Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
If AA is truly a religion, can someone explain the religious service that is practiced?


Not many people are making the claim 'AA is a religion' - they are, however, making (and quite adequately supporting) the claim 'AA is religious'.

I am pretty sure (although I could be wrong) you are aware of the difference between these two claims?
 
Not many people are making the claim 'AA is a religion' - they are, however, making (and quite adequately supporting) the claim 'AA is religious'.

Fair enough I supopose.
I'll ask it this way then:

If AA is religious:-
what are its' religious teachings?
what are the religious services that are given & by whom?
and what is the purpose behind these religious teachings?
and (presumably) religious conversions?
 
Last edited:
Fair enough I supopose.
I'll ask it this way then:

If AA is religious:-
what are its' religious teachings?

That there is a higher power (hereinafter "God").

That turning oneself over to God is helpful.

That it is useful to confess the nature of one's wrongs to God.

That God can remove one's character defect and shortcomings.

what are the religious services that are given & by whom?

Meetings at which the above are discussed and explored.

and what is the purpose behind these religious teachings?
and (presumably) religious conversions?

A difficult question to answer. Whose purpose? You have perpetually insisted that Bill W's purpose is irrelevant. You also insist that it is impossible to impute any purpose to AA as a whole, and that one must disregard any references to AA literature, and any personal experiences with AA are anecdotal.

Yet you also insist that AA has a "group conscience" that has steadfastly refused to change the supposedly meaningless references to God in its founding documents.

It is rather puzzling.
 
That there is a higher power (hereinafter "God").

A higher power: Implying a single god?
Clearly you haven't been paying attention

That turning oneself over to God is helpful.

Close, but no cigar.

That it is useful to confess the nature of one's wrongs to God.

... (as we understand him) and to ourselves and another human being.

That God can remove one's character defect and shortcomings.

Again, close but wrong,

Meetings at which the above are discussed and explored.

So you are saying that a group of alkies getting together to discuss sobriety is now a religious service? You have to be kidding me.

A difficult question to answer. Whose purpose? You have perpetually insisted that Bill W's purpose is irrelevant. You also insist that it is impossible to impute any purpose to AA as a whole, and that one must disregard any references to AA literature, and any personal experiences with AA are anecdotal.

Yet you also insist that AA has a "group conscience" that has steadfastly refused to change the supposedly meaningless references to God in its founding documents.

It is rather puzzling.

Does that mean you don't know?
 
If AA is truly a religion, can someone explain the religious service that is practiced?

And once again Alfie either doesn't understand the distinction between religion and religious organisation, or is deliberately peddling his strawman. How many times has it been said here that the two aren't the same ? And yet he continues...
 
I've already expressed my willingness to take the position that it cannot be definitively (empirically, logically, scientifically) demonstrated that any such thing as a "self" exists at all.

Sigh. "Self" is just a synonym for the human being who is doing the talking. Surely you accept that human beigns exist ?

I'm comparing two very different (and contradictory) definitions for self, provided by YOU on two separate occasions

No, you are not. You are comparing ONE of them... the one I've provided, and one that is unrelated.

Vacuous definitions do have the advantage of being easy. Feel free to continue to make it easy on yourself. I wouldn't want to make you work or anything.

At this point you're just throwing random insults. I've provided a definition already. Maybe the definition wasn't quite as clear-cut as you'd have liked, but it is one, nonetheless. A human being is the sum total of the molecules that compose it, and the organs and tissues that those molecules and cells form. Like defining an automobile, there will be _some_ circularily to the definition. "You" is just an instance of "human".

I submit that the intuitive default is that the "conscious self" has an existence separate from the "unconscious", by definition. What is at issue here is not whether the intuitive default represents the most accurate view of the self; it's whether adopting that stance might work for an individual chosing to make his appeals to an "inner self", or "higher self" representing his version of the concept, "higher power".

1) The unconscious mind controls things like respiration. It's like saying the janitor is more influent and powerful than the CEO.

2) I don't agree that their existence is intuitively separate. In fact it's quite difficult to determine exactly where that distinction lies, seeing as how it shifts from moment to moment.

"Doesn't make sense to meeeee..."

So, basicaly when I DON'T include words that indicate that it's my opinion, you feel like I'm being arrogant, and when I do, you make fun of the fact that it's my opinion. If you've got time to play these silly games on the internet, why don't you go outside and do something useful for your community, instead ?

Ya think?

Vacuous response.

Would you say that Nolan 'interacted' with Wilson?

Not in the sense that Wilson returned the favour.

And if your guess is NOT correct?

Have you ever studied logic ? If my guess is not correct then we can't infer the religiosity of AA's members without some other means. :rolleyes:
 
And once again Alfie either doesn't understand the distinction between religion and religious organisation, or is deliberately peddling his strawman. How many times has it been said here that the two aren't the same ? And yet he continues...

And as usual Belz assumes we are all talking from the same (his) hymn book. And is incapable of grasping nuance and/or simple differences in definition and the broader concepts and/or connections around same.

Religious
adjective
1. of, pertaining to, or concerned with religion: a religious holiday.
2. imbued with or exhibiting religion; pious; devout; godly: a religious man.
3. scrupulously faithful; conscientious: religious care.
4. pertaining to or connected with a monastic or religious order.
5. appropriate to religion or to sacred rites or observances.
–noun
6. a member of a religious order, congregation, etc.; a monk, friar, or nun.
7. the religious, devout or religious persons: Each year, thousands of the religious make pilgrimages to the shrine

religion

–noun
1. a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, esp. when considered as the creation of a superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs.
2. a specific fundamental set of beliefs and practices generally agreed upon by a number of persons or sects: the Christian religion; the Buddhist religion.
3. the body of persons adhering to a particular set of beliefs and practices: a world council of religions.
4. the life or state of a monk, nun, etc.: to enter religion.
5. the practice of religious beliefs; ritual observance of faith.

Perhaps Belz could - instead of engaging hair splitting:rolleyes: - endeavour to respond to the original questions. But that - no doubt - will be too much to ask.
 
Last edited:
"Self" is just a synonym for the human being who is doing the talking.
We've been down this road. "Let go of my arm" = "Let go of me". Vapid. Pedantic. Contrived.

A human being is the sum total of the molecules that compose it, and the organs and tissues that those molecules and cells form.
One might similarly argue that a novel, or a poem, is the sum total of the molecules of ink that compose it, and the paper upon which it is written, and the arrangements and shapes of the letters those molecules form -- but I think most readers, and authors, would consider that to be missing something important.

Like defining an automobile, there will be _some_ circularily to the definition. "You" is just an instance of "human".
A definition which offers nothing that would serve as a basis for considering it any less reasonable to say that "you" is just an instance of "automobile". You may choose to adopt that, the shallowest of all possible senses of the word "self" -- but (again) this isn't about YOU.

The unconscious mind controls things like respiration.
And intuition, which may be defined as: "knowing something without knowing how you know it".

It's like saying the janitor is more influent and powerful than the CEO.
Hold your breath for three minutes, and we'll talk more about who is more influent and powerful.

I don't agree that their existence is intuitively separate.
I don't agree that you don't agree. Seriously. What I'm saying is that unless your brain is wired in some very unique way, what it feels like is that YOU are this little man inside your head. A homunculus. You don't have full access to every little corner of your mind any more than anyone else does.

So, basicaly when I DON'T include words that indicate that it's my opinion, you feel like I'm being arrogant, and when I do, you make fun of the fact that it's my opinion.
What I object to is that you are presenting your opinion as evidence; just as others here have done, you are arguing that because X does not make sense to YOU, it can't make sense to anyone. We're talking about other people's beliefs here; specifically: those of alcoholics in AA. Remember?

If you've got time to play these silly games on the internet, why don't you go outside and do something useful for your community, instead ?
Perhaps the reason this accusation is so seldom heard around here is that it takes only the tiniest smidgen of critical thinking to recognize that in this particular regard, we're all living in glass houses. Some more than others. Case in point:

Belz
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 18,224

Dymanic
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 3,145


Vacuous response.
After having argued for nearly fifty pages that the whole question rests on how "higher power" is defined, the irony in seeing you make the statement: "What qualifies as higher powers depends on the definition of 'higher power' we use" -- as if this unique and penetrating insight had just occured to you -- seemed to demand some kind of recognition.

Not in the sense that Wilson returned the favour.
Did you SEE the film? Wilson very clearly did have lines. As the audience, we couldn't hear them; but Nolan very obviously could. It didn't have to be real; it just had to work.

If my guess is not correct then we can't infer the religiosity of AA's members without some other means.
Bingo.
 
A higher power: Implying a single god?
Clearly you haven't been paying attention

Oh, stop it with this attitude that anyone who disagrees with you must not be paying attention.

Close, but no cigar.

What does that mean? Do you deny that this is part of AA's teachings? It's pretty much a direct quote.

... (as we understand him) and to ourselves and another human being.

So what? Is Catholic confession not religious because the penitent confesses to a priest as well as his god?

Again, close but wrong,

Argument by assertion isn't helpful. If you're not going to explain why you claim I'm wrong, what's the point in having a discussion?

So you are saying that a group of alkies getting together to discuss sobriety is now a religious service? You have to be kidding me.

You're being totally dishonest now. I never said that.

First of all, I never said that AA meetings are a religious service, or that AA is a religion. Some people have made that claim in this thread, but I'm not one of them. You asked what are the religious teachings of AA, and I gave you an answer. And instead of providing an intelligent response, you stuck your fingers in your ears and shouted "nuh-uh!" a bunch of times and distorted what I said.

Second, "a group of alkies getting together to discuss sobriety" would not necessarily be religious. However, a group of alkies getting together to discuss how they are confessing their wrongs to God and turning their lives over to him (yes, *sigh*, "as they understand Him" -- I fail to see why you think that's a useful distinction) is helping them stay sober, is religious.

Interestingly, though, while -- again -- I am not claiming that AA is a religion, the arguments you've been making in this thread would mean that many actual religious services aren't "religious" either.

Does that mean you don't know?

It means I don't know how you reconcile these contrary positions of yours. What would you accept as evidence that AA is religious? You dismiss any written materials because, hey, "take what you want and leave the rest." You dismiss any accounts from people who have attended AA meetings with a religious bent because, well, every meeting is different, and your meetings aren't like that. It seems that under your standards, it is impossible to say anything about AA: that it's religious, that it's not religious, that it's effective, that it's not effective, etc. Yet I notice that doesn't stop you from saying positive things about AA.
 
Oh, stop it with this attitude that anyone who disagrees with you must not be paying attention.

You stated there is "a" singular god. That is not the fact given the variety of higher powers that one may choose (or not) to adopt.

What does that mean? Do you deny that this is part of AA's teachings? It's pretty much a direct quote.

It means your quote is incorrect.

So what? Is Catholic confession not religious because the penitent confesses to a priest as well as his god?

Is discussing things with my therapist a religious practice too then, whilst also sharing it with my higher power (say the universe)?

You're being totally dishonest now. I never said that.

The I have misunderstood you, please feel free to elaborate.
 
Ask him to explore other AA groups. Groups are made up with people, the people attending determine if the group gets steered towards religions, god, ect eventually
.
I had some friends express to me that their particular group focused on giving up to a higher power with the implication that higher power was simply a smarter part of yourself and wasn't the central focus of the group meeting. The members of the group itself decided things would be a lot more productive if religion were kept out of it and the focus remained on: Identifying what was going on inside you that made you drink. They had to go through a number of different meetings around town in order to arrive at a place where religion wasn't being crammed down their throat.

They also noted that court ordered groups tend to trend towards the religious aspect of it.

Best wishes with that.



I'm dealing with a spouse who has alcohol issues. His first therapist (social worker) told him to go to a Beginner's AA meeting, and to "Keep An Open Mind."

He went, and was instantly uncomfortable. Not only was Jesus Christ mentioned constantly as the Savior, but the meeting ended with, "The Lord's Prayer."

He related this to the social worker, who berated him for not going to a Beginner's meeting. (Which it WAS listed as.) And then told him that, "The Lord's Prayer" is not really religious, anyway.

My husband now sees a psychologist who specializes in cognitive behavior and doesn't push AA.

Now I'm furious that MY new therapist is telling me that AA would be a good resource for my husband. "It's not religious, it's spiritual," and "Your higher power can be anything at all, the ocean, even yourself."

I'm not confrontational, and I tried to remember some of the advice I've received here about debating. I told her that I had done research on AA, that it had a 5% success rate, and that the Supreme Court had ruled that it was religious. Then I started to get emotional and told her that it was all based on a Buchmanite group designed to get people to accept Christ as the Savior, and that the Higher Power stuff was nonsense, since sure, it starts out as, "the ocean," but ends up referring to God. And the "higher power" definitely CANNOT be yourself, since it has to be some outside force. As Henry Ford said of his cars, you can have any color you want so long as it's black. Well, you can have any Higher Power you want so long as it's God.

As former Catholics, my husband and I tend to get a bit touchy when religion is sold to us. It is very difficult to get away from, "Magical Thinking," and I've been working so hard to restructure my thoughts, to think more critically, to learn about logic, and to question things. And it took a lot for me to "talk back" to my therapist about this, and I still feel guilty, like I should just accept it as good advice. Such is the mark that being a good little Catholic girl leaves on person.

I feel so angry that the majority of people don't question AA at all.:mad:
 
You stated there is "a" singular god. That is not the fact given the variety of higher powers that one may choose (or not) to adopt.



It means your quote is incorrect.

As published on AA.org, the 12 Steps include a belief in "a Power greater than ourselves."

Steps 3, 5, 6, 7, and 11 refer to "God" and/or "Him."

So if you're going to claim that my paraphrase "That there is a higher power" implies that there is only "a" singular god, then you must agree that AA's 12 Steps do the same thing. Which also means that my paraphrase was accurate.

Is discussing things with my therapist a religious practice too then, whilst also sharing it with my higher power (say the universe)?

As I explained in my previous post, it would depend on the conversation. I have no idea what kind of therapist you see, and what methods he or she uses.

It's the substance of the conversation, not the identity of the participants, that makes it religious or not. Chatting with a priest about yesterday's baseball game? Not a religious activity. Talking to your neighbor about how Jesus saved your soul? A religious activity.

The I have misunderstood you, please feel free to elaborate.

I thought I was pretty clear in my previous post, but I'll try. I think you and I seem to be using very different definitions of "religious." You seem to be equating "is religious" or "religious activity" with "is a religion." Which is strange, since you yourself quoted the following definition of religion just a few posts ago:

Religious
adjective
1. of, pertaining to, or concerned with religion: a religious holiday.
2. imbued with or exhibiting religion; pious; devout; godly: a religious man.
3. scrupulously faithful; conscientious: religious care.
4. pertaining to or connected with a monastic or religious order.
5. appropriate to religion or to sacred rites or observances.
–noun
6. a member of a religious order, congregation, etc.; a monk, friar, or nun.
7. the religious, devout or religious persons: Each year, thousands of the religious make pilgrimages to the shrine

You will note that only definitions 4-6 imply some connection to a formal religious organization or ritual.

When I say that AA is "religious," I mean it in the sense of definitions 1 and 2. Note the example given in definition 2 of "a religious man." A person need not be a priest or even a member of a church to be described as "a religious man."

The other problem I think you and I are having is that you keep reading all sorts of negative implications into what I'm saying. When I say that AA is religious, I am not saying that it doesn't help people. (I think the jury is still out on that one.) I am not saying that one has to be religious to participate. I am not saying that every AA meeting everywhere is religious.

What I am saying is that, taken as a whole, based on its stated principles and (recommended) methods, based on the accounts of many current and former members, and based on the fact that the "group conscience" is not interested in changing the religious language that some people find inappropriate and exclusionary, AA is religious.

It's like if I said that Alabama is a conservative state. I would not be implying that every single resident of Alabama is a conservative, or that everything that happens there is conservative. It's a generalization based on the overall tendencies of a large, sort-of-diverse population. But that doesn't make it a false statement.

I'm having a little trouble figuring out exactly what part of the above you disagree. Let me pose you a few questions:

Is praying to a deity religious?

Would you agree that Bill W. was a religious man?

Do you agree that the Big Book is religious?

Do you agree that the 12 Steps are religious? (Let's put aside the whole issue of them being voluntary, and "take what you want and leave the rest," because that's a separate issue. Church attendance is voluntary, too, but ) If your answer here is "no," would your answer change if we strike the words "as we understood Him"?

Do you agree that it some AA meetings are religious?

And maybe this is the best question to get to the heart of the point:

Suppose we were not talking about AA. Suppose we are talking about some hypothetical organization that is structured like AA. Let's stipulate that this hypothetical organization is not a church or a religion. Do you believe it is possible for such an organization to be "religious"? If so, how would you go about decided whether that label is appropriate? What criteria would you use?
 
And as usual Belz assumes we are all talking from the same (his) hymn book. And is incapable of grasping nuance and/or simple differences in definition and the broader concepts and/or connections around same.

Perhaps Belz could - instead of engaging hair splitting:rolleyes: - endeavour to respond to the original questions. But that - no doubt - will be too much to ask.

Alfie, I've already answered this. You need to pay closer attention to the thread. Saying "religion" and "religious organization" are the same is like saying that "heat" and "something that's hot" are the same.

A "religious organization" is an organization with strong religious undertones. Again, I've said this before, but you weren't paying attention.
 
We've been down this road. "Let go of my arm" = "Let go of me". Vapid. Pedantic. Contrived.

What in the blue hell are you talking about ?

One might similarly argue that a novel, or a poem, is the sum total of the molecules of ink that compose it

I wouldn't. That's not how we usually define the word "novel". We would describe the word "book" this way because it refers to a physical object, while "novel" refers to a particular pattern, of which the book can be an instance.

A definition which offers nothing that would serve as a basis for considering it any less reasonable to say that "you" is just an instance of "automobile". You may choose to adopt that, the shallowest of all possible senses of the word "self" -- but (again) this isn't about YOU.

I hope you're using FedEx to move those goalposts. Since when have I been talking about the "self" ? "You" is simply shorthand for "the human I'm talking to".

Hold your breath for three minutes, and we'll talk more about who is more influent and powerful.

You have very odd definitions for those words. Just because your body has a failsafe against holding your breath to death doesn't mean the unconscious mind is a separate entity from the conscious part.

I don't agree that you don't agree. Seriously. What I'm saying is that unless your brain is wired in some very unique way, what it feels like is that YOU are this little man inside your head. A homunculus. You don't have full access to every little corner of your mind any more than anyone else does.

What does this have to do with the question of whether they are separate or not ?

What I object to is that you are presenting your opinion as evidence; just as others here have done, you are arguing that because X does not make sense to YOU, it can't make sense to anyone.

Your interpretation, not my words. In the future I'll refrain from saying "in my opinion" or "to me". Since I get criticized by you for projecting my opinions onto reality either way, I might as well cut my sentences short.

In the meantime, could you provide some evidence that refutes what has been said in this thread, namely that AA members as a rule interpret the higher power to be God ?

Perhaps the reason this accusation is so seldom heard around here is that it takes only the tiniest smidgen of critical thinking to recognize that in this particular regard, we're all living in glass houses.

I don't play games. I have no time to waste playing "gotcha".

Belz
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 18,224

Dymanic
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 3,145

What do you think this proves ? It's amazing the number of posters here who feel intimidated by something so trivial as a post count. 18,224 posts in 5 years is less than 10 posts per day. How is that excessive ? I spend maybe 30-45 minutes per day here. Again, how is that excessive ? If you're going to attack me personally I suggest using better arguments than your own inferiority complex.

After having argued for nearly fifty pages that the whole question rests on how "higher power" is defined, the irony in seeing you make the statement: "What qualifies as higher powers depends on the definition of 'higher power' we use" -- as if this unique and penetrating insight had just occured to you -- seemed to demand some kind of recognition.

I was making my SUMMARY of the thread. It stands to reason that I'd revisit some of the things that were said. :rolleyes:

Wilson very clearly did have lines.

You cannot interact with things that aren't real, Dymanic. You'd like to be able to, but you can't.
 
Last edited:
One might similarly argue that a novel, or a poem, is the sum total of the molecules of ink that compose it, and the paper upon which it is written, and the arrangements and shapes of the letters those molecules form -- . . .

Funny, if you read what AA members write, that is exactly what you will find. You will read how the door knob is a higher power because it is made up of atoms and . . . well, you just have to read it to believe it. (Section 1-10)

http://books.google.ca/books?id=U4q...onepage&q=door knob is a higher power&f=false

You will also notice that this guy says he has heard "more than one person" say a door knob is their higher power which refutes the claim made by some in this thread.

If you punch "Door knob as higher power" into Google, you get thousands more references to it being used in AA meetings.
 
Funny, if you read what AA members write, that is exactly what you will find. You will read how the door knob is a higher power because it is made up of atoms and . . . well, you just have to read it to believe it. (Section 1-10)

http://books.google.ca/books?id=U4q...onepage&q=door knob is a higher power&f=false

You will also notice that this guy says he has heard "more than one person" say a door knob is their higher power which refutes the claim made by some in this thread.

If you punch "Door knob as higher power" into Google, you get thousands more references to it being used in AA meetings.

Well those aren't True AAers.
 
tsig said:
Funny, if you read what AA members write, that is exactly what you will find. You will read how the door knob is a higher power because it is made up of atoms and . . . well, you just have to read it to believe it. (Section 1-10)

http://books.google.ca/books?id=U4q...onepage&q=door knob is a higher power&f=false

You will also notice that this guy says he has heard "more than one person" say a door knob is their higher power which refutes the claim made by some in this thread.

If you punch "Door knob as higher power" into Google, you get thousands more references to it being used in AA meetings.

Well those aren't True AAers.
More likely they are AAers trying to throw a lifeline that a recalcitrant drunk might find of use, and something that on calmer reflection is accepted as counter-productive. Like, damn, I wish I hadn't said that; I'll try to do better next time.
 
What in the blue hell are you talking about ?
"YOU is the sum of things that are your body".

We would describe the word "book" this way because it refers to a physical object, while "novel" refers to a particular pattern, of which the book can be an instance.
My point. So perhaps what "YOU" refers to (real or not) is something more than the sum of things that are in your body -- in much the same way that "novel" refers to something more than ink and paper, eh?

Since when have I been talking about the "self" ?
It would have been appropriate for you to have been doing so ever since we first started talking about the concept, "A power greater than ourSELVES" -- but other than a couple of pathetically weak attempts, you've mostly just been falling back on crying "strawman", or "irrelevant", or "moving the goalposts".

Just because your body has a failsafe against holding your breath to death doesn't mean the unconscious mind is a separate entity from the conscious part.
I won't bother to ask you to unpack the broader concept, "entity", because whether or not they actually ARE separate entities is irrelevant to the matter at issue here.

In the meantime, could you provide some evidence that refutes what has been said in this thread, namely that AA members as a rule interpret the higher power to be God ?
I don't see the burden being on me to do that, any more than it would be to provide evidence that Americans as a rule accept the theory of evolution as a refutation of the claim: "the US is a creationist nation".

But I will offer the observation that an abundance of alternatives to AA is available to those able to embrace the dogma of mainstream religon, and that some very significant number of AA members, many of whom have tried these, openly express having found in AA a system of personal belief that works for them precisely because it differs from the dogma of mainstream religion. Among them are pantheists, neopaganists, totemists, polytheists, gaiaists, and on across the full spectrum of philosophical and, yes, religious viewpoints. Yes, of course, Christians -- and atheists, and agnostics, and perhaps even adherents to naive panpsychism, who subscribe to the idea that inanimate objects such as doorknobs possess sentience (though I don't recall ever actually meeting anyone who claimed to take the idea seriously).

In sharp contrast with the way things work here at the JREF forum, for the purposes of recovery in AA one is not required to defend his beliefs with evidence, or logic, or anything else -- and, as has been observed, discussion of those details probably occupies far less time and attention in AA than it does around here. With that in mind, how it is that you can presume to know how "they" -- as a rule -- are interpreting their respective higher powers is beyond me, but it seems to me that the burden for providing evidence falls on the one making the affirmative claim: "They're talking about the Protestant God".


If you're going to attack me personally...
This from the same guy who just said: "If you've got time to play these silly games on the internet, why don't you go outside and do something useful for your community, instead?"

...I suggest using better arguments than your own inferiority complex.
Interesting (though hardly surprising) that you would interpret the difference in post counts that way. I see it exactly the other way around. By your own rough calculation, you spend an average of maybe 3 or 4 minutes on each post you contribute. That's not far from what I might have guessed, considering how poorly thought out so many of your posts appear to be. If that level of effort reflects the degree of genuine interest you have in discussing this, why are you here at all?

You cannot interact with things that aren't real, Dymanic. You'd like to be able to, but you can't.
I disagree, which is the reason I introduced the "Wilson" analogy in the first place. It's called "adopting the intentional stance", and I will continue to argue that it is the most natural thing in the world for humans to do (and I can direct you to some reading as well as some research which supports this position).
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom