeli governments) and actions
http://cc.msnscache.com/cache.aspx?q=3970864648740&lang=en-GB&mkt=en-GB&FORM=CVRE10

The translator in the article, Nazila Fathi of The New York Times' Tehran bureau, produced the only translation of Ahmadinejad saying anything like Israel must be wiped off the map.

All Grade A material, indeed.
 
Eos:
"Why do you keep harping about "land stealing" when there are much bigger issues at hand? If people could live with each other, then they wouldn't care that they live beside each other.
I don't accuse neighbours who come from other countries of stealing land. I don't care where they came from, where they now live, or what dirt they occupy while they live.
This fixation on who is on what dirt is only part of the issue. The fixation is part of the scapegoating.
Jews steal land. Jews rape children. Jews are sons of dogs. Keep chanting these hate causing statements demon. You become part of the problem."


This comparison is wrong in so many respects, I can only imagine you're being deliberately provocative. You don't really think there is any sort of comparison between what the Palestinians suffered and what you would experience if immigrants moved in next door?

That's right everyone! How dare anyone keep "harping about" stealing land, killing people, destroying homes, starving them, destroying their crops and olive groves, killing little kids, stealing their water, shooting at and killing international peace campaigners and journalists. Those are the minor issues eh?
Er... What exactly are the big issues again? I must have missed that bit. What exactly are the bigger issues if not about killing people and robbing their land?
 
Last edited:
"Being an anomaly" is irrelevant. It only took a few dedicated lads to pull off a rather spectacular set of aircraft crashes. Some anomalies are more troubling than others. A vigorous minority tends to pull a majority along with it. Lenin comes to mind.

That Tsunami that hit Indonesia was an anomaly too. Wow, a few hundred thousand worth of anomaly. :eek:

DR

Ditto Bush and Cheney. The coming elections should be interesting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom