Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

So Israel invaded Lebanon before to get rid of Hizbollah, and it was this invasion (where they came in, got rid of Hizbollah, and left) that CREATED Hizbollah?

Um...

-Andrew

Sharon believed an invasion would solve Israel's problems in the North, and maybe even last, and let Israel expand.

As a result of that invasion, Hezbollah was created as a 'resistance'.
 
Sharon believed an invasion would solve Israel's problems in the North, and maybe even last, and let Israel expand.

As a result of that invasion, Hezbollah was created as a 'resistance'.


One minor little detail there. You've not mentioned the world "occupation". I think I made it clear my proposal was for Israel to go in, get rid of Hizbollah, and leave. Not to stay there for 18 years.

If Lebanon really wants peace with Israel it should be no issue for the two to work together to remove Hizbollah off the face of the earth and establish a lasting peace - Israel had no problem with doing this after Egypt attacked it during the Yom Kippur War.

Once Hizbollah is gone and Lebanon and Israel are at peace they don't need to occupy Lebanon.

This is an excellent way for each side to show their true colours. If Lebanon doesn't really want peace, they won't cooperate. If Israel really wants to occupy Lebanon, they won't leave.

This will then make it excellently clear to the UN which country is the problem, and the Security Council can pass a resolution authorising an international task force to destroy the problem country and give it to someone else.

Problem solved. Let's get started. First thing's first, a ceasefire agreement between Israel and Lebanon, and a treaty of co-operation between the Lebanese Government and the Israeli Government...

-Andrew
 
One minor little detail there. You've not mentioned the world "occupation". I think I made it clear my proposal was for Israel to go in, get rid of Hizbollah, and leave. Not to stay there for 18 years.

If Lebanon really wants peace with Israel it should be no issue for the two to work together to remove Hizbollah off the face of the earth and establish a lasting peace - Israel had no problem with doing this after Egypt attacked it during the Yom Kippur War.

Once Hizbollah is gone and Lebanon and Israel are at peace they don't need to occupy Lebanon.

This is an excellent way for each side to show their true colours. If Lebanon doesn't really want peace, they won't cooperate. If Israel really wants to occupy Lebanon, they won't leave.

This will then make it excellently clear to the UN which country is the problem, and the Security Council can pass a resolution authorising an international task force to destroy the problem country and give it to someone else.

Problem solved. Let's get started. First thing's first, a ceasefire agreement between Israel and Lebanon, and a treaty of co-operation between the Lebanese Government and the Israeli Government...

-Andrew

Great idea, but it's a little late for that now....
 
One minor little detail there. You've not mentioned the world "occupation". I think I made it clear my proposal was for Israel to go in, get rid of Hizbollah, and leave. Not to stay there for 18 years.

It's a well-organised militia with support in the local population. How do you propose to "get rid of it" if it doesn't want to be gotten rid of? Go around from house to house and arrest the ones wearing the offical Hezbollah decoding ring?

Yes, it's possible to "break the back" of the Hezbollah and destroy its capability to conduct significant attacks -- but even assuming that Israel manages to do this, how do you suggest they prevent the Hezbollah from reorganising and reforming without having a military presence in South Lebanon?

This will then make it excellently clear to the UN which country is the problem, and the Security Council can pass a resolution authorising an international task force to destroy the problem country and give it to someone else.

Frankly, I don't think an efficent international task force can be established today, with the reduced militaries of the NATO countries and the ever lessened focus on infantry troops. With the war in Iraq, even USA doesn't have the troops to spare (not that American troops would be a good diplomatic card to play, or that the US would want to get their troops involved with Lebanon again,) so what other nations are there that could realistically supply the UN with the necessary 20,000+ bodies?
 
Last edited:
It's a well-organised militia with support in the local population. How do you propose to "get rid of it" if it doesn't want to be gotten rid of? Go around from house to house and arrest the ones wearing the offical Hezbollah decoding ring?

Yes, it's possible to "break the back" of the Hezbollah and destroy its capability to conduct significant attacks -- but even assuming that Israel manages to do this, how do you suggest they prevent the Hezbollah from reorganising and reforming without having a military presence in South Lebanon?


Well, the innocent Lebanese want peace, right? So the Lebanese will prevent the return of Hizbollah, won't they? They do have their own armed forces...

I mean, surely the grounds for this war being wrong are that the Lebanese civilians don't support Hizbollah, isn't it? They're "innocent" right?



Frankly, I don't think an efficent international task force can be established today, with the reduced militaries of the NATO countries and the ever less focus on infantry troops.

I don't agree.

Timor-Leste is significantly larger than Lebanon, and Australia and New Zealand managed to successfully occupy the entire area and drive out Indonesia without too much trouble. Israel is less than 50% bigger than Timor-Leste.

I'm sure the combined efforts of the UN could hustle up enough troops to occupy Lebanon or Israel if necessary. Heck, New Zealand did most of the fighting in Timor-Leste and we only have ONE Infantry Regiment! (Okay, admittedly they are exceptionally good, but still...;) )

-Andrew
 
I mean, surely the grounds for this war being wrong are that the Lebanese civilians don't support Hizbollah, isn't it? They're "innocent" right?

It doesn't matter one whit wheter a civilian supports or opposed the Hezbollah, whether he supports or opposed attacks against Israel or even if he's a card carrying memner of the NRA. He's not a combatant, he is not a valid target and he is due protection. Political affiliation does not matter.

You're not seriously suggesting that it's okay to kill someone just because they hold the opinion that the Hezbollah are right, do you?

Timor-Leste is significantly larger than Lebanon, and Australia and New Zealand managed to successfully occupy the entire area and drive out Indonesia without too much trouble. Israel is less than 50% bigger than Timor-Leste.

That's hardly a comparable operation. An effective stabilisation force, with enough "bite" to efficently suppress the Hezbollah (and the other militias operating in the area) would require a large number of infantry for a large number of years, in a partially hostile environment where they would take losses. What with both Iraq and Afghanistan already soaking up "able bodies", I just don't see where the necessary soliders would come from.

I could be wrong -- I hope I am wrong, but I don't see enough nations willing to foot enough of a bill (both in terms of money and of blood) to put together a large enough force to actually work.
 
Last edited:
:eek:

Well, I wasn't meaning anything quite that blatant (is it genuine???)

Don't know, hope not.


but yeah, that kind of thing (I was actually specifically thinking of the Lebanese bringing a whole bunch of western journalists to take photos of a mass funeral etc...).

So. Your opinion on such matters?

-Andrew

Its not moral, but its what I would do if I was a terrorist organisation wanting to gain the moral high ground.

Hezbollah operating among civillians is a win-win situation for the group. Either Israel refrains from attacking for fear of hurting civillians or Hezbollah gets to moan about Israel attacking civillians.

I think they also gain in other ways. Hezbollah get the moral high ground locally by appearing to defend the civillians against Israel and from providing the social services that the Lebanes government can't.

At the moment Hezbollah have the best of both worlds. They aren't a government so Israel can't declare war on their country. On the other hand, they get a free reign to operate like a government in their own area.

As such it would be like the situation in Sri Lanka if the LTTE were also a part of the Sri Lankan government and were much more powerful than the Sri Lankan Army but didn't actually want full independence, but virulently hated the Indians (so actually its not exactly like the situation in Sri Lanka).

Off topic, but why doesn't Russia support the Israelis in this. Isn't it very much like what they did to the Chechnyans?
 
Timor-Leste is significantly larger than Lebanon, and Australia and New Zealand managed to successfully occupy the entire area and drive out Indonesia without too much trouble. Israel is less than 50% bigger than Timor-Leste.

I'm sure the combined efforts of the UN could hustle up enough troops to occupy Lebanon or Israel if necessary. Heck, New Zealand did most of the fighting in Timor-Leste and we only have ONE Infantry Regiment! (Okay, admittedly they are exceptionally good, but still...;) )

-Andrew

No, no. There weren't any NZers in East Timor. At least I don't remember seeing any on the Australian news.:)

Seriously, I don't think there was much coverage of their role at all. Maybe I just missed it, after all our news is never one sided.
 
Well, I'm assuming here that Israel actually means what it says when it says that these civilian casualties were inevitable and unintentional in their efforts to thwart the type of terrorism that would lead to even more deaths. As for civilians have only themselves to blame, I think that the world's a little more complicated than that. There are probably elderly and infirm people that are unable to evacuate, that have or will end up as civilian casualties but are still worth being publicly mourned, acknowledged, and remembered by Israeli leadership. I think that would apply even to the eccentric, the stubborn, and the foolish: it's still good PR and good policy, in the most cost-free of ways, to mourn their inadvertant deaths in the course of fighting terrorism.

Will Hezbollah or Lebanon be mourning innocents killed in Israel?

And how come all the outrage when Israel accidentally kills innocents, but none when Hezbollah on purpose kills innocents.
 
And how come all the outrage when Israel accidentally kills innocents, but none when Hezbollah on purpose kills innocents.

For three reasons.

There is an issue of magnitude -- Israel's recent actions has caused much greater civilian suffering than Hezbollah's.

There is an issue of debate -- Much of the traffic of posts that attack Israel's killing of civilians comes in the form of replies to posts that defend the Israeli actions. Nobody here is defending Hezbollah's killings of Israeli civilians, so naturally there is no traffic of replies counter to that position.

There is an issue of familiarity -- Israel is one of us. They're one of the good guys. A western, enlightened democracy; part of the North American/Western European cultural and political sphere. As such Israel's actions hit closer to home than Hezbollah's action does. (This is the same reason why terriorist attacks against Israelis get more attention in the West than does terrorist attacks against Iranians or Indonesians.) In additiona, humans are emotionally less forgiving of our friends than other people, because we expect better of our friends.
 
He's not a combatant, he is not a valid target and he is due protection. Political affiliation does not matter.


Absolutely. And if Israel is shown to be targetting non-combatants I will join you in condeming it and demanding those responsible are punished.

But also bear in mind it doesn't take much to turn a protected person or object into a legitimate target. If, for example, the enemy are storing weapons in a religious building, you are perfectly within your rights to bomb it.


You're not seriously suggesting that it's okay to kill someone just because they hold the opinion that the Hezbollah are right, do you?

No.


That's hardly a comparable operation.

Isn't it? When INTERFET went into Timor-Leste the Indonesian army were slaughtering thousands of civilians. Indonesia threatened INTERFET with the combined efforts of their armed forces - Air Force, Army, and Navy.



An effective stabilisation force, with enough "bite" to efficently suppress the Hezbollah (and the other militias operating in the area) would require a large number of infantry for a large number of years, in a partially hostile environment where they would take losses.


I believe the UN is currently talking about 20,000 troops.


What with both Iraq and Afghanistan already soaking up "able bodies", I just don't see where the necessary soliders would come from.

Iraq is primarily US forces, and there's no way the US would be involved in a UN operation, so that's irrelevant. Afghanistan and Timor-Leste have soaked up Australian and New Zealand forces, and Afghanistan has certainly tied up British forces and Canadian.

But there's still plenty to be provided. The French have ample forces, India has an enormous army. The Scandanavian states usually feature highly in UN operations, as do many Asian states like Malaysia. Germany might even get involved.

-Andrew
 
John Howard stated he would be prepared to send limited numbers of Australians to Lebanon if the overall force was over 10,000 and there was a mandate to disarm Hezbollah.

link

gumboot, do the Australians and NZers work together in East Timor and Afghanistan or do they have seperate mandates. Sorry for my ignorance about this.
 
John Howard stated he would be prepared to send limited numbers of Australians to Lebanon if the overall force was over 10,000 and there was a mandate to disarm Hezbollah.

link

gumboot, do the Australians and NZers work together in East Timor and Afghanistan or do they have seperate mandates. Sorry for my ignorance about this.

He has hardly got anyone left to send, and I have three teenage boys....
 
John Howard stated he would be prepared to send limited numbers of Australians to Lebanon if the overall force was over 10,000 and there was a mandate to disarm Hezbollah.


Noted that in our papers yesterday. :) I think that was the first suggestion of such a thing, and thought at the time it was throwing down the gauntlet to the UN. To be honest I was a little shocked to see them take it up.



gumboot, do the Australians and NZers work together in East Timor and Afghanistan or do they have seperate mandates. Sorry for my ignorance about this.


The New Zealand forces in East Timor are under direct Australian command. Our troops in Afghanistan have their own specific territory - Bamyan and Bagram airfield in Bamyan Province. They work with coalition forces and the local government, however they are fairly independent.

NZSAS, when they were in Afghanistan (I'm not sure what they're up to at the moment) operated very closely with SASR (Australian SAS) and American Special Forces. They were given a Presidential Unit Citation for their work.

New Zealand has a weird command structure. After World War One - and in particular Passchendael - we were so horrified by the scale of loss (more men per capita than any other participant in the war) that the NZ Government made special conditions for future NZ Forces. All NZ commanders reserve the right to withdraw our troops from any action which threatens New Zealand's interests, exceeds our mandate, or would result in unacceptable levels of NZ deaths.

This condition was used in World War Two when Freyberg withdrew our forces at the Battle of Monte Cassino.

This continues to this day - and although our forces are put under command of elements in the operation, our Chief of Defence Force has ultimate command over our forces via Commander Joint Forces New Zealand - my Father's boss.

In addition we have staff officers posted to the various commands - including Darwin for East-Timor and the Operation Enduring Freedom HQ in Florida.

-Andrew
 
He has hardly got anyone left to send, and I have three teenage boys....

Well he did say Australia would have a niche role as part of a large contingent with a strong mandate. It doesn't sound like he is itching to send many over.

Also, given obesity levels etc, I am not sure that the draft would work out.
 
The New Zealand forces in East Timor are under direct Australian command. Our troops in Afghanistan have their own specific territory - Bamyan and Bagram airfield in Bamyan Province. They work with coalition forces and the local government, however they are fairly independent.

snip

-Andrew

Interesting post, we tend to hear more about NZs lack of military strength in terms of running down the NZAF and backing out of ANZUS then we do about the actual commitments of NZ. That said, I do remember hearing about the NZ SAS being on the ground in Afghanistan.
 
There is an issue of familiarity -- Israel is one of us. They're one of the good guys. A western, enlightened democracy; part of the North American/Western European cultural and political sphere.

So, where was the ourage about thousands of civilian dead in Kosovo? Surely we expected better from our friends?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom