Your argument rests on making it appear as though all definitions of terms used in this thread are so vague as to be useless. Apparently you think that doing so will make your interpretations just as good as everybody else's.
My argument rests on showing why
your definition of one particular term -- "YOU"-- is so
broad as to be useless (which was quite obviously your intent). I'm glad you mentioned "everybody else's" interpretation, because the very point I'm making is that we all DO know what the pronoun "YOU" refers to: the
self. That it defaults to a logically flawed proposition (the homunculus) is beside the point; for the purposes of recovery, what counts is how it
feels.
But if you HAD evidence of the contrary I assume you'd have presented it by now.
You're asking me to prove a negative. This causes me to wonder: have you ever heard of Russell's teapot?
No more single-case testimonies, please.
I will restate these as factual claims; that is, not as simply my observations, but as observations that may be made by anyone:
1) An abundance of alternatives to AA is available to those able to embrace the dogma of mainstream religon.
2) Some very significant number of AA members openly express having found in AA a system of personal belief that works for them
precisely because it differs from the dogma of mainstream religion. [Note: you may recognize this as the underlying premise that inspired the starting of this thread.]
3) Among them are pantheists, neopaganists, totemists, polytheists, gaiaists, and on across the full spectrum of philosophical and, yes, religious viewpoints.
Assuming that we are in agreement on those, I will stipulate that my mention of not recalling having met any enthusiastic adherents to naive panpsychism was indeed personal
testimony, and therefore lacks value as evidence. My
opinion, if you will indulge that, is that the whole "doorknob" thing was never more than a bit of facetious hyperbole; in short, a joke. You know, like my crack about the caffeine?
There's a reason why science seeks physical evidence.
To be sure, AA isn't science -- but that doesn't make it religion.
Or perhaps you'd rather distinguish between "perceived" interaction and "real" interaction ? As usual, I'm talking about the real stuff.
The point I've been making since very early in the thread (which your time constraints must have prevented you from either reading or grasping) is that where "the real stuff" refers to that which can trigger measureable physiological responses (say), that distinction IS quite fuzzy, and for the puposes of an alcoholic seeking recovery in AA (or a castaway seeking to preserve some modicum of mental and emotional stability in the face of prolonged isolation),
unimportant.