What in the blue hell are you talking about ?
"YOU is the sum of things that are your body".
We would describe the word "book" this way because it refers to a physical object, while "novel" refers to a particular pattern, of which the book can be an instance.
My point. So perhaps what "YOU" refers to (
real or not) is something more than the sum of things that are in your body -- in much the same way that "novel" refers to something more than ink and paper, eh?
Since when have I been talking about the "self" ?
It would have been
appropriate for you to have been doing so ever since we first started talking about the concept, "A power greater than ourSELVES" -- but other than a couple of pathetically weak attempts, you've mostly just been falling back on crying "strawman", or "irrelevant", or "moving the goalposts".
Just because your body has a failsafe against holding your breath to death doesn't mean the unconscious mind is a separate entity from the conscious part.
I won't bother to ask you to unpack the broader concept, "entity", because whether or not they actually ARE separate entities is irrelevant to the matter at issue here.
In the meantime, could you provide some evidence that refutes what has been said in this thread, namely that AA members as a rule interpret the higher power to be God ?
I don't see the burden being on me to do that, any more than it would be to provide evidence that Americans
as a rule accept the theory of evolution as a refutation of the claim: "the US is a creationist nation".
But I will offer the observation that an abundance of alternatives to AA is available to those able to embrace the dogma of mainstream religon, and that some very significant number of AA members, many of whom have tried these, openly express having found in AA a system of personal belief that works for them precisely
because it differs from the dogma of mainstream religion. Among them are pantheists, neopaganists, totemists, polytheists, gaiaists, and on across the full spectrum of philosophical and, yes,
religious viewpoints. Yes, of course,
Christians -- and atheists, and agnostics, and perhaps even adherents to naive panpsychism, who subscribe to the idea that inanimate objects such as doorknobs possess sentience (though I don't recall ever actually meeting anyone who claimed to take the idea seriously).
In sharp contrast with the way things work here at the JREF forum, for the purposes of recovery in AA one is not required to defend his beliefs with evidence, or logic, or anything else -- and, as has been observed, discussion of those details probably occupies far less time and attention in AA than it does around here. With that in mind, how it is that you can presume to know how "they" --
as a rule -- are interpreting their respective higher powers is beyond me, but it seems to me that the burden for providing evidence falls on the one making the affirmative claim: "They're talking about the Protestant God".
If you're going to attack me personally...
This from the same guy who just said: "If you've got time to play these silly games on the internet, why don't you go outside and do something useful for your community, instead?"
...I suggest using better arguments than your own inferiority complex.
Interesting (though hardly surprising) that you would interpret the difference in post counts that way. I see it exactly the other way around. By your own rough calculation, you spend an average of maybe 3 or 4 minutes on each post you contribute. That's not far from what I might have guessed, considering how poorly thought out so many of your posts appear to be. If that level of effort reflects the degree of genuine interest you have in discussing this, why are you here at all?
You cannot interact with things that aren't real, Dymanic. You'd like to be able to, but you can't.
I disagree, which is the reason I introduced the "Wilson" analogy in the first place. It's called "adopting the intentional stance", and I will continue to argue that it is the most natural thing in the world for humans to do (and I can direct you to some reading as well as some research which supports this position).