AlBell
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 28, 2009
- Messages
- 6,360
Ok.The only AA meetings I've been to was in my early teens, where my uncle attended. It was held near the library, and I my mother would take us there since she also drove my uncle to the meeting. I was allowed to stay withing hearing distance, probably due to age and the perception I was no threat. Many people got the impression I didn't or couldn't talk in those days. When I did some would complain about those giant 5 and 6 letter words. I even read their literature as I listened.
And there we disagree.I seen many proclaim their religious advantages, while a few of the others showed differing levels of discomfort when it was mentioned so adamantly. It almost appeared to me to be a hindrance for some, and I don't think the "higher power" is not religious line was much help for them. My uncle in particular had a very religious wife, and she relished the religious interpretation she perceived AA to embody. The situation is stacked against the irreligious in that context.
And we agree.For those atheist dealing with their problem, there's no innate reason the "higher power" condition must get in the way.
We disagree again. What ones gets from AA meetings is what one chooses to get.It does require reformulating the nature of what it represents, in ways your unlikely to get from an AA meeting.
I'd say it's highly likely the alcoholic who bought that line of reasoning (which is what got him or her to the point AA seemed like a good idea) continues to drink alcoholically.Selling yourself the idea that your newly developed 'willpower' makes it safe to have a drink is itself a product of the 'willpower' lie. If it were true you wouldn't be trying to sell yourself the idea that it was safe. Your willpower is no more separated from your biochemistry than your belief is. Belief is powerful, but it doesn't come seperately from your biochemistry, or as a dualism with 'independent' power over your biochemistry. The two way nondualistic relationship is what gives it power, and selling yourself on the idea that 'willpower' alone can make it safe to drink violates that fact.
Note that I identify 'willpower' with conscious descision-making. For alcoholics and drinking, conscious thought, and rational thought, are usually not synonymous.