Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The only AA meetings I've been to was in my early teens, where my uncle attended. It was held near the library, and I my mother would take us there since she also drove my uncle to the meeting. I was allowed to stay withing hearing distance, probably due to age and the perception I was no threat. Many people got the impression I didn't or couldn't talk in those days. When I did some would complain about those giant 5 and 6 letter words. I even read their literature as I listened.
Ok.

I seen many proclaim their religious advantages, while a few of the others showed differing levels of discomfort when it was mentioned so adamantly. It almost appeared to me to be a hindrance for some, and I don't think the "higher power" is not religious line was much help for them. My uncle in particular had a very religious wife, and she relished the religious interpretation she perceived AA to embody. The situation is stacked against the irreligious in that context.
And there we disagree.

For those atheist dealing with their problem, there's no innate reason the "higher power" condition must get in the way.
And we agree.

It does require reformulating the nature of what it represents, in ways your unlikely to get from an AA meeting.
We disagree again. What ones gets from AA meetings is what one chooses to get.

Selling yourself the idea that your newly developed 'willpower' makes it safe to have a drink is itself a product of the 'willpower' lie. If it were true you wouldn't be trying to sell yourself the idea that it was safe. Your willpower is no more separated from your biochemistry than your belief is. Belief is powerful, but it doesn't come seperately from your biochemistry, or as a dualism with 'independent' power over your biochemistry. The two way nondualistic relationship is what gives it power, and selling yourself on the idea that 'willpower' alone can make it safe to drink violates that fact.
I'd say it's highly likely the alcoholic who bought that line of reasoning (which is what got him or her to the point AA seemed like a good idea) continues to drink alcoholically.

Note that I identify 'willpower' with conscious descision-making. For alcoholics and drinking, conscious thought, and rational thought, are usually not synonymous.
 
Right now I'm going to give up believing that Advil actually works on my headache and take some Vicodin which actually does work. ;)

GB
Funny story there. When I was young, and my mother give me aspirin for a headache, it never worked. None of them did. Later, I would take a days maximum dose at once (tooth) and no more for 24 hours. This worked a little, and after that regular single doses started working for normal headaches. I've often wondered if it now works because of the associative link my body made between the acetaminophen and pain reduction.

It's still pointless for major injury type pain. I've got pain shots from doctors that made me babble like a baby, but still had no effect on the pain. My pain tolerance is fairly extreme by most peoples standard. I once drove home after crushing my heal breaking it completely loose and splitting my leg bone up lengthwise. This was after a guy, who said he was an army nurse, asked me to wiggle my toes. When I did he said it wasn't broken. I did have help getting to the car. To this day I've never filled a pain prescription for that injury, though a few people offered to pay me to :p.
 
I'd say it's highly likely the alcoholic who bought that line of reasoning (which is what got him or her to the point AA seemed like a good idea) continues to drink alcoholically.
You may be right, I've never had to actually deal with that particular addiction. But my point was mainly on the issue of the connection between biochemistry and willpower or belief. That belief, in spite of having actual power, is not an 'independent' power over biochemistry. They are simply parts of the same machine. These are claims independent of any AA issue, just related.

As for my perception of the feelings of the members, those were my perceptions. I don't think either of us can take an authoritative view on that. People have many different reasons for discomfort in a religious context, including belief with a sense of hopelessness of living up to that belief. I'm somewhat more confident in my reading of my uncles perceptions, but didn't spell them out. It's best for people to choose what they get from such meetings, no one size fits all is going to be very useful.

I did use 'willpower' in a somewhat restricted unspecified sense that's doesn't necessarily play well with all notions of willpower. So your disagreements may well be very justified.
 
Funny story there. When I was young, and my mother give me aspirin for a headache, it never worked. None of them did. Later, I would take a days maximum dose at once (tooth) and no more for 24 hours. This worked a little, and after that regular single doses started working for normal headaches. I've often wondered if it now works because of the associative link my body made between the acetaminophen and pain reduction.

It's still pointless for major injury type pain. I've got pain shots from doctors that made me babble like a baby, but still had no effect on the pain. My pain tolerance is fairly extreme by most peoples standard. I once drove home after crushing my heal breaking it completely loose and splitting my leg bone up lengthwise. This was after a guy, who said he was an army nurse, asked me to wiggle my toes. When I did he said it wasn't broken. I did have help getting to the car. To this day I've never filled a pain prescription for that injury, though a few people offered to pay me to :p.

I really wonder how much over the counter pain medications rely on the Placebo Effect, drummed into people through constant advertising. They never seem to work on my headaches, chronic back pain, etc. because I don't seem to have the Belief required to make them work.

Yet I know from experience that alcohol, marijuana, and opiates definitely work without any Placebo Effect involved. And the empirical data seems to support my own experiences.

Dymanic's arguments basically boil down to using AA's "God Stuff" as a Placebo Effect. Which I have agreed might work for those willing to Believe. But it is an admission that AA is a Religious Organization.

GB
 
It sounds like GB is on a cruisade. ;)

But if he were really trying to separate AA from the judical and medical communities, he would be lobbying them, not attacking the religiosity or otherwise of AA members on an anonymous internet forum. :confused:

Perhaps he could show us what he is doing where it actually counts.

If he does, which I doubt, could someone tell me please? - he is still on ignore. :)

delete
 
Last edited:
I agree with pretty much everything you say here, but as usual for you, it's an argument that tacitly acknowledges that AA is Religious.
Based on equating "false belief" with "religious belief" -- which, I will argue, is itself a false belief (but not a religious one). It keeps coming back to how broadly higher power may be defined, and whether the definition might include concepts that are not inherently religious in nature (irrespective of whether they are "real" or "false").

And I have no problem with Religious people believing what they like, but when they expect a non-theist to "fake it till they make it", I have a problem.
As we've noted previously, that phrase does not appear anywhere in either AA's Big Book or the 12 & 12, so let's note that the available evidence suggests that in this context, recovery house people are the proper referents of the pronoun, "they".

I agree that a suggestion to simply pick something and call it a "higher power" is not a realistic -- or even an available -- option. I don't see the choice as one of picking something to believe in and trying or pretending to believe in that. I agree that I am essentially arguing for a "placebo effect", but implicit in that is the expectation that it will work (unless it's a person being treated for hypocondria, as the comedian Richard Lewis points out).

I see it as a matter of searching the things you already believe in (on some level, at least) and finding one you might rely on as sort of an emotional crutch (not to put too fine a point on it). It might be as simple a matter as merely acknowledging that in something you're already relying on. The "doorknob" hyperbole is offered merely as an illustration of just how large the possible search space might be; to highlight the difference between AA's approach to that and the sort of limitations the individual may have had placed upon him during previous encounters with religious belief systems.
 
Based on equating "false belief" with "religious belief" -- which, I will argue, is itself a false belief (but not a religious one). It keeps coming back to how broadly higher power may be defined, and whether the definition might include concepts that are not inherently religious in nature (irrespective of whether they are "real" or "false").

As we've noted previously, that phrase does not appear anywhere in either AA's Big Book or the 12 & 12, so let's note that the available evidence suggests that in this context, recovery house people are the proper referents of the pronoun, "they".

I agree that a suggestion to simply pick something and call it a "higher power" is not a realistic -- or even an available -- option. I don't see the choice as one of picking something to believe in and trying or pretending to believe in that. I agree that I am essentially arguing for a "placebo effect", but implicit in that is the expectation that it will work (unless it's a person being treated for hypocondria, as the comedian Richard Lewis points out).

I see it as a matter of searching the things you already believe in (on some level, at least) and finding one you might rely on as sort of an emotional crutch (not to put too fine a point on it). It might be as simple a matter as merely acknowledging that in something you're already relying on. The "doorknob" hyperbole is offered merely as an illustration of just how large the possible search space might be; to highlight the difference between AA's approach to that and the sort of limitations the individual may have had placed upon him during previous encounters with religious belief systems.

The thing is "Higher Power" IS defined in AA literature...as GOD.

The Placebo Effect only works if one has the Belief to make it work. In AA that means a belief in God.

GB
 
I wish I had said "What one gets from AA meetings is what one chooses to get .. .. or too often more likely, chooses not to get." :(
 
That's true too. So one would be best served looking for similarities, not differences (in the stories of others), while taking what you need and leaving the rest generally.

A difficult concept it seems for some who (seem to) believe that attendance at AA means we need to leave behind all power of independent thought. :);)
 
Last edited:
The thing is "Higher Power" IS defined in AA literature...as GOD.
Your entire argument rests upon this single false belief. But hey, if believing it makes you feel better, then I'd be the last one to discourage you from clinging to it.

It is not a "Belief", "False" or otherwise. It is an Empirical Fact evidenced by AA's literature. If YOU really believe what you are saying, then you are truly Delusional.

But I suppose if it makes you feel better to cling to YOUR False Belief/Delusion, who am I to discourage you? ;)

GB
 
Your entire argument rests upon this single false belief. But hey, if believing it makes you feel better, then I'd be the last one to discourage you from clinging to it.

Actually GB is partly right - sometimes it is this "one god" that GB seems so obsessed by, in very much the same way that Bill W was. But sometimes it isn't that god, and the doors are left wide open for everyone else for whom this god does not fit.

Sadly he seems to have a skotoma around these parts of the literature and argument - so much for critical thinking.
The best of us have skotomas, this seems to be his.
 
Last edited:
Any AA group that wanted to change to something you propose would be a confederacy of dunces.

That is the current AA set up.

You could always start you own organization.

Why, I'm not an alcoholic?

Can I call the waaaaambulance for you?

That's hilarious . . . . . well, not really but when I was in second grade I laughed at it.

That's the extent of your counter argument? Actually, not surprising after reading your posts.
 
I really wonder how much over the counter pain medications rely on the Placebo Effect, drummed into people through constant advertising. They never seem to work on my headaches, chronic back pain, etc. because I don't seem to have the Belief required to make them work.
I suspect quiet a bit, but the effect does exceed the placebo alone. Yet that probably helps the placebo work better. I suspect in my case it's more like a gag effect when you look at puke. Not so much a placebo as it is a body response conditioned by the drug that releases helping chemicals. People under hypnosis can even physically blister when they think they are being burned. Blistering is not a physical effect of heat, but a system response similar to an immune response. I did hot roofs awhile after high school, and after a few months I no longer blistered from 400 to 600 degree tar splashes.


Yet I know from experience that alcohol, marijuana, and opiates definitely work without any Placebo Effect involved. And the empirical data seems to support my own experiences.
Haven't had much experience with opiates, but the morphine drip in the hospital did nothing, pain or otherwise. Alcohol actually makes pain worse for me, but I don't react to alcohol the way most people do. Never liked getting drunk. Came from my Dads side, for which there are no alcoholics on that side of the family. Marijuana is most definitely perfect for a sprained ankle. I'm guessing because it finally let my muscles relax, so that the spasms and tension wasn't making it hurt anymore.

Dymanic's arguments basically boil down to using AA's "God Stuff" as a Placebo Effect. Which I have agreed might work for those willing to Believe. But it is an admission that AA is a Religious Organization.

GB
I agree that AA go a long way in helping support religion. Yet I'm guessing that has a lot to do with the nature of the issues its members have to deal with, including their belief structures atheist or not, to make it work. It's not an easy road and shouldn't be underestimated. Glenn Beck is an AA graduate :rolleyes:.
 
Whether you think false beliefs are "okay" or not, I submit that you can't not hold them . . .

[snip of some very interesting points]

... intellectual life, I guess you'd call it; in my search for answers to difficult (and often rather abstract) questions. I need to be able to recognize when it may only serve to isolate me from those around me, and to be able to sort of give it a rest (I won't claim to be very good at this; it's one of the things I'm working on).

Can't say I really disagree with any of this. The issue though is that this is a situation where a program of recovery is being based on false beliefs without anyone checking to see if it works. It is the equivilent of homeopathy being fed to the unsuspecting simply on the bases of the mistake claim that it does no harm. Both treatment programs do cause harm even if it is only that they prevent a person from pursuing a better therapy.

Agreed -- but I think it's like saying that because guns can be used for similarly evil purposes, they have no possible justifiable uses. Belief IS powerful. It can work for you, and it can work against you. It's something that can only be taken on a case by case basis.

Yes but that brings up the issue of AA being touted as the only way to a cure, or that AA is 100% effective "for people who really work the program."

Everybody can make a claim as long as they put such a qualifier behind it. "This sugar pill will enlarge your penis as long as you take it everyday and believe." Then when someone complains that they have taken the pill everyday for 20 years without any effect, the person can always say, "Well, there are a lot more days and are you sure you are really working the program and believing in it enough?"

That's the type of sophistry that goes on in alternative medicine and it goes on in AA as well. In the literature and in the meetings.
 
I wish I had said "What one gets from AA meetings is what one chooses to get .. .. or too often more likely, chooses not to get." :(

What difference does it make, it's still a fallacy. To top it off, it also follows along with the long standing religious tenet that members must leave their brains at the door.
 
Both treatment programs do cause harm even if it is only that they prevent a person from pursuing a better therapy.

Please provide examples of other programs and/or treatments, statistics etc that that are "better". I genuinely want to know.

Yes but that brings up the issue of AA being touted as the only way to a cure, or that AA is 100% effective "for people who really work the program."

And this is simply an outright lie.
Nowhere is "100%" stated, nor is it said that AA is the "only way" to a cure.
 
The issue though is that this is a situation where a program of recovery is being based on false beliefs without anyone checking to see if it works.
I think we can make the simple observation that embracing a belief -- even a false belief -- can produce a change in inner states (and I will continue to hold that we all do this). We can extrapolate from that that such a practice might be of benefit to a person struggling with some difficulty: isolation, fear, fatigue, depression, etc. (which, I will continue to hold, is the reason evolution has hard-wired this particular feature of human cognition). We can further extrapolate that this benefit would be manifest in statistical studies comparing a program which encourages the practice with others that do not -- but only if there were definitive ways to measure the results of that benefit. I believe I have now reiterated several times that I make no claim regarding the effectiveness of the AA program, and the reason for that is that I do not see any strong basis for making that measurement. But where I most disagree with you is where you state that this is the issue. Whether the embracing of a belief is of benefit or not is really NOT the issue; the issue in this thread is whether the belief itself is inherently religious in nature.

Yes but that brings up the issue of AA being touted as the only way to a cure
A strawman that has already been debunked here through directly quoting AA literature. AA makes no such claim.

...or that AA is 100% effective "for people who really work the program."
AA does not make this claim either. "Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path" is the passage from AA literature which you are (obviously quite deliberately) misquoting. With regard to both this and the claim above, it certainly is possible that some AA members hold these views, but again: it's got squat to do with AA being a religious program. Your strategy here appears to be to just try to sling mud on AA from any direction, in the hope that if you can get some of it to stick, that will somehow rescue your failed attempts to make your case directly.
 
Your strategy here appears to be to just try to sling mud on AA from any direction, in the hope that if you can get some of it to stick, that will somehow rescue your failed attempts to make your case directly.

No, unlike the pro-AA side in this discussion, my strategy is to provide evidence and reasons supporting my claims.

You keep saying these things have nothing to do with AA being religious. It has already been established that AA is religious, the issues I brought up were to draw attention as to why that religious leaning is detrimental beyond simply trampling on the beliefs of atheists and agnostics.

It has been claimed that believing in something is better than not believing. That maybe true but it hasn't been established that a false belief works better than a belief that is true. But, it is well established that forcing people (atheists) to try and believe in something they know is false will never be of benefit.

Add to that the smug, self righteous way AA, and its members who easily believe the BS, disregard the issue and complaints, namely by saying atheists aren't working the program properly, and you have assured failure for an entire group.

That you think these things are not related to AA's religosity is evidence that you really have no understanding of the issues. If you are only interested in whether or not AA is religious, you could have bowed out of the discussion long ago as that has been proven.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom