Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

What propaganda have I been brought up on?
Would you like to tell me how Hezbollah are going to destroy a nuclear superpower like Israel?
And why you are describing all these enemies who want to "wipe Israel off the map", maybe you would you like like to define "what Israel" we are talking about here. Israel seems to have some problems defining just how much land it intends to steal and keep...help me out.
 
Read the links in the post above yours. That should answer all your questions.

Make Israel the bad guys. Hezbollah is doing a GREAT job of that. There is more than one way to wipe someone off the planet.

Review Israel's objectives. Then get back to us. Make sure you read WHY. Israel has no intention of taking over Lebanon. There's no sense in telling Lebanese citizens that, but Hezbollah does. Why don't you ask yourself why?

Then read this, all of it. It's what is taught to all children in all the countries full of people that despise us, not just Saudi Arabia.
 
Last edited:
Your links do not answer my questions at all I`m afraid.
Oh my, you have ABC news, I have something a little more authoratitive.
I don`t know why I`m wasting my time on you but we`ll see.

If you do a search on the BBC website using the words "wiped off the map", out of 21 results over 3 pages, 15 articles refer to Iranian President Ahmadinejad and his "call" for Israel to be "wiped off the map".

Do you have any idea where the BBC (or ABC for that matter) got the phrase "wiped off the map"? Considering the BBC has its own Farsi speaking journalists and translators one would presume that these would have translated Ahmadinejad's speech. Did this phrase emanate from Farsi translators working for the BBC or was it "lifted" from the NYT? ( http://www.nytimes.com/2005/10/30/we...0c6a&ei=5 070 )

I ask this, you see, because MEMRI (the Middle East Media Research Institute), gives this as the correct translation: ""'Imam [Khomeini] said: 'This regime that is occupying Qods [Jerusalem] must be eliminated from the pages of history.' This sentence is very wise. The issue of Palestine is not an issue on which we can compromise."
http://memri.org/bin/articles.cgi?Pa...sd&ID=SP101305

This sentence comes immediately after 4 paragraphs which when taken together belie the BBC translaton.

""'When the dear Imam [Khomeini] said that [the Shah's] regime must go, and that we demand a world without dependent governments, many people who claimed to have political and other knowledge [asked], 'Is it possible [that the Shah’s regime can be toppled]?'

"'That day, when Imam [Khomeini] began his movement, all the powers supported [the Shah's] corrupt regime… and said it was not possible. However, our nation stood firm, and by now we have, for 27 years, been living without a government dependent on America. Imam [Khomeni] said: 'The rule of the East [U.S.S.R.] and of the West [U.S.] should be ended.' But the weak people who saw only the tiny world near them did not believe it.

"'Nobody believed that we would one day witness the collapse of the Eastern Imperialism [i.e. the U.S.S.R], and said it was an iron regime. But in our short lifetime we have witnessed how this regime collapsed in such a way that we must look for it in libraries, and we can find no literature about it.

"'Imam [Khomeini] said that Saddam [Hussein] must go, and that he would be humiliated in a way that was unprecedented. And what do you see today? A man who, 10 years ago, spoke as proudly as if he would live for eternity is today chained by the feet, and is now being tried in his own country... "

As you can see from this translation the previous paragraphs talked about various regimes: the Shah's regime, the Communist regime in USSR, and Saddam Hussein, all examples of apparently invincible regimes that ceased to exist. They weren't "wiped off the map" (although the US is giving it a good shot in Iraq!)

University of Michigan history professor Juan Cole also translated the phrase and argued in a private, off-the-record email group that the "wiped off the map" translation was wrong:

"I object to the characterization of Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad as having "threatened to wipe Israel off the map." I object to this translation of what he said on two grounds. First, it gives the impression that he wants to play Hitler to Israel's Poland, mobilizing an armored corps to move in and kill people. But the actual quote, which comes from an old speech of [Ayatollah] Khomeini, does not imply military action, or killing anyone at all.

The second reason is that it is just an inexact translation. The phrase is almost metaphysical. He quoted Khomeini that "the occupation regime over Jerusalem should vanish from the page of time." It is in fact probably a reference to some phrase in a medieval Persian poem. It is not about tanks."

Cole then goes on to state: "The phrase he then used as I read it is "The Imam said that this regime occupying Jerusalem (een rezhim-e ishghalgar-e qods) must [vanish from] from the page of time (bayad az safheh-ye ruzgar mahv shavad)." Ahmadinejad was not making a threat, he was quoting a saying of Khomeini and urging that pro-Palestinian activists in Iran not give up hope-- that the occupation of Jerusalem was no more a continued inevitability than had been the hegemony of the Shah's government. Whatever this quotation from a decades-old speech of Khomeini may have meant, Ahmadinejad did not say that "Israel must be wiped off the map" with the implication that phrase has of Nazi-style extermination of a people. He said that the occupation regime over Jerusalem must be erased from the page of time. Again, Ariel Sharon erased the occupation regime over Gaza from the page of time."
http://www.juancole.com/2006/05/hitc...-hitchens.html

As you can see both the MEMRI translation and Juan Cole's are virtually identical and make no mention of Israel being "wiped off the map".

Iranian officials have also challenged the translation:

Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki during a Feb. news conference:
"Mottaki also denied during a press conference in Brussels that Tehran wanted to see Israel "wiped off the map."
"Nobody can remove a country from the map. This is a misunderstanding in Europe of what our president mentioned," he said. "How is it possible to remove a country from the map? He is talking about the regime. We do not recognize legally this regime."
http://www.forward.com/main/article....man20060223131

Ambassador Ali Asghar Soltanieh on CNN on 02 April 2006:
"BLITZER: But should there be a state of Israel?
SOLTANIEH: I think I've already answered to you. If Israel is a synonym and will give the indication of Zionism mentality, no.
But if you are going to conclude that we have said the people there have to be removed or we they have to be massacred or so, this is fabricated, unfortunate selective approach to what the mentality and policy of Islamic Republic of Iran is. I have to correct, and I did so."
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIP.../02/le.01.html

I accept that translations are a tricky business. I`ve lived in many countries and have friends who translate all the time. But there is no denying that those with political agendas can selectively choose translations to obscure the big picture and manipulate the media.

People should understand that they should be extra careful with translations pushed by those who are behind the White House agenda to dishonestly paint the Iranian government as irrational, a blatant attempt at "shaping" public opinion in order to fast-track us to war.
Everyone should insist that the the translations should be honestly reported and refrain from using blatant propaganda, if they ARE being honest in their intentions of course.
The speech in Persian is here:
http://www.president.ir/farsi/ahmadi...4sahyonizm.htm

Now, you want to talk to me about propaganda? That I`ve been brought up on? You still haven`t told me what that is.
 
Last edited:
AUP:
"Have you been reading Littlegreenfootballs?"

I suspected that too as I said in a previous post.
Sad.
 
Hizbollah has already said they were surprised at the reaction to the kidnappings and attacks. They didn't actually want a war.

When they got a war and then still allowed Lebanon to be pounded by the IDF without giving up their hostages to end it, they certainly demonstrated they didn't mind having a war.

No matter who paid the price.
 
More on this:

quote:
Sunday, August 27, 2006

Ahmadinejad: We are Not a Threat to Any Country, Including Israel

Believe it, don't believe it, that's up to you. But at least we should know what exactly he said, which is not something our US newspapers will tell us about Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's speech on Saturday:

Kayhan reports that [Pers.] Ahmadinejad said, "Iran is not a threat to any country, and is not in any way a people of intimidation and aggression." He described Iranians as people of peace and civilization. He said that Iran does not even pose a threat to Israel, and wants to deal with the problem there peacefully, through elections:

"Weapons research is in no way part of Iran's program. Even with regard to the Zionist regime, our path to a solution is elections."

Ahmadinejad seems to be explaining what his calls for the Zionist regime to be effaced actually mean. He says he doesn't want violence against Israel, despite its own acts of enmity against Middle Eastern neighbors. I interpret his statement on Saturday to be an endorsement of the one-state solution, in which a government would be elected that all Palestinians and all Israelis would jointly vote for. The result would be a government about half made up of Israeli ministers and half of Palestinian ones. Whatever one wanted to call such an arrangement, it wouldn't exactly be a "Zionist state," which would thus have been dissolved.

The schlock Western pundits, journalists and politicians who keep maintaining that Ahmadinejad threatened "to wipe Israel off the map" when he never said those words will never, ever manage to choke out the words Ahmadinejad spoke on Saturday, much less repeat them as a tag line forever after.

Supreme Jurisprudent Khamenei's pledge of no first strike against any country by Iran with any kind of weapon, and his condemnation of nuclear bombs as un-Islamic and impossible for Iran to possess or use, was completely ignored by the Western press and is never referred to. Indeed, after all that talk of peace and no first strike and no nukes, Khamenei at the very end said that if Iran were attacked, it would defend itself. Karl Vicks of the Washington Post at the time ignored all the rest of the speech and made the headline, 'Khamenei threatens reprisals against US." In other words, on Iran, the US public is being spoonfed agitprop, not news.

Although Iran's protestations of peaceful intentions are greeted cynically in the US and Israel, in fact Iran has not launched a war of aggression in over a century. The US and Israel have launched several during that period of time.

Ahmadinejad made the remarks in a speech inaugurating work on a heavy water nuclear reactor in Arak. I don't think that work is very advanced. The Iranians maintain that it is for peaceful energy generation.

Much of the electricity produced in France, South Korea and Japan is generated by nuclear plants.

posted by Juan @ 8/27/2006 06:36:00 AM
http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2006/08/27/18301167.php


Come on Eos, let`s hear your "thoughts". Your "thoughts" too, no one else`s and I`m still waiting for you analysis of the propaganda I was brought up with, you know the sort of propaganda that leads me to question the official line...some would call that "scepticism".
 
Last edited:
Yes, definitely scratch that idea, I'm sure the clue to geopolitical progress is to be found in measuring the skulls and serotonin levels of "terrorists" and realizing the gulf separating their human nature from ours.

Wow. You are so awesome at building straw-men, I am in amazement!

Imagine! Take EOS's claim that Hezbollah blames everything on Israel and turning into a claim that Hezbollah is genetically different from the rest of humanity. It takes balls to lie that blatantly.
 
On the one (mis)translation about pushing Israel off the face of the map.

Below is a conference poster from the "The World Without Zionism" conference where the quote originated. The graphic used in the conference seem to clearly support the "push Israel off the map" theme.

If Iran really intends to say something different, perhaps their artwork should more closely match their words too.

106144f29581aed30.jpg
 
More to the topic. Using cluster bombs in civilian areas was a mistake and should be investigated.
 
All this just still boils down to 'whoever holds the biggest stick'.

No rational thinking person would rush a pissed off, 7ft, 300lb UFC fighter who was wielding a baseball bat, armed only with a cotton-bud...

That's something only a fanatic terrorist, with a belief in an invisible being who lives in the sky, would do....

DB
 
"Using cluster bombs in civilian areas was a mistake"

Yes, always a mistake by our good allies isn`t it? Never a cynical plan, always a mistake.
Do you know anyone living along the seaboard in Lebanon right now? I do. A beautiful coastline...the ecological disaster that Isreal has let loose on that part of the Mediterranean is awful. It`s a disaster down there and who gives a ****? No one `cause it`s Isreal..
If Hezbollah had blown up those power stations we would never have heard the end of it....now that would not be a mistake.
 
Last edited:
Something I got in my email, that demon and unique ignore:

There can be no peace
- as long as the Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a best-seller in arab lands and widely believed as fact;
- as long as arab children are brought up to believe that jews are the sons of apes and dogs;
- as long as official imams can call for the murder of jews and the enslavement of jewish women;
- as long as the poverty and hopelessness of the arab/ muslim world is blamed on the west and on Israel;
- as long as an arab calling for peace with Israel is regarded as a criminal

As for Hamas, they have NEVER accepted the principle of Oslo (that Israel could exist) and in fact launched a wave of terrorist bombings after the Oslo announcement.

And we all know how this hits us:
http://www.fpri.org/fpriwire/0908.200110.garfinkle.sept11.html
Osama bin Laden hates the United States mainly for what it is, not for what it does. As he sees it, what it does is a natural consequence of what it is: decadent, immoral, materialistic, and sexually perverse.

The version of modern history that much of the Arab “street” believes after decades of government press-spawned disinformation is truly bizarre. It explains why Palestinians in Nablus danced to celebrate the terrorist strike of September 11, and why it has been hailed in the Egyptian and Syrian press.



I like how the liars tell the PRESS one thing, and their people another. Keep eating their lies demon, keep ignoring what they believe. Keep your head in the sand. I don't care.

http://changingworldviews.blogspot.com/2006/01/iran-is-ranting-death-to-america.html

Take it from their mouths, not what they preach to the press, but what they say all day long in schools and their mosques.

Iran leader defends Israel remark
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4384264.stm
Shouting "Death to Israel, death to the Zionists", the protesters dragged Israeli flags along the ground and then set them on fire.
Many carried posters and placards sporting the slogan "Israel should be wiped off the map".

Seriously. How can you ignore this??
 
Last edited:
"As for Hamas, they have NEVER accepted the principle of Oslo (that Israel could exist) and in fact launched a wave of terrorist bombings after the Oslo announcement."

Just to take that one point...you obviously know absolutely nothing about what happened after Oslo.

But before we move on to that, how about addressing my post about the "wiped off the map" issue.
What are your thoughts on that? Note how I say "YOUR" thoughts.
 
Last edited:
Have you been reading Littlegreenfootballs?
I have no idea what that is. I've just been watching all this since I was a kid. Who has thwarted peace all along? Who believes all Americans need to die? Until these warmongers stop leading people people into Jihad, then we'll see no peace.

I can't believe you think Israel should lie down and take it. I'm glad they have reduced Hizbollah's threat.
 
"Who has thwarted peace all along? Who believes all Americans need to die? Until these warmongers stop leading people people into Jihad, then we'll see no peace."

Tell me who the warmongers are...who believes all Americans must die, show me the evidence about those who have thwarted peace all along.
 
"As for Hamas, they have NEVER accepted the principle of Oslo (that Israel could exist) and in fact launched a wave of terrorist bombings after the Oslo announcement."



But before we move on to that, how about addressing my post about the "wiped off the map" issue.
What are your thoughts on that? "Note how I say "YOUR" thoughts.

Fine, what is your take on Oslo?

My thoughts are that Israel is seen as evil stain on the map, and there are many many people who want to see the "children of dogs" off the land. They will continue to plot and fight and plan for Israel's demise, and hope and wish that Israel and all westerners die.

My thoughts are that there will never be peace until people stop believing that garbage and accept that people are different. Not everyone can be the same.

Racism and stereotypes will continue as along as people preach this hate to each other. Racism and stereotypes prevent peaceful coexistence.

Do you deny this?
 
"Who has thwarted peace all along? Who believes all Americans need to die? Until these warmongers stop leading people people into Jihad, then we'll see no peace."

Tell me who the warmongers are...who believes all Americans must die, show me the evidence about those who have thwarted peace all along.

I already did. Why didn't you read my posts? You figure Bin Laden is a cute putty tat, and that there is no such thing as Jihad? You figure the Iranian leader LOVES jews and Israel? You think the flag burnings don't happen? You don't think Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a best-seller?? You think suicide bombers aren't promised virgins and rivers of honey after they kill "evildoers"?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom