Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
More likely they are AAers trying to throw a lifeline that a recalcitrant drunk might find of use, and something that on calmer reflection is accepted as counter-productive. Like, damn, I wish I hadn't said that; I'll try to do better next time.

No, not so's you'd notice. The majority pretty much accept that a higher power can indeed be a door knob with a few saying it isn't their idea of a HP but "whatever works for you."

Another interesting thing that comes up often and is directly counter to what has been said in this thread is this:

That being said - my first point is that Alcoholics Anonymous shouldn't be judged by what gets said at meetings - but by what is written in official publications of AA.

http://adventureswithlarry.com/articles/article_doorknobs.php

This one, and there are many more, is making a case that AA is christian because that is what the official publications say.

It would seem that the only people who don't believe AA is religious are the three or four people who post here. :D
 
Creepy how the OP knew what we were thinking before even starting the thread.

That's because some of us have been working this argument for years (in an effort to separate AA from the Judicial and Medical communities) and know all your BS arguments before you even pull them out of your A...er...Hat.

GB
 
That's because some of us have been working this argument for years (in an effort to separate AA from the Judicial and Medical communities) and know all your BS arguments before you even pull them out of your A...er...Hat.
Seems like much effort for small reward if you agree with qayak that people who insist that AA is not religious are so few in number. Especially considering that AA is already separate from the Judicial and Medical communities.
 
It sounds like GB is on a cruisade. ;)

But if he were really trying to separate AA from the judical and medical communities, he would be lobbying them, not attacking the religiosity or otherwise of AA members on an anonymous internet forum. :confused:

Perhaps he could show us what he is doing where it actually counts.

If he does, which I doubt, could someone tell me please? - he is still on ignore. :)
 
AA does not make medical diagnoses though does it?
It (alcoholism) has many earmarks of a disease and the WHO states same. But we are going over old ground here; if you are going to make assertions about this so called connection, please provide evidence.
 
Last edited:
That's because some of us have been working this argument for years (in an effort to separate AA from the Judicial and Medical communities) and know all your BS arguments before you even pull them out of your A...er...Hat.

GB

I agree. It is almost impossible to make any real progress on the problem of alcoholism when all these lies are ingrained so deeply as truth. With AA as the poster child for recovery, we can rest assured that alcoholism will be with us for a very long time.
 
Which is surprising with all the claims AAers make about alcoholism being a disease.
If your bias and hostility toward AA is so severe as to have begun to result in delusions such as the notion that the disease theory of alcoholism originated with AA, I have good news: there IS a cure for that. It's called "Wikipedia".

The Scottish physician Thomas Trotter (1760–1832), was the first to characterize excessive drinking as a disease, or medical condition.[9]

The American physician Benjamin Rush (1745–1813) [...] argued that "habitual drunkenness should be regarded not as a bad habit but as a disease", describing it as "a palsy of the will".
 
Seems like much effort for small reward if you agree with qayak that people who insist that AA is not religious are so few in number. Especially considering that AA is already separate from the Judicial and Medical communities.

Actually the reward has been seeing that courts are increasingly striking down Judicially enforced AA attendance as a violation of the Separation Clause of the constitution, and that the Medical community has been increasingly distancing themselves from their cozy relationship with AA.

It's really appalling that you are so intellectually bereft that you can't even acknowledge the facts of reality.

Now, if we could just start making progress against Addiction Ideology, end the Drug Wars, and separate Puritanical Politicos from their undue influence of Drug Classifications and Over-zealously forcing the Medical community to adhere to their Puritan standards, we might REALLY start getting somewhere.

GB
 
Last edited:
Actually the reward has been seeing that courts are increasingly striking down Judicially enforced AA attendance as a violation of the Separation Clause of the constitution, and that the Medical community has been increasingly distancing themselves from their cozy relationship with AA.

Now, if we could just start making progress against Addiction Ideology, end the Drug Wars, and separate Puritanical Politicos from their undue influence of Drug Classifications and Over-zealously forcing the Medical community to adhere to their Puritan standards, we might REALLY start getting somewhere.

GB
You ever think about cutting back on the caffeine?
 
snigger

Actually I agree with GB here - in one respect anyway.
I do not believe the judiciary should be mandating AA attendance. It is a dereliction of the state's responsibility to punishment/rehabilitation, the responsibility of funding same, etc.

I also agree with Dynamic. And caffeine is also a drug. :D
 
If your bias and hostility toward AA is so severe as to have begun to result in delusions such as the notion that the disease theory of alcoholism originated with AA, I have good news: there IS a cure for that. It's called "Wikipedia".

AA has a SIN theory of Alcoholism, and adopted the term Disease to disguise their ideas. I've stated this from the beginning of my involvement with this thread.

I have also been very clear that the Disease Model of addiction is dubious as a BLANKET model for all "addictive" behaviour patterns, though it certainly has merit in some cases.

I for one, do not recall any posters on this thread claim that AA originated the Disease Model of addiction, rather that AA was the popularizer of their (pseudo)-Disease Model.

GB
 
You ever think about cutting back on the caffeine?

I hate Coffee, only occasionally drink caffeinated sodas, and occasionally weak tea. I don't like too much Caffeine; it makes me jittery. You know what they say about assumptions. :p

I have to say, given Alfie's Jekyll and Hyde routine, and his limited knowledge, I appreciate his acknowledgment that judicially enforced attendance of AA is problematic.

GB
 
The popularizer of whose pseudo-disease model?

I thought my sentence structure was very clear: "their" referring to AA. I don't like to assume, so I can only speculate that: 1) you're being disingenuous, or 2) that you have a reading comprehension problem. :p

GB
 
Correct GB! The dishonest & ineffective 'Sin' model of alcoholism - promoted for decades by AA as one their cornerstones - has been one of the primary things I most strongly object to - publicly, within the meetings themselves. It ties in with the entirety of the big book (other than the beginning chapter 'the doctor's opinion' , a chapter that becomes increasingly distanced as the book progresses from beginning to end, so that by the time one reads 'To Agnostics' the AA program is nearly fully god-based).
Of course, I don't expect True Believers to ever admit that, for a number of reasons we've mentioned elsewhere in this thread.
Good post, as usual GB!
 
I thought my sentence structure was very clear: "their" referring to AA. I don't like to assume, so I can only speculate that: 1) you're being disingenuous, or 2) that you have a reading comprehension problem.
I do sometimes have a reading comprehension problem. It often crops up when I encounter pronouns with missing referents.

Of course, if you don't want to answer the question, that's fine.
 
I agree. It is almost impossible to make any real progress on the problem of alcoholism when all these lies are ingrained so deeply as truth. With AA as the poster child for recovery, we can rest assured that alcoholism will be with us for a very long time.

Fortunately NIDA under director Dr Nora Volkow is making progress on de-mystifying programmes like AA and focusing more on empirical research. However they are still hamstrung by the Socio-Political definitions of Addiction Ideology, and the political disincentives to conduct research into psychotropic intervention.

But a quick look at NIDA's website shows that they have made huge strides in progress towards abandoning any "one size fits all" approach.

Where the progress needs to be made, is in the delegitimizing the Puritanical Addiction Ideology that AA has been a Major part of promoting since its inception. This can only be done when the mainstream media drops its love affair with AA.

GB
 
I do sometimes have a reading comprehension problem. It often crops up when I encounter pronouns with missing referents.

Of course, if you don't want to answer the question, that's fine.

AA has a SIN theory of Alcoholism, and adopted the term Disease to disguise their ideas. I've stated this from the beginning of my involvement with this thread.

I have also been very clear that the Disease Model of addiction is dubious as a BLANKET model for all "addictive" behaviour patterns, though it certainly has merit in some cases.

I for one, do not recall any posters on this thread claim that AA originated the Disease Model of addiction, rather that AA was the popularizer of their (pseudo)-Disease Model.

GB

It seems then that your biggest problem is comprehending context. There is no missing referent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom