Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems then that your biggest problem is comprehending context. There is no missing referent.
The best I can make of that is: "AA was the popularizer of it's own model". If that's what you're saying, my opinion is that you might have worded it more clearly, but then, I am a little tired; maybe it is just me. I know you're going to want to present evidence to show how AA did this, so please proceed.
 
The best I can make of that is: "AA was the popularizer of it's own model". If that's what you're saying, my opinion is that you might have worded it more clearly, but then, I am a little tired; maybe it is just me. I know you're going to want to present evidence to show how AA did this, so please proceed.

I already have.

Perhaps I should take the time to go through this thread and repost all the posts which quote directly from AA's source material and website. But I suspect you're just trying to make me waste my time repeating myself...or you could just have a memory problem, I wouldn't want to assume that one is more likely than the other.

GB
 
I already have.

Perhaps I should take the time to go through this thread and repost all the posts which quote directly from AA's source material and website. But I suspect you're just trying to make me waste my time repeating myself...or you could just have a memory problem, I wouldn't want to assume that one is more likely than the other.
Actually, the issue of the disease concept does not fascinate me, so you really needn't bother. When it came up early in the thread, I dismissed it as tangential to this discussion, and I still feel that way. As you may or may not recall, I also stated my position: that I have found the disease model useful in my own recovery as a metaphor, whether it ultimately ends up passing the test as hard science or not. If you want to do the whole dance with Jellinek and all that, you might want to take it to the fresh thread devoted exclusively to the disease concept that started up this morning over in the Science forum (if you hurry, you could still get in before it goes to page 3).
 
Actually, the issue of the disease concept does not fascinate me, so you really needn't bother. When it came up early in the thread, I dismissed it as tangential to this discussion, and I still feel that way. As you may or may not recall, I also stated my position: that I have found the disease model useful in my own recovery as a metaphor, whether it ultimately ends up passing the test as hard science or not. If you want to do the whole dance with Jellinek and all that, you might want to take it to the fresh thread devoted exclusively to the disease concept that started up this morning over in the Science forum (if you hurry, you could still get in before it goes to page 3).

Fair enough.

Though I agree Addiction Models are tangential, I think discussing them in the context of this thread is relevant. Largely because AA claims to promote one Model (the Disease Model), while actually presenting another Model altogether (the Sin Model).

I might indeed pop over to the science sub-forum and look for that thread.

GB
 
Funny, if you read what AA members write, that is exactly what you will find. You will read how the door knob is a higher power because it is made up of atoms and . . . well, you just have to read it to believe it. (Section 1-10)

http://books.google.ca/books?id=U4q...onepage&q=door knob is a higher power&f=false

You will also notice that this guy says he has heard "more than one person" say a door knob is their higher power which refutes the claim made by some in this thread.

If you punch "Door knob as higher power" into Google, you get thousands more references to it being used in AA meetings.

Just amazing. And the reason why the door knob works, according to the book, is because God's there, too.
 
My point. So perhaps what "YOU" refers to (real or not) is something more than the sum of things that are in your body -- in much the same way that "novel" refers to something more than ink and paper, eh?

No. We could go on about consciousness/mind for quite a bit and derail even further, but a book which is an instance of a novel is, for all intents and purposes, the same as another book which is another instance of the same novel. Since humans have self-referential processes, each one's "mind" is distinct from the other, even if the pattern is the same, say a Star Trek transporter accident-made copy. Although both copies are identical they are not the same object. But please, feel free to continue to twist what I said to your liking.

"A power greater than ourSELVES" -- but other than a couple of pathetically weak attempts, you've mostly just been falling back on crying "strawman", or "irrelevant", or "moving the goalposts".

That's because you've been doing that all along. Your argument rests on making it appear as though all definitions of terms used in this thread are so vague as to be useless. Apparently you think that doing so will make your interpretations just as good as everybody else's.

I don't see the burden being on me to do that

No, indeed. But if you HAD evidence of the contrary I assume you'd have presented it by now.

But I will offer the observation

No more single-case testimonies, please. For every belief you'll find a believer and for every supernatural event you'll find someone who claims to have experienced it. There's a reason why science seeks physical evidence.

In sharp contrast with the way things work here at the JREF forum, for the purposes of recovery in AA one is not required to defend his beliefs with evidence, or logic, or anything else

This we can agree to. Unfortunately that is entirely irrelevant to the OP.

This from the same guy who just said: "If you've got time to play these silly games on the internet, why don't you go outside and do something useful for your community, instead?"

Yes, because you DO play games. Telling you what you actually do is not a personal attack. Using my post count as some sort of argument IS. I find it odd that you didn't get that.

Interesting (though hardly surprising) that you would interpret the difference in post counts that way.

See what I mean by playing games ? I suggested that you have an inferiority complex because our relative post count affects you, implying that I have no such view on that number. And your retort is that you think _I_ interpret the difference that way. You either have serious reading problems or you're just looking to "win" this conversation, whatever the hell that would accomplish.

By your own rough calculation, you spend an average of maybe 3 or 4 minutes on each post you contribute.

That might have something to do with me having short breaks at work during which I can browse the web. I seldom have half an hour to spend on a post, so I summarise.

That's not far from what I might have guessed, considering how poorly thought out so many of your posts appear to be.

Oddly enough, only those who disagree with me seem to think they are poorly thought out, so far. I submit that the two are related, somehow.

If that level of effort reflects the degree of genuine interest you have in discussing this, why are you here at all?

Wow. So this entire line of reasoning only served to turn my "If you've got time to play these silly games on the internet, why don't you go outside and do something useful for your community, instead?" around. If I had any remaining doubt about your trolling, it's just been removed.

I disagree, which is the reason I introduced the "Wilson" analogy in the first place. It's called "adopting the intentional stance", and I will continue to argue that it is the most natural thing in the world for humans to do (and I can direct you to some reading as well as some research which supports this position).

Well, of course. Why wouldn't Dymanic try to muddle the definition of "interaction", now ? You've done it with every other term we've used. Or perhaps you'd rather distinguish between "perceived" interaction and "real" interaction ? As usual, I'm talking about the real stuff.
 
Your argument rests on making it appear as though all definitions of terms used in this thread are so vague as to be useless. Apparently you think that doing so will make your interpretations just as good as everybody else's.
My argument rests on showing why your definition of one particular term -- "YOU"-- is so broad as to be useless (which was quite obviously your intent). I'm glad you mentioned "everybody else's" interpretation, because the very point I'm making is that we all DO know what the pronoun "YOU" refers to: the self. That it defaults to a logically flawed proposition (the homunculus) is beside the point; for the purposes of recovery, what counts is how it feels.

But if you HAD evidence of the contrary I assume you'd have presented it by now.
You're asking me to prove a negative. This causes me to wonder: have you ever heard of Russell's teapot?

No more single-case testimonies, please.
I will restate these as factual claims; that is, not as simply my observations, but as observations that may be made by anyone:

1) An abundance of alternatives to AA is available to those able to embrace the dogma of mainstream religon.

2) Some very significant number of AA members openly express having found in AA a system of personal belief that works for them precisely because it differs from the dogma of mainstream religion. [Note: you may recognize this as the underlying premise that inspired the starting of this thread.]

3) Among them are pantheists, neopaganists, totemists, polytheists, gaiaists, and on across the full spectrum of philosophical and, yes, religious viewpoints.

Assuming that we are in agreement on those, I will stipulate that my mention of not recalling having met any enthusiastic adherents to naive panpsychism was indeed personal testimony, and therefore lacks value as evidence. My opinion, if you will indulge that, is that the whole "doorknob" thing was never more than a bit of facetious hyperbole; in short, a joke. You know, like my crack about the caffeine?


There's a reason why science seeks physical evidence.
To be sure, AA isn't science -- but that doesn't make it religion.

Or perhaps you'd rather distinguish between "perceived" interaction and "real" interaction ? As usual, I'm talking about the real stuff.
The point I've been making since very early in the thread (which your time constraints must have prevented you from either reading or grasping) is that where "the real stuff" refers to that which can trigger measureable physiological responses (say), that distinction IS quite fuzzy, and for the puposes of an alcoholic seeking recovery in AA (or a castaway seeking to preserve some modicum of mental and emotional stability in the face of prolonged isolation), unimportant.
 
Here's an example of how willpower is often driven more by belief than biology:
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/10/101014144318.htm

Now this article was looking more directly at attitudes about willpower, not religion. Yet the principles apply. Only in a religious context, it's not about the beliefs associated with willpower directly, but about the supposed strength of will provided through the religious tenets.

Being a belief driven effect, AA groups will tend to flock around silly religious notion to drive the effective beliefs. Thus the religious context of particular AA groups provides, more often than not, the apparent religious context to AA.
 
Now this article was looking more directly at attitudes about willpower, not religion. Yet the principles apply. Only in a religious context, it's not about the beliefs associated with willpower directly, but about the supposed strength of will provided through the religious tenets.

Belief is powerful. However, why do people always assume that it has to be a false belief? "God can't help you but believing he can helps" would be better stated, "You can help yourself and believing you can adds to the effect."

I don't buy the whole thing that because belief helps, false beliefs are okay. This same fallacy is what allows religions to behave the way they do and allows them to prey on the weak and downtrodden.

Being a belief driven effect, AA groups will tend to flock around silly religious notion to drive the effective beliefs. Thus the religious context of particular AA groups provides, more often than not, the apparent religious context to AA.

It isn't the "particular group" giving AA the "apparent religious context." It is AA literature, the GSO, and then the individual group that gives it its definite religious context. This is a religious organization from top to bottom.
 
Being a belief driven effect, AA groups will tend to flock around silly religious notion to drive the effective beliefs.
Anecdotally, I haven't found that to be so. Unless you consider 'group conscience' a silly religious notion?

Thus the religious context of particular AA groups provides, more often than not, the apparent religious context to AA.
Your AA meetings and mine seem quite different. But yes, if one wishes to find it, there is apparent religious context in the literature.

"Take what you want; Leave the rest". ;)
 
Anecdotally, I haven't found that to be so. Unless you consider 'group conscience' a silly religious notion?

Religious, sometimes, but 'group conscience' is in fact 'mob rule' and it is used because it is an effective tool for controlling people. You put the tenets in place and then give each person a single vote. In order for change to happen, it needs to start with one person, they need to convince their groups, then they need to convince the majority of the groups in their area, then they need to convince the majority of the groups in their district, then on the national level, then on the international level.

Nothing changes because of human nature. People, and especially the type who find themselves in groups such as AA, resist change. So this process will be a fight all the way. To top it off, there are an infinite number of ways to derail a change process and only one way for it to happen so the chances of anything changing is infinitely small.

To top it off, AA literature itself "suggests" :rolleyes: that change is not good and that any change should be studied very carefully because it could adversely affect the group and therefore, the recovery of individuals. It is fear mongering in favour of the status quo.

Go read on the decisions and comments made in past years by the GSO directors. Some have even stated they are nothing more than figureheads for Bill W. "suggestions :rolleyes: on recovery."

In fact, the director positions are set up specifically so that no change can take place. For an organization this large, with this few national meetings and such a system for change, directors are not in position long enough. The change process starts over again each time new directors are brought in.

Mob rule is democracy but it is democracy at it's poorest, where the majority get to trample on the rights of minorities and individuals. That's the best definition of the AA system and what happens inside AA itself.
 
Belief is powerful. However, why do people always assume that it has to be a false belief? "God can't help you but believing he can helps" would be better stated, "You can help yourself and believing you can adds to the effect."

I don't buy the whole thing that because belief helps, false beliefs are okay. This same fallacy is what allows religions to behave the way they do and allows them to prey on the weak and downtrodden.
I don't buy that crap is ok either. But it's like the guy you explain how his homeopathic medicine is a sugar pill, and get the response: "Well, why to you have to tell me that.. Now it want work for me anymore!!!" Think it does any good to tell him: "Well you already know you felt better because of what you believed, so believe it without the homeopathic crap. I'm trying to tell you how to have your cake and eat it to, and all you can do is accuse me of being mean."?

I guess they would be happier if I charged them for some voodoo. It really comes down to avoiding responsibility. If it wasn't really in their control they don't have to face the emotional ramifications of that. So it's easier to round robin your way out of facing responsibility, by placing the control on something external, like a God. Belief as a causal factor in and of itself is an alien concept in such a religiously driven society. Unless of course you point out the followers of "The Secret", then they pump if so full of Universal one-ism crap it rivals religion in absurdity.

It isn't the "particular group" giving AA the "apparent religious context." It is AA literature, the GSO, and then the individual group that gives it its definite religious context. This is a religious organization from top to bottom.
Few people understand how to separate a belief factor as a causal agent from a religious factor to begin with. Much like religion claims ownership of morality, it claims ownership of belief.

Belief is both a product of biochemistry and a causal agent of biochemistry. If I say "boo" and scare you, the adrenaline rush, blood pressure, etc., is very real biochemistry, essentially no different than a pill. From nothing more than what someone else said. There is no mind body dualism, one is the product of the other, with feedback.

This, I think, is why religion is so tenacious. Because only religion provides a working, if ridiculous, methodology of dealing with belief and its effects, barring the equally ridiculous "secret". Even at the cost of a round robin approach, offloading the belief factor on a external fairy tale about faith in that same fairy tale, and selling out your wealth, morality, and laws to some guru of that fairy tale. As if selling your belief to a fairy tale proclaiming the power of belief makes sense. Sure it's power, for the guru you pay to give it to.

Right now I'm going to give up believing this headache is going to go away, and take some advil. :(
 
Right now I'm going to give up believing this headache is going to go away, and take some advil. :(

Right now I'm going to give up believing that Advil actually works on my headache and take some Vicodin which actually does work. ;)

GB
 
Religious, sometimes, but 'group conscience' is in fact 'mob rule' and it is used because it is an effective tool for controlling people. You put the tenets in place and then give each person a single vote. In order for change to happen, it needs to start with one person, they need to convince their groups, then they need to convince the majority of the groups in their area, then they need to convince the majority of the groups in their district, then on the national level, then on the international level.
Any AA group that wanted to change to something you propose would be a confederacy of dunces.

To top it off, AA literature itself "suggests" :rolleyes: that change is not good and that any change should be studied very carefully because it could adversely affect the group and therefore, the recovery of individuals. It is fear mongering in favour of the status quo.
You could always start you own organization.

Mob rule is democracy but it is democracy at it's poorest, where the majority get to trample on the rights of minorities and individuals. That's the best definition of the AA system and what happens inside AA itself.
Can I call the waaaaambulance for you?
 
"God can't help you but believing he can helps" would be better stated, "You can help yourself and believing you can adds to the effect."
I agree with your implication: that those may be regarded as functionally equivalent. I also agree with the underlying premise: that the objective is a change in inner states.

I don't buy the whole thing that because belief helps, false beliefs are okay.
Whether you think false beliefs are "okay" or not, I submit that you can't not hold them. One of the reasons that I have argued this so vigorously is that I see it as part of a broader ongoing discussion. I have a theory: Militant atheism is not driven by frustration with trying to deal with "them"; those fuzzy-thinking believer types who want to convert the world to their absurd fantasies. It is driven but by a desire to disown those tendencies in one's self.

It is the nature of human cognition to assume; to fantasize; to extrapolate from sparse information; to anthropomorphize; to attribute agency and intent; to play connect-the-dots without noticing that you're doing so. Error-prone though they may be, the view that these tendencies represent defects in human cognition is to overlook the advantages they can confer in a world where perfect information is non-existent and life-or-death decisions often turn on the ability to formulate reasonable guesses in some few hundreds of milliseconds. Declaring one's self to be a skeptic (critical thinker, atheist, whatever) does not render one immune to false beliefs (as a brief tour of this forum will confirm). The notion that an unwavering commitment to evidence and logic can provide a cure for these defects is itself a fantasy.

We are not Vulcans. In purely theoretical situations, what counts is what is most logical and best supported by evidence; in purely practical situations, what counts is simply what works. If it works for the wrong reason, it still works. "Embrace your false beliefs" is never likely to become a popular slogan around here, but I find that there are times when it is appropriate to ask whether my committment to critical thinking is serving me as well in my personal life as it does in my... intellectual life, I guess you'd call it; in my search for answers to difficult (and often rather abstract) questions. I need to be able to recognize when it may only serve to isolate me from those around me, and to be able to sort of give it a rest (I won't claim to be very good at this; it's one of the things I'm working on).

This same fallacy is what allows religions to behave the way they do and allows them to prey on the weak and downtrodden.
Agreed -- but I think it's like saying that because guns can be used for similarly evil purposes, they have no possible justifiable uses. Belief IS powerful. It can work for you, and it can work against you. It's something that can only be taken on a case by case basis.
 
I agree with your implication: that those may be regarded as functionally equivalent. I also agree with the underlying premise: that the objective is a change in inner states.

Whether you think false beliefs are "okay" or not, I submit that you can't not hold them. One of the reasons that I have argued this so vigorously is that I see it as part of a broader ongoing discussion. I have a theory: Militant atheism is not driven by frustration with trying to deal with "them"; those fuzzy-thinking believer types who want to convert the world to their absurd fantasies. It is driven but by a desire to disown those tendencies in one's self.

It is the nature of human cognition to assume; to fantasize; to extrapolate from sparse information; to anthropomorphize; to attribute agency and intent; to play connect-the-dots without noticing that you're doing so. Error-prone though they may be, the view that these tendencies represent defects in human cognition is to overlook the advantages they can confer in a world where perfect information is non-existent and life-or-death decisions often turn on the ability to formulate reasonable guesses in some few hundreds of milliseconds. Declaring one's self to be a skeptic (critical thinker, atheist, whatever) does not render one immune to false beliefs (as a brief tour of this forum will confirm). The notion that an unwavering commitment to evidence and logic can provide a cure for these defects is itself a fantasy.

We are not Vulcans. In purely theoretical situations, what counts is what is most logical and best supported by evidence; in purely practical situations, what counts is simply what works. If it works for the wrong reason, it still works. "Embrace your false beliefs" is never likely to become a popular slogan around here, but I find that there are times when it is appropriate to ask whether my committment to critical thinking is serving me as well in my personal life as it does in my... intellectual life, I guess you'd call it; in my search for answers to difficult (and often rather abstract) questions. I need to be able to recognize when it may only serve to isolate me from those around me, and to be able to sort of give it a rest (I won't claim to be very good at this; it's one of the things I'm working on).

Agreed -- but I think it's like saying that because guns can be used for similarly evil purposes, they have no possible justifiable uses. Belief IS powerful. It can work for you, and it can work against you. It's something that can only be taken on a case by case basis.

I agree with pretty much everything you say here, but as usual for you, it's an argument that tacitly acknowledges that AA is Religious. Again, you're just making my case for me.

And I have no problem with Religious people believing what they like, but when they expect a non-theist to "fake it till they make it", I have a problem. And when they expect the secular community to adopt their Puritan ideology, I have a problem.

GB
 
Anecdotally, I haven't found that to be so. Unless you consider 'group conscience' a silly religious notion?


Your AA meetings and mine seem quite different. But yes, if one wishes to find it, there is apparent religious context in the literature.

"Take what you want; Leave the rest". ;)
The only AA meetings I've been to was in my early teens, where my uncle attended. It was held near the library, and I my mother would take us there since she also drove my uncle to the meeting. I was allowed to stay withing hearing distance, probably due to age and the perception I was no threat. Many people got the impression I didn't or couldn't talk in those days. When I did some would complain about those giant 5 and 6 letter words. I even read their literature as I listened.

I seen many proclaim their religious advantages, while a few of the others showed differing levels of discomfort when it was mentioned so adamantly. It almost appeared to me to be a hindrance for some, and I don't think the "higher power" is not religious line was much help for them. My uncle in particular had a very religious wife, and she relished the religious interpretation she perceived AA to embody. The situation is stacked against the irreligious in that context.

For those atheist dealing with their problem, there's no innate reason the "higher power" condition must get in the way. It does require reformulating the nature of what it represents, in ways your unlikely to get from an AA meeting. Selling yourself the idea that your newly developed 'willpower' makes it safe to have a drink is itself a product of the 'willpower' lie. If it were true you wouldn't be trying to sell yourself the idea that it was safe. Your willpower is no more separated from your biochemistry than your belief is. Belief is powerful, but it doesn't come seperately from your biochemistry, or as a dualism with 'independent' power over your biochemistry. The two way nondualistic relationship is what gives it power, and selling yourself on the idea that 'willpower' alone can make it safe to drink violates that fact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom